Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Did you grow up calling your parents by their first names?

108 replies

annaak · 07/06/2024 18:38

I had a friend in primary school whose family did this - her Mum and Dad were always Sarah and Rick to their kids. My Mum used to hate it, she thought it was really affected. It really bothered her for some reason!

They weren’t especially hippy people, just quite relaxed middle class artsy parents (lots of music lessons and drama classes etc. in their house). I always quite liked the vibe of it and wondered if I would do the same with my own kids one day.

Anyway, got me wondering did any of you grow up doing this, or are any of you bringing up your children this way? Did you/do you find people are weird about it?

OP posts:
WaftherAngelsthroughtheskies · 08/06/2024 11:50

MinPinSins · 08/06/2024 08:17

I did this for my entire childhood (so they were never anything but their names). Some of these responses are bizarre, an suggest a lot of insecurity if their parental relationship hinges on a name. For me and my brother, it was because we had a childhood nanny who used their names, so it was normal to us. Once we knew their names, we weren't going to call them Mum or Dad when we know they are actually Janet and Steve! We were strong willed children, and not willing to call them the 'wrong' thing!

Some people in person did react as weirdly as people on here. The worst was after my parents split up, my father had a gf who found it so weird, she would call him dad to try to encourage us to. Like 'can you pass this to dad?'. I really don't understand why it matters to anyone.

My son can call me whatever he wants (as long as it's not offensive), but he's 11 weeks so can't talk yet!

The thing is, @MinPinSins it's not about parents' insecurity in emphasising their relationship through a name, it's about giving security and confidence to the child. It reinforces subconsciously that this child has an unconditional claim on that adult. Can you really think it's bizarre or weird for parents to think that use of parental titles is a good thing?

HaroldAndThePurpleCrayon · 09/06/2024 01:20

No, I never did. However, I imagine that it might sound quite posh, daring and unconventional if your parents have names like Genevieve Rose and Montgomery Lewis; just plain Chuck and Edna doesn’t have the same hip and glamour factor.

maras2 · 09/06/2024 02:07

Tried it once in 1959.
I can still visualise the death stare from my Mum.😱

positivewings · 09/06/2024 06:18

I've always called my mum by her name it's normal in our family to use names.
My mum said it's my name mum isn't on my birth certificate.
My sister's kids call her by her name.
My kids call me mum.

Donkeysdontdance · 09/06/2024 06:36

My cousin did this just to show us all how intelligent she is. Bore off

Pickled21 · 09/06/2024 06:47

Nope but we are south asian and it would be considered rude. I wouldn't like it if my kids called me by my name. I'm their mum, I don't mind what variation of that they use. Dd says mum, ds says mama and dd2 says mummy.

dumpertruckbigmouth · 09/06/2024 08:19

I went through a very short phase in my teens, when I feel out with my parents so I referred to them as 'Mr [Surname]' and 'Mrs [Surname]'. I did this deliberately to deny them the status of 'Mum' and 'Dad'. I think the phase lasted about two days before we all burst into laughter.

The only times that my (now adult) sons have called me by my first name was when they were imitating their (abusive) father, so I really would not like them to do this.

However, I do know families in which children refer to their parents by their first names, and this works very well for them.

ClonedSquare · 09/06/2024 09:00

No, and I don't know anyone who does. I'd find it very odd or probably assume it was a step-parent or foster-parent scenario.

I get sad that my 2.5 year old sometimes calls me mum not mummy. Definitely wouldn't be happy with him using my name!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page