Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mum annoyed because of what I said about ds

123 replies

Doyouknowsurely · 17/01/2026 20:20

I am despairing today. I welcome brutally honest opinions here.

I’m a single parent. I took dc 3 to a large park/play area/walk today and met my niece (4), my parents and my sibling’s in laws. So there was me and two sets of grandparents.

My dc’s dad is involved but for context his parents have died so for DC it is nice he has my sibling’s in laws to be ‘grandparents’ too. My dc refers to them as granny and grandpa as they refer the same to my parents.

Anyway… we (me and my parents) arrive first and went to grab and drink. While sitting and chatting and waiting for nephew and nephew’s grandparents, my mum tries to hug dc. Dc is having none of it and won’t sit on her knee and keeps moving away. I should be clear here that my mum adores dc and both my parents are good to us and they are always buying presents and wanting to see us. But, dc 3 can sometimes be like this, just didn’t want to move off the chair and didn’t want a hug right then. When he’s done this to me I just say oh ok maybe later then? And he’ll either say yes later or just ignore me and carry on with what he’s doing. I was starting to get a bit irritated with mum as she was making an unhappy face and saying please, I want to hug you and dc was getting more annoyed. I said to her just leave him alone a bit he doesn’t like it and he’s said no so just leave it now, he will come to you if you just leave him a bit. I don’t know exactly what tone I said it in, perhaps I was offhand. I just wanted dc to be able to chill and bit and drink his drink. She responded sort of shocked as if she wasn’t doing anything wrong and she just wanted to hug him.

So… then nephew and nephew grandparents arrive. Again for context they’ve met my family a lot and we were all together for Christmas for example. Dc is excited to see his other ‘grandparents’ and immediately runs over and is holding their hands and so on. Obviously this is because they are more of a novelty as they don’t see them as much as my parents.

What happens after that is my mum seems to descend into a huge mood. Very sulky, barely speaking to anyone. chatting when she has to be not really engaging. Kept going off to the toilet for long periods of time. I asked what was wrong, she said nothing but continued to be very off and cold.

Nephew’s grandparents are very energetic (slightly older than my parents by a couple of years). They are very involved with nephew and both are hands on, they’ll basically be a huge help when they are around, you don’t really have to ask anything they just help with ordering food, getting the kids to eat, getting coats on… my parents do help but it’s often if they are in the right frame of mind or aren’t feeling too tired ie you can’t rely on the help if that makes sense. As my mum was being so withdrawn and as they are quite full on, the kids were running and playing with them rather than my mum, it was a perfect storm (so to speak!).

Eventually we get to the cars and say goodbye to them and it all comes out…im awful for telling my mum to back off a bit because it’s made my DC go off her (!!!), i was very cruel, dc isn’t interested in my mum because i said what I said in front of him. My mum was visibly upset so she obviously genuinely feels hurt, however she didn’t really say goodbye to ds properly like she is usually does and instead got in the car (dad came round to the window to say bye to him like usual).

I since messaged her and said it was really unpleasant to behave like that and I hadn’t meant to do anything to put Ds off her, in fact it was the opposite, I was trying to tell her how to best make him want to come to her. She’s now not speaking and neither is my dad by the looks of it either. They’re usually always on their phones in the evening and they’ve not even read my messages. I feel exhausted by it all. Welcome honest opinions on this. I don’t want to hurt my mum but it’s not the first time something like this has happened where I get silent treatment. Sorry for the essay.

OP posts:
Doyouknowsurely · 17/01/2026 20:49

RudolphRNR · 17/01/2026 20:46

Your mum was being annoying but you made it worse. Both of you at fault. Your child shouldn’t be guilt tripped into hugs by the use of a sad face. Your mum shouldn’t be told off in front of your child. Give her some space then make up.

I agree with the pp though that I can really understand why your mum is sore with regards to the other “grandparents”. Your sibling’s in laws are a distance from your son, no actual relation. It’s nice they are an extra presence in his life but if it was me I would have made them auntie and uncle and kept the title of grandparents as a privilege for the actual grandparents. I see why your mum is sensitive and easily upset by them essentially taking over.

@RudolphRNR i hadn’t ever thought about using auntie and uncle but really it came from the fact the cousins are almost the same age so it felt more natural for them both to call them
the same thing. Obviously I can’t imagine how I would feel in that context but I would hope I would see it as a nice thing for my grandson

OP posts:
Ooodelally · 17/01/2026 20:52

Your mum was being pathetic and is still being pathetic giving you the silent treatment 🙄 you’ve done nothing wrong at all, children should be supported to not accept unwelcome physical contact. Ignore your mum she’ll soon come round when she realises the other “grandparents” will be seeing your DS and she isn’t…

youalright · 17/01/2026 21:00

I think its hard because its something that has changed over the generations. Years ago it was seen as rude if a child didn't hug people hello/goodbye etc so they where forced to now its very much if the child says no you step away and leave them alone. Older generations haven't all caught up with this yet

Obscurity · 17/01/2026 21:03

Doyouknowsurely · 17/01/2026 20:32

@ExtraOnions this is an interesting perspective, I just thought it was nice he could do that as he’s very close to nephew and obviously nephew calls them that

My nephew used to call my husband daddy. My husband hated it! It was embarrassing tbh. My DH felt awkward - very uncomfortable - because he wasn’t his dad and he didn’t know if he was allowed to correct him or not so just had to put up with it. My sister just let her son get on with it - she actually thought it was funny!

For context, my nephew is my sister’s boy, there’s no dad on the scene, and my nephew would hear our kids call their dad - my husband - daddy.

TheSunRisesInTheEast · 17/01/2026 21:12

I think all this hugging, kissing and saying "I love you" is quite naff, especially between adults, and seems to have been introduced in the last twenty or so years. I'm 60, loved my parents, grandparents, aunts & uncles to bits, but we never hugged, kissed or told one another "I love you". We were loving in our communication and talking with one another and there was never a bad word spoken either way, but we just weren't demonstrative. I hug, kiss, and tell my granddaughters I love them, but if they don't want a hug and a kiss, I don't push it. It's lovely if they do want a cuddle, usually if they're ill or tired, and I make the most of it then, but I certainly wouldn't get in a strop if they didn't want physical contact. Your mum should understand how fickle children can be and make allowances for it. They're unpredictable, sometimes going over the top with affection and at other times completely ignoring you, it's just how it is 🤷

Delphiniumandlupins · 17/01/2026 21:12

I think you can be sorry that your mum is upset, even though she has overreacted. Explain that your sibling's in-laws are less familiar and that is why they are an interesting novelty. If you had told your DC that he had to accept her hugs he would likely have objected and she would have felt rejected. Perhaps you could have quietly whispered to her that he sometimes just needs to come round in his own time, rather than telling her off.

MrsPerfect12 · 17/01/2026 21:13

Don’t keep calling your mum. You were not wrong. You were advocating for your son! do not start undermining that now. Leave them to stew and call you. They’re behaving poorly.

alphabetQ · 17/01/2026 21:15

Ah, OP, I feel as though I could have written this myself. I wish I had some solid advice, but I'm afraid I can only offer you sympathy and commiseration.

My DM is exactly the same. She adores my kids, and they adore her, but she almost keeps score between herself and DC's other Grandparents—every extra minute they've got to spend with them, every time DC mention them to her, etc etc. I've tried to tell her that DC obviously love her and that it's good they have so many people to love and be loved by in their lives, but she takes it all so personally. As if my kids' love is a zero sum game and any affection they show to anyone else has been taken away from her "lot". It's tough, and it (at least in my DM's case) obviously runs very deep.

I hope you find a way forward with your mum so she can enjoy her relationship with her grandchild to the fullest, and so can you.

Hippydippysillybilly · 17/01/2026 21:40

Bit childish of your mum. Grandkids are little people and have the right to say no, not now, to a hug, and they haven't learnt diplomacy at that age! Your DC was just not up for a hug at that moment. Your DC then had fun with other adults as your DM was sulking! She will get over it no doubt. Try not to stress about the silent treatment, even though it is mean of them.

Morepositivemum · 17/01/2026 21:45

Yanbu but I’d say your mum was just having one of those days and saw something that wasn’t there. Tbh it’s better she told you then letting it build up even more. You’ve a good thing on the hugs- they’ll come back when they’re ready etc.

noworklifebalance · 17/01/2026 21:46

YANBU at all.
A child should never be made to feel bad, emotionally blackmailed etc to give an adult a hug or physical contact. They should never have to justify why they don’t want either.

noworklifebalance · 17/01/2026 21:50

Happyher · 17/01/2026 20:46

You’ve unintentionally upset your mum. Best to make up with her. Call on her with DS and flowers or chocolates and she’ll come round

Really?! This will encourage more of this nonsensical immature behaviour. Don’t give it oxygen, it will only get worse and then it’ll start messing with your son’s head as much as yours as he gets older.

cheeseonsofa · 17/01/2026 21:51

TheBlueKoala · 17/01/2026 20:47

Good on you for defending your dc's right to his body. No child should ever be forced to hug/cuddle someone. Your mother seems to be very immature and emotionally needy. Maybe send her this article :
https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/the-well-child/202512/doctors-orders-your-kids-dont-have-to-hug-anyone/amp

This
Wasalso coming to say that your Mum is emotionally immature @Doyouknowsurely
An adult should not persist when your son was uncomfortable, just behave in an adult way and understand he has the right to say no
Poor boundaries and poor respect for the boundaries of others.
She behaved immaturely , sulked and is now stonewalling you.

The fact you feel so anxious means her love and the relationship with you is conditional on you doing as she says.

Counselling with someone who understands toxic family dynamics would be helpful @Doyouknowsurely

GrillaMilla · 17/01/2026 22:20

I can't see what you've done wrong.
This is her issue.

Your mum is being silly, and now sulking and giving you the silent treatment is very childish, and quite cruel I think, given that she must know you'll be fretting and distressed.

I know it's hard, but I wouldn't contact again. You've tried, so leave her.

Difficult though if she does this regularly, all you can do is ignore the sulking and stand firm.

Endofyear · 17/01/2026 22:29

You didn't do anything wrong OP and your mum is behaving like a spoilt toddler. Leave her to her sulk and don't worry about it. If this is a pattern of behaviour (silent treatment and sulking) you need to break the pattern. Don't call, don't apologise, let her sulk until she's ready to start behaving like an adult.

Happyher · 17/01/2026 22:44

noworklifebalance · 17/01/2026 21:50

Really?! This will encourage more of this nonsensical immature behaviour. Don’t give it oxygen, it will only get worse and then it’ll start messing with your son’s head as much as yours as he gets older.

Edited

Oh for gods sake! It’s her Mum! She sounds like she’s close to her parents, probably relies on them for childminding. Her mum obviously felt jealous and left out. Why does mumsnet always want families estranged.

noworklifebalance · 17/01/2026 22:50

Happyher · 17/01/2026 22:44

Oh for gods sake! It’s her Mum! She sounds like she’s close to her parents, probably relies on them for childminding. Her mum obviously felt jealous and left out. Why does mumsnet always want families estranged.

Where did I say about estrangement?
It’s OP’s mum that is behaving badly here - to try and force a 3yo to show affection, then suggest OP is turning her grandchild against her and then to ignore OPs calls etc. Making a huge drama about herself (no thought about how the 3yo may have felt at the time).
Now OP is upset and trying to fix the situation.
That is a pretty toxic situation.
Worse still that it is her mum/dad that are behaving like this.

HarvestMouseandGoldenCups · 17/01/2026 22:51

Let her be in a mood then. Quite honestly id have told her to grow up.

My nephew is the same age and often he doesn’t want to cuddle. He’s allowed to not want physical contact! I just say ‘OK mate, what would you rather do.’

Id be tempted to tell her she’d ruined a lovely day with her mood and stomping off to stew in the toilets and that I hoped it made her feel better to ignore me.

Noshadelamp · 17/01/2026 23:03

Doyouknowsurely · 17/01/2026 20:44

@FlashingFairyLight i can’t help feeling sorry for her though and worried that she was so upset. I know I will be awake worrying about this tonight.

No child should have to pander to an adult to avoid trouble or being ignored. Disgusting behaviour from your mother.

You are probably conditioned by your mother to react this way when she's "upset".
She's being childish at best, but it really seems more emotionally manipulative than anything.

You haven't done anything wrong. She's being selfish and dramatic. If she really was concerned about your DC not liking her, she would be engaging and saying goodbye to them, not ignoring them.

Don't let her emotionally manipulate your dc.
You did the right thing by establishing boundaries.

TheatreTheatre · 17/01/2026 23:07

Your Mum had no business cajoling and guilt tripping your Ds into a hug he wasn’t interested in at that moment.

And adults taking young children’s emotional responses personally is pathetic.

I would say to your Mum you are sorry she is upset and you need to have a calm talk about what happened. Tell her her that your Ds does love her, he adores her, but like any kid sometimes he simply doesn’t want to be hugged. And that you think it important that children are able to say no when they don’t want to hug someone. But it was just a fleeting moment, and had she continued to chat and be fun he would, as you said, have turned his affection to her when he felt ready and spontaneous.

But overall it sounds as if your Mum is quite immature and self absorbed about all this stuff.

Has she always been like it?

BunnyLake · 17/01/2026 23:09

The years of forcing children to hug their relatives are gone (or should be). I understand your mum might be upset at the perceived slight but she should be made aware that we no longer force kids to have hugs and kisses when they don’t want to. Good manners should still prevail so an acknowledgement of her presence is acceptable.

Strongle · 17/01/2026 23:13

Your mum was out of order with the hug.

but. I don’t understand why you’re calling your siblings in laws “grandparents” to him. Why not auntie and uncle? Or just their names? They aren’t his granny and grandpa?

Bufftailed · 17/01/2026 23:25

This sounds really tricky but your DM is really overreacting. I really dislike the whole forcing forcing children to hug relatives. And if anyone makes a fuss about it they will off course back of further. Hopefully your mum calms down and gets it in perspective.

FlapperFlamingo · 17/01/2026 23:28

She’s jealous and also ridiculous, does she not understand kids at all. If they don’t want a cuddle then move on, they will later. If they are calm and having a drink then leave them to do it. You did nothing wrong.

redlorryyellowbus · 17/01/2026 23:42

Stop stressing. She sounds worse than the toddler!

Swipe left for the next trending thread