Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL. Am I over reacting?

78 replies

Twointhehand1 · 03/09/2025 18:47

MIL can be a busy body and a bossy but this really irks me and I can’t put my finger on why this particular thing bothers me so much.

DH is an only child with a small extended family. He has one aunt, MILs sister and she has 3 adult children, all around our age. We don’t tend to send each other greeting cards for any occasion but we do wish them happy birthday etc on the family WhatsApp. I don’t think that the lack of a physical card bothers any of us.

MIL is a prolific card sender. Makes her own and gets everyone a card. Over the years she’s repeatedly asked if we’re getting such and such a card and we’ve replied ‘no’ and explained that we don’t exchange cards, so she is aware of where we stand and the lack of a card isn’t a mistake. They also don’t get us cards either.

Despite this she repeatedly purchases cards on our behalf and gives us them to sign. Eg, sign this before you go and I’ll take it to x with mine. She never asks for payment but I find it really controlling. I’m an adult and I know how to purchase a card if needed. I don’t get my own adult cousins cards and feel forced into doing something that I’ve explained that I don’t want to do.

Tonight she’s arrived at our house ‘just passing’ with a wedding anniversary card for cousin and wife for us to sign.

DH finds it annoying but says it’s not a hill to die on. She has a tendency to get sulky etc when they disagree and DH feels that it’s petty to refuse to sign the card and it does no harm to actually send them.

YABU-sign the bloody card
YANBU-it’s a form of control. Refuse!

OP posts:
MyLittleNest · 10/09/2025 19:03

She sounds overbearing and controlling. You and her DH are grown adults and she is out of line. I'd tell her that you will handle the card yourself and then don't do it.

I do think it is a generational thing to send cards, but that is not the point. DH isn't her little boy anymore. Absolutely tedious and ridiculous of her!

I bet DH's cousins, being around your age, just toss those cards right into the bin!

Megapint · 10/09/2025 21:26

I actually think it's quite lovely. It's really nice to receive a card rather than a message on WhatsApp or FB. It feels like that person though of you rather than saw the other birthday messages and jumped on the band wagon. She wants the family to think 'well' of you. Soon all us card senders will die out. You'll miss us!.

Ferrissia3 · 10/09/2025 21:38

Twointhehand1 · 03/09/2025 21:30

I can very honestly say that shes done much worse and more hurtful things but thats a story for another day. This is why im surprised this annoys me so much.
I suppose I see it as controlling as it’s her way of manipulating us to do what she thinks should be done. We say no we’re not doing that and she makes us in a passive aggressive way.

This doesn't surprise me - I imagine that if she was lovely and respectful in all other ways then you would feel differently about the cards.

It's not about the cards, it's about having your boundaries repeatedly and willfully disrespected in a situation where you need to be on alert for this behavior, because it's affected your family in the past, and most likely will continue to do so (and may even get worse) if you go along with the card insistence.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page