Can you help settle a food disagreement?

[Fooddrama]

Family of 4. 2 adults and 2 teenage dc.

Whole family usually have porridge or weetabix for breakfast on weekdays. There are no weight or health issues and food is plentiful in the house.

Weekend morning, adult1 has a toasted bagel for breakfast and is going to have a toasted muffin with eggs for lunch.

Dc1 has a toasted bagel for breakfast and is going to have a sandwich for lunch.

Dc2 has toast for breakfast and would also like a sandwich for lunch.

Adult1 says dc2 can't have a sandwich, as they've already had bread today, but can have a toasted muffin instead.

Adult2 thinks that bagels/bread/muffins are all more or less the same so it makes no difference and dc should have what they want for lunch.

Adult 1 is mental

I agree with adult 2 which I guess is you.

Zero difference between toast, toasted muffin, toasted bagel. Its all wheat, water, salt, yeast, preservatives

Of course adult 2 is right.

Is adult 1 really stupid?

It’s all basically the same so yes agree with adult two

Adult 2 is right.

and who made adult 1 the food police anyway?

Adult 1 is bonkers and being weirdly controlling in a totally arbitrary way. Is there an argument to say that eating less processed bread-type products is probably a good thing? Sure. Does that mean you should ban your teenager from eating bread at 2 meals on a given day? No. And yes, adult 2 is quite right that muffin and bread are essentially the same thing anyway.

Surely a muffin is worse than a sandwich with higher carbs and sugars

bread is bread so Adult2 is correct

Adult 2 is right and adult 1 is being weird.

Seems controlling!

Adult 1 is an idiot. Already had bread today, wtf? It's surely not unusual to have toast for breakfast and a sandwich for lunch.

Adult 1 is ridiculous. Parents can’t control what teenagers eat to that degree & shouldn’t try to.

It's all bread and it's a ridiculous argument.

Have something instead of bread, I could understand the thinking behind... but just, have different shaped bread is pointless.

I'd be pleased if a) teens were up in time for breakfast and b) ate breakfast.
It's up to them what they eat on a weekend as long as it doesn't disrupt the general eating plan.
Adult 1 is mad and unreasonable

Does adult1 have disordered thinking around food because if sc2 wants a sandwich for lunch so what

So what is wrong with adult one then, why are they being weird and food controlling?

Adult 2 is correct.
Adult I is very strange!

And agree with the others, how come adult 1 is so ignorant about food?

Assuming adult 1 has prepared some amazing low carb lunch dish that contains no bread, why isn't Adult 1 eating it? (presumably himself)

As long as DC can make it themselves, who cares?

Tell Adult 1 to do one

An excellent way of giving your kids issues around food!!

Muffins are bread, bagels are bread, bread is bread. If adult 1 can have a bagel and a muffin in the same day, then dc2 can have toast and a sandwich in the same day. Dc1 can have a bagel and a sandwich but this isn’t an issue?!

I buy enough sliced bread for everyone to have some once a day, if they have more we run out. Yes, I am aware I could buy more but then I end up with way too much and it goes mouldy before we use it.
However assuming it's not something like that then there's no difference between bread and a muffin.