Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked by this government dietary advice for babies and children?

527 replies

fourfoxsakes · 09/01/2026 08:50

from the government in Northern Ireland that is published online? Surely we don’t do these things any more such as mixing baby rice with milk and advising people to feed their very young children rice crispies and cornflakes for breakfast and advising people to give juice with meals! Surely this is bad advice, I am honestly surprised that the government have been allowed to publish this crap. I have no doubt people still do these things which is an individual parenting choice but surely the government shouldn’t be advocating for this?

To be shocked by this government dietary advice for babies and children?
To be shocked by this government dietary advice for babies and children?
To be shocked by this government dietary advice for babies and children?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
C152 · 09/01/2026 19:02

normanagfriends · 09/01/2026 16:56

Her son wasn't even out of surgery 12 hours and there was no mention of him needing to eat, he was still on fluids. I'm not of the chia pudding/nut butter ilk, but even I wouldn't think fizzy drinks and a heavy chocolate bar would be appropriate. She was concerned the anaesthetic was curdling in his stomach (not sure what that means) and that was why she wanted him to eat, not because he was hungry or needing to eat.

This seems pretty judgemental. If he had surgery, presumably it was under GA, meaning no food or drink since the night before. So it's quite feasible this child hadn't had anything to eat or drink for 24hrs. As soon as they wake up from GA, they are encouraged by staff to eat and drink as soon as they are able - it's a requirement before they are able to go home. As for offering unhealthy food immediately after surgery - you offer whatever they will be tempted by. I bring cookies and a mini can of Sprite, as I know they won't be rejected. Happy to give you an alternative view so you can reassess your view of what's appropriate in these circumstances.

C152 · 09/01/2026 19:07

FizzySnap · 09/01/2026 14:34

I genuinely had no idea people felt this strongly about generic cereals. If you prefer porridge or toast, you could’ve ordered that from the hospital menu.

This made me laugh. This has not been a possibility in any of the 5 London hospitals I have experience of. Some stale, non brand rice crispies and a slice of bread (not toast, they won't toast the bread for you, I asked), if you're lucky.

C152 · 09/01/2026 19:20

Natsku · 09/01/2026 14:50

It'll be because they expect more children will eat rice crispies, because, as you said, they are more likely to be used to it. Not for catering reasons, breakfast in hospitals in my country are always porridge (always, you don't get a choice) except weekends when its more of a brunch so its porridge plus something else, so clearly easy enough to do in a ward environment,

I'm afraid I disagree with you here. I believe it's down to budget. Own brand rice crispies are significantly cheaper than other options and require less time and skill from staff. (There was a marked difference in food - and the availability of food - between GOSH, which has a ton of money, and my local hospital.)

Natsku · 09/01/2026 19:26

C152 · 09/01/2026 19:20

I'm afraid I disagree with you here. I believe it's down to budget. Own brand rice crispies are significantly cheaper than other options and require less time and skill from staff. (There was a marked difference in food - and the availability of food - between GOSH, which has a ton of money, and my local hospital.)

Yeah someone else explained about the lack of catering facilities, which would make cereal the cheaper and easier option (with proper facilities porridge would be cheaper, its a very cheap food when made in mass quantities but requires proper facilities for that).
Its a real shame that there can be such a difference in food quality between different hospitals, food is so important to recovery when you're ill/injured so patients ought to have good quality food whatever hospital they're in.

Octavia64 · 09/01/2026 20:02

normanagfriends · 09/01/2026 17:36

So your mum could cook then? A bloody good curry from scratch isn't simple (I'm not talking about curries that use tinned tomatoes and a spoon of curry powder).

er tinned tomatoes and a lot more than one spoon of curry powder was her curry….

i never ate it after the first time it gave me diarrhoea. I had plain rice instead.

Kirbert2 · 09/01/2026 20:04

C152 · 09/01/2026 19:20

I'm afraid I disagree with you here. I believe it's down to budget. Own brand rice crispies are significantly cheaper than other options and require less time and skill from staff. (There was a marked difference in food - and the availability of food - between GOSH, which has a ton of money, and my local hospital.)

There can even be a difference between wards in the same hospital too! One ward my son was on had its own chef funded by a charity so the menu was bigger (though still not particularly healthy) and they also had extra staff funded by the charity who would do things such as make the children milkshakes to order which my son loved, make parents teas/coffee and nip to the canteen for a cooked breakfast if that is what the child wanted to eat.

The other wards were just a smaller bog standard kiddie menu and definitely no special milkshakes!

CatsMagic · 09/01/2026 20:46

vanillalattes · 09/01/2026 10:15

Well, it’s not because they have rice crispies and diluted apple juice for breakfast occasionally.

This won’t be popular but I think most of it is lifestyle related - too many snacks, too much screen time and not enough exercise and time out of the house.

Bang on.

But the orthorexics of Mumsnet prefer to apply their fanatical puritan logic around diet and nutrition as it helps convince them they are absolutely in the right.

Grammarnut · 09/01/2026 22:51

Happytap · 09/01/2026 18:51

I don't shop at Waitrose no, I use Aldi for all my seeds and nuts as it's by far the cheapest. I buy flax/chia/ cashews and mixed seeds from there. My DC eat chia pudding for breakfast because they've been given it since they started weaning.

I have taken on a lot of points from this thread but acting as though everyone who feeds their kids non processed foods must live in Kensington doesn't help the conversation either.

I fully appreciate that there are things I hadn't thought about and have taken that on board, and I do think there is more nuanced discussion to be had which include not demonising other foods.

I'm not the OP so can't comment on the salmon. Avocado is full of good fats and baby and toddlers need lots of good fats to support brain development.

Thank you. Avocado may be good for us but it is not good for the environment, sadly. I always think it tastes like soap.

It's very true that if you introduce foods at weaning DC will eat them. My DC were gently weaned onto very spicy food and like and eat it to this day (and so does DS' DC).

normanagfriends · 09/01/2026 22:53

C152 · 09/01/2026 19:02

This seems pretty judgemental. If he had surgery, presumably it was under GA, meaning no food or drink since the night before. So it's quite feasible this child hadn't had anything to eat or drink for 24hrs. As soon as they wake up from GA, they are encouraged by staff to eat and drink as soon as they are able - it's a requirement before they are able to go home. As for offering unhealthy food immediately after surgery - you offer whatever they will be tempted by. I bring cookies and a mini can of Sprite, as I know they won't be rejected. Happy to give you an alternative view so you can reassess your view of what's appropriate in these circumstances.

There's nothing judgemental about it, this child had had major surgery and the mother was trying to force a fizzy drink and mars bar down him, calling it a good breakfast. My DC have eaten/drank loads of crap, I'm not particularly bothered, especially when sick, but the nurses were even telling her he wasn't up to eating, and should start with clear liquids when he felt ready.

MoreDangerousThanAWomanScorned · 09/01/2026 22:55

Grammarnut · 09/01/2026 22:51

Thank you. Avocado may be good for us but it is not good for the environment, sadly. I always think it tastes like soap.

It's very true that if you introduce foods at weaning DC will eat them. My DC were gently weaned onto very spicy food and like and eat it to this day (and so does DS' DC).

There are absolutely loads of foods that I introduced at weaning that my children won't eat now! Including, for one of them, the sainted bowl of porridge...

AndSoitComesAroundAgain · 09/01/2026 23:01

vanillalattes · 09/01/2026 09:10

Does everything you eat have perfect nutritional value?

Snap, crackle and pop...fond memories of childhood.

Foodfoodbaby · 09/01/2026 23:04

wishingonastar101 · 09/01/2026 09:16

I wouldn't feed my kids fruit juice or cereal on a regular basis. Maybe cereal on a camping trip...

Juice is just refined sugar with all the fibre removed. Better off having a glass of water and a satsuma.

Cereal is UPF refined carbs and sugar... total junk.

Agree!!

I’m really surprised actually that so many people are saying it’s fine. Perhaps I have issues, but there is no way I’d feed my children cereal and juice as a typical breakfast.

Grammarnut · 09/01/2026 23:10

MoreDangerousThanAWomanScorned · 09/01/2026 22:55

There are absolutely loads of foods that I introduced at weaning that my children won't eat now! Including, for one of them, the sainted bowl of porridge...

I think porridge is an acquired taste and can be unacquired later on either taste or tecture grounds. But generally speaking DC will eat what you feed them if you feed it early (this probably doesn't include sprouts and green beans, however).

HostaCentral · 09/01/2026 23:14

Foodfoodbaby · 09/01/2026 23:04

Agree!!

I’m really surprised actually that so many people are saying it’s fine. Perhaps I have issues, but there is no way I’d feed my children cereal and juice as a typical breakfast.

Nonsense. As previously stated the rest of Europe cheerfully send their children off to school on sweet pastries, cakes, bread and Nutella, biscuits and a glass of milk. Cereal and toast is not the evil Mnetters believe them to be.

nevernotmaybe · 09/01/2026 23:15

Grrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 09/01/2026 12:15

This may help you to understand the pathological process:

https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/sugars-and-dental-caries

Giving a page that does not in fact describe the process at all, to a biomedical scientist and ex medical researcher for a while, is an interesting approach.

Sugar is and always remains neutral. It is bacteria (a specific strain) in the mouth that metabolises the sugars and excretes acidic waste.

You also ignore how that page specifically gives a multiple risk grouping as a major issue, including brushing and fluoride on top together as one.

It's not like my comment said give them as much sugar as possible. It cleared up a myth from those who don't understand what happens, and was me saying being paranoid about any at all is silly if you are competent and practice good oral hygiene.

Jellycatspyjamas · 09/01/2026 23:21

Foodfoodbaby · 09/01/2026 23:04

Agree!!

I’m really surprised actually that so many people are saying it’s fine. Perhaps I have issues, but there is no way I’d feed my children cereal and juice as a typical breakfast.

It’s a bit of puffed rice and apple juice, you’d think folk were giving their kids a morning fag and a wrap of cocaine.

Natsku · 10/01/2026 06:11

Grammarnut · 09/01/2026 22:51

Thank you. Avocado may be good for us but it is not good for the environment, sadly. I always think it tastes like soap.

It's very true that if you introduce foods at weaning DC will eat them. My DC were gently weaned onto very spicy food and like and eat it to this day (and so does DS' DC).

I weaned my youngest on curries and other spicy food (food i don't like but I wanted to make an effort to give him a wider diet than me) and he absolutely loves spicy food, has been adding hot sauce to his meals himself since he was a toddler. Though he also went through the fussy toddler stage and for a long while pretty much all he ate was beetroot, porridge and ketchup! I kept offering foods though and he eventually started eating again though everything had to be served with ketchup, even pancakes Grin

Natsku · 10/01/2026 06:12

HostaCentral · 09/01/2026 23:14

Nonsense. As previously stated the rest of Europe cheerfully send their children off to school on sweet pastries, cakes, bread and Nutella, biscuits and a glass of milk. Cereal and toast is not the evil Mnetters believe them to be.

Parts of Europe do, plenty other parts do not and think both cereal and pastries/nutella/cake for breakfast are terrible for children.

PandorasSockBox · 10/01/2026 06:20

Well just look at the number of NHS staff, whoare overweight or obese and draw your own conclusions.

Missey85 · 10/01/2026 07:28

Jellycatspyjamas · 09/01/2026 23:21

It’s a bit of puffed rice and apple juice, you’d think folk were giving their kids a morning fag and a wrap of cocaine.

😂😂😂

vanillalattes · 10/01/2026 08:11

Foodfoodbaby · 09/01/2026 23:04

Agree!!

I’m really surprised actually that so many people are saying it’s fine. Perhaps I have issues, but there is no way I’d feed my children cereal and juice as a typical breakfast.

Why? What on earth do you think will happen if you do? 😂

brightnails · 10/01/2026 08:29

Grrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 09/01/2026 09:02

It's really high in sugar and therefore bad for teeth. Yes, drinking it with a meal is better than in isolation, but eating whole fruit and drinking water is much better for both gut and dental health.

we don’t advise against juice with meals. and one glass of juice a day isn’t contraindicated for sugars either

Imenti · 10/01/2026 10:48

I agree they should not be suggesting juice at all! Water or fine, or at a push squash, not juice. Also - popcorn! Shouldn't be giving that to any child under 5 due to the safety concerns. Hope they've told them to quarter the grapes in that advice somewhere as well. Cereal everyday isn't ideal, could mix it up with some some scrambled eggs.

Grammarnut · 10/01/2026 15:23

Natsku · 10/01/2026 06:11

I weaned my youngest on curries and other spicy food (food i don't like but I wanted to make an effort to give him a wider diet than me) and he absolutely loves spicy food, has been adding hot sauce to his meals himself since he was a toddler. Though he also went through the fussy toddler stage and for a long while pretty much all he ate was beetroot, porridge and ketchup! I kept offering foods though and he eventually started eating again though everything had to be served with ketchup, even pancakes Grin

Me too. My son went through a phase of only eating crisps and cottage cheese, whatever I offered. Doctor said don't worry, he won't starve and dentist said at least it wasn't sweets. He eats widely now - but not sprouts or green beans (token ceremonial sprout at Christmas).

AndSoitComesAroundAgain · 10/01/2026 15:28

I think some of it is genetic. No amount of exposure would make one of my dcs like spice, despite me loving it.. The other one however loves it too! It is similar for me, no amount of trying sprouts would ever change my mind.

Swipe left for the next trending thread