Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mother in law interfering?

104 replies

Woodenbones198901 · 10/11/2024 10:33

Hi i know this is called Mumsnet but I’m a new dad to a baby girl, who’s absolutely incredible at 12weeks she has been as good as gold and starting sleeping through the night since week 8.. all down to get amazing devoted mum/my wife.

I have a question and I’m in intrigued to see if I am being unreasonable. It’s regarding my mother-in-law

I find my mil to be quite interfering at times, and I feel like she crosses some boundaries. I could be wrong but Im interested in other peoples views on the matter.

My mil has often said she sees my child as “her 3rd child” which I find strange. She loves my daughter which is great but I feel it’s the love of a mother to a baby not a grandmother to a baby, if that makes sense.

Sone things that I find inappropriate

1- she says “nana” constantly to my baby!!! an example and I quote “smile for nana, that’s it for nana, nana, big smiles for nana”. she can’t do an actively or anything without saying “nana” in her face, I counted 48 times once in a 36hour period , I have tried to bring this up in a “jokey” way and she says she’s doing it so she knows who her “nana” is, I think she’s doing it to make sure one of her first words is “nana”. I find that I’m now having to talk to be baby and say mummy and daddy way more than what feels natural/normal just because I will be heartbroken if her first world is “nana” simply because it’s said to her so much! I’m also worried that when my child is showing signs of speaking maybe sounding the letter m/n my mil will mouth “nana” instead “mumma”

2- she snatches and tries to take my child out of my arms.. one occasion was when mil was staying over, it was morning and I got up to change her nappy..I went to go back into our bedroom to have morning cuddles and smiles with my wife, when all of sudden my mil opens her door, arms up takes her out of my arms, takes her straight downstairs to play with her, I was in shock and all I could here downstairs was “nana.. nana” another example but this time I was expecting it and I wasn’t allowing it to happen to me again, we were staying around her house, my baby was having a nap on me, she woke up and was making noises, not properly crying but close to tears, for a few seconds which she does after all her naps because she was hungry, my wife was sitting next to me, I was waiting for my wife to get ready to feed her, my mil jumps up off the sofa arms out “I’ll rock her” I said “no she’s just hungry and wants feeding, I then passed her to my wife who wasnt quite ready to feed but wasn’t getting her snatched from my arms again. She was taken back by this.

3- entitlement! mil bought us a pram which was very generous of her, but I feel she thinks that means she’s entitled to push her whenever it comes out. We visited them last weekend and we went for a walk and my wife used our baby carrier as it’s sometimes easier then pushing a pram and it’s nice to be close to the baby. My mil says “I don’t like the carrier it means I can’t look at her and push her” which annoyed me because I work so i don’t often get to the parenting things like pushing her in a pram, accept on weekends and I thought that if we took the pram that moment would had been taken away from me. We have never got the pram out in her company and her not grab it and push it immediately, got given anyone else the option to push her.

4- always calling to find out how the baby is. We had to take our child to a chiropractor as she had lower back pain. Within 10mins of us coming out she was phoning, I felt like she thinks she’s the third parent! My parents waiting till the next day to ask, I’m quite fortunate that my parents give us space and are not the interfering type. I know it can be harder when it’s the fathers mil that is interfering.

5- on a recent visit to my Mil we arrived late around 7:30pm which happened to be our baby’s nap time mil was taken back and disappointed saying “oh but it’s my time with her” we left our baby in her car seat in the lounge with the visor Down, making it dark for her. Mil was itching to look at her, we said “no she’s sleeping” I also said “ it will mess up our routine if you wake her up” we went back and forth to the car unloading stuff, I heard mil husband saying “don’t do it” then mil comes in to the bedroom and says “she’s awake” mil obsession with her meant she had to open the visor and look at her causing her to wake up. She denies it but it was Blatantly obvious she did.

I was chatting to my wife about it but understandably being her mother she sees nothing wrong with it, but I can’t help but think something isn’t right, I may be making mountains out of mole hills but I’d like to know other people’s opinions on the matter.

Thank you

OP posts:
ssd · 10/11/2024 10:45

Sure

TH1NG1E · 10/11/2024 10:48

It sounds like you definitely don't like her. So anything she does is irritating you. You are entitled to your boundaries, you need to discuss them with your wife and agree on what's OK. If your wife it happy with how her Mum is, maybe let her go alone with the baby sometimes.

TouchOfSilverShampoo · 10/11/2024 10:50

ssd · 10/11/2024 10:45

Sure

And why say that? Because the poster is a man?

Op - Your MIL sounds incredibly over excited and annoying. You need a chat with your wife about your boundaries and your time with the baby. Why are you spending so much time with her?

You might find it tapers off when the baby is at toddler age and it's more difficult to swoop in and snatch up but you do need to start drawing some firm lines otherwise she turns into the sort of MIL who will judge your every movement (school choices, holidays etc etc).

Justsayit123 · 10/11/2024 10:51

Irritating. Why do you see them so much?

SensibleSigma · 10/11/2024 10:52

It’s totally normal and yes, slightly irritating.

Hankunamatata · 10/11/2024 10:53

My mil was like this (dh mum) and funnily she did those things and they irked dh (her son) and not me. It was almost like a competitive thing as dh worked during the week and he felt his mum was taking his time with dc.

We tried to find balance and dh was t afraid to stop his mum taking dc from him and say no mum I'm having a hold

ThatGutsyHedgehog · 10/11/2024 11:03

This sounds really really annoying - it sounds similar to my MIL when we had our DS!
If your wife is on mat leave could she see her mum when your at work and keep the weekend more for family time?

Woodenbones198901 · 10/11/2024 11:18

L.

OP posts:
Woodenbones198901 · 10/11/2024 11:22

TH1NG1E · 10/11/2024 10:48

It sounds like you definitely don't like her. So anything she does is irritating you. You are entitled to your boundaries, you need to discuss them with your wife and agree on what's OK. If your wife it happy with how her Mum is, maybe let her go alone with the baby sometimes.

Actually used to get on her very well, we have a good relationship, but unfortunately ever since our baby was born I have found she’s changed

OP posts:
ApiratesaysYarrr · 10/11/2024 11:29

"We had to take our child to a chiropractor as she had lower back pain. "

A 12 week old? If your 12 week old non verbal baby genuinely has back pain, they need to see a dr urgently, not a chiropracter.

bzarda · 10/11/2024 11:29

Totally understand this and would find it really annoying and frustrating. I do think it's best if you speak to your wife about how this is making you feel so she can speak to your MIL as you don't want to have tension and conflict with her, especially if you need her for childcare later on.
I had to grow a huge backbone when my daughter was born and state our boundaries very clearly and it made things easier as she got older as my relatives knew I wasn't going to disrupt her naps so they could hold her etc.

Itisjustmyopinion · 10/11/2024 11:32

Oh this thread will be interesting. If a regular poster said all this they would be told they are right and to tell MIL to back off

As this poster is a man he will be told he is unreasonable

Typical MN double standards

bridgetreilly · 10/11/2024 11:33

Honestly, I think that’s pretty normal. Be firm about e.g. not handing the baby over all the time. Way too early to worry about first words. Don’t give in over things like the pram. Just ignore as much as possible.

Falseshamrok · 10/11/2024 11:33

Woodenbones198901 · 10/11/2024 10:33

Hi i know this is called Mumsnet but I’m a new dad to a baby girl, who’s absolutely incredible at 12weeks she has been as good as gold and starting sleeping through the night since week 8.. all down to get amazing devoted mum/my wife.

I have a question and I’m in intrigued to see if I am being unreasonable. It’s regarding my mother-in-law

I find my mil to be quite interfering at times, and I feel like she crosses some boundaries. I could be wrong but Im interested in other peoples views on the matter.

My mil has often said she sees my child as “her 3rd child” which I find strange. She loves my daughter which is great but I feel it’s the love of a mother to a baby not a grandmother to a baby, if that makes sense.

Sone things that I find inappropriate

1- she says “nana” constantly to my baby!!! an example and I quote “smile for nana, that’s it for nana, nana, big smiles for nana”. she can’t do an actively or anything without saying “nana” in her face, I counted 48 times once in a 36hour period , I have tried to bring this up in a “jokey” way and she says she’s doing it so she knows who her “nana” is, I think she’s doing it to make sure one of her first words is “nana”. I find that I’m now having to talk to be baby and say mummy and daddy way more than what feels natural/normal just because I will be heartbroken if her first world is “nana” simply because it’s said to her so much! I’m also worried that when my child is showing signs of speaking maybe sounding the letter m/n my mil will mouth “nana” instead “mumma”

2- she snatches and tries to take my child out of my arms.. one occasion was when mil was staying over, it was morning and I got up to change her nappy..I went to go back into our bedroom to have morning cuddles and smiles with my wife, when all of sudden my mil opens her door, arms up takes her out of my arms, takes her straight downstairs to play with her, I was in shock and all I could here downstairs was “nana.. nana” another example but this time I was expecting it and I wasn’t allowing it to happen to me again, we were staying around her house, my baby was having a nap on me, she woke up and was making noises, not properly crying but close to tears, for a few seconds which she does after all her naps because she was hungry, my wife was sitting next to me, I was waiting for my wife to get ready to feed her, my mil jumps up off the sofa arms out “I’ll rock her” I said “no she’s just hungry and wants feeding, I then passed her to my wife who wasnt quite ready to feed but wasn’t getting her snatched from my arms again. She was taken back by this.

3- entitlement! mil bought us a pram which was very generous of her, but I feel she thinks that means she’s entitled to push her whenever it comes out. We visited them last weekend and we went for a walk and my wife used our baby carrier as it’s sometimes easier then pushing a pram and it’s nice to be close to the baby. My mil says “I don’t like the carrier it means I can’t look at her and push her” which annoyed me because I work so i don’t often get to the parenting things like pushing her in a pram, accept on weekends and I thought that if we took the pram that moment would had been taken away from me. We have never got the pram out in her company and her not grab it and push it immediately, got given anyone else the option to push her.

4- always calling to find out how the baby is. We had to take our child to a chiropractor as she had lower back pain. Within 10mins of us coming out she was phoning, I felt like she thinks she’s the third parent! My parents waiting till the next day to ask, I’m quite fortunate that my parents give us space and are not the interfering type. I know it can be harder when it’s the fathers mil that is interfering.

5- on a recent visit to my Mil we arrived late around 7:30pm which happened to be our baby’s nap time mil was taken back and disappointed saying “oh but it’s my time with her” we left our baby in her car seat in the lounge with the visor Down, making it dark for her. Mil was itching to look at her, we said “no she’s sleeping” I also said “ it will mess up our routine if you wake her up” we went back and forth to the car unloading stuff, I heard mil husband saying “don’t do it” then mil comes in to the bedroom and says “she’s awake” mil obsession with her meant she had to open the visor and look at her causing her to wake up. She denies it but it was Blatantly obvious she did.

I was chatting to my wife about it but understandably being her mother she sees nothing wrong with it, but I can’t help but think something isn’t right, I may be making mountains out of mole hills but I’d like to know other people’s opinions on the matter.

Thank you

Off subject but How on earth did you know your 12 week old had lower back pain?! And if she was in pain why didn’t you take her to a doctor??

sesquipedalian · 10/11/2024 11:34

I think at the moment, you are making mountains out of molehills - it’s natural to be protective of your new baby, and your MIL clearly wants to be involved. If your wife doesn’t think she’s overstepping the mark, then on balance she probably isn’t. Saying “Nana” all the time - not a problem. It won’t be your child’s first word, and if she makes some noise that Nana interprets as “Nana”, does it really matter? Taking her out of your arms - she’s trying to help, even if that’s not how you interpret it. Just tell her, “The baby’s fine: just leave her with me.” Pram - of course she wants to push her grandchild! I would guess it hasn’t even crossed her mind that you don’t get much of an opportunity to do it - in her head, you’re around the baby far more than she is. It’s not an unreasonable thing for a grandparent to want to do. Calling to find out how the baby is - this is as much calling to find out how her daughter is. Ask your wife: if she says it’s too much, then maybe think about how you can have a word, but clearly, she means well. Waking the baby up - not OK. But it will need your wife to say to her mother, “Please can you just let the baby be when she’s sleeping? I don’t want to mess up her routine” and to make it clear to her mother where the boundaries are. Your baby is still very young, and clearly your MIL is very excited about her new granddaughter. Allow her to be a bit excited - you’d be disappointed if she weren’t! Things will settle down - but do allow her a little “Nana” time without thinking that she’s intent on taking over.

Shinyandnew1 · 10/11/2024 11:36

ApiratesaysYarrr · 10/11/2024 11:29

"We had to take our child to a chiropractor as she had lower back pain. "

A 12 week old? If your 12 week old non verbal baby genuinely has back pain, they need to see a dr urgently, not a chiropracter.

I thought that!

Woodenbones198901 · 10/11/2024 11:39

TouchOfSilverShampoo · 10/11/2024 10:50

And why say that? Because the poster is a man?

Op - Your MIL sounds incredibly over excited and annoying. You need a chat with your wife about your boundaries and your time with the baby. Why are you spending so much time with her?

You might find it tapers off when the baby is at toddler age and it's more difficult to swoop in and snatch up but you do need to start drawing some firm lines otherwise she turns into the sort of MIL who will judge your every movement (school choices, holidays etc etc).

She is definitely over excited which is nice but I feel like she’s over the top with her excitement!

we don’t actually see her that much, but when we do it’s usually for a weekend because they live about 50mins away

Mil has spoken about moving to our village but I have said to my wife that it can not happen

OP posts:
MrsGlennBulb · 10/11/2024 11:41

ApiratesaysYarrr · 10/11/2024 11:29

"We had to take our child to a chiropractor as she had lower back pain. "

A 12 week old? If your 12 week old non verbal baby genuinely has back pain, they need to see a dr urgently, not a chiropracter.

Yes, a proper doctor - not these chiropractors who have somehow been allowed to call themselves doctors (a whole other thread). Your baby needs to see a GP.

Nanny0gg · 10/11/2024 11:42

Woodenbones198901 · 10/11/2024 11:39

She is definitely over excited which is nice but I feel like she’s over the top with her excitement!

we don’t actually see her that much, but when we do it’s usually for a weekend because they live about 50mins away

Mil has spoken about moving to our village but I have said to my wife that it can not happen

You can't stop her...

Some of what she does is normal, some is irritating. Most people speak in the third person when talking to babies/small children.
Waking the baby up is not on

Please elaborate on the back pain? How could you possibly know and you really take a baby to a chiropractor??
And don't leave her in the car seat for too long, that will help

Shinyandnew1 · 10/11/2024 11:42

Woodenbones198901 · 10/11/2024 11:39

She is definitely over excited which is nice but I feel like she’s over the top with her excitement!

we don’t actually see her that much, but when we do it’s usually for a weekend because they live about 50mins away

Mil has spoken about moving to our village but I have said to my wife that it can not happen

You can’t actually stop anyone moving to your village!

sushiandarollie · 10/11/2024 11:44

Is your wife appreciative of her mother help? Or does she find her overbearing? She does sound overbearing but it’s a difficult one because a new baby is hard and if she was disinterested in your child you wouldn’t like this either? I have no mother in law and my mum never offered help and in all honestly I had an easy baby but my god I found it HARD. I was so envious of my friends mums who would pop over at 7am to help. Don’t get me wrong my parents loved our child and came round to have a cuddle but would not help in any way! It was a year before my mum even did a nappy. So please don’t cut her off/get worked up about the little things. But you NEED to just set boundaries. Don’t have it every weekend she comes over. Have an evening maybe say every Wednesday evening she comes over and just let her have her time and just take an hour out - read a book/go and have a bath /go gym. It’s healthy to let her have her turn. It’s also very common. I find it’s either no help or too much. Where are the MIL who help but respect boundaries?!

Woodenbones198901 · 10/11/2024 11:45

That is what we are doing , she’s over every Monday now, but has said she now wants to come over Sunday so she can do bath time and more time with her, again which is taking over more

OP posts:
TH1NG1E · 10/11/2024 11:46

Itisjustmyopinion · 10/11/2024 11:32

Oh this thread will be interesting. If a regular poster said all this they would be told they are right and to tell MIL to back off

As this poster is a man he will be told he is unreasonable

Typical MN double standards

If a man or woman posted what has been posted I'd think they are making a mountain out of a molehill.

ThatGutsyHedgehog · 10/11/2024 11:49

Woodenbones198901 · 10/11/2024 11:45

That is what we are doing , she’s over every Monday now, but has said she now wants to come over Sunday so she can do bath time and more time with her, again which is taking over more

Twice a week is really over the top
You need to speak to your wife though

Woodenbones198901 · 10/11/2024 11:49

it was lots of little signs, she only ever turned her new one way, she hates her neck being touched, hatesd her car seat, we used to lay her on her back when she was crying and place a rolled up towel under her knees (I do this to help with my lower back) and she wouid stop crying immediately, 3 sessions at the chiropractor abs it’s made an incredible amount of difference. Loves her car seat, sleeps through thr night, and generally a lit happily, it was due to the forceps delivery

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread