Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Feeling that I will never belong anywhere because I am mixed race.

104 replies

thisplaceiscraziness · 01/06/2024 13:02

Off the back of another thread I thought it of interest to ask here on experiences of being mixed race or how you see mixed race people . I often feel like I don’t belong in any community.
I feel judged for not being enough of one race or another.

Seen as black but not accepted as such by the community due to being lighter skinned. Often being rejected or seen as trying to be black.

Not feeling like the white community fully accept me, exclusion from social events or conversations or worse, being hounded by assumptions and the idea that it’s ok to talk to me about race or immigration in an offensive way as i’m mixed and 3rd generation.

I experience racism & exclusion for being black and the same for not being black enough.

I shamefully veer from immersing myself in black culture/ politics to avoiding it for feeling stupid or like an imposter.

I don’t know where else I can ask anonymously and get honest responses.

I have realised am 35 and don’t know where I belong. I have 4 children and don’t want to pass this lack of self worth on to them.

Can anyone relate or tell me how you view mixed race people?

OP posts:
MsLuxLisbon · 01/06/2024 16:42

MurielThrockmorton · 01/06/2024 14:13

I am bisexual and there are perhaps some parallels there, we all have a personal identity but also different social identities to fit into the people around us and help us to refine who we are (in psychology this is Social Identity Theory / Self-categorisation Theory). There's no real bisexual community, there are lots of misconceptions about us from heterosexuals, but we are also often rejected by lesbians (I lost my lesbian friendship group after 10 years of being in relationships with women when I started to see a man). Research shows that the mental health of bisexual people is worse than that of lesbians and gay men, probably because there is no natural community. This not fitting into one place or another is probably similar with race and ethnicity.

I don't think you can compare something invisible, such as sexual orientation, with something as visible as race.

MurielThrockmorton · 01/06/2024 17:01

I don't think you can compare something invisible, such as sexual orientation, with something as visible as race.

It's not just about what people see though, it's about whether you feel you have a sense of community, and that goes much deeper than just what people look like. It's not so much strangers' reaction to you. It's about your relationships and the groups that you fit within. Having people who understand you and share similar experiences as you and have your back is important to all of us. if we don't see our experiences reflected in other people, we can feel what's known as existential loneliness, which some studies indicate is one of the worst sorts of loneliness to experience.

maddening · 01/06/2024 17:09

All.my heritage is white but my dad's parents were immigrants from eastern Europe and I grew up.with both UK and my eastern European heritage/culture. When I meet people from that or neighbouring countries I don't feel shunned by them - it is just nice to share a bit of that heritage. I guess that only my surname indicates anything different about me and British people (regardless of colour) ask about it's origin and are always nice when I explain. As per pp there is a difference as it is not Visual through skin colour.

WandsOut · 01/06/2024 17:13

My daughter is mixed race and says there is zero education or awareness ever brought up in school about this or discussed as part of any diversity in her school.

Beigel · 01/06/2024 17:17

I feel as if I don't have a community either. I'm mixed culture (I tick the 'White other' box on forms), bisexual and high masking AuDHD. I have developed a deep sense of being inauthentic that I never used to feel growing up.
I wonder whether the whole 'culture wars' thing has played into my feelings? Before the concept of cultural appropriation was widely known, I remember feeling comfortable with claiming little bits of identity from here and there.

DoritosFries · 01/06/2024 17:19

WandsOut · 01/06/2024 17:13

My daughter is mixed race and says there is zero education or awareness ever brought up in school about this or discussed as part of any diversity in her school.

Depends on the school my son is mixed and his school does a lot to raise awareness but this is a diverse school in London. So perhaps that's more down to where you live.

WandsOut · 01/06/2024 17:21

vivainsomnia · 01/06/2024 15:02

I'm white but consider mixed race as a race of its own. Maybe it is time to use another word than 'mixed'.

But it's not a race of its own. It's having mixed heritage, coming from different backgrounds and a need to feel embraced and welcomed in both, as well as being accepted wherever you have landed.

Mixed heritage or mixed race replaces words which caused offence.

Other wise what word can people use to describe themselves? I'm also mixed race. I'm not a new race of my own. I'm the combination of two different people from two different places. I belong in both cultures. I'm not a new race.

sunflowrsngunpowdr · 01/06/2024 17:21

VeryGoodVeryNiceChickenNugget · 01/06/2024 13:55

I'm mixed, also 3rd gen. I personally couldn't care less how people view me.

I grew up in a very diverse area, in London though where race or ethnicity has never been a problem. I went to school with a lot of 2nd gen kids so ethnicity just was what it was and no one thought anything of it.

We were all brought up in English London culture though, religion and not eating bacon sandwiches was kept for keeping your mum happy, church and sundays.

I identify as English and have always been accepted as.

My white, working class husband has experienced more prejudice (recently, from white middle class liberals no less) than I ever have. I've experienced none.

This is also my experience. I think being born in London makes a massive difference. I've never experienced real racism although there were definitely times at school when I was picked on by some black girls for not being black enough or trying too hard to be white. These days it's more common to see overt racism directed at white people by white peoples and others too 🤷🏽‍♀️

WandsOut · 01/06/2024 17:23

@DoritosFries that's really good to know - we live in Scotland so it's just generally batshit here.

If there are any resources or videos etc that you have that I can share with my daughter's school that would be great.

Lavenderflower · 01/06/2024 17:24

I cannot relate to your experience. However, I grew up in London with lots of mixed race people.

mitogoshi · 01/06/2024 17:24

How do I see mixed race people? Like people, honestly I have no opinion from a race perspective as it's not something that matters at all but it's interesting trying to work out interesting mixes from a purely curiosity perspective eg I have half English half Japanese friends and they look Hispanic/Polynesian, whereas another friend is half Pakistani, 1/4 Scottish and 1/4 Cote D'ivoire- she's absolutely gorgeous by the way, jaw droppingGrin

It's just pigment at the end of the day though, all the same underneath, but I do know some ethnic communities are more colour conscious than us pasty white types! I can't imagine being in your shoes not feeling like i belong though i can reassure you than I like most people really are not bothered

WandsOut · 01/06/2024 17:24

There's also the racism that comes from our own family members when we've married out of the expected cultural norms.

VeryStressedMum · 01/06/2024 17:28

I am mixed race (not black). I never cared what colour anyone was but in high school it became apparent that one side didn't accept me. I don't know if it's because I'm white passing (light olive) and my skin was so much lighter than theirs or if it was just because I was mixed and it would have been the same whatever my skin looked like.
White people however accepted me with no reference to my race. This is probably as I more or less looked white and everyone assumed I was English.
I married a white person and our children are really white. All my friends are white (I live in a predominantly white area) they know I am mixed race and it's never been brought up.
I would love friends of all cultures but unfortunately my experience is they don't want to be friends with me.

vivainsomnia · 01/06/2024 17:34

But it's not a race of its own
I know that. My point is that that's how I perceive it nowadays, especially 3rd generation. After all, many people are mixed race, it's just a question of how others perceive us and which race we feel we belong to most.

QuickFinish · 01/06/2024 17:39

My adult kids are dark skinned and it's hard to know where they are from. They also have generic foreign expat accents. They look and sound nothing like me. I find it strange that if you ask them where they are from they don't have a set answer but it doesn't seem to bother them in the slightest. I find it odd as I 'feel' English (also British) It's interesting chatting to them about it. I think the fact they are close and are all in the same position as siblings makes it ok.

One was called a 'foreigner' and berated for stealing English people's jobs once but apart from that they say they've never been aware of experiencing any racism.

They don't seem to have any need to belong to any ethnic or cultural group or any nationality.

SaltedCaramels · 01/06/2024 17:44

You might be interested in the stories here mixedracefaces.com/mrfhome

MsLuxLisbon · 01/06/2024 17:50

MurielThrockmorton · 01/06/2024 17:01

I don't think you can compare something invisible, such as sexual orientation, with something as visible as race.

It's not just about what people see though, it's about whether you feel you have a sense of community, and that goes much deeper than just what people look like. It's not so much strangers' reaction to you. It's about your relationships and the groups that you fit within. Having people who understand you and share similar experiences as you and have your back is important to all of us. if we don't see our experiences reflected in other people, we can feel what's known as existential loneliness, which some studies indicate is one of the worst sorts of loneliness to experience.

I still don't think you can compare orientation and race. Two completely different things and I find your comparison to be derailing.

LemonDrizzles · 01/06/2024 17:51

I'm mixed as well. But my family is also mixed so that helps. Growing up,I hung with mixed groups. In adulthood, this has been harder to find. Though I just don't look mixed with some of what I'm mixed with.

LemonDrizzles · 01/06/2024 17:55

Just to add, my mum is mixed with black and Chinese. Dad mixed with Greek Cypriot and English.

Mixedmix · 01/06/2024 17:56

Willyoujustbequiet · 01/06/2024 14:37

I look at it that everyone is mixed really. We're all just layers of different races and people. Especially being British. I laugh when people get so anti English/Scottish whatever because its just flagging up ignorance of their own history.

If anyone judges us because of what we are or how we look rather than our actions then they're dumb and not worth our time.l

I really dislike it when someone tells a mixed race person that 'everyone is mixed race.' I am half white and half Asian. I faced a lot of racism as a child but not so much now (in my 20s). I haven't met anyone the same mix as me apart from my siblings.

thisplaceiscraziness · 01/06/2024 18:00

JacqueIineHyde · 01/06/2024 14:07

My daughter's mixed race and reading things like this makes me sad. I don't want to hijack your post OP, but is there anything your parents/ family could've done to stop you from feeling this way?

I think my experience is marred by some complex upbringing stuff - so perhaps the way i feel on reflection is partly this. So if your not abusive then i’d say your already winning and you clearly care for your daughter.
I suppose i’d just say celebrate all parts of her and just notice her for who she is - as you probably already do.

i heard a great statement today - Michelle obama’s mum died and one of the reflections was that her mum would always say something like - “don’t worry about if other people like you - come home - we will always like you here.”
I wish i was told that as a kid - maybe that’s a good one to say 🥰

OP posts:
MurielThrockmorton · 01/06/2024 18:02

I still don't think you can compare orientation and race. Two completely different things and I find your comparison to be derailing.

I see parallels in being in the middle of different communities without a clear community of your own, and not being accepted by either. People can take it or leave it though, I suggest you just move on.

thisplaceiscraziness · 01/06/2024 18:03

something2say · 01/06/2024 14:46

Hello OP. I am sorry to hear how you feel and so many can relate. I'm another outlier to your discussion, in that I am a white woman BUT I have never felt I fit in either because I experienced child abuse within a moneyed middle class culture, but it was especially violent with shades of sexual abuse, and I cut my entire family off in my 20s, for the sake of my healing, and this combination makes me different from normal people. I have gone through life with a massive burden of psych issues to wade through, and I used to think I didn't fit in anywhere. To survivors, I am rich and posh and it couldn't have been that bad. To my own class, I am a fallen person who must have been bad and deserved it.

I wrote and published my own self help book about ten years ago, having worked in the industry helping survivors of abuse and voilence flee and find safety, and I helped them come to terms with it for so long, parallel with doing my own self help, and one day I thought, you know, I have all this child abuse crap that separates me from others in my mind (Lucky them, none of them understand, look at the mean and ignorant comments I get for not having a family etc etc) and I realised - yes I have that issue, but there are other issues in life that I do not wield, and I am thankful for that. It was quite a profound moment of realisation and it helped me a lot.

I also think (being a new age hippy now) that we have come into the age of Aquarius, which says that we are all diverse and different but we all matter and are of equal value. So when I look around I think, that person has suffered lots of death, that one had an accident, that one lost a baby, that person is not very well, that person lost a parent young and so on, whatever it may be, and I can see that myself, that person who suffered child abuse and cut her family off in order to heal - that's my lot, and I bear it and look more kindly on others bearing other things. I feel I belong with them and the 'normal people' are other to us, except there aren't too many 'normal people' because everyone seems to bear something at some point in their life. I have worked with 'others' all my career really and we are one big happy group now, where everyone gets to self express and be who they are and find their way.

I'm sorry you field so many stupid comments and that this issue is being thrust onto your back for no good reason. I'm sorry you feel different. I too feel different. I think lots of us privately do.

Sorry for the long post x I just wanted to say hi from another 'other' x

I love this and wish I knew you in real life - could you let me know your book, given my life i might find it helpful 🥰

OP posts:
thisplaceiscraziness · 01/06/2024 18:09

Thanks so much to everyone - i’m in a real period of self adjustment and awareness and trying to iron out my kinks etc
I think reading all of your responses regardless of if your mixed or not the general consensus seems to be this is much more about how we see ourselves as we can do sweet nothing about how others see us.
I can see how the bisexual experience has so many commonalities - thanks for your thoughts.

If anything this thread has taught me a few things about the focus being on coming back to myself.
I have certainly been affected by the US race discourse and this is probably what triggered my sense of alienation.
I grew up in a white middle class area and my black family have a lot of trauma / generational issues which i think meant i could never fully benefit from the culture which saddens me greatly.

I think that i’ve just got a bit lost overall and need to just get back to finding joy.
I do have friends and family that care for me , i think the thing i’ve been doing is swinging away from caring for myself and looking for reasons that im not right.

i make myself not fit in and it’s probably deeper than my skin colour!
Id really like to be friends with each of you !
here’s to being human - however that comes !

OP posts:
something2say · 01/06/2024 18:18

My book is called Purple Dragon Mother: Healing from Child Abuse xxx