The only 'conclusion' I've come to (that it's a relationship which has previously been problematic, with lots of unmet expectations and problems in communication, and that you would like it to be different) is based entirely on what you have said here. For example --
they’re type of people that say ‘well you never make the effort’. We put in the effort but stopped as it wasn’t being reciprocated.
They’re the kind of people that preach effort is reciprocated but our messages and calls would go unanswered. Didn’t hear from them during the pregnancy. We had them arguing with us as we wanted to attend a family gathering with them and we made it clear we wouldn’t want him passed round like a parcel and we were told we were being controlling
It’s hard as a new mom and feeling lonely that the people who say they’re just a message away not respond is a bit of a slap in the face
Messages and calls have gone unanswered the past year. When it came to a month before baby was born, the family popped up, messaging to check in asking if we need anything, offering to cook and come round etc. when he was born we had the usually flood of messages from everyone (to which I feel I have to express to some of you, was hugely appreciated) the family again offered the same as mentioned before.
Come to a month later, messages had stopped we were being left on read, phone calls not returned. we have tried but radio silence.
by asking if I should stop being so available to people who don’t make an effort when I’ve tried with them for months
I want the biggest happiest family for my baby and I would never cut contact out of pettiness, all we ever want to do is protect our kids and yes there are family members that will be kept at a distance for very reasonable reasons. But there are also family members that can’t see these safeguarding issues and it is difficult to navigate communication.
Basically, this has never been an unproblematic relationship. Nothing has changed. You need to accept that it is what it is and find support elsewhere.