Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was I unreasonable to have stayed out all day?

83 replies

Pianko · 23/08/2023 16:36

I currently work 2 days a week to save nursery fees, my husband works full time 5 days a week. We have a 4 year old and my husband has an older child, my stepchild who is 12 (13 in Oct).

Obviously as its the holidays they've been at home a lot (no problem) and have even stayed at home alone all day previously when mum has worked or both me and DH have been working.

Last week they happened to be at ours on a day I wasn't working however I did have an appointment early in the morning for our 4 year old and so told them I was popping out to that.

Whilst I was out a friend called who has similar aged DC and asked if I fancied going out with them for the day. I said yes and text DSC to say I'd be back later than planned and sent them some money to their bank if they wanted to go and get something for lunch. No problem.

I ended up being out most of the day until after DH was back home (so gone from around 8am to around 5pm ish). He thinks I was unreasonable to leave DSC at home alone all day when I wasn't working (it's seemingly not an issue when I am) and says I should have come all the way home, (i was already closer to the place we were going after my appt than i was home) and made them come with me, come home earlier because I knew they were at home or rang him to tell him at work.

I disagree, both he and ex seem to have no problem with DSC being left alone when it suits them, but it's suddenly a problem if I'm not in work? DSC in the middle of all this couldn't have cared less and spent the day chilling out and playing online with friends. I told them where I was going, asked if they were okay at home and sent them money if they needed anything, also had my phone on me all day and was contactable.

OP posts:
saffronsoup · 24/08/2023 19:55

Insommmmnia · 24/08/2023 12:27

Given the child's mother and father have been leaving them alone all day when it suits them then I think they are the ones at fault here

The OP is just following their lead on their ideas about whether a 12 year old can be left alone all day

By demanding the OP doesnt leave the child alone the DH is actually expecting the OP to override his parental decisions.

I'm guessing it probably wouldn't go down well if the OP usually tried to over ride the parental decisions

Where did her DH demand she not leave the child alone?

Asking someone to ring you at work if plans change is not demanding the child not be left alone.

WunWun · 24/08/2023 19:56

All these "I would never leave a 12 year old alone all day" people... Some people have no choice but to do this?! I'm sure if you end up a poor single parent for some reason you might have to.

Not that that's the OPs situation, but it's not exactly child abuse.

saffronsoup · 24/08/2023 19:57

Heyahun · 24/08/2023 12:32

do this all the time - i have a 15 year old step son - and a 2 year old!

Step son sleeps half the day anyway so i go out in the mornings with 2 year old and leave him asleep and when i get back he's either gaming or asleep

hes no interest in coming to most of the activities i do with younger one

we do other stuff as a family.

I think 12 and 15 are different.

My 12 year old would just be on the screen all day. He would be happy to be on his own but would eat any and all junk he could find in the house and would spend the ten hours on a screen. So not something we do any more than we have to. He also does get lonely if its too many days alone.

15 year olds can go out on their own and with friends or walk wherever. Most people don't let their 12 year olds roam free during the day.

Pebblepaint · 24/08/2023 20:00

I think it is different when it's for work than for other reasons actually. I don't dispute a 12 yp will be "fine" all day on their own and sometimes needs must, but I wouldn't want to leave them all day more frequently than necessary. Not because they won't be safe, but because they won't feel cared for and that does matter in your formative years.

Lemonyyy · 24/08/2023 20:05

I would do the same and the 13yo in my house is biologically mine. Sometimes young teens need space, they don’t want to do the same days out as a 4yo.

CherryMaDeara · 24/08/2023 20:06

Pebblepaint · 24/08/2023 20:00

I think it is different when it's for work than for other reasons actually. I don't dispute a 12 yp will be "fine" all day on their own and sometimes needs must, but I wouldn't want to leave them all day more frequently than necessary. Not because they won't be safe, but because they won't feel cared for and that does matter in your formative years.

If DH wants someone home with his son then he needs to be the one to stay home. OP is not his nanny.

NoSquirrels · 24/08/2023 20:09

I’d tell your DH that should the same situation arise again - staying out unexpectedly- then you’ll text or call to let him know, and he can decide if he wants to get back earlier from work.

Insommmmnia · 24/08/2023 20:17

saffronsoup · 24/08/2023 19:55

Where did her DH demand she not leave the child alone?

Asking someone to ring you at work if plans change is not demanding the child not be left alone.

He thinks I was unreasonable to leave DSC at home alone all day when I wasn't working

Phoning him was one of the options, the last one, all of the other options included the OP going well out of her way hes quite happy to leave his child home alone when it suits him

New posts on this thread. Refresh page