Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Only the middle class and above think that Class isn't a thing any more.

351 replies

FindingMeno · 11/09/2024 05:53

Just that really.
If you're working class it's as plain as the nose on your face.

OP posts:
Leah5678 · 12/09/2024 18:18

It's the other way roun. Evidenced by Mumsnet where most people are middle class or even higher but constantly go on about this stuff. Lots of rich people on this website who claim to be broke too, and "champagne socialists' as they're called. Plus people going on about how even though they earn 100k+ a year they're are still working class because their grandma was.

OhMaria2 · 12/09/2024 18:18

MidnightPatrol · 11/09/2024 06:13

Is there some context to this…?

Does there need to be?

2Old2BABPpresenter · 12/09/2024 18:19

FindingMeno · 11/09/2024 05:53

Just that really.
If you're working class it's as plain as the nose on your face.

Fuck, DP is right then that we are middle class 🤦🏼‍♀️🤣🤦🏼‍♀️🤣

OhMaria2 · 12/09/2024 18:21

FindingMeno · 11/09/2024 06:39

If you're working class you know you're working class.

This times a thousand.

Budgies99 · 12/09/2024 18:22

But what do you mean by class?

Do you mean economic level?

Does everyone not treat everyone as an equal? I do this, so 🤔

Budgies99 · 12/09/2024 18:27

FindingMeno · 11/09/2024 14:09

Many ways, mostly to do with lack of opportunity.
Dear.

What is holding you back? What opportunities are you lacking?

AtYourOwnRisk · 12/09/2024 18:32

Rhaenys · 12/09/2024 18:13

I grew up MC and it’s only negatively affected once in my life*, and it’s only now I’m realising just how much of a positive impact being MC has had on me.

I think in terms of social mobility, you can become MC if you’re born WC, but if you’re born MC you can’t become WC, no matter what you end up doing career wise. I first came to realise this after coming across Ann Russell on TikTok. She went to a private school but has spent the majority of her working life as cleaner. She still identifies as MC. I too went to a private school but have only ever done menial jobs, yet I still identify as MC. I acknowledge the opportunities I had throughout my childhood and the connections I made still have a positive impact on me even now.

*For sixth form I decided to go to a community college for a bit of ‘life experience’. One of our tutors incorrectly told the class that I’d been to a more prestigious private school than the one I went to, and from then on everyone treated me differently and I was dismissed as “the posh bird”.

But isn’t that less to do with your MC status than your teacher (nastily) lying about you? I mean, if your peers didn’t have any issue with your accent, self-presentation, previous education etc until he told them you’d gone to a more prestigious school than you had?

fliptopbin · 12/09/2024 18:34

SleepGoalsJumped · 12/09/2024 15:40

@Bushmillsbabe
You don't have to answer these, but here's a few markers:

Do you say Red Sauce or Ketchup?

Napkin or Serviette?

Toilet or loo?

When you didn't hear, do you say pardon, sorry or something else? What about if you burp?

Do you care which piece of cutlery gets used for what in a meal?

How do you thank people?

Is it a lounge, living room or sitting room and does it contain a sofa or settee?

What is your evening meal called and what is the final course called?

Is your progenatrix mother, mummy, ma, or mum (and how often do you drop obscure latin terms into what you say?)

That's just a few linguistic markers. There are also loads connected with taste in decor, furniture, books, music, cultural entertainment, how milestones are celebrated etc etc. And whilst many people will ernestly protest that none of these matter, people still clock them and notice if someone is using options on any of these that they don't expect.

Lots of these are regional rather than class based. ( The linguistic ones, specifically).

Budgies99 · 12/09/2024 18:36

fliptopbin · 12/09/2024 18:34

Lots of these are regional rather than class based. ( The linguistic ones, specifically).

Edited

But does anything of this matter?

fliptopbin · 12/09/2024 18:38

Budgies99 · 12/09/2024 18:36

But does anything of this matter?

I don't think so myself. Evidently others do though.

Budgies99 · 12/09/2024 18:40

Each to their own, live and let live.

Live your life, set your own goals, step towards them. Or be happy with your goal, be chilled and happy.

Do the best we can.

Rhaenys · 12/09/2024 18:42

AtYourOwnRisk · 12/09/2024 18:32

But isn’t that less to do with your MC status than your teacher (nastily) lying about you? I mean, if your peers didn’t have any issue with your accent, self-presentation, previous education etc until he told them you’d gone to a more prestigious school than you had?

To be fair to him, he didn’t say it nastily at all. It was more “oh Rhaenys went to X, didn’t you?!” We all had the same regional accent too, it wasn’t like they were cockneys and I spoke with RP. 😂 It was so unexpected and quite shocking the way things changed and I ended up leaving.

Leah5678 · 12/09/2024 18:53

Fangirl79 · 11/09/2024 13:39

Has anyone else noticed cultural or class appropriation by MC of WC? For example in the Civil Service, where senior mandarins have to sign up to social mobility pledges and race to shed any UMC markers, start vocally supporting a football team and dropping their (metaphorical) aitches? Parents worried their children are less likely to get into Oxbridge finding ways to suggest deprivation in UCAS forms, the roll call of humble ancestors who would previously have been airbrushed out, now cited to refute accusations of priviledge? Now that certain opportunities are being directed at less advantaged young people for social mobility purposes, and class has become a contested concept, it's like people want to enjoy the fruits of higher class but cos play lower class in order to scoop up any affirmative action goodies. An example from my own experience- the Cambridge-educated DD of a Judge and a hospital consultant applying for Civil Service internship described as the child of an 'NHS worker'.
So to answer the original post, I don't think it's a question of MC and above being unaware of class, more being unaware of their priviledge whilst increasingly alarmed that their class is under fire, so pretending it doesn't exist.
And then at the top of the pyramid are those who confidently know what their class is, so don't need to keep obsessing about it.

Yup especially on Mumsnet, on one thread you'll see posters saying how 100k household income isn't enough to reproduce and on the other thread the same people are sob storying about how they're "working class" and broke 🤣

Seriously the title of the thread should be the other way round I see way more moaning about class on this site than I ever heard when I was living in a shelter for homeless mums and babies.

The average person earns half of what the average mumsnetter earns and moans about being broke half as much too

CurlewKate · 12/09/2024 19:25

@Budgies99 "Live your life, set your own goals, step towards them. Or be happy with your goal, be chilled and happy. "

That's a bit "rich man at his castle, poor man at the gate"

There are many people whose goals are limited by circumstances beyond their control. As a society, we should be doing our best to broaden the opportunities available to our kids.

CurlewKate · 12/09/2024 19:34

". An example from my own experience- the Cambridge-educated DD of a Judge and a hospital consultant applying for Civil Service internship described as the child of an 'NHS worker"

Pictures or it didn't happen.

VeneziaJ · 12/09/2024 19:38

Nellodee · 11/09/2024 06:43

You know you’re working class when you struggle to get your passport photo signed.

And middle class when you can sign one 😂

Beautifulweeds · 12/09/2024 19:54

Erm no! There always has been and most likely always will be a view of what class we are all in. The few seconds of saying what you do and how you live your life is a label.

He's posh, she's a skank, they're scroungers, they're rich etc. Hopefully and generally IME it doesn't matter, dig deeper. People are people no matter the background 🙄

Apollobinds · 12/09/2024 21:20

I grew up in a WC family (or maybe even underclass) unemployed parents on benefits, council house, poverty, prison stays, drug/alcohol abuse.
I have married a MC man, his dad a civil servant, mum a SAHP. Homeowners, car each, savings to pay for daughters wedding, numerous holidays abroad.
DH is lovely however sometimes I have to get him to ‘check his privilege’.
I’ve told him about this post. His response was that class doesn’t exist anymore!! I think only a MC person could say that!

I still consider myself WC despite now having a life similar to the one I described for DH parents.

I also didn’t know anyone who could sign my first passport photos. My work colleagues mum had to do it, she was the only person I vaguely knew who had a professional job.

Lwrenn · 12/09/2024 21:42

Apollobinds · 12/09/2024 21:20

I grew up in a WC family (or maybe even underclass) unemployed parents on benefits, council house, poverty, prison stays, drug/alcohol abuse.
I have married a MC man, his dad a civil servant, mum a SAHP. Homeowners, car each, savings to pay for daughters wedding, numerous holidays abroad.
DH is lovely however sometimes I have to get him to ‘check his privilege’.
I’ve told him about this post. His response was that class doesn’t exist anymore!! I think only a MC person could say that!

I still consider myself WC despite now having a life similar to the one I described for DH parents.

I also didn’t know anyone who could sign my first passport photos. My work colleagues mum had to do it, she was the only person I vaguely knew who had a professional job.

We've similar sounding family backgrounds and if you don't mind me asking, was it a culture shock being around your DHs family?
My dps family are WC, just larger and more educated and hard working than my family. I adore them, I'd be very proud of my family if they'd had even a wee bit of the values my partners family have.

I met some really nice MC men before DP and I got together and I didn't entertain anything more than casual dating with them because of my own insecurity about my family background.
The idea of a nice family with a garden without a sofa in it was just a bit too terrifying when I was younger 😂

keffie12 · 12/09/2024 21:50

I wouldn't know what you would call me then. I was bought up in a middle class professional family.

It was my mom side that was this. My father was good stock from poverty in a village who made good.

He was in the RAF. He was allowed to date my mom (yes you read that right) because my mom was 30 and the family and extended needed to get mom "off the shelf" My dad's credentials on the surface looked good. That's the simple basics.

I recreated my childhood in adult which in therapy speak is known today as affluent neglect/abuse.

Ex came from "good stock" too 🙄 Irish background family worked in good trade jobs.

I fled finally abuse from him after 16 years, and we went through the fires of hell with the aftermath. We is my 4 youngsters with him. We ended up in the whole system of this country.

Because I am educated etc I was able to come through it all, rebuild my life and my children. Believe me knowing this system as i do I wasn't supposed too. Background helped me fight appropriately. My sheer tenacity and indomitable spirit I have as I was told was the only reason i came through it with my family in tack.

We were involved with children services and believe me all I will say is the system is needed but doesn't work and still doesn't.

I turned to alcohol to cope. I am now 21 years sober.

I got rehoused in social housing in a very nice place (not inner city social housing) Yes I happily remarried a good decent man from Welsh stock this time

I'm still classed as middle class because I speak well etc etc. Even because of where I live. It's considered affluent even in social housing where I am.

My grown children are all university degrees, good jobs and happy families. 2 live abroad with their families.

So what are we? Ecletic yup - in layman's terms, here's a new class for you "fcuked up" 🤣

Class in the 2 countries 2 of my 4 live in doesn’t really exist. Two here are classed as middle class as in there jobs and homes, backgrounds and there wives backgrounds

2 of 5 of my grandchildren are mixed race. We don't fit into any darn box 🤣 You can shove the box up your

Me I'm a citizen of the U.K and the world.

We all come into the world the same way and go out the same way. It maybe nicer for some than others. At its core we are all the same. Its the - (dash) - in the middle that matters as to how you live your life

That's my 2 penneth for what it's worth on it all

I'm me and that's it

Flatspat · 12/09/2024 21:52

As a MC person who predominantly works with WC people, immigrants and refugees and in general people who need a professional level of support in my area (which I won't say because it's very outing!) I believe strongly that the difference between WC and MC people is the knowledge of how to spend money wisely, save and plan. It's something that can be learned and you can move up and down.
I work with many WC people who have far higher incomes than me and I have a decent salary but they are still living in rented accommodation so the property is never paid off, the children don't have the benefit of tutors and clubs that most middle class parents would scrimp and save for the mindset of i didn't do it and it didn't hurt me is strong. Many have big all inclusive holidays and a lease car that take up massive amounts of money and they will pay these off monthly spending everything with nothing show for it and hitting their overdraft before tge next payday.
I know not everyone who is WC earns that or does this but it's something most MC people wouldn't do. Most of my MC friends buy 2nd hand cars, keep hold of them and holiday in the UK most years with an occasional overseas holiday choosing to save, pay into a pension, pay off mortgages, tutors and clubs for children. Most have enough in the bank to live a few months if there is an issue with work.
I don't want to cause any offence and this is just my observation of working for years with this group of people.

VickyPollard25 · 12/09/2024 22:40

bigvig · 11/09/2024 07:14

This absolutely. The biggest factor holding back social mobility is not race, sexuality or gender - it's class. Everyone who is poor knows that.

This made me think of Gary Stevenson. I wouldn’t have understood how this was true before I heard him explain how he didn’t know about university systems and what it took to get the right jobs. I’d really recommend everyone listens to him speak - it’s eye opening.

Fangirl79 · 12/09/2024 23:22

CurlewKate · 12/09/2024 19:34

". An example from my own experience- the Cambridge-educated DD of a Judge and a hospital consultant applying for Civil Service internship described as the child of an 'NHS worker"

Pictures or it didn't happen.

Can't help with pictures but it did happen. She was a lovely, bright girl, keen to join the CS fast stream. She was placed in my Directorate for the summer in her long vac before her final year. She was an excellent prospect, but the Department specifically wanted work experience opportunities to be reserved for social mobility cases. Her application listed her parent as an 'NHS worker'. It was only as we got to know her the reality of her background emerged.

flashspeed · 13/09/2024 00:04

Now all of the people who want to look middle class will stride into threads on class saying "class? what do you meeeeean? class isn't a thing anymore!"😂

sarahzbaker · 13/09/2024 01:57

It's so stupid. Working class people can and are, be very intelligent. Bunch of poo