Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why have a 'gender reveal' party if you clearly want a specificly a boy or girl?

90 replies

Healingsfall · 22/09/2024 16:48

Couple I know who's baby is due in January had a "reveal" if boy or girl this weekend. He found out at the scan and planned a reveal for his partner and family/friends.

The last few months she has been saying they think it's a boy, he (her partner) would love a boy etc and they are excited to find out what they're having.

They filmed the reveal and posted it on Instagram, and he looks despondent from the outset, and as they pull the confetti tube things and it pops with pink confetti you can see the disappointment on both faces whilst trying to mask disappointment and act happy. If anyone is a Sex and the City fan it's like watching miranda pull the "excited " face when saying it's a boy!

Clearly, all the people in said video thought it was going to be a boy because their reactions as the pink confetti is displayed wasn't a complete reaction of joy, more surprise, and delayed congratulations. It was really weird.

I found out if boy or girl at the birth of both my children and remember being completely thrilled each time. I can't imagine reacting so deflated at the sight of pink or blue confetti having built everyone up what we thought they might be?

OP posts:
Somatic · 22/09/2024 20:38

@Jc2001 @ChocolateLemsip sometimes one (or both) of the parents don’t know and it literally is the first time they find out. I had no idea about this until a colleague had one a few years ago and it was a big fuss to make sure the sonographer didn’t tell them the sex during the scan but instead wrote it down and put it in a sealed envelope. The couple then gave the envelope to the baker who opened it and knew what stereotypical colour to make the inside of the cake.

I can’t believe medical professionals don’t tell them to bugger off tbh.

Evenstar · 22/09/2024 20:49

Thankfully the Guns or Glitter theme doesn’t seem to have arrived here yet 🤢

Why have a 'gender reveal' party if you clearly want a specificly a boy or girl?
ChocolateLemsip · 22/09/2024 20:51

Somatic · 22/09/2024 20:38

@Jc2001 @ChocolateLemsip sometimes one (or both) of the parents don’t know and it literally is the first time they find out. I had no idea about this until a colleague had one a few years ago and it was a big fuss to make sure the sonographer didn’t tell them the sex during the scan but instead wrote it down and put it in a sealed envelope. The couple then gave the envelope to the baker who opened it and knew what stereotypical colour to make the inside of the cake.

I can’t believe medical professionals don’t tell them to bugger off tbh.

Ludicrous

bringincrazyback · 22/09/2024 20:52

Evenstar · 22/09/2024 20:49

Thankfully the Guns or Glitter theme doesn’t seem to have arrived here yet 🤢

I'm speechless. And depressed.

Waitingfordoggo · 22/09/2024 21:03

And why is “what dick or fanny” it has important anyway ?
Why not hair colour reveal ?
Number of fingers reveal ?

So that people will know how to start stereotyping them. So that they know whether to buy pink or blue, dolls or Lego (or indeed guns or glitter). So they know whether the baby will go shopping with mummy or play football with daddy when its older.

There are literally no other reasons why the wider family and friends would need to know.

Because, after all this time, sex stereotypes are more entrenched and more rigid than ever.

That’s what makes the whole thing so depressing and stupid.

wateringcanface · 22/09/2024 21:08

not completely relevant but mirandas face wasn't disappointment in the gender, more that she was indifferent about the gender and didn't get why people were excited

Baby gender reveals are cringe, especially awful when there appears to be disappointment. But sometimes I think disappointment can be mistaken for indifference or hatred of being filmed and observed for a reaction.

Reugny · 23/09/2024 18:01

Somatic · 22/09/2024 20:38

@Jc2001 @ChocolateLemsip sometimes one (or both) of the parents don’t know and it literally is the first time they find out. I had no idea about this until a colleague had one a few years ago and it was a big fuss to make sure the sonographer didn’t tell them the sex during the scan but instead wrote it down and put it in a sealed envelope. The couple then gave the envelope to the baker who opened it and knew what stereotypical colour to make the inside of the cake.

I can’t believe medical professionals don’t tell them to bugger off tbh.

I think it makes the sonographer's job more interesting and joyful especially when sometimes they see unpleasant stuff.

Darkdiamond · 23/09/2024 18:38

With my first child, I went out of my way to avoid finding out the sex of the baby, which was difficult in a country where everybody found out. I thought it would be the most amazing experience to find out at birth, but actually, after a prolonged, terrible labour and EMCS, I didn't care. I was just happy to have survived and felt so strangely out of it and numb. It was such an anticlimax.

With baby number 2, I found out at 16 weeks and it was such a happy day. I remember going for tea and cake afterwards with DH and texting my family and friends and it was such a sweet, lucid moment. It was also a lovely lift around the halfway mark of the pregnancy and was so lovely. Good job I did it, as I had another very difficult delivery and right after the baby was born, I remember saying 'I don't feel well' while they put an oxygen mask on. I ended up quite poorly and am so glad that nice moment wasn't robbed from me either.

Baby number 3, there way never any question that I would find out. My friends, family and colleagues were all so excited gor me to find out and I loved texting them. It was so lovely to narrow down the names and have a better understanding of who this baby was. Because, really, if a sonographer could have told me the baby's eye colour, personality, hair type, if she had dimples or would look like me or my husband or be good at maths, I would have wanted to know all of that too. I wanted to know whatever they had to tell me because I was desperate to find out as much as I could, just because I was so insanely interested! Anod of course, right after birth number 3, baby was struggling to breathe and was whisked off the the NICU and I didn't see them until the next day.

So for me, each birth was arduous in its own way, and none of them had a moment afterwards where I could say 'ahh, finally, my baby!'. Either I was out of it or the baby's health was in danger in the first few moments after birth and I am so glad that I had that little moment for myself of getting to know more about my child while ai could enjoy it.

If I ever got pregnant again and somebody said they would organise a sex reveal and it would just be finding out by seeing if a cake was pink or blue, with my close friends there, would I say no? No, I would probably do it for a laugh! With my last pregnancy everyone was so excited to know and I imagine they would find it fun too, as a light hearted way to lighten the mood when things can be tough. If there was he slightest risk that I could possibly be disappointed then I wouldn't have one as I would need to deal with those feeling privately.

Raveonette · 23/09/2024 19:09

Evenstar · 22/09/2024 20:49

Thankfully the Guns or Glitter theme doesn’t seem to have arrived here yet 🤢

That's absolutely grim

Allswellthatendswelll · 24/09/2024 07:46

Darkdiamond · 23/09/2024 18:38

With my first child, I went out of my way to avoid finding out the sex of the baby, which was difficult in a country where everybody found out. I thought it would be the most amazing experience to find out at birth, but actually, after a prolonged, terrible labour and EMCS, I didn't care. I was just happy to have survived and felt so strangely out of it and numb. It was such an anticlimax.

With baby number 2, I found out at 16 weeks and it was such a happy day. I remember going for tea and cake afterwards with DH and texting my family and friends and it was such a sweet, lucid moment. It was also a lovely lift around the halfway mark of the pregnancy and was so lovely. Good job I did it, as I had another very difficult delivery and right after the baby was born, I remember saying 'I don't feel well' while they put an oxygen mask on. I ended up quite poorly and am so glad that nice moment wasn't robbed from me either.

Baby number 3, there way never any question that I would find out. My friends, family and colleagues were all so excited gor me to find out and I loved texting them. It was so lovely to narrow down the names and have a better understanding of who this baby was. Because, really, if a sonographer could have told me the baby's eye colour, personality, hair type, if she had dimples or would look like me or my husband or be good at maths, I would have wanted to know all of that too. I wanted to know whatever they had to tell me because I was desperate to find out as much as I could, just because I was so insanely interested! Anod of course, right after birth number 3, baby was struggling to breathe and was whisked off the the NICU and I didn't see them until the next day.

So for me, each birth was arduous in its own way, and none of them had a moment afterwards where I could say 'ahh, finally, my baby!'. Either I was out of it or the baby's health was in danger in the first few moments after birth and I am so glad that I had that little moment for myself of getting to know more about my child while ai could enjoy it.

If I ever got pregnant again and somebody said they would organise a sex reveal and it would just be finding out by seeing if a cake was pink or blue, with my close friends there, would I say no? No, I would probably do it for a laugh! With my last pregnancy everyone was so excited to know and I imagine they would find it fun too, as a light hearted way to lighten the mood when things can be tough. If there was he slightest risk that I could possibly be disappointed then I wouldn't have one as I would need to deal with those feeling privately.

I had similar- hideous birth with DS and so spaced out and overwhelmed. I was glad I found out before.

Hopefully the birth for this one I'm pregnant with will be much better but I'll still probably find out. Pregnancy is a long slog so I think nice to have something at the midpoint.

Equally friends have said it's completely magical finding out at the birth. So I think really each to their own.

I also think a bit of cake with close family is fine. It's the big performative social media ones which are a bit naff. Also gender disappointment I have no time for.

SallyWD · 24/09/2024 07:52

I really dislike gender reveal parties. It only matters to the parents, maybe some grandparents too. It just seems so self involved to invite loads of people to witness a gender reveal.

CameltoeParkerBowles · 24/09/2024 07:56

Circumferences · 22/09/2024 16:50

All I can say is why on earth does anyone have a gender reveal anyway
Literally, who else cares what sex your baby is. No one. That's who.

Nailed it in the very first post. Who gives a shit, apart from the parents? No-one.

FitAt50 · 24/09/2024 08:00

Because they are common.

Darkdiamond · 24/09/2024 13:06

Allswellthatendswelll · 24/09/2024 07:46

I had similar- hideous birth with DS and so spaced out and overwhelmed. I was glad I found out before.

Hopefully the birth for this one I'm pregnant with will be much better but I'll still probably find out. Pregnancy is a long slog so I think nice to have something at the midpoint.

Equally friends have said it's completely magical finding out at the birth. So I think really each to their own.

I also think a bit of cake with close family is fine. It's the big performative social media ones which are a bit naff. Also gender disappointment I have no time for.

Totally. Ultimately, there are things that do go along with what sex of reproductive organs your child has. I like having names for just one sex picked and I like picking clothes with the sex in mind. I actually enjoy that specific process as its fun. Like, as backward as it probably makes me seem on mumsnet, I liked going through just girls' names when I knew I was having a girl, and wouldn't have bought a pink flowery baby grow had I known I was having a boy. I found picking stereotypical, traditional, gender conforming outfits for the baby more fun than neutral outfits and yellows and greens.

I like that stuff. It's fun. It's part of the anticipation of finding out more about this person. I got 3D scans of the babies towards the end and was obsessed with those too, looking at their faces and imagining them in 'real life'.

I found that finding out in pregnancy meant the surprises were more spaced out in a way which I personally enjoyed. There does tend to be a weird snobbery around finding out before the birth from some people who love the surprise when the baby is born, and think it's wortht he wait to find out at the end. However, a lot of those 'Team Yellow' fanatics are actually placing a huge emphasis on the baby's sex by wanting the birth to be the ultimate setting for finding out the sex.

Most people have a normal, balanced attitude towards other people's attitudes, but with some people I just think 'Give over, you're the one deliberately avoiding knowing some basic anatomical information about your child in order to make the build up to finding out as climatic as possible, and actually, the ultimate 'gender reveal'!

mrlistersgelfbride · 24/09/2024 13:10

Yep, 100% agree. It's nuts!
My sister in law was clearly disappointed at her gender reveal when she discovered it was a boy.

Knowing I'd have gender disappointment was actually the main reason I didn't find out the gender.
I don't know why more people don't do it.
Best suprise I've ever had 😊

New posts on this thread. Refresh page