Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have expected my daughters to be flower girls

1000 replies

Notmotherofflowergirls · 06/04/2024 16:02

Just created an account for people to pile on to me and tell me I am an idiot. I don’t think I can tell my real friends.
I am inwardly cringing!
My brother is getting married in 3 months time to a woman with no nieces or nephews.
My mother and I naturally assumed that my two girls 4 and 6 would be the flower girls. There are no other kids in the family although stepdad has grandchildren.
My mother was feeling left out of all the planning. DB was uncommunicative about the plans and always referred us to SiL and when my mum asked to contribute she was batted away.
Finally Mum insisted that she would buy the flower girl dresses and finally brother agreed. So on Wednesday SiL posted an invoice for three flower girl dresses from a Shop in Dublin. She included a nice note saying that she mustn’t feel obliged to pay.
My mum asked who the third dress was for: it turns out all three are for her cousin’s girls.
Brother came round and said that they will be only kids at wedding.
My brother was asked point blank if he didn’t want his nieces there and all he could say was he would speak with SiL. He did look sheepish.
My dad died and while my mum has not remarried she has been with her partner for 9 years. His kids are not invited. My stepdad isn’t going and is angry that my mum has been made to feel so upset.
I feel as if I have been kicked in the guts. My mum keeps bursting into tears.
My DH says he’s ongoing either Have we overstepped? Would anyone else have made the same assumption?

OP posts:
Winterstormm · 07/04/2024 08:12

polkadotclip · 07/04/2024 07:00

It's not at alll cheeky.

The SIL probably has no idea that the MIL expected the grandchildren to be flower girls, she got a message that MIL would like to contribute to the wedding and would like to pay for dresses.

She sent a message saying this is what the dresses cost, pleaaae don't feel obliged to pay.

She asked children she knows and has a relationship with to be part of her wedding party.

It's completely normal everywhere except Mumsnwt to have a child free wedding except for members of the wedding party. Cousin may be bringing them home early, etc.

Most of the hundred plus weddings I have been to were like this.

Only on Mumsnet do people think that invitations addressed to a couple extend to their 7-child blended family. That's not the real world.

Have a fun time being child free at the wedding and invite BIL and SIL to tea afterwards to as your kids and get to know them.

Going NC is a batshit reaction.

The bride is inviting distant cousins who are children, but not the groom's nieces. Either have a completely child free wedding or invite all the children family members. This isn't a blended family situation as these are the groom's full blood nieces, not step nieces.

And yes the bride is being a CF because the couple didn't tell OP or OP's mum that OP's daughters aren't invited. She could've said 'oh no need to pay as I'm paying for my cousin's children's dresses. They're the only children who have been invited.' They have left it last minute to announce this.

SuperwomansAMyth · 07/04/2024 08:14

InterIgnis · 07/04/2024 08:09

Always the way it seems, in a world where grown ass men famously have zero agency.

What makes me laugh is the ‘he’s being controlled by that witch. Don’t stand for it, YOU tell him what he needs to do!’. As if the problem isn’t actually that he’s being controlled, just that he’s being controlled by the wrong person.

Exactly. I asked my DH if he realised that his mother always blaming me for everything he did that she didn't like was her basically saying he was weak and spineless. He then realised how insulting it was to him personally as well.

SlightlygrumpyBettyswaitress · 07/04/2024 08:16
  1. you have a brother/son problem
  2. see 1) Would be interested in the SIL view. No doubt from the get go she had her cousins kids picked out. No doubt your brother knew this.
NeverBeforeToday · 07/04/2024 08:17

Icouldbehappy · 06/04/2024 20:50

I do say so.
They don’t cross my mind and I don’t care about any aspect of their lives. I’m pretty sure that they don’t care about my family either 😂

I merely commented to empathise with the original OP as it was a fairly similar situation.

What do you mean by “hostile”?
Where have I spoken with hostility?

My younger DS is now 17 so this was years ago. Again, I commented to show that I would have no tolerance for anyone excluding my children from a family event.

I’m sure it’s quite common here for posters to comment on their own experiences, either to agree or disagree with the OP. Or other posters.
I didn’t realise that I needed anyone’s permission before I described a situation of my own.

Your tone is more aggressive than you think. You are coming across a bit Jeremy Kyle/Eastenders and I can only imagine how you behaved in real life about this!

phoenixrosehere · 07/04/2024 08:19

Winterstormm · 07/04/2024 08:12

The bride is inviting distant cousins who are children, but not the groom's nieces. Either have a completely child free wedding or invite all the children family members. This isn't a blended family situation as these are the groom's full blood nieces, not step nieces.

And yes the bride is being a CF because the couple didn't tell OP or OP's mum that OP's daughters aren't invited. She could've said 'oh no need to pay as I'm paying for my cousin's children's dresses. They're the only children who have been invited.' They have left it last minute to announce this.

When did a cousin’s children become distant cousins?!

I have cousins who are older than me and their children are around the same age as me. I have more of a relationship with them than I do my SIL. It is not out of the ordinary.

The bride did say that OP’s mum didn’t have to pay. The mum kept insisting on contributing and wouldn’t drop it. The mum could have left it alone, didn’t and offered herself to pay for them. If she was so concerned on who was going to be flower girls, and only wanting to pay for her granddaughters, she should have asked who they were before offering.

FlamingoQueen · 07/04/2024 08:22

Your Mum cannot pay for the dresses! That is the most ridiculous thing ever. She needs to say that after a conversation she assumed they were for her grandchildren, not 3 other children. You need to stop being involved in this wedding, accept it will probably be the last times that you see your brother (I reckon his wife will just prefer her side of the family) and enjoy the wedding.

ChatLike · 07/04/2024 08:24

I am from a different culture and find this fascinating. Weddings are completely seen as a blending of friends and family. It would be unheard of not to invite your sibling’s children. All relatives are invited, and then the budget and venue adjusted down accordingly. Whilst these weddings can be far from plain sailing, I do find it a bit sad that weddings here seem to have become just about the bride and groom.

Unless there are toxic family dynamics going on, I think it is nice to have inclusive weddings with lots of different friends and family meeting each other. I would be heartbroken if my sibling did not invite my kids and vice versa.

InterIgnis · 07/04/2024 08:30

SuperwomansAMyth · 07/04/2024 08:14

Exactly. I asked my DH if he realised that his mother always blaming me for everything he did that she didn't like was her basically saying he was weak and spineless. He then realised how insulting it was to him personally as well.

It really is, like he’s an object that must fall under the control of someone. Anything they don’t like must be the fault of the wife, it could never be something he’s chosen to do.

If the expectation is that she manage him like he’s a toddler and it’s her responsibility to coordinate play dates with his family then I’m not surprised she’s keeping her distance from them.

phoenixrosehere · 07/04/2024 08:34

InterIgnis · 07/04/2024 08:30

It really is, like he’s an object that must fall under the control of someone. Anything they don’t like must be the fault of the wife, it could never be something he’s chosen to do.

If the expectation is that she manage him like he’s a toddler and it’s her responsibility to coordinate play dates with his family then I’m not surprised she’s keeping her distance from them.

I bet the bride has no idea and her fiancé is giving bare minimum information due to knowing what his mum and sister are like.

InterIgnis · 07/04/2024 08:36

phoenixrosehere · 07/04/2024 08:34

I bet the bride has no idea and her fiancé is giving bare minimum information due to knowing what his mum and sister are like.

I wouldn’t be surprised if that’s the case. There’s a very good chance that she’s under the impression that they’re each dealing with their respective families, and that they’ve been told the details.

phoenixrosehere · 07/04/2024 08:40

InterIgnis · 07/04/2024 08:36

I wouldn’t be surprised if that’s the case. There’s a very good chance that she’s under the impression that they’re each dealing with their respective families, and that they’ve been told the details.

Yea, especially since they were intent on paying for the wedding themselves.

SuperwomansAMyth · 07/04/2024 08:40

phoenixrosehere · 07/04/2024 08:34

I bet the bride has no idea and her fiancé is giving bare minimum information due to knowing what his mum and sister are like.

I agree with this as well. She probably has no idea how her fiance's family are feeling and what is going on there. She might not have worked out her assigned role as social secretary yet and assume DB is capable of dealing with his own family.

NeverBeforeToday · 07/04/2024 08:41

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

So all the kids were invited apart from yours?
The groom was close to your DH.
Your child is his godson.

Umm could it then possibly be you that was the reason? You don’t sound that easy to be around. 🤷🏼‍♀️

SuperwomansAMyth · 07/04/2024 08:41

FlamingoQueen · 07/04/2024 08:22

Your Mum cannot pay for the dresses! That is the most ridiculous thing ever. She needs to say that after a conversation she assumed they were for her grandchildren, not 3 other children. You need to stop being involved in this wedding, accept it will probably be the last times that you see your brother (I reckon his wife will just prefer her side of the family) and enjoy the wedding.

So the brother is incapable of managing a relationship with his family if his wife doesn't do it for him? If so, I'd be questioning just what gender stereotyped expectations this man is going to have of me and if it's what I want to sign up for.

NewFriendlyLadybird · 07/04/2024 08:44

sunshinestar1986 · 07/04/2024 01:29

It's so weird how little input the man's family is allowed to have
I totally understand how awful some mother in laws can be, but I don't get why men are not allowed much input in their own wedding!
He should be able to say that he wants some of his family members etx
How depressing

Unless of course, he's not all that close to you op?
I have 2 brothers, will definitely get involved in one of them but the other not so much

No one’s ‘allowing’ or not allowing anything. Planning of any event is best done by a very small number of people and I know of very few straight men who are particularly interested in planning their weddings. Maybe the brother has opted out, maybe he’s the one who preferred a child-free wedding. He’s almost certainly the one who did not put the OP’s partners adult children on the guest list. Remember that we know these adult children are married themselves, so any invitations would have to include their respective spouses or there’d be a whole other Mumsnet thread. If they’re not that close, why should they be invited? Maybe the bride wasn’t even planning on flower girls until the groom’s mother randomly started insisting on paying for dresses. Maybe it didn’t occur to anyone in the wedding planning group that she had already appointed flower girls.
The only thing that I will allow they did wrong was not say sooner that it would be a child-free wedding. But clearly the invitations haven’t been sent out yet! Maybe they hadn’t decided until the OP, mother and stepfather started acting all histrionic.

diddl · 07/04/2024 08:49

So who is responsible for not inviting your daughters Op?

We both decided who we wanted to invite & did so.

Mouse82 · 07/04/2024 08:49

Happywrappy · 06/04/2024 18:48

God I hate weddings!! I think the bigger issues are not inviting step siblings, or nieces (assuming the chosen flower girls are also children), and not giving mother of the groom a role to play. Very poor show on SIL’s part. Does she have precedence for being selfish or a trouble maker? Honestly though, this probably isn’t an unusual scenario; the groom rarely has a vision for their wedding in the same way the bride does, so if a family is going to feel pushed out it’s typically the groom’s. Accept he doesn’t care all that much about the day and is stuck between a rock and a hard place trying to please SIL. Also accept that this might just be the start of losing your brother bit by bit. Christmas plans will look similar, with your family always featuring as lower priority. Hey ho, you can always hope for a swift divorce!

As they say, careful what you wish on others, “Be careful what you wish for others, it just might get you.”
― Mokokoma Mokhonoana

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 07/04/2024 08:57

I'm astonished that a majority of posters on the poll think the OP isn't being unreasonable. The OP's posts and take on this are one of the most childish, silly and ridiculous I've read in some time.

NewFriendlyLadybird · 07/04/2024 08:58

Concannon88 · 07/04/2024 01:14

@user1492757084

It is very generous of your mother to buy the flowergirl"s dresses. You could buy your own daughter's a pretty outfit too and arrange for them and a baby sitter to be outside the church with any neighbours and well wishers from the town.

This has got to be a joke right? What church? What neighbours? What town?

The bucolic vision of a TV Jane Austen adaptation. I hope the OP’s brother has a handful of coins ready to toss into the air for the surprisingly clean and well dressed little urchins.

Mouse82 · 07/04/2024 08:58

I wouldn't be surprised if she keeps any future pregnancies low key etc and with good reason after this reaction to their wedding.

Needanewname42 · 07/04/2024 08:58

It's all a bit presumptuous.
The mother assumed the DGDs would be flowersgirls - at any point did she ask was there going to be flowergirls - if so who?

Who are the bridesmaids- my guess - the flowergirls mums.

I do think the brother is being a bit too laid back but maybe he doesn't like his own family either.
But how awkward 😬 his mum made the offer to him about flower girls dresses. He knows his own neices weren't going to be invited never mind be flowergirls. He could have spoken up but chose not to He let his partner do his dirty work.

SuperwomansAMyth · 07/04/2024 09:00

He might be one of those men who is happy to throw his partner under the bus and let her take the blame, so he doesn't have to and everyone stays happy with him. This does not usually end well.

PlateSpinnerJuggler · 07/04/2024 09:00

I'd feel completely same as you...
I am pretty close to my siblings as are we to my husbands - nieces and nephews come before cousins kids irrespective of which side bride or groom...

Itsaloadofbollocksbut · 07/04/2024 09:01

Runnerinthenight · 06/04/2024 23:42

Bullshit! Weddings are about bringing families together, not about the B&G being selfish as fuck!

Have never, ever been to a wedding that has brought 2 families together. Including my own.

They're a celebration of the couple.

Poettree · 07/04/2024 09:04

This isn't your wedding, it's not your mothers. You don't need to get involved. Turn up on the day, enjoy yourself and for god's sake don't sulk about your kids not being bridesmaids. It's not about you. I admit I think it's a bit mean to leave out your kids and I wouldn't do that but it's one day, who honestly cares.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread