Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

get a kindle - yes or no?

119 replies

Changedusernameforthis2 · 22/05/2025 12:34

I've always held off getting a kindle - as I have always been a real book person- but recently I've found a number of American magazines that are expensive to ship but much cheaper on a kindle version- if you have a kindle, what do you think of it?

OP posts:
knittasgonna · 22/05/2025 14:10

If you're reading magazines for print articles, a kindle might be great. I use mine for books, and I much prefer the reading experience on the kindle to reading on a tablet or phone. There's no glare, it's easier on my eyes, and I just find it more pleasant. However, I haven't used mine with magazines, so not sure how well that works. For photo-heavy books or magazines, I prefer a tablet. It is definitely more awkward to carry around a tablet, though. A kindle e-reader is lightweight and easier to fit into a bag.

Auburngal · 22/05/2025 14:10

I have a Kindle. Love it. 99% of my books on there are non fiction. My love of fiction died with GCSE English Lit. I can dip into a subject I fancy. Most books I have, the chapters don't run after each other - they are separate.

FancyBiscuitsLevel · 22/05/2025 14:17

I’m a real book person who has a kindle as well!

pros for the kindle - it’s lighter. This is the big big pro. It fits in small bags, doesn’t weight as much as one book and means you can carry around multiple books easier. This comes into its own on holidays / long train journeys. It also is easier to get hold of new books if you don’t enjoy the one you are using or finish it quickly, quickly on the hotel WiFi and download a new book.

you can change the font size easily -very good for those of us in denial about needing new reading glasses /keep forgetting to pick up reading glasses.

Once you’ve got it, books are often cheaper- particularly the 99p daily deals.

Downsides - if there’s a map or family tree at the start of the book, it’s harder to flick back to have a Quick Look to get it clear in your mind who’s who /where are they.

it’s not as easy to share ! So many books I’ve read and thought “oh, xxx would love that” and unlike a physical book, you can’t just give it to them. (I do share a kindle library with dh and dc1)

It’s just not as nice as a real book.

Hankunamatata · 22/05/2025 14:20

Should add kobo book amd magazine subscription is cheaper then amazon at £8.99. And kobo app is great and syncs to reader

Moier · 22/05/2025 14:22

I've had one scince they first came out.
Reading is one of my biggest passions.
Just bought a new one last month.
I pay for kindle unlimited .. there is thousands of books for free.
If you buy a book and read it within two weeks you can return for a refund or transfer it to someone else's kindle for them to read.
A kindle is 100% better than using your phone.

ThisReplyHasBeenDeleted · 22/05/2025 14:23

I have a kindle but I rarely use it unless I have to read in bright sunshine outside. My iPad is much MUCH more 'user-friendly' and can do everything a Kindle can, only quicker!
It's also easier to scroll through my 'library' (5000+ books), access collections, mark as 'read', etc on the iPad.

SoManyTeeth · 22/05/2025 14:24

I can't see an e-ink Kindle working that well for magazines, unless the text is reflowable and you don't care too much about the pictures (or you splash out on a colour one). And given you want something handbaggable, if the magazines are stuck as non-reflowable pdf-style pages, reading them on anything smaller than a large tablet is going to involve a lot of tedious zooming and panning.

If the magazines do reflow the text on screen (and you don't care too much about the pictures) then sure, a Kindle would work if the magazines you want are available on that platform, but I second the concerns others have about the locked-down nature of Kindles.

I don't read magazines on my e-reader, but wanted something I could easily pocket or put in a bag, and use to read books from a variety of sources, so I use a small phone-shaped Android-based e-reader (a Moaan Inkpalm 5 Plus; was about £85 from AliExpress during a sale with some coupons). I've installed apps like Moon+ Reader and KOReader for my own ebook files, Libby and Borrowbox for library ebooks, and the Kindle and Kobo apps to read books I've obtained in the past through those services, as well as a couple of useful tools like F-Droid for downloading open-source apps, and a better browser (not that it's a fun browsing experience, but I might occasionally download books from websites). I think one or two of the Android reading apps are optimised more for phone screens than for e-ink, but you can often improve the experience by doing things like turning off page-turn animations. It's much more versatile than the Kobo I had before (it's basically an extra-light, e-ink, wifi-only, speakerless phone), but without the temptation to doomscroll or play mindless games that there is with a phone. And in most of the reading apps, I can tell them to use the volume buttons as page turn buttons, which my old touchscreen Kobo didn't have.

Edit: this is a bit me-specific, but another reason I personally don't like Kindles is because the text formatting is too restrictive. I'm extremely short-sighted and like to read in bed, without glasses digging into my face. I have to get text within 10cm of my eye to be able to read it, which means, firstly, normal-size text looks huge, and secondly, to read normal-length lines of text, I have to constantly swing my eye massively from side to side, which gets a bit wearing.

E-readers are great for my situation partly because I can get them close to my face in bed without having to balance half a book like a tent on my temple, rest my face on half a book, or strain to hold the book fully open/fold the book back on itself (and occasionally twang myself in the face). But the other benefit is that I can adjust the text size so it's ludicrously tiny, and adjust the margin size so they're ludicrously wide. I could easily do that on a Kobo, and my Inkpalm is already very narrow and lets me set text size to whatever the reading app I'm using allows.

But any time I've fiddled around with a Kindle to see if I could make the text comfortably readable without my glasses, it was clear that Amazon had just arbitrarily decided that I shouldn't be allowed to do that.

CocoPlum · 22/05/2025 14:26

SixFeetUnder · 22/05/2025 14:00

I wouldn't be without my paperwhite, it's size means it's handy to keep in my handbag and battery life is great. I also bought a page turner (hear me out!) which is great for if I'm chilly and want to lie under a blanket without my arm hanging out to keep turning the page.

YES to a page turner, I get freezing hands and it's amazing 😄

TimeForATerf · 22/05/2025 14:27

I have had a kindle since they first came out, at least 16 years ago, I’m in about my 4th. This one can be read in bright sunlight and is small and light and slides in my handbag, I do have the App on my IPAD but the kindle is far more portable if I’m not reading at home, and it has a better battery life.

I wouldn’t be without one.

shadlo · 22/05/2025 14:31

I'm another kobo user, been using them forever. My previous one just died last year after 9 years of use.
When I first went down the ereader route (around 15yrs ago) kindles were tied to amazon only, whereas kobo used multiple different formats in ebook so you had a much wider choice.
When I upgraded (to one with a built in back light many years ago) I just stuck with kobo as they are great.
Not sure if kindle has changed to allow other formats now or not as I've not looked into them since going kobo.

ERthree · 22/05/2025 14:33

I always said i would never give up my books, i love the smell of them, the feel of them and opening a new book brings so much pleasure. Lockdown hit and i bought a kindle, i love it so much. I still read real books. We can have both.
Buy the paperwhite, it is worth it.

Cynic17 · 22/05/2025 14:33

I have had several over the years - wouldn't be without one.
It's an easy way to store thousands of books, and light enough to go in your bag or pocket. Ideal for holidays, as the weight is so much less than a suitcase full of paperbacks, and also you can never run out of books.

CarlaH · 22/05/2025 14:36

I think kindles are brilliant except for those occasions where a book has a family tree or map as part of it. Unless I am particularly dim I have found that enlarging text has no effect of that sort of thing and as I am hard of seeing I have my kindle set to largish text all the time.

Not sure photos come out all that brilliantly either so if you are into biographies or autobiographies they might not work all that well.

saraclara · 22/05/2025 14:38

I don't use my kindle much at home, but it's fantastic for travelling. Light, compact, contains hundreds of books, and the battery pretty much lasts all holiday.

Bluevelvetsofa · 22/05/2025 14:39

A Kindle is very portable, more than a tablet I think. I would find reading on a phone difficult. The length of charge on my tablet would mean I was frequently recharging.

I like the light adjustment. I read in bed and dim the background so it doesn’t disturb. If you have Prime, there are books for free, so it’s a bit like a library and you can send them back when you’ve read them. Kindle Unlimited has a bigger selection and there are often deals on subscription.

WaryHiker · 22/05/2025 14:39

Moier · 22/05/2025 14:22

I've had one scince they first came out.
Reading is one of my biggest passions.
Just bought a new one last month.
I pay for kindle unlimited .. there is thousands of books for free.
If you buy a book and read it within two weeks you can return for a refund or transfer it to someone else's kindle for them to read.
A kindle is 100% better than using your phone.

Although please don't read books and then return them for a refund. It's really hard on those of us who make our living by writing novels. You can't imagine how dispiriting it is to look at your your sales numbers and realise that people are reading then returning your books simply because Amazon allows them to do it.

TakingHavenInTescoExpress · 22/05/2025 14:43

Reading on a Kindle is a completely different and much better experience than reading on a phone screen. I love mine, it goes everywhere with me, takes up very little room in my bag and is much lighter than a tablet.

Lollygaggle · 22/05/2025 14:44

Love kindle for travelling and have signed up to bookbub which alerts you ,free of charge, to cheap books (normally around 99p) in genres you are interested in . Some great books available although the sci fi is a little flakey the literary fiction, historical fiction , mystery and non fiction picks have yielded some gems.

The downside is you have to upload them quickly because some revert to normal price within a day or so.

My latest kindle is a reconditioned oasis purely because , like my first generation, it has physical turn buttons , a must if you read fast (even on small font setting).

TreeDudette · 22/05/2025 14:44

You can carry 40 books in your pocket for a week away... One of my favourite things! I do still have all my paperbacks but now books I get on Kindle.

Murdoch1949 · 22/05/2025 15:17

Love, love, love my Kindle. So light, so convenient. The days of taking heavy books on holiday gone. With your Kindle you can also use the same books on your iPad or tablet if you download the Kindle app. You can also have a family sharing account, so books my son buys I can download to my Kindle. I also get daily offers of books that are much discounted to 99p. I rarely pay full price for a book unless it is a favoured author. Mine is 10 years old, I need a new one with the light. Soon. But I love my first one in it's gorgeous leather cover!

BIossomtoes · 22/05/2025 15:36

CarlaH · 22/05/2025 14:36

I think kindles are brilliant except for those occasions where a book has a family tree or map as part of it. Unless I am particularly dim I have found that enlarging text has no effect of that sort of thing and as I am hard of seeing I have my kindle set to largish text all the time.

Not sure photos come out all that brilliantly either so if you are into biographies or autobiographies they might not work all that well.

It’s the only down side. I love Cara Hunter’s books apart from the texts, Twitter feeds, etc which stubbornly refuse to be enlarged. So annoying.

CloudywMeatballs · 22/05/2025 15:38

If you like to read, then YES. Definitely get a Kindle.

I know you can get the Kindle app on your phone or tablet, but that's still reading on a screen, and we should all be trying to cut back on our screentime. The Kindle's screen is designed to be just like reading on paper with no stress for the eyes.

Reasons I love my Kindle.
I like lying down in bed to read. That's much more difficult with a real book that requires two hands.
These days I need reading glasses but I can read my Kindle without them when I increase the font size. This is especially helpful when I'm lying down in bed.
I don't need the light on at night to read (and you can adjust the brightness).
I can carry hundreds of books on something that weighs barely anything and can fit in my handbag. As others have said, this is especially good for travelling.
Through my local library system I can borrow books in the Libby app and open them on my Kindle. I haven't paid for a book in ages and almost always read books that have been released recently.
I can read outside without glare.

Reasons I don't love my Kindle.
A Kindle doesn't smell like a book. (It doesn't have any smell at all but I do love the smell of a bookshop.)
Can't think of any others.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 22/05/2025 15:42

I wouldn't be without one! I was resistant at first, but I'm so glad I relented. So much more practical.

nightmarepickle2025 · 22/05/2025 15:44

I love mine. It's better than a tablet as it doesn't affect your sleep like the blue light from a tablet. Plus you can't get messages/ browse the internet on it so much more relaxing just before bed.

Auburngal · 22/05/2025 16:17

Sign up to Bookbub. Set up your genres you like to read then get almost a daily email with cheap deals on ebooks.