Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have handed the new owners the no more HMO letter from the council regarding the street.

195 replies

itsmeits · 17/04/2025 08:13

Thats it basically, new owners of down the road have been at the property this morning with the builder.
They politely introduced themselves, I welcomed them to the street and said look forward to seeing them around.

The Man then told me we won't see them as the house will be a HMO.
I asked do you not know there is an order no more HMOs on the street - did the estate agent not tell you, it's a protected area due to the amount of HMOs in the area. The 10% rule.

They both looked flabbergasted and informed me it would be a HMO.
Said I would be back in a minute, toddled back to mine printed the email (took out personal info) and handed them the information.
Pissed was not the word. I have been told I am lying and made this up. Advised they speak to councilort confirm the information.

YABU - leave them to - even though there is an order saying no more on the street.
YANBU - this information should be on the house listing when selling so potential buyers know.

OP posts:
Jennifershuffles · 17/04/2025 11:51

Funnywonder · 17/04/2025 11:44

Would you be ok living in an area where you are completely surrounded by them? That is exactly what has happened a few miles from me. Long time residents have had to leave the area due to the partying, exploded bags of rubbish, damaged cars as people compete for parking spaces, furniture abandoned in gardens/alleyways, vandalism etc. These are a mixture of students (yeah, our future doctors/engineers/lawyers/accountants) and other young people who have heard about the 24 hour party atmosphere and fancied a slice of it. They wouldn’t behave like that in their family homes. It sounds extreme. It didn’t start out that way. It was a quiet family area in a bustling part of town. Now it’s like the Wild West and regularly features on the local news. If HMO’s had been limited to a certain proportion, this wouldn’t have happened, as the whole culture of the area wouldn’t have altered so drastically. I would never begrudge students their fun and their full immersion in student life, but this situation shows what can happen when HMO’s are allowed to increase unchecked.

I do live in an area that has quite a lot of HMOs (London one street away from a university) and I don't recognise that situation in my area.

There's the occasional student party and a bit of fly tipping down the side of my house (I think because it's not overlooked and there's no way to know who does it) but generally it's a quiet nice neighborhood. The main noise is from council run festivals they have in the park over the summer.

AlisounOfBath · 17/04/2025 11:53

Morningstarter · 17/04/2025 11:02

Your local council in South Africa 10 years ago!

and if in the Uk…. You were aware of this and didn’t whistle blow?

Could you keep your racist stereotypes to yourself please? Thanks.

Funnywonder · 17/04/2025 11:56

AlisounOfBath · 17/04/2025 11:53

Could you keep your racist stereotypes to yourself please? Thanks.

Quite.

I think someone has been reading too many Tom Sharpe novels.

CamillaMacauley · 17/04/2025 12:02

People say streets shouldn’t be overwhelmed with HMOs - in an ideal world no they shouldn’t. But also in an ideal world young professionals would be able to afford to buy or even rent a whole house yet they can’t. 🤷‍♀️. If people (other than landlords) can’t afford to buy the houses then what happens? Ideally the property market needs to crash so normal people can buy again but people don’t seem to want that either.

Many cities and even rural areas have a property crisis, multiple people fighting to rent or buy one house so prices keep rising. Supply and demand. In Manchester a hmo might cost 550 a month, a studio flat will be 1k plus. So people need HMOs. Hopefully if Labour gets more houses/flats built then prices will fall, but nobody wants new houses built near them either.

Badbadbunny · 17/04/2025 12:05

ftp · 17/04/2025 11:19

They could sue their solicitor if he knew that they planned an HMO

Only if he told the solicitor of his intentions. Solicitors aren't mind readers.

Badbadbunny · 17/04/2025 12:07

CamillaMacauley · 17/04/2025 12:02

People say streets shouldn’t be overwhelmed with HMOs - in an ideal world no they shouldn’t. But also in an ideal world young professionals would be able to afford to buy or even rent a whole house yet they can’t. 🤷‍♀️. If people (other than landlords) can’t afford to buy the houses then what happens? Ideally the property market needs to crash so normal people can buy again but people don’t seem to want that either.

Many cities and even rural areas have a property crisis, multiple people fighting to rent or buy one house so prices keep rising. Supply and demand. In Manchester a hmo might cost 550 a month, a studio flat will be 1k plus. So people need HMOs. Hopefully if Labour gets more houses/flats built then prices will fall, but nobody wants new houses built near them either.

It's not young professionals in HMOs that's the problem. It's the druggies, unemployed, mental health sufferers, criminals, illegal immigrants, etc. People in "naice" areas with young professionals won't understand what streets full of HMOs with social problem tenants are like - they need to leave their naice areas and take a look at places like Blackpool.

EllieQ · 17/04/2025 12:09

Ottersmith · 17/04/2025 11:30

I really can't understand this thread. I lived in HMO until my mid 30s. Nearly everyone I know lives in a HMO in London. How can anyone who is single live any other way in an expensive City? How is it any different to a house being divided into flats? Or do you all live on streets where everyone owns the whole house and there are no flats either? I don't get it.

I think that in most places outside London, it’s unusual for ‘normal’ houses (terraces/ semi-detached) to be divided into flats as there hasn’t been the same housing pressure. I live quite centrally and near a university, and there’s a couple of larger terraced houses near me that have been divided into flats, but that’s all. There are also some newer developments that are mainly purpose-built flats. So yes, I think most people will live on streets where most of the houses are owned by one person (whether as occupier or landlord).

And as people have previously said, HMOs are not the issue, it’s the concentration of HMOs in one area that can cause problems with parking, rubbish etc.

Sabire9 · 17/04/2025 12:31

EmeraldShamrock000 · 17/04/2025 08:27

You were 💯 in the right.
HMO's are a disaster.
Families squished together.

We have several in my not very long road so I very much understand people's objections to them.

The problem is that there are vast numbers of people reliant on being able to access this type of housing, and there really aren't any other options for them as far as either social housing or the private sector.

What happens to these people if there's massive resistance to the building of new HMO's? We just accept that high levels of homelessness are tolerable for low income single people, to protect the quality of life of those who are already housed?

Mrsbloggz · 17/04/2025 12:39

Morningstarter · 17/04/2025 11:17

Shame she never whistle blew

True, but those who whistleblow will be targeted by those who lose out because of the whistle blowing.
We would all like to stand up for what's right but if the cost is losing your job and being seen as a liability for future employers it's not such an easy thing to do 😬

DrPrunesqualer · 17/04/2025 12:42

They need to apply for permission to turn the property into a HMO .
They will be refused so I wouldn’t worry OP

Blackdow · 17/04/2025 13:10

Morningstarter · 17/04/2025 11:17

Shame she never whistle blew

What are you talking about? It happens at all levels of council and governments. Contracts given to their mates even though their companies have no track record of being competent for the job, red tape moved aside, permits granted which should be refused, on and in it goes… then the councillor/MP leaves office and suddenly has a job in the private sector with one of those people they helped. Or bit donations come in, or someone’s family member gets a job. You really are a bit dim if you think it doesn’t happen in the UK and seem to think it is solely south africa. Very very weird.

CluelessAboutBiology · 17/04/2025 13:26

TucanPlay · 17/04/2025 08:50

Well done! As a person who is "sandwiched" in an area that has been flooded with HMOs for students, it's good you told them. I got vicarious satisfaction from reading that.
I like students, and having young people around, and I don't object to HMO's. It's about balance. My neighbourhood has been turned into a student campus, sadly the council didn't introduce the sandwich rule until after HMO licenses had been granted to the houses either side. This impacts the value of my house, all because of greedy HMO landlords, and a Uni that keeps enrolling more and more students every year.

We have a 3 bed semi and there is a house a few doors down the same style that is an HMO with SIX bedrooms! They must have split the lounge into two bedrooms and either had a loft conversion or extension.

CamillaMacauley · 17/04/2025 13:26

Badbadbunny · 17/04/2025 12:07

It's not young professionals in HMOs that's the problem. It's the druggies, unemployed, mental health sufferers, criminals, illegal immigrants, etc. People in "naice" areas with young professionals won't understand what streets full of HMOs with social problem tenants are like - they need to leave their naice areas and take a look at places like Blackpool.

Sure. But then that antisocial behaviour needs dealing with. And support for people with mental health issues, etc. We can’t say that HMOs are ok but only for nice people. The not so nice people still need to live somewhere and if private HMOs weren’t available then the chances are the council would have to have more hostels/sheltered accommodation and I’m not sure the behaviour would be any different. Or they’d be homeless and also causing issues.

Badbadbunny · 17/04/2025 13:29

CamillaMacauley · 17/04/2025 13:26

Sure. But then that antisocial behaviour needs dealing with. And support for people with mental health issues, etc. We can’t say that HMOs are ok but only for nice people. The not so nice people still need to live somewhere and if private HMOs weren’t available then the chances are the council would have to have more hostels/sheltered accommodation and I’m not sure the behaviour would be any different. Or they’d be homeless and also causing issues.

Yes, how about the landlords of HMOs being taxed more so that they pay out of their profits towards the social costs of their residents?

And huge fines for the ones with HMOs who aren't compliant with H&S, local authority regulations, etc.

Another factor is that often the "problem" tenants aren't even local and were transported in to run down/cheaper areas, often by the local councils, or by gangmasters, etc. After all the poor Chinese cockle pickers who perished in Morecambe Bay had been living in very poor conditions in HMOs, several to a room in mattresses on the floor, certainly weren't "local" to Morecambe! Nor the newly released prisoners literally bussed into places like Morecambe and Blackpool from all over the UK.

CamillaMacauley · 17/04/2025 13:35

Absolutely. I think all 2nd home owners should be taxed through the roof. HMO landlords, normal landlords, holiday home owners, the lot. While rent caps are enforced so they can’t pass the cost on, hopefully it’ll become unprofitable and prices plummet meaning that more people can buy and the govt should buy others up so they can rent stuff out at a reasonable rate as social housing,

Blackdow · 17/04/2025 13:46

CamillaMacauley · 17/04/2025 13:35

Absolutely. I think all 2nd home owners should be taxed through the roof. HMO landlords, normal landlords, holiday home owners, the lot. While rent caps are enforced so they can’t pass the cost on, hopefully it’ll become unprofitable and prices plummet meaning that more people can buy and the govt should buy others up so they can rent stuff out at a reasonable rate as social housing,

Never going to happen. We need a rental market.

Mrsbloggz · 17/04/2025 14:02

Blackdow · 17/04/2025 13:46

Never going to happen. We need a rental market.

Do we need a rental market?
Yes ✅

Do we need a situation where buy to let landlords are able to outcompete potential owner occupiers and push up the price of housing so that normal people can't afford a decent place to live?
No❌

PomPomSugar · 17/04/2025 14:05

Seeline · 17/04/2025 09:06

Depending on the size of the HMO, it might not even need PP. One refusal of PP at a different site does not mean nothing else will get PP if it needs it.

It does if there is an Article 4 Direction

Aprilweather · 17/04/2025 14:05

For those wondering about issue with HMOs.

HMOs themswlves are not an issue. I lived in few too. It's too many HMOs in the same place which are an issue.
It creates generally transient spaces where people don't have any attachment to the area, many get tenant issues (like too many student HMOs etc) affecting the rest of the street etc. I would not buy on a street with many HMOs because I saw what they can do. Overwhelmed bins, too many people and cars streets and houses were not designed for, public transport issues, noise, etc.
There are examples up and down the country of people being stuck in hell because 15 out of 20 houses became HMO on the same street.

Limiting number of HMOs per area is actually great. You still have some, but not enough to overwhelm.

Alwaysinamood · 17/04/2025 14:08

Morningstarter · 17/04/2025 10:52

Oh don’t be daft

in South Africa possibly

not the uk

I know first hand it happens

TennisLady · 17/04/2025 14:40

MuddlingMackem · 17/04/2025 10:52

I know someone who lives in Durham who has said this is a huge issue in the part of the city she lives. 🙁

Yep! Bought a house on a new estate with a thing that prevents them from becoming HMOs. They got bought by students parents who let their friends live in with them, still against rules but when council investigated said they said there isn’t more than 2 unrelated people living in them all, despite the fact we could clearly see that was happening.

TennisLady · 17/04/2025 14:46

Ottersmith · 17/04/2025 11:30

I really can't understand this thread. I lived in HMO until my mid 30s. Nearly everyone I know lives in a HMO in London. How can anyone who is single live any other way in an expensive City? How is it any different to a house being divided into flats? Or do you all live on streets where everyone owns the whole house and there are no flats either? I don't get it.

HMOs outside of London must be very different…

WiddlinDiddlin · 17/04/2025 14:47

HMO's have their place -theres some in the centre of my local city that are very well run - but they are city centre, no parking, aimed at people who do not have cars (there is bike storage), their neighbours are shops/businesses and other HMO's.

In my friends city however, its all student HMO's rammed into residential areas and these are a huge problem. Student behaviour is often poor, they bring cars, they don't have any investment in the local community, they know they're only there temporarily so they don't care if they are loud, leave litter everywhere, piss off the locals and make life hell for them. Fines and punishments will be dealt with by Mummy and Daddy, the Unis' barely bother with the punishments they could dole out anyway, so they get away with being utter shits.

dogsandcatsandhorses · 17/04/2025 14:53

JohnofWessex · 17/04/2025 08:45

I might give The Council a call to let them know whats planned

This.
A lot of conveyancers outsource the searches and they’re notoriously slow. The couple might have economised and not had searches done.

TheWombatleague · 17/04/2025 15:16

TallulahBetty · 17/04/2025 09:17

I saw; it was still worth making the point.

Edited to add - being a SPAG pedant isn't an insult.

Edited

A semicolon? Where are the related independent clauses, or the separated items in a list, that would necessitate its use?