Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I think my 21 year old son prefers his girlfriends mum over me.

103 replies

DarkandStormy77 · 26/08/2023 18:29

He's been going out with his girlfriend for over 4 years. She's a lovely girl. Both her parents have good jobs, lovely house, cars etc. Can afford to go to fancy restaurants and also holidays few times a year. His dad and I are working class, live in an overcrowded damp council house and have never been able to afford to take our kids on holiday abroad. Anyway I'll cut to the chase. For Christmases & birthday's, he'll get me like a Yankee Candle, cheap plonk/chocolates or item from Next. For the gf mum he will get her clothes from the white company and stuff from the rituals in one gift or expensive wine etc. I know I probably sound jealous but it really hurts. I was in tears when I found out what he spends on her. It's not about the money though as I really do appreciate what he gives me as it's the thought that counted. It's just when I discovered he must vaule his relationship with gf mum more than the one that actual carried him for 9 months, spent 9 hours in labour and has scrimped and saved to give him the best of everything well it really cut deep. Sorry if I'm not wording this right, kinda in tears writing this but aibu?

OP posts:
amlie8 · 26/08/2023 19:44

21-year-old boys men aren't known for being very sensitive, OP. I would be as hurt as you are, but I would also try to remember that the silly bugger won't have given it a second thought, he probably has no idea that this would hurt you. It doesn't mean he prefers the MIL. As PPs have said, he's trying to impress and fit in.

SweetStrawberrie · 26/08/2023 19:45

OP it seems a bit like you are projecting your own insecurities onto your son.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 26/08/2023 19:52

since being with his GF DS presents are far less generous, more generic, but I guess the GF has a hand in it
i have no idea what they buy her parents

Ilovemydog2 · 26/08/2023 19:55

OP, don’t be so hard on yourself.

My mum buys plonk for herself and is stuck in her ways about wine and lots of things so I’d buy a bottle of it for her but I’d never dream of getting my MiL one who is a wine snob. So if I buy her a bottle, I end up paying through the nose. Even though I love my mother far more.

Definitely a case of keeping up with the Joneses. Remember he’ll likely be trying to let them know he’s good enough for their daughter too.

Nosleepforthismum · 26/08/2023 20:00

Aww OP I would be upset too. Are you still with DS’s dad? Can he not have a word with him?

Serendipitoushedgehog · 26/08/2023 20:01

It sounds like he’s trying to impress the gf’s mum. I would just tell him how you feel. A lot of men are pretty crap at presents in my experience (not that it’s a genetic difference lol, just seems like society lets them be that way) so I think you should call him out and tell him he’s upset you.

Serendipitoushedgehog · 26/08/2023 20:02

MrsLargeEmbodied · 26/08/2023 19:52

since being with his GF DS presents are far less generous, more generic, but I guess the GF has a hand in it
i have no idea what they buy her parents

Why do the women always get the blame for these kind of things? It’s your son! If he’s buying you crap presents, blame him not his girlfriend.

DreamTheMoors · 26/08/2023 20:03

Oblahdeeoblahdoe · 26/08/2023 18:34

It sounds like a 'keeping up with the Joneses' situation. I assume it's his GF who is guiding his choice of gifts which doesn't make it any fairer. Ask him how he'd feel if you did the same to him with a sibling for example.

I wanted to say this as well, @DarkandStormy77- your son surely feels pressured into buying his girlfriend’s mum the expensive gifts being he’s seen how they live, he’s seen the clothes she wears, etc Etc.
It’s a lot of pressure.
I know your boy loves you. You’re his mum!!

electriclight · 26/08/2023 20:10

He loves you but he's still trying to impress his gf and her family. He's buying gifts his gf suggests and spending more because they spend a lot of money on him.

He might have deleted photos out of embarrassment because most young adults are embarrassed by their family.

Lads his age are not known for thoughtfulness or sensitivity.

Talk to him to reassure yourself.

But I do think at least part of it is your own insecurities. I don't really think a high street shop like White Company would look down on you. Even your posts on here are apologetic.

PacificState · 26/08/2023 20:14

Aw OP. This would upset me too, especially the bit about deleting family photos.

Can you find an unpressurised moment to talk to him about it? Don't criticise what he's done, just say 'I know this might seem really over-sensitive to you but it's been upsetting me and I need to tell you how it makes me feel'. Then describe what you feel (feel like you're not good enough, like he likes his mil more than he likes you, like he's ashamed of the presents you bought him) - not 'you shouldn't have done that' but 'when you did that it made me feel xxx'. And if you can say nice things about his gf and her family, say those at the same time!

Have you tried to meet up with them/make friends?

It is hurtful, I don't blame you for being upset. But if he's a good 'un he will hopefully take your feelings on board if you explain without criticising him.

Plus, give him instructions for what you would like as gifts - if you don't want the Yankee Candles etc say you'd like to try some White Stuff ones! If you don't want cheap plonk say that you'd really like to try <brand name> booze. Men respond well to present instructions! As others have said I suspect his gf is telling him exactly what to buy her mum - it's almost certainly not that he's being more thoughtful, he's just following instructions.

AutumnSunlight · 26/08/2023 20:14

Bless you my darling ❤Only people who have been through this will get it. My DD displayed some similar behaviour for several years. Singing the praises of her friends mums and her boyfriends mums... (And their dads!)

This was when she was at college and her first 2 years at uni. We are working class and were financially poor - so poor that DD got full help with bursaries and grants and all kinds of stuff. (We are a bit better off now but were really struggling then.)

DH was working 26 hours a week in a local chain store in town, on minimum pay - lost his well paid job he had been in some 2 decades when the factory shut down, and had to take what he could get at the time.

I worked part time (16 hours a week,) as I had not been in the best of health for several years, and we got by, but weren't well off. Never asked anyone for anything though and paid for everything ourselves.

DD was smart and academic (still is) and she went to a 'good' uni. There were some posh middle class and upper middle class people there, and whenever DD came home for the holidays, she would say 'Hugo's dad is in such a good job, and he travels to 20 different countries a year with his work, and he has a flash £50K car,' and 'Harriet's dad has such an amazing business of his own, and he has smart suits and a lovely car, and he just breezes in when I'm at her house, all happy and 'heyyy girls!' I was like 'okaaay...' She continued... Yet my dad doesn't seem to have the same ambition to do well in any career. Why is he so dull and uninterested in furthering his career and doing better in life? Why the menial jobs?'

I was so angry and upset with her. I didn't show it though, and just said (with a frown) 'well YOU never went without, and had everything you wanted, and he and I never asked for anything off everyone. His 'menial jobs' gave you everything you wanted!'

She said 'oh I love him and all but my friends dads seem to be more successful in life, and have loads of friends and more hobbies... My dad seems a bit boring in comparison.' I said 'He is not THEM, he is his own person. Remember these 'dads' are not at home half the year. YOUR dad is always there for you! And many of these dads very likely had a better start and more advantages in life than yours.... AND you're only seeing their best side!

She was basically comparing the fast living trendy career driven dads of her friends to the boring (in her opinion) unambitious, oik (with hardly any friends,) that is her own dad! SO hurtful and rude. I never told him, and he still doesn't know she said it. She also berated our 'small' house a few times and compared it to her friends parents 'mansions.' Hmm

Ten years on her attitude is different and the snobbery she had has gone, and she is a different person. Kind and thoughtful and lovely.... But I often wonder if she remembered these few conversations... She was so rude! Especially about her own dad! Even though it was him she had a go at, I felt really hurt - for him. He is the love of my life and MY husband and HER FATHER and she was so cruel. I know she was only 17-20, but FFS she was brutal! I started crying too when I dropped her off at her friend's house. I was upset for him!

She ALSO seemed to prefer her friends mums a bit too for a year or so (when at uni) and told me a few times about her successful, trendy, slim and fit mums of her friends. (When I was in a bog standard job, chubby, and wore jeans and a polo shirt...) Felt a lot like she preferred them to me, and it did hurt.

I can imagine you are VERY hurt @DarkandStormy77 and I have no answers for you. Only sympathy and empathy. And I am sure it will pass, as it did for me and DH. DD is a dream now, and has only lovely, kind things to say to us and about us now. Flowers Thankfully!

Could you talk to your son about it?

MrsLargeEmbodied · 26/08/2023 20:16

Serendipitoushedgehog · 26/08/2023 20:02

Why do the women always get the blame for these kind of things? It’s your son! If he’s buying you crap presents, blame him not his girlfriend.

no,
it is a fact.

Rewis · 26/08/2023 20:18

buying clothes for your girlfriends mom (especially at 21) is a bit odd to me. So maybe the gf has something to do with it? And then he buys your presents alone and just isnt particularly thoughtfull?

MrsLargeEmbodied · 26/08/2023 20:19

@DarkandStormy77
he is very young.
he will mature

NannyGythaOgg · 26/08/2023 20:20

When I was young I was one of seven kids in a 3 bed semi.

My best friend lived in a big detached house and another friend lived in an even bigger and more expensive detached house - even had a tennis court.

I have stayed friends with my best friend all this time and she still has a lot more money than me. She has stayed in touch with the other friend and a met up with her a while back. She told me how jealous she was of me when we were kids. Because my mum took us places and did things with us whilst she only ever felt an encumbrance to her parents. She went on holiday to expensive places but was never allowed to just be a child - she was constantly with adults.

Children see things differently - and he is currently enjoying the different lifestyle and possibly does feel embarrassed - he's 21, quite possibly his girlfriend feels the same about different aspects of her parents.

They'll both grow out of it.

And my friends and I are equal, despite monetary differences. They may have felt less of my when we were teenagers because at that stage it matters. They certainly don't now

Ohhbaby · 26/08/2023 20:23

DarkandStormy77 · 26/08/2023 19:43

I do feel he's embarrassed by us. Had an argument with him last year as he untagged himself from any of the family pic's on Instagram and deleted any he had. Saying he was clearing up and they were embarrassing as his friends had mocked him. I got really upset because one included my mum (who died back in 2021) standing proudly with her grandchildren (he was her favourite) on her birthday. Felt like he's deleting us from his life. I feel like I'm not worthy enough or whatever..God I'm overreacting, I just know it and my mh right now is at an all time low so that isn't helping. Thank you all for your replies/advice. I'll stop wasting your time now. Sorry.

Edited

This is very normal though op, just for reassurance.
I remember my brother used to walk 50 yards in front of us or behind us when we walked anywhere as a family when he was a teen.
We weren't poor by any means, but my brother was just embarrassed that we walked every where.
He used to say that one day he will drive past us in his ferrari and through bread and tinned food at us😂😂

Ahh we laugh so hard when we think back on it. And my brother does too, it was just a phase. It happens in all families not just poor ones.
We were very much middle class. Big house, 2 cars, overseas holiday once a year. We werent rolling but lacked nothing.

But my brother still went through a phase where he clearly did not want to be associated with us..
I'd say it sounds normal to me.

I reckon your ds will start appreciating you and what you've done for him, somewhere down the line. It's worse for him now because there is a materialistic diffence between you and gf family. Ist hard when you're young to appreciate your parents. We're selfish buggers at a certain age

Totaly · 26/08/2023 20:26

I think you are wrong to worry about this.

DD dates a boy who’s from a wealthy family. They have taken her on holiday, brought her meals, most weeks, paid for first class travel back to Uni, let her stay over all summer, fed her etc etc - I don’t care if she buys his mum a more expensive gift then me, this woman loves DD and is very generous with her.

Im happy that she’s happy and well card for. I still see lots of her and spend time together. I don’t want her money!! I’d be happy with a card.

Janiie · 26/08/2023 20:35

I think its odd for a 21yr old to buy his gf's dm clothes and fairly extravagant gifts but the fact that you get cheap things is of course hurtful. The deleting stuff from sm is awful.

Totally understandable that you feel hurt op. Just try to rise above it and realise he is immature and obviously desperate to impress his gf. Have some <high end> Wine and Cake.

GrumpyPanda · 26/08/2023 20:40

TeaKitten · 26/08/2023 19:05

So why are you crying that he’s bought you stuff you do like?

OP hasn't said she likes the presents. In fact they sound like pretty crap presents. Seems to me he's investing neither money nor thought in them and I bet it's the latter that's the most hurtful. He just grabs the first thing that he figures will satisfy the "gift" label, no matter what.

UndercoverCop · 26/08/2023 20:40

Why are you equating financial value with how he feels about the relationships? Her parents sound like they spend a lot of money on him and he would probably feel embarrassed to give them cheap gifts, nothing to do with how he feels about them. Actually if he was completely comfortable with them he'd be able to say I know you like fancy things Judy but they're a bit beyond my budget, hope you have a lovely birthday, here's a bunch of flowers/cheap box of chocolates.

UndercoverCop · 26/08/2023 20:42

@Totaly ·
*I think you are wrong to worry about this.

DD dates a boy who’s from a wealthy family. They have taken her on holiday, brought her meals, most weeks, paid for first class travel back to Uni, let her stay over all summer, fed her etc etc - I don’t care if she buys his mum a more expensive gift then me, this woman loves DD and is very generous with her.

Im happy that she’s happy and well card for. I still see lots of her and spend time together. I don’t want her money!! I’d be happy with a card.*

This is a really secure, healthy attitude

Custardslices · 26/08/2023 20:46

He should be ashamed of himself.

He can never deny where he's come from, or should he ever be ashamed of this.

I'd tell him exactly how you feel.

billy1966 · 26/08/2023 20:47

I can definitely understand your hurt, particularly about the pictures.

It is indeed likely that his girlfriend has a hand in those gifts.

Some lads can be very insensitive.

You sound like wonderful parents.

Justrolledmyeyesoutloud · 26/08/2023 20:48

Oblahdeeoblahdoe · 26/08/2023 18:34

It sounds like a 'keeping up with the Joneses' situation. I assume it's his GF who is guiding his choice of gifts which doesn't make it any fairer. Ask him how he'd feel if you did the same to him with a sibling for example.

I thought this too

PrincessPeaches123 · 26/08/2023 20:49

Very hurtful. Completely get where you are coming from. X

Swipe left for the next trending thread