Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Re sister’s requests

71 replies

SugarOverload · 15/07/2023 09:09

My sister and I both have 2 year olds. Born a couple of months apart. I also have an older girl (7).

I was suppose to have my niece last week for the day so my sister could pick up an extra shift. She tells me money is tight right now. In my view she is a bit of a helicopter parent, but each to their own, and she made some requests.

That I take my niece to another room for a nappy change to provide privacy, my DH work from home and there’s a chance he could walk through for a coffee for example. She also doesn’t want her changed in front on 7 year old. Whether I agree or not, it’s not a hassle so I said fine. Future note for further in the post, this would of course involve me leaving my son for a few minutes in a very baby proofed living room.

She said my niece struggles with food more than my 2 year old so can I cot up food smaller than I usually would. Ok, done.

She then calls me the night before asking that I do not leave my niece in the living room at all and that I take her with me wherever I go. I said I’m not doing that, I’ll have 3 children with me and I’ll need to get on with other things. At most it’ll be a few minutes, for a wee, make a snack, put a few clothes away, etc, and my stairs are in my living room so I can hear them well. There are stair gates in front of the kitchen and stairs, no breakables in reach, no small toys or ornaments, all furniture is bolted to the wall.

I also pointed out she expects me to leave my son in the same living room to change her daughter in privacy. She said it’s not the same because I’m happy to leave him for a couple minutes. She also asked if DH could stop work to watch my niece for a couple of minutes if I need a wee, etc. I said no.

Whether I think it’s safe of not AIBU to think she shouldn’t make requests that involve me doing something with my child that she’s not happy with for hers.

Similar thing have happened before, when they were first born she stayed overnight with me while our partners worked away. She slept on the other side of the bed (DH’s side, sheets changed!) and put up a travel cot. There’s a wardrobe that side with a couple bits on the top. She was worried they’d jump off and fall in the cot so, although they weren’t near the edge, I made sure everything was pushed back. The cot wasn’t even up against the wardrobe, and even in the impossible event something did fall, it wouldn’t have landed in the cot. I put it down to being a first time mum and thought nothing much more, until she said ‘well if you feel it’s safe can we swap and your baby go hear instead. I said no, mainly because of all the moving of cots last thing at night (because she also didn’t think my cot was safe, so we would of had to move cots about not just swap the babies).

Although both babies were perfectly safe, it hurt that she felt happy to put my baby in a situation she didn’t think was safe to ensure her own was ok.

OP posts:
MarySmit · 15/07/2023 09:12

She is rediculous to have a long list of requirements, when she is asking for free childcare. She needs a nanny if she is so inflexible.

FloweryName · 15/07/2023 09:15

If you were supposed to have your niece for a day, what ended up happening?

Its a shame considering you both have children the same age and it could be very convenient for both of you with babysitting, but she’s making it impossible. I wouldn’t agree to babysit her child with such ridiculous demands.

NewUserName2023 · 15/07/2023 09:15

She sounds very anxious - possibly PND?

OrigamiOwls · 15/07/2023 09:19

She needs to pay for professional childcare.

SugarOverload · 15/07/2023 09:20

I’ve encouraged her to seek more help for herself before but I don’t like to pry unless she wants to tell me how that’s going.

She wasn’t happy for her to come over, which hurts in itself, I’m not an unsafe parent, so I’m assuming she missed a days work and pay.

OP posts:
buckeejit · 15/07/2023 09:24

Oh dear love her. At 2 years old that's sad that she's still so anxious. There's more going on for her. I hope she gets some help. It's not nice for you Flowers

Incognito2023 · 15/07/2023 09:26

Even for a PFB she seems too anxious (doesn’t want her 2 yr old nephew in same room during a nappy change?!)

She needs to calm down and trust you with her child.

I ‘m guessing she doesn’t have any other time away from her child - eg/ no nursery, babysitters etc ?

And imagine if something did actually happen to her DD while you are looking after her, she doesn’t sound likely to accept that accidents will sometimes happen…

Pkhsvd · 15/07/2023 09:33

The cot thing doesn’t entirely make sense though as you thought it was safe so it’d be fair to suggest you do it.
Her other requests seem a bit over the top but fair enough that you agreed to what you were happy with and not to what wouldn’t work for you

Dacadactyl · 15/07/2023 09:36

Erm, no. YANBU and she is ridiculous.

If I'm looking after someone else's child, I'm gonna look after them in EXACTLY the same way that I look after my own kids.

If she doesn't like it, she'd better find someone else.

Lists of demands when you're doing her a favour? Give me a break!

applesandmares · 15/07/2023 09:38

I don't think she's unfair to make requests when it comes to perceived safety of a child, but I also don't think it's unfair for you to decline them if you can't or just don't want to fulfil them. She can then decide whether or not she's comfortable. If she isn't, I can see why it would be hurtful for you, but everyone parents differently don't they, and she'll just have to find childcare elsewhere.

I think you're being a bit sensitive about her asking you to swap cots and the idea that she's happy to put your child at 'risk' and not her own. You know there is no risk, because it's your home. You're used to it and you're comfortable that things won't fall from a wardrobe, furniture is bolted to the walls properly etc. She doesn't necessarily know these things, she'll have to take your word for it, and if you're an anxious parent that can be quite hard to do. I don't think she wants to put your child in harms way.

MisschiefMaker · 15/07/2023 09:42

I think most of her requests were reasonable- not wanting her DD changed in front of your DH (although weird that you can't do it in front of your 2 yr old), food cut up smaller so her DD will eat it. But you were right to draw the line at not leaving her alone for even a minute in a childproofed room. I'm assuming no backstory where the child has been injured on your watch.

towriteyoumustlive · 15/07/2023 09:42

She sounds rather neurotic.

Her demands are unreasonable. It's perfectly OK to leave a 2 year old for a couple of mins in a safe room!

Thunderisntnicebythebeach · 15/07/2023 09:42

Just tell her you understand and hope she finds a suitable sitter...
She will end up without a job...
Not your concern

Mariposista · 15/07/2023 09:46

DOn't feel guilty for a second. She sounds crazy. Needs more going on in her life.

SugarOverload · 15/07/2023 09:54

Niece has never come to harm while with me. She was worried about 7 year old trying to pick her up as she does that with her brother sometimes. But not often, it’s addressed when she does and I’d have a talk about her not doing that with her cousin. But also, kids are kids and you can reduce risk and never completely eliminate it. I think I’ll be saying no if asks in the future as I would be worried about her reaction any small bumps.

Niece does go to a nursery and grandparents. I think there are similar asks of grandparents on both sides but they’re probably more likely to just do it to see their granddaughter. Also they’ll only have her to look after.

OP posts:
SugarOverload · 15/07/2023 10:03

@applesandmares maybe, I didn’t think of it that way, I suppose I’m feeling like she doesn’t think I’m a good parent and everything gets a bit blurry.

@MisschiefMaker it wouldn’t have been in front of husband, there’s a slim chance he’d of walked through the living room to the kitchen while I was changing her nappy. But I was happy to take her upstairs if that’s what my sister wants.

OP posts:
LadyBird1973 · 15/07/2023 10:11

I think she's unreasonable and I'd have been insulted on behalf of my husband and child with the nappy request - is she saying she thinks your dh is potentially a paedo?

Re the food, that's a reasonable request since her child can't cope with bigger pieces yet.

The cot thing I would totally see that as her being willing to put your child at risk instead of hers (even though the risk was not real).

Frankly I'd refuse to ever look after my niece in these circumstances and I would strongly encourage her to get help for her anxiety levels. I'm not unsympathetic to her, as o was also extremely anxious when I had a a baby for the first time but if you want favours in the form of childcare, you cannot police every single little thing the other person does!

SugarOverload · 15/07/2023 10:14

@LadyBird1973 DH is very laid back and hasn’t taken offence, putting it down to anxiety. She’s asking this for any situation with men around, so same with my mums partner for example

OP posts:
user1492757084 · 15/07/2023 10:18

Your sister has anxiety problems - just do your best and trust yourself.

lilymani · 15/07/2023 10:23

It's not just anxiety is it as literally wants to put OP's baby in (what she thinks is 😅) harm's way to protect her own baby from the exact same danger

scoobysnaxx · 15/07/2023 10:24

She is too anxious.

Tell her to get therapy to help.

It will soon rub off on her daughter if she doesn't.

lilymani · 15/07/2023 10:26

@Pkhsvd I know from objective experience that my brother is ridiculously laidback.

If I genuinely felt he was putting either baby at real risk, I wouldn't be happy for his baby to play Jesus to die / get hurt on behalf of my baby!

orangeleavesinautumn · 15/07/2023 10:27

If you are caring for someone elses child, you do it the way the mother wants, or you don't do it at all. It doesn't really matter if you disagree, you just do it. There is no point in doing it at all if the way you do it is going to make the mother anxious.

AssertiveGertrude · 15/07/2023 10:27

She’s nuts sorry - no way would I agree to have the child

Jongleterre · 15/07/2023 10:29

Three options-

  1. respect her wishes and care for her child as she demands.
  1. Nod and agree but care for the child as you see fit.
  1. Tell her that her demands are unreasonable and she will have to get childcare elsewhere.