Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is a man a good dad to one kid but not the other?

103 replies

TheCosySeal · 25/02/2024 08:14

I had a friend over last night for a catch up. She’s a single mum to a 14 year old. She was really upset and venting about how her child gets treated compared to the kids her ex went on to have with his now wife.

She couldn’t understand how he can be what appears a great dad to his youngest two children but pretty mediocre to their child.

A few examples are he’s never shown any interest in their DC school life, never took their DC to school, picked up, been to assembly, parents evening, he leaves it all to her saying he’s working so can’t. Yet he does the school run for his kids, he goes to their celebration assembly’s, parents evening.

Has took his DC on abroad holidays and some of these are long haul. Her child only gets invited to UK breaks when they go.

Never spends any 1:1 time with their DC as he says it unfair to leave his other DC out but takes his other kids out 1:1 When their DC isn’t around! Posting about his daddy/daughter days on his social media or her DC gets told all about it when she’s over.

Never been to a docs, dentist app.

How it appears from the outside is that he really is a hands on capable dad to the children with his wife but can hardly lift a finger to send a text to their child.

What makes someone act like this?

Incase it’s relevant my friend and her ex were only together a very short amount of time when she got pregnant and they split up before their DC was even born.

OP posts:
user1471538283 · 27/02/2024 08:53

I think it's because they view the DC as an extension of the woman. If the woman is no longer then the DCs aren't either.

According to my ex not only did he not pay anything for my DS he gave his new girlfriends DC "anything they wanted". This meant my bf should do the same. There was never any tie there. He couldn't even be arsed to remember birthdays or Christmas.

My DF and DGFs were completely different. They were all invested in their children. My DF continued to be the only parent that gave a shit after he and my DM divorced.

Shuffleshoop · 27/02/2024 08:54

Because he cares what his current partner thinks of him, but doesn't give a crap about his kids. If they broke up he would repeat it again I'm sure. It doesn't mean it hurts your DC any less.

Vod · 27/02/2024 09:29

TheCosySeal · 27/02/2024 08:45

Thanks everyone. I think everyone has summed it up perfectly to be honest.

Not sure I will be telling her though that she’s to blame, il just continue to support her if needed.

No, I'm not sure that would do anything to help. Probably the only benefit to telling her would be if it looked like she were going to do it again with another child, which it doesn't sound like. It sounds like the DD will probably stop bothering of her own accord soon enough anyway. She's of an age where she'll know if he's trying to pretend a bond exists out of duty.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread