Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Starmer is utterly reprehensible

1000 replies

Thegreyhound · 12/05/2025 20:31

I know everyone will disagree, that’s ok- But I just have to say that Starmer today seems to have sunk lower than I ever believed he would with his incendiary ‘island of strangers’ and ‘incalculable damage’ rhetoric.
I find it particularly shocking because he has calculated this and decided it’s worth it to throw immigrants under the bus and essentially give all the ground in the debate to Farage, Tommy Robinson and Enoch Powell types.
Policy can be altered without making statements that are designed to impact race relations and make life even more difficult for people who are just trying to get along and make a living here.
Starmer is vile. This country does indeed feel like an island of strangers these days but the strangers are not the immigrants :(

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
BatchCookBabe · 12/05/2025 22:34

Thegreyhound · 12/05/2025 22:25

What do you mean men who don’t share our culture and values? What could you possibly mean?

Don't pretend to be naive. You know exactly what that poster means. And she's 100% right.

woodlandcalm · 12/05/2025 22:34

caringcarer · 12/05/2025 22:19

In 2022-23 the NHS alone paid out £113 million in translators and translating services for patients. Councils spend millions more for same services. If people want to live in the UK they should speak decent English as a minimum entry requirement or pay for their own translation services. Having skilled immigrants coming to UK to work and contribute to UK economy is quite different than allowing in people with a criminal record, people with low skills who won't earn enough to live so will just need to claim benefits and people coming in to the UK illegally, throwing their passports into the sea and claiming they are either a child, gay or Christian so can't go home and need to be put up in 4* hotels at £145 per night per person. Plus food money and phone plus credit.

DWP also pay millions on an interpreter contract, giving advice on claiming to non-English speaking benefit claimants.

delightfuldweeb · 12/05/2025 22:35

Booksaresick · 12/05/2025 21:39

Im a migrant and I agree with him

So do you deserve to be here? Would you kick yourself out?

TempestTost · 12/05/2025 22:36

Keirawr · 12/05/2025 21:59

What exactly has he said that’s wrong? You don’t have to be a brain surgeon to work out that if you bring in people who don’t speak the language or congregate in segregated inner city ghettos, or don’t adopt some of the values, then you get an island of stranger groups where people don’t have much in common.

I suspect that fact is very inconvenient to acknowledge as it doesn’t quite fit with the ‘#be kind’ persona.

Trevor Phillips did a film about this a while ago - about the way communities remained segregated, even though they might work in an integrated setting. I think he saw it as a real failure of the policies he brought in.

MichaelandKirk · 12/05/2025 22:37

Lardychops · 12/05/2025 21:54

Or Luton

Or many parts of Birmingham. Sparkhill and Sparkbrook. A friend of mine moved out and she almost cries when she sees what it has become.

JandamiHash · 12/05/2025 22:37

TempestTost · 12/05/2025 21:25

Generally - I don't think he's vile. I don't think he is an amazing leader, or an idea man, or a visionary. And I think all governments now are in a very difficult position.

As far as immigration - no, I don't think he is throwing immigrants "under the bus". His fundamental duty of care is to citizens and permanent residents of the UK, and the economy and social fabric of the nation. People in other nations have governments with a similar duty of care to do what's best for the people there.

Immigration can have positive elements and there have always been some people who immigrate. But we don't live in a time where people drop a bunch of people off the boat and they need to make it or sink with no state support. You cannot have a social welfare state with unlimited immigration. It's not a viable model.

For the last 30 years or more all we have heard from big business and liberal political types is that immigration is a positive economically socially and economically. That is because easy movement of labour favours big business, the wealthy, and the professional middle classes. Working class people who objected to this and pointed out it certainly wasn't good for them were dismissed as bigots - a massive betrayal of them by the Labour Party.

And yet now we know they were right all along - even central banks and the WEF have acknowledged that immigration is not all equal, that it can cost the economy more than those workers generate, that it affects wages for the working classes, that it affects the housing and rental market and also contributes to housing problems - not to mention the draws on health care and education.

So no - I don't think the leader of the Labour Party, actually having some balls to stand up for left wing labour principles, is vile. Though it took him long enough to get there, that's for sure.

Excellent post

BatchCookBabe · 12/05/2025 22:39

woodlandcalm · 12/05/2025 22:34

DWP also pay millions on an interpreter contract, giving advice on claiming to non-English speaking benefit claimants.

Well this will stop now.

Tryingtodobetter82 · 12/05/2025 22:40

James O'brien sketch…

www.facebook.com/share/r/1C5rzQmeAn/

Manxexile · 12/05/2025 22:41

@Wowwee1234 - "Except 'most' people don't think like racists..."

I used to think the same as you - until I got to know more people who weren't in my immediate circle of friends and acquaintances.

I was surprised, and now I know not everybody thinks like me...

Bushmillsbabe · 12/05/2025 22:43

AlteredStater · 12/05/2025 22:01

Yes I totally agree - our parents and ourselves one day, there won't be enough care workers - there aren't now. How Starmer thinks cutting care worker immigrants is a good idea, I just don't understand.

We need to make care work more attractive for English speaking people. None of my grandma's carers spoke much English, and mistakes were made in following advice from her GP. She felt really isolated as any attempts to talk to the carers in her home were met with a smile and them talking over her in their first language. Not all the carers fault, but horrible for my grandma to not be able to communicate her needs effectively

Alwaysinamood · 12/05/2025 22:43

My local town centre is over run with illegal immigrants. They are staying in the hotels, social housing and flats. All male. I don’t care what anyone else says but they all need to go. There’s been knife attacks, rapes, I went shopping with my ten year old daughter who is blonde and pretty and we got followed round the shops by a gang of them staring at her. I felt so uncomfortable I’ve not taken her shopping since. We went to get a subway too and one just walked in, stole some drinks from the self service and walked out. It’s a disgrace. There’s hundreds of them coming in every day!!! So unless you have first hand experience of your town being taken over by men with no paperwork, morals and god knows what intentions, do not even try to justify it!!

TempestTost · 12/05/2025 22:44

Nigelshotfrenchwife · 12/05/2025 22:10

Why do we assume the spouse won’t be a net contributor?
Presumably they are an adult, so their full education has been already paid in their country of origin, and if they married a Brit they are more likely to integrate.
Also, I thought the discourse was about the problem with illegal immigration, specially young single men.
Why so hostile to that person?

Some cultures don't allow women to work outside the home.

BatchCookBabe · 12/05/2025 22:44

Keirawr · 12/05/2025 21:59

What exactly has he said that’s wrong? You don’t have to be a brain surgeon to work out that if you bring in people who don’t speak the language or congregate in segregated inner city ghettos, or don’t adopt some of the values, then you get an island of stranger groups where people don’t have much in common.

I suspect that fact is very inconvenient to acknowledge as it doesn’t quite fit with the ‘#be kind’ persona.

This. ^

notprincehamlet · 12/05/2025 22:44

Thatcher will be smiling up at him.

BatchCookBabe · 12/05/2025 22:44

floppybit · 12/05/2025 21:59

People of all ethnic backgrounds agree with him. Many migrants agree with him. I bet you will tell me this isn’t true, but I’m pretty confident you don’t have recently arrived immigrants for neighbours and this doesn’t affect you, so you can sit in your ivory tower and call everyone else racist.

And this! ^

Tryonemoretime · 12/05/2025 22:45

In my grandson's class, he was one of a very few whose 1st language was English. That's bound to have had an effect on his education ......

JandamiHash · 12/05/2025 22:47

Thegreyhound · 12/05/2025 21:40

There are many many born and bred brits who gain from a system they have never paid into. And that’s at both ends of the wealth divide

We have a duty to look after our citizens, and I’m proud to live in a welfare state. But we have to limit immigration and recognise it’s gone too far with the most vulnerable being affected. A good society should always prioritise the most vulnerable

MyHeartyCoralSnail · 12/05/2025 22:47

This is probably the first sensible thing that’s come out of his mouth since being elected.

Theres a massive issue re immigration and integration.

Addressing this issue will only be partly solved by reducing the people coming in as students or carers etc.

We also need to addrsss the lack of integration of people already here. We need to be very firm that British culture/way of life comes first. Multiculturalism simply doesn’t work..

JandamiHash · 12/05/2025 22:49

cardibach · 12/05/2025 21:42

Spouses should be able to get a visa I think.

This just places people (women) in a more vulnerable position

user1471538275 · 12/05/2025 22:50

@Thegreyhound Those who do not share our values - what do you mean.

They mean those who come from places where the culture believes women must be obedient, modest and preferably silent. Where it is acceptable to beat women who do not conform to this expectation.

They have grown up and been socialised with this attitude - it does not change when they arrive here and therefore they view women who do not fit this pattern in a negative way.

They do not share our values of tolerance for other people's beliefs, their right to hold them and express them or for women's right to wear whatever they choose to wear.

Nominative · 12/05/2025 22:50

I think he's wrong to try to take on Reform at their own bigoted game, because he will never outdo them in racism. I also don't understand why he is targeting legal immigration which we obviously need, rather than illegal immigration which is what bothers people most anyway.

Xis · 12/05/2025 22:52

What is the issue with Bradford? Educate me. I know there is a large population with Pakistani heritage there but they’ve been there since the 70s, I thought. The men and younger women generally work. Am I wrong? There is a population of older women who don’t speak English who’ve never worked but that’s because they stayed home to bring up their children at a time when it was possible and more common generally for families to live on one income.

I thought it was places like farming communities in Lincolnshire where there was a rapid influx of Eastern Europeans where there were tensions. Local people blamed poor public services on the large increase in new arrivals. Firstly, I think this time of situation was settling down even before Brexit. Secondly, Brexit means it is no longer an issue. Thirdly, I’ve never heard Eastern Europeans being accused of not learning English and not integrating. They had a reputation as hardworking, reliable workers, so I guess this isn’t the population being complained about.

I’m not going to discuss whether the perception that the country is being swamped by immigrants is accurate or not. It’s how people feel when they hear about small boats laden with people arriving daily and hear discussion of the cost of housing these people. The U.K. was previously insulated from unregulated immigration by the English Channel until the people-traffickers got bold so I guess the small boat phenomenon is a shock to many Brits, even though this is a small fraction of what many other countries experience.

One last point. We now live in a global society. The U.K. can’t go and intervene in other countries, destabilise them, then withdraw and expect no comeback. I support every Iraqi and Afghan who turns up on these shores by whatever means. This country left those countries in a mess so why shouldn’t they come here looking for a better life?

JandamiHash · 12/05/2025 22:53

Teado · 12/05/2025 21:42

Bradford always gets mentioned in these debates. How will the proposed changes benefit places like Bradford?

Bradford is an incredibly beautiful but deprived city with high rates of poverty, and 50% child poverty rates in some areas. Putting more people on the country and speeding the spending more thinly puts these vulnerable communities at risk. The high immigration communities are also difficult for services to engage with, and that puts a bigger strain on everything. Not to mention, because of the culture of many immigrants settling there, there’s a higher risk of child marriage, cousin marriages and trafficking and abuse of women. It might be uncomfortable to hear but it’s true.

HellsBalls · 12/05/2025 22:53

@Alwaysinamood What you are describing there is cultural enrichment. Those poor, destitute men are simply fleeing persecution. You should pity them.
They are the future carers and doctors this country so desperately needs. They will soon be net contributors to our society, as will the 400 undocumented illegal immigrants, sorry, asylum seekers, who landed this morning, and the hundreds who land tomorrow, and the hundreds who land on Wednesday, and on Thursday, etc infinitum.
Now suck it up and stop with the bigotry.

Thegreyhound · 12/05/2025 22:53

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread