Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Black Monday anyone? The tories should be in jail

994 replies

Upthebracket22 · 26/09/2022 06:51

The pound is now at its lowest point against the dollar since decimalisation in 1971 at 1.03. It’s probably going lower and the Bank of England will likely need to step in with an emergency interest rate rise today. Black Monday possibly?

All because of the mini budget on Friday. The Tories should be in jail. Especially if their rich backers were shorting the pound as it appears to get rich.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
potniatheron · 26/09/2022 17:02

I love it when people talk about 'rich Tory backers shorting the pound' thus showing that they have no idea how the financial markets work.

The current sterling crisis started when the Asian money markets closed last Wednesday.

the real weathervane to watch is 10 year gilt yields - currently above 4%. Remember what happened with Greek bond yields in 2014.

Yes we are in a sterling crisis and the BoE will step in to stabilise.

The derivatives market is pricing in a 1.5 percentage point increase by November. Rates will top 6% by May.

Tighten your belts folks we're in for a ride :-) but I'm not really sure how you'd put anyone in jail for it.

Problem is we have borrowed way too much since 1997 and we are now going to pay for it

BambinaJAS · 26/09/2022 17:08

Hepwo · 26/09/2022 16:42

Basic rate cut by 1ppt from April 2023 – from 20p to 19p
This is the first cut to the basic rate of Income Tax in 15 years (the last cut to the basic rate was in 2008- 09).

19% is the lowest the basic rate has ever been in the modern Income Tax system.

This is a tax cut worth over £5 billion for workers, savers and pensioners.

31 million taxpayers will benefit from this policy in 2023-24, with an average gain of £170.

I think it's good to allow people to keep more of the money they earn.

Especially when the press have been telling us there's a cost of living crisis and SOMETHING MUST BE DONE!

Well something has been done.

You're welcome.

You seem confused.

Cutting taxes does not happen in isolation

Having more income after tax is great, but not at the expense of inflation wiping out all of that NOMINAL gain in income.

How hard is this to understand?

The only people who will have a net real gain in income until 2026 are the ones making over £150k

Everybody else is poorer in real terms.

Do you get it now?

scaredoff · 26/09/2022 17:08

midgetastic · 26/09/2022 16:58

the average saving of 170 is skewed to the higher levels

Basic rate tax payers will save on average 130 and those on the average salary will save even less

And yes it's wiped out by the additional inflation

not to mention the long term decimation of public services that is going to be necessary to pay for it.

That's what I don't get. People go "ooh, must vote Tory because Labour would increase my tax bill by X-hundred pounds!" with one half of their brain. And then with the other half of their brain they complain about the state of the NHS (which Labour started, against Tory objection, and reinvigorated under Blair/Brown after years of Tory decline), public transport, schools etc.

And the two halves of their brain just manage to never talk to each other.

SerendipityJane · 26/09/2022 17:09

Problem is we have borrowed way too much since 1997 and we are now going to pay for it

Not if we can get our grandchildren to.

scaredoff · 26/09/2022 17:09

Problem is we have borrowed way too much since 1997 and we are now going to pay for it

Ah, so it IS all Gordon Brown's fault!

I KNEW IT!!!

PestorPeston · 26/09/2022 17:12

Why do some of the staunch Tory supporters on here think we can have an economy like the US? Have they never realised that energy is sold in $s

potniatheron · 26/09/2022 17:14

scaredoff · 26/09/2022 17:09

Problem is we have borrowed way too much since 1997 and we are now going to pay for it

Ah, so it IS all Gordon Brown's fault!

I KNEW IT!!!

I wouldn't say that. Brown for the most part continued the neo-Thatcherite monetary policies that he'sd inherited.

he was, unfortunately, a big fan of Modern Monetary Theory which we now know to be a mirage.

he allowed the remnants of our manufacturing sector to decline but this arguably has been a global issue due to the rebalancing of manufacturing towards the East.

Only Germany has continued to be a strong manufacturer in Europe and that is only because they could use their strength to impose their exports on weaker, southern European economies. Now that Vlad has them by the short and culries, their dominance is coming to an end and they are having to step in to nationalise their faltering energy firms.

My point being that the West's stagnation is a global issue that's been going on since the late 70s and I don't think it's helpful to blame Brown, who was really just another common or garden neoliberal.

I picked 1997 becayse it was the last time we had a surplus. Ever since then the deficit has widened and widened and now is at a point where the international money markets have lost confidence.

Lonelycrab · 26/09/2022 17:15

The current sterling crisis started when the Asian money markets closed last Wednesday

The £/$ rate didn’t really change much weds-Fri am though, it only really started falling after KK started speaking, and continued to fall after that.

CurseOfBigness · 26/09/2022 17:16

WhatdoImean · 26/09/2022 16:37

I think couple of issues have been conflated here

  1. Tax cuts for the rich. My personal view is reprehensible and does nothing for the poorer people with a cot of living crisis. These will not (I think) have any effect/impact/cause for the run on the pound. Politically, they are awful, but not economically disastrous
  2. The lack of funding for the above - THAT is what is driving the markets. They are borrowing to give out huge payouts, with NO clear economic model on how it will be re-payed. The supposed method they are quoting ("More rapid growth" etc.) simply does not work, economically. Where it has been tried, you get a brief period of stimulus and then massive inflation. Mind you - this one is so bad (and badly targeted) that we are STARING with the inflation and going down-hill from there.....

Thank you for a clear breakdown. That made a whole lot more sense to me.

The two points are interrelated but have different impacts.

I read the trickle down economics approach has never worked. That may factor in too…

Freudenhaus · 26/09/2022 17:16

potniatheron · 26/09/2022 17:02

I love it when people talk about 'rich Tory backers shorting the pound' thus showing that they have no idea how the financial markets work.

The current sterling crisis started when the Asian money markets closed last Wednesday.

the real weathervane to watch is 10 year gilt yields - currently above 4%. Remember what happened with Greek bond yields in 2014.

Yes we are in a sterling crisis and the BoE will step in to stabilise.

The derivatives market is pricing in a 1.5 percentage point increase by November. Rates will top 6% by May.

Tighten your belts folks we're in for a ride :-) but I'm not really sure how you'd put anyone in jail for it.

Problem is we have borrowed way too much since 1997 and we are now going to pay for it

I cover bond markets and stg was pricing in tax cuts as they had been flagged. However, the degree to which they slashed taxes then sent it plunging today

vera99 · 26/09/2022 17:18

potniatheron · 26/09/2022 17:14

I wouldn't say that. Brown for the most part continued the neo-Thatcherite monetary policies that he'sd inherited.

he was, unfortunately, a big fan of Modern Monetary Theory which we now know to be a mirage.

he allowed the remnants of our manufacturing sector to decline but this arguably has been a global issue due to the rebalancing of manufacturing towards the East.

Only Germany has continued to be a strong manufacturer in Europe and that is only because they could use their strength to impose their exports on weaker, southern European economies. Now that Vlad has them by the short and culries, their dominance is coming to an end and they are having to step in to nationalise their faltering energy firms.

My point being that the West's stagnation is a global issue that's been going on since the late 70s and I don't think it's helpful to blame Brown, who was really just another common or garden neoliberal.

I picked 1997 becayse it was the last time we had a surplus. Ever since then the deficit has widened and widened and now is at a point where the international money markets have lost confidence.

so 'tldr basically we are royally fucked. Credit maxed out, forced firesale economy, mass business failure and unemployment and a housing market crash.

SleeplessInEngland · 26/09/2022 17:18

Halifax and Virgin Money have announced they’re ceasing mortgages to new customers until the situation becomes clearer.

Safe to say this mini budget has been an utter disaster.

poetryandwine · 26/09/2022 17:19

The pound is currently at USD 106.75 according to Bloomberg.

@Kissingfrogs25 is another contributor notable for decent writing but utterly devoid of analytical thought. Goady. Even claims to know that @Fladdermus can’t find Swden on a map, when @Fladdermus is actually Swedish.

All the recent threads about government policy have at least one such contributor. Maybe it’s the same person under different names? Maybe they are from Conservative HQ? I really think that when it becomes clear they will never make a meaningful point it is best to ignore them.

Ontobetterthings · 26/09/2022 17:20

I'm going America in the next month. I'm wondering what to do, but dollars now or see if it improves

CurseOfBigness · 26/09/2022 17:21

scaredoff · 26/09/2022 17:08

not to mention the long term decimation of public services that is going to be necessary to pay for it.

That's what I don't get. People go "ooh, must vote Tory because Labour would increase my tax bill by X-hundred pounds!" with one half of their brain. And then with the other half of their brain they complain about the state of the NHS (which Labour started, against Tory objection, and reinvigorated under Blair/Brown after years of Tory decline), public transport, schools etc.

And the two halves of their brain just manage to never talk to each other.

Well a good thing that Truss has done is open discussion about taxes and public services so people can start making those connections in their brains.

Tax is not a dirty word! It’s needed for a stable society.

Tax is the privilege paid to enjoy a stable society.

basilmint · 26/09/2022 17:24

Some key workers like teachers, nhs staff and police officers could actually end up paying more tax because the 1% income tax rate is offset by freezing the threshold at which you start paying tax.

Research by Lib Dems published in Guardian

SleeplessInEngland · 26/09/2022 17:24

All the recent threads about government policy have at least one such contributor. Maybe it’s the same person under different names?

During partygate the same couple of boris apologists with exactly the same writing style sock-puppeted relentlessly, so nothing would surprise me.

SerendipityJane · 26/09/2022 17:27

SleeplessInEngland · 26/09/2022 17:18

Halifax and Virgin Money have announced they’re ceasing mortgages to new customers until the situation becomes clearer.

Safe to say this mini budget has been an utter disaster.

Remember: there are some for who all is going swimmingly. Who cares if it's a few of a few ?

vera99 · 26/09/2022 17:27

Sir Keir when he wins his landslide needs to listen to progressive forces in his party and beyond such as Andy Burnham looking for electoral reform. Establish a Royal Commission on electoral reform, vote it through Parliament and have the next election done on PR terms. Also, having a government of national unity, good tories welcome (the rest in that disused jail were bringing back) and a 10-year plan for rebuilding our economy and society.

Probably involves rejoining the single market, and mass housebuilding programme making the UK an attractive place to invest again thinks Atlee's post ww2 government that built our NHS and welfare state.

The working title maybe For the Many not the Few!

AuntSalli · 26/09/2022 17:36

Grumpybutfunny · 26/09/2022 14:54

Come up north! You have generations of it because by definition if they have worked for even a few months they aren't counted in the stats. That's before you even get started on those who work 16 hours and wouldn't dream of a full time job

@Grumpybutfunny people who have zero hour contracts which by the very nature means that their hours on a week on week basis, are just marked down by the government as having done the minimum because if they don’t put that tick in the box the weeks that they do indeed only work 16 hours those people would get absolutely no assistance from the government. In this scenario the reality of it is it’s the universal credits people being kind to them because they do in fact work full time hours every week.

swimlyn · 26/09/2022 17:44

Absolutely a smash-and-grab.

They're in your house looking for valuables to take and sell.

You will do nothing though, as you don't believe your eyes...

Wake up UK! 😩

Blossomtoes · 26/09/2022 18:03

Hepwo · 26/09/2022 16:52

The Guardian!

Tee hee.

Direct, verbatim quote from yesterday’s interview. I heard it with my own ears. Does it miraculously become fiction when the Guardian prints it?

LadyFromage · 26/09/2022 18:14

Virgin Money and Halifax have just pulled their mortgages for new customers. Cannot offer them in the current volatile economic situation. 1922 letters being submitted (allegedly). BOE and Treasury forced to make statements to try and calm the market.

I am not an economist but this is all shit scary, to me. This is not how a stable country operates.

Lalalolol · 26/09/2022 18:18

ancientgran · 26/09/2022 13:55

If they are lucky they will be renting their house.

I found this on Reddit today -

Are UK citizens going to walk out into the streets in masses, demand that this shit show stops now and get Truss to step down?

Or are UK citizens simply going to keep swallowing this BS nonsense from their Gov that will ruin their country's future?

newnamethanks · 26/09/2022 18:24

Anyone out there with GCSE Economics ? A C will do. Please pop round to Number 10 and explain to Mr Kwarteng How Things Work. He needs some help.