Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To be done with autism

1000 replies

stargirl1701 · 11/07/2023 13:54

I'm done with it.

DD1 is autistic. She is nearly 11, diagnosed at 5. We have made numerous adjustments at home. School have made numerous adjustments. All to no avail.

She swore and kicked her little sister yesterday. Immediate consequence no screens for 24 hours and sent to her room. Of course, meltdown. 2 HOURS later after punching and kicking me she complies.

I'm done.

The needs of the many are now coming first. I'm on my sixth anti-depressant, DD2 is terrified in her own home, DH spends his life walking the dog trying to remain calm in the face is extreme provocation.

I'm done. No more. The 3 of us are coming first for the first time in more than a decade. I'm done.

No more empathy. No more trying to understand. Done.

No matter what we do, she has violent meltdowns. She thinks of no-one but herself. Modelling doesn't work. Talking incidents through doesn't work. She won't use any strategy she has been taught to avoid a meltdown.

I'm done. Time to live our lives.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Dixiechickonhols · 11/07/2023 17:37

I can fully understand why you are focusing on violence as a line in the sand. No one should be hit or kicked.
The last few pages have had examples where it’s been taken out of families hands with police involvement.
Age of criminal responsibility is a bit higher in Scotland it’s 12 but the dd is only a year off.
If she attacks mum especially in public then potentially there will be ramifications.
Is she violent to none family?

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 11/07/2023 17:37

A NDN of my DM has an autistic DS. As a child and whilst growing up he was awful. He liked to sell animal charity products door to door in the area and outside a supermarket which was great but then it got to the stage that it was irritating to feel like you had to buy something or donate to the charity. Luckily that stopped when someone complained to the charity. He was obsessed with right and wrong and criminals and once had me call the police as he’d got into an abandoned car but was trying to drive it… (someone had left the keys inside). He had washing issues and liked lotion put on every day in an intimate place by his DM and his bottom wiped. In the end with the help of my DM who’d worked as a Senco with special needs children they came up with ways so he could gradually do things himself. I think he did like the power he had over his DM sometimes but was stuck in the pattern of liking it. He constantly had violent outbursts which did get worse in puberty. His DM would’ve sent him away to a residential school and I think at one point there was talk of funding for this but she’d have felt very guilty sending him there.

In the end when he reached 18 she asked him to leave home but found him a flat where social services pay most of the rent, she covers the rest and he has a job for bills and other expenses. He’s much happier there (it took a change of one flat and area though) and his DM is much happier, remarried and his younger DSis is much happier. He bullied her and was very unpleasant to her. I hate to say it but if he was my child I’d have put him into a residential home if I could’ve done. Well I don’t know what I’d do as he isn’t my child but I can see why some parents would do that. Her only escape from him was when he was at school and when she worked every Saturday.

TimeToMoveIt · 11/07/2023 17:37

It sounds like you've tried almost everything. Sometimes firmer boundaries do work better. I'd say its worth a try.

My younger 2 dcs spend most of their time in separate spaces to limit the kick odds at each other.

Younger ds is the same age as your daughter and luckily enjoys spending time in his room or in his little cubby hole where he has a desk. Where as older ds who has the same prefers to be downstairs.

They both like to eat on their own so that's what they do quite a lot of the time, even if it means one of them wants to eat upstairs

Things are a lot calmer these days. I hope you can find something that works for your family. Quite frankly it can all be shit , many of us have moments where we have just had a enough

GrouchyKiwi · 11/07/2023 17:37

I hear you, OP, I really do.

My eldest has violent meltdowns. We have to keep her away from her younger sisters. She is also 11.

Apologies if you've already answered this; am replying quickly. Does she get enough sleep? We've found that melatonin helps DD1 sleep better, which in turn helps her control herself better. Regular meltdowns have become very irregular - the last was 3 weeks ago. And they're shorter, easier to help her through.

stargirl1701 · 11/07/2023 17:38

@AutismProf

You are correct to say it is very difficult to disregard the teacher in me. I have changed though as a teacher over the three decades. DD1 has made me an infinitely better teacher. I don't use punishment or reward in my classroom. I did in the 1990s but I look back in horror at Golden Time and the damage I did as a young teacher.

We used Plan B quite early after she was diagnosed when she was about 6 years old. It just seemed to make no difference.

It's worth re-visiting with her at 11. I will try again.

OP posts:
Yellowlegobrick · 11/07/2023 17:38

It’ll be really interesting to see what the outcome is of this change. You should keep us in the loop.

This. It will be interesting, i wonder if very clear, black and white boundaries with zero room for interpretation could even help

stargirl1701 · 11/07/2023 17:39

@Msplace

Either RTFT or DOFD

OP posts:
IAmSalmaFuckingHayek · 11/07/2023 17:39

AutismProf · 11/07/2023 17:26

I have read the OP's posts on the thread.

There's no evidence in what OP has said that her daughter has PDA. PDA is very rare. Pervasive, illogical noncompliance hasn't been described.
Demand avoidance in autism is common, usually precipitated by anxiety or overwhelm.

OP firstly, what you are describing for your daughter is not punitive, except for forcing her to stay in her room. I would be inclined to move to timetabled access for both of your daughters to shared spaces, once everyone has calmed from this precipitating incident.

OP you say you have read Ross Greene, but you aren't talking like someone who has read Ross Greene. I am not saying you are lying, just that the messages don't seem to have dropped into place. It is a definite clash with teacher training, antecedents behaviour consequences type approaches. You are still talking about consequences and behaviours and not talking about expectations she is having difficulty meeting, lagging skills, and unsolved problems.

Ross Greene says kids do well when they can. There are expectations she is having difficulty meeting, and crucially, the expectation is not "don't attack your sister" as you list in the expectations you have identified for her. That is a hugely loaded phrasing which describes a behavioural consequence of the expectation she can't meet. Which is probably something like "lose a game with good sportsmanship" or "share screen time fairly" or "transition easily off the screen at the end of her designated time".
Attacking her sister at that point is just the symptom of the unsolved problem - it isn't the unsolved problem.

You can't do a plan B of a behavioural description, that is fundamental Greene. You must identify the lagging skill. You cannot plan B when you begin by inducing shame. And she is ashamed - hence huge self defensive meltdown .

Can you work out what the actual unsolved problem is?

She doesn't WANT to upset you all, you know.

Yes!! All of this.

PhoenixIsFlying · 11/07/2023 17:40

I'm sorry to read you are struggling. I haven't read all the posts as my daughter is back from school and I don't get a second. She requires my attention constantly. I spend 3 hours a day making up stories that I text to school, on the way back and an hour in the evening. I feel like I am going mad. I also have to pretend to be a baby all the time which drives me nuts.
The big difference for my daughter was going to a secondary school for Girls with autism. It meant a tribunal and a year out of school, delaying her schooling by a year. The school has been transformational , my daughter is flourishing. It doesn't change everything but really helps. I've got to go as I am being screamed at that I'm ignoring her.

MostlyBlueberryFlavoured · 11/07/2023 17:40

Mariposista · 11/07/2023 14:17

GOOD FOR YOU OP.
Be as strict as you need to be, for the sake of your sweet second child and marriage.
I hope you get a good outcome.

FUCK OFF with your disgusting ableism. Seriously.

Msplace · 11/07/2023 17:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

x2boys · 11/07/2023 17:41

Msplace · 11/07/2023 17:34

I say this as someone with experience of autism you clearly have little to no understanding of it and need to learn more about your childs diagnosis in order to learn how to manage her complex needs. Her needs aren't being met and she is acting out. By the way autistic people dont respond to punishments and punishing them for a meltdown or acting out isn't going to work because they can't infer that they are being punished for their behaviour and for other reasons that i cant be arsed to get into.

I think the op.knows her daughter better than a,stranger on the internet
And as the saying goes if you have met one person with autism.you have met one person with autism.
What works for one child might not work for another as the spectrum.is so vast and people all have different needs

stargirl1701 · 11/07/2023 17:42

@LeafCuttingAnt

No EOTAS.

Another avenue may be pursuing a CSP which does have legal backing. Another massive protracted battle against the LA.

OP posts:
Manthide · 11/07/2023 17:42

Sheranovermytoes · 11/07/2023 14:08

I can see how people get to his and get fed up of kowtowing to the needs of one person in a household. My sister had ASD and as a child I had enough of being booted, spat at and listening to her constant demands. My mum had enough too and took a similar stance. Luckily she was able to adjust eventually after stress and tantrums and it did get better. My mums view was that if we don't teach her that she can't do this at home, she won't survive in the real world. There are ways I'm sure OP but the action has to be right for he child, you don't want the situation to be made worse.

Ds is autistic and he understands that he has to live in a NT world. Thankfully any aggression was normally against inanimate objects rather than people and his 3 sisters are very protective of him. Constant reinforcement from a young age helped him though he still has his moments. He's 20 and can get very upset about to us minor things. His younger sister used to not understand why his needs had to come first sometimes but now they get on well.

nosykids · 11/07/2023 17:42

hamsterchump · 11/07/2023 17:27

Do you think the rest of us just love being ordered around? Everyone prefers to be asked and asked nicely! Ridiculous pathologising.

I have diagnosed PDA and it is far more complex than wanting to be asked nicely/politely - this will make no difference to whether I do something or not. Even if I want to do something I can't do it if someone else suggests it first. It is a pervasive need for full autonomy. I don't recognise authority or hierarchies and won't show respect unless I feel it is earned. There is a huge element of self sabotage and I also resist very ordinary, day to day things that I feel I should do (like hoovering). Childhood examples - arguing with teachers and parents, very little schoolwork done, never accepting any help with anything, very manipulative and skilled in getting my own way. Adult examples - refusing to take medication that I know is likely to help me, immediate response of 'no' to any request from dh/dc, find it impossible to work in structures where I report to someone (also don't want to manage other people, as I believe in their autonomy too), write a to do list and do none of the things listed because the list is telling me what to do...and many more. I have (diagnosed) ADHD too - it's fun in my brain.

stargirl1701 · 11/07/2023 17:42

@Msplace

'Tis good advice. You ought to take it.

OP posts:
StopStartStop · 11/07/2023 17:43

stargirl1701 · 11/07/2023 14:06

@x2boys

I mean:

She remains in her own room when we are at home. No more of DD2 sobbing in hers whilst DD1 rampages around kicking, hitting and biting DH and I. The house is ours. We will use it.

She eats first by herself before we have our family meal.

No screens. That's a privilege she doesn't get.

No extra effort expended for her. She wanted to get every single Cub Scout badge and I made that happen. No more.

You're desperate. I can see that.
But you are deliberately planning to be cruel to your disabled child.
You are planning to punish her. To show her you don't love her - to demonstrate that by putting her in solitary confinement and by making her eat every meal alone.
Is there a grandma or aunt she could stay with for a while? To give you all a break without hurting her further. Her life already hurts.

FlopsiesAngrySandwich · 11/07/2023 17:43

Aaaaandbreathe · 11/07/2023 17:09

Can't get by this. I understand your frustration and was with you to a point, but this is nothing short of cruel and bad parenting.

Why don't you just lock her in the basement? Awful.

Hopefully you contact SS and they have a solution that actually benefits your daughter rather than you punishing her because she has a disability she cannot cope with or you even try to understand.

I have an autistic child. She was very hard work for years but I did everything I could to ensure her needs were being met and she is now happy. And I know other parents of autistic children who put up with more than you are and still love their child.

I feel so sorry for your 'D'D. She's 11 ffs and you are not advocating for her or trying to find out if there is an extra issue. Taking screens away and making her an outcast will not help her. YOU are the selfish one.

But it's not cruel. The child is happy in her own room. It may well suit her better too and lessen the frequency of meltdowns.

MostlyBlueberryFlavoured · 11/07/2023 17:44

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 11/07/2023 17:37

A NDN of my DM has an autistic DS. As a child and whilst growing up he was awful. He liked to sell animal charity products door to door in the area and outside a supermarket which was great but then it got to the stage that it was irritating to feel like you had to buy something or donate to the charity. Luckily that stopped when someone complained to the charity. He was obsessed with right and wrong and criminals and once had me call the police as he’d got into an abandoned car but was trying to drive it… (someone had left the keys inside). He had washing issues and liked lotion put on every day in an intimate place by his DM and his bottom wiped. In the end with the help of my DM who’d worked as a Senco with special needs children they came up with ways so he could gradually do things himself. I think he did like the power he had over his DM sometimes but was stuck in the pattern of liking it. He constantly had violent outbursts which did get worse in puberty. His DM would’ve sent him away to a residential school and I think at one point there was talk of funding for this but she’d have felt very guilty sending him there.

In the end when he reached 18 she asked him to leave home but found him a flat where social services pay most of the rent, she covers the rest and he has a job for bills and other expenses. He’s much happier there (it took a change of one flat and area though) and his DM is much happier, remarried and his younger DSis is much happier. He bullied her and was very unpleasant to her. I hate to say it but if he was my child I’d have put him into a residential home if I could’ve done. Well I don’t know what I’d do as he isn’t my child but I can see why some parents would do that. Her only escape from him was when he was at school and when she worked every Saturday.

Charming.

StopStartStop · 11/07/2023 17:44

You can't separate the autism from the person. When you say you're 'done with autism' you mean you're done with your child.

x2boys · 11/07/2023 17:44

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 11/07/2023 17:37

A NDN of my DM has an autistic DS. As a child and whilst growing up he was awful. He liked to sell animal charity products door to door in the area and outside a supermarket which was great but then it got to the stage that it was irritating to feel like you had to buy something or donate to the charity. Luckily that stopped when someone complained to the charity. He was obsessed with right and wrong and criminals and once had me call the police as he’d got into an abandoned car but was trying to drive it… (someone had left the keys inside). He had washing issues and liked lotion put on every day in an intimate place by his DM and his bottom wiped. In the end with the help of my DM who’d worked as a Senco with special needs children they came up with ways so he could gradually do things himself. I think he did like the power he had over his DM sometimes but was stuck in the pattern of liking it. He constantly had violent outbursts which did get worse in puberty. His DM would’ve sent him away to a residential school and I think at one point there was talk of funding for this but she’d have felt very guilty sending him there.

In the end when he reached 18 she asked him to leave home but found him a flat where social services pay most of the rent, she covers the rest and he has a job for bills and other expenses. He’s much happier there (it took a change of one flat and area though) and his DM is much happier, remarried and his younger DSis is much happier. He bullied her and was very unpleasant to her. I hate to say it but if he was my child I’d have put him into a residential home if I could’ve done. Well I don’t know what I’d do as he isn’t my child but I can see why some parents would do that. Her only escape from him was when he was at school and when she worked every Saturday.

Yeah good luck.in finding a residential home
Of course your an expert what with your mums next door neighbours child having autism🙄

Msplace · 11/07/2023 17:45

x2boys · 11/07/2023 17:41

I think the op.knows her daughter better than a,stranger on the internet
And as the saying goes if you have met one person with autism.you have met one person with autism.
What works for one child might not work for another as the spectrum.is so vast and people all have different needs

I am autistic myself for a start and my child is autistic with complex needs. They were physically violent with meltdowns too but there is always a way to manage it. She says in her OP that her child is autistic and acting out including physically. No matter where your child is on the spectrum there is a way of preventing that and something has gone wrong somewhere such as feeling overwhelmed hence my comment about learning about autism to prevent it

stargirl1701 · 11/07/2023 17:45

@StopStartStop

Everyone who used to have her now refuses. Her grandparents included. She is not manageable for people in their late 70s.

OP posts:
MostlyBlueberryFlavoured · 11/07/2023 17:46

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

loislovesstewie · 11/07/2023 17:47

PhoenixIsFlying · 11/07/2023 17:40

I'm sorry to read you are struggling. I haven't read all the posts as my daughter is back from school and I don't get a second. She requires my attention constantly. I spend 3 hours a day making up stories that I text to school, on the way back and an hour in the evening. I feel like I am going mad. I also have to pretend to be a baby all the time which drives me nuts.
The big difference for my daughter was going to a secondary school for Girls with autism. It meant a tribunal and a year out of school, delaying her schooling by a year. The school has been transformational , my daughter is flourishing. It doesn't change everything but really helps. I've got to go as I am being screamed at that I'm ignoring her.

I've been various cartoon characters for 20 years! The good thing is that they are all characters that he likes, so I should be flattered.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.