Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kissing babies

119 replies

MUMbailey70 · 21/05/2022 22:07

Yesterday my partners son and girlfriend came around with their 3 month old baby. A little boy. They are very funny about anyone holding him but i did manage to get a little cuddle. As I held him i absent mindedly kissed the top of his head. I was in no uncertain terms told that kissing was a no no and I felt terrible. They told me that they had already fallen out with her mother over the issue. I obviously wont do it again as its against their wishes but I just wanted to ask what other people think of it. I know you shouldnt kiss babies on the mouth because of the worry of hpv but did I do something wrong ?

OP posts:
BabyNo11989 · 24/05/2022 08:54

I usually don’t comment on these types of threads, but so much mis-information gets thrown around.

For the TLDR crowd : parents, do whatever you feel is right for yourself and your baby / whatever you are comfortable with.
Anyone else must respect your wishes as the right and respectful thing to do, otherwise bugger off and lose baby privileges.

If any random person tries to kiss my baby without consent they will definitely be getting kicked to the kerb in no uncertain terms.

But…For any interested in the current medical facts on this and hasn’t read the links posted by PPs :

I say this as both somebody about to give birth any day now to PFB, AND a person who has family members affected hugely with HSV (myself and DP included).

HSV (not HPV), which I assume is what the OP is referring to, has many strains. It’s almost impossible to avoid it in some form, in every day life, unless you are a hermit.

This absolutely can, in rare cases, be fatal to newborns.

However… HSV1 and HSV2, the strains causing oral and genital issues, are present in as much as 75% of adults by the age 25, more likely as we age / have contact with more people.
These can be latent and asymptomatic in as much as 80% of affected people.
You will probably never know they are “infected”.

The “but I’ve never had a cold sore” crowd… I’m talking to you. This means nothing.

There is no vaccine currently, and neither strain is routinely screened for by GPs or sexual health clinics for numerous reasons.

It is not always infectious, but CAN be transmitted WITHOUT any visible “coldsores” from a process called viral shedding. This would be through skin contact, as others have correctly stated.

It usually transmits to mucous membrane areas eg. mouth, nose, eyes etc but CAN affect hands etc. in rarer cases.

If the mother is HSV+, the baby will receive her antibodies in utero and through breast milk, and is therefore protected for the first few months of life.
Unless mother is newly / primary infected in late pregnancy, in which case no antibodies formed yet and no protection for baby.

So vulnerable baby = “no kissing” rule would have to also apply to the babies own father / other parent / any other family members etc.
Because it’s highly likely at least one of them has HSV and probably isn’t showing signs.

Additionally, HSV negative mum and dad (or caregiver) must then kiss no other people going forward, as they could also then unknowingly newly catch it and pass along to unsuspecting baby.

So no kisses allowed at all, unless you are the HSV negative parent, who has not recently kissed / close contact with any other persons.

In short, unless you are 100% certain (impossible) of people’s status, including your own and partner’s… You can’t protect baby with any certainty.

Nobody wants HSV, or any other nasty buggies, but they lurk among us. And not just within the “nans” and “Great Aunt Mildred’s”.

Always check in with mama/ parent regarding their views and consent.

Nobody is entitled to baby anyway.

Finally, not just applicable to HSV. Same thing goes for any other illness. Cold, Covid, sickness, sore throat. Stay away from the poor mites, why wouldn’t you.

Until they are in Nursery and turn into plague carriers and it will then be the other way round… they will take you down.

Calphurnia88 · 24/05/2022 09:18

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 24/05/2022 08:43

But it's ONLY if she has a cold sore, not otherwise.

Cold sores are the new Covid on MN !

Yes but in my case I wasn't going to ask every visitor if they had herpes and if they were currently experiencing a flare up or had one recently. It's not just herpes either, other infections such as RSV and whopping cough can be transmitted via kissing and new babies haven't the immune systems to fight them off.

Much easier and less likely to offend by implementing a general 'don't kiss the baby on or near its face' rule - if people thought their need for a kiss was more important than the health of my baby then I would rather they didn't visit.

Norgie · 24/05/2022 09:25

Crikey. My kids were smothered in kisses by their grandparents as babies, as my grandkids are by me and their grandad.
I'm glad their parents don't bat an eyelid, even when raspberries were blown on bare tummies.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 24/05/2022 09:31

Calphurnia88 · 24/05/2022 09:18

Yes but in my case I wasn't going to ask every visitor if they had herpes and if they were currently experiencing a flare up or had one recently. It's not just herpes either, other infections such as RSV and whopping cough can be transmitted via kissing and new babies haven't the immune systems to fight them off.

Much easier and less likely to offend by implementing a general 'don't kiss the baby on or near its face' rule - if people thought their need for a kiss was more important than the health of my baby then I would rather they didn't visit.

But if you're worried about whooping cough and RSV then a no kissing rule won't so anything to protect them.

Curiosity101 · 24/05/2022 09:33

You did something wrong because you went against a parents wishes.

As it happens I do think they're being OTT requesting no kisses at all. But it's their child and their rules - in this case they need to be respected. Also no kisses is easier to enforce than no kisses on the mouth etc, so I can see it from that point of view maybe.

Hopefully you apologised and they accepted it? It'd be a shame if they didn't, cause it was just an accident and the baby wasn't put at risk.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 24/05/2022 09:43

Norgie · 24/05/2022 09:25

Crikey. My kids were smothered in kisses by their grandparents as babies, as my grandkids are by me and their grandad.
I'm glad their parents don't bat an eyelid, even when raspberries were blown on bare tummies.

So did all my family and friends with my 32 weeker as soon as he was out of hospital at 35 weeks. As I said up thread his dad gets cold sores,he always has , he didn't kiss him when he had one and all was good,just took sensible precautions.

Calphurnia88 · 24/05/2022 09:45

InChocolateWeTrust · 24/05/2022 08:45

God there are some bonkers types out there.

We instinctively go to kiss babies chubby little cheeks because we are biologically programmed to shower them with affection, it's completely normal.

And mums are biologically programmed to protect their babies from physical harm, it's completely normal.

As has been stated, current guidance is not to kiss babies. You can find plenty of resources online that explain why. There have also been widely reported cases of babies dying due to well meaning relatives who just wanted some 'affection' passing on a deadly virus.

Yes it's rare, but as mum to a newborn I wouldn't risk it to satisfy someone's need to kiss a vulnerable infant. What's wrong with a cuddle? I don't know everyone's medical status and have enough to worry about without adding more!

TW: www.google.com/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-6315321/amp/Baby-died-just-eight-days-old-catching-herpes-cold-sore.html

user2908143823142536475859708 · 24/05/2022 10:02

Someone kissed my daughter and now she gets cold sores constantly, everytime she gets a cold there's an almighty cold sore on her mouth. I'm still really pissed off for my dd because her cold sores hurt her.

I told everyone no kissing because I knew people did get cold sores even though no one visiting had an active cold sore but this is the reason why you don't fucking kiss babies that are not yours.

I've never kissed anyone else's newborn before and wouldn't never do that, I think it's weird you would kiss a child that's not yours.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 24/05/2022 10:04

*The herpes simplex virus can be passed to a baby through a cold sore if a person has a cold sore and kisses the baby.

The herpes virus can also be spread to your baby if you have a blister caused by herpes on your breast and you feed your baby with the affected breast or expressed breast milk from the affected breast.

A baby is most at risk of getting a herpes infection in the first 4 weeks after birth.

You should not kiss a baby if you have a cold sore to reduce the risk of spreading infection.

Cold sores and other blisters caused by the herpes virus are at their most contagious when they burst. They remain contagious until completely healed*

From the NHS website, note IF THE PERSON HAS A COLDSORE.

Calphurnia88 · 24/05/2022 10:17

I am going to bow out of this conversation.

There is a clear divide here between those who view 'no kissing' as a simple rule to implement to limit risk to baby, and others who think it's OTT. For those who welcome kisses - good for you. In the case of those of us who are more cautious - please respect our wishes. This isn't about you, our baby is just too precious to put at risk (no matter how small the risk may be - and whilst there's been a lot of focus on herpes due to the widely reported deaths, it's not just about that). It doesn't mean all contact is banned, or that I will never allow kisses.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 24/05/2022 10:19

Yeah,me too.

DiscoBadgers · 24/05/2022 10:45

@MrsPelligrinoPetrichor my friend’s baby died of neonatal herpes. The person who kissed the baby had never had a cold sore before and was unaware they carried the virus. As a result, they didn’t recognise the early signs of a cold sore, and by the time the scab came up the damage was done.

Blarting · 24/05/2022 15:18

HiJenny35 · 22/05/2022 00:30

Yabu, they don't want you to that's the end of it, there's nothing to discuss, their baby, their situation to deal with if the baby catches covid or any other bug, why would you even consider kissing a baby when theres so many bugs going round. You knew they were nervous. They have ever right to say they aren't comfortable with this.

So many bugs going round? Really?

Awaits cries of what about monkey pox!

Bloodyhelldog · 24/05/2022 16:48

This isn't about you, our baby is just too precious to put at risk
**
Jesus.
**
**
**
**

Calphurnia88 · 24/05/2022 17:10

Bloodyhelldog · 24/05/2022 16:48

This isn't about you, our baby is just too precious to put at risk
**
Jesus.
**
**
**
**

At least @ me if you're going to quote me. And use the full context:

There is a clear divide here between those who view 'no kissing' as a simple rule to implement to limit risk to baby, and others who think it's OTT. For those who welcome kisses - good for you. In the case of those of us who are more cautious - please respect our wishes. This isn't about you, our baby is just too precious to put at risk (no matter how small the risk may be - and whilst there's been a lot of focus on herpes due to the widely reported deaths, it's not just about that). It doesn't mean all contact is banned, or that I will never allow kisses.

Even if the risk is <1%, the worst case scenario (death) is too unbearable for me to put the health of my baby at risk to satisfy others completely unnecessary need to put their mouth on my child. Clearly others feel the same.

But do continue with the faux outrage 🙄

Bloodyhelldog · 24/05/2022 18:12

It's neither faux, nor outrage.

Just soft lads. Soft lads as far as the eye can see.

jadey1991 · 24/05/2022 18:17

@MUMbailey70 hi op I don't think you did anything wrong. Of course you didn't no what about the kissing. I'm a mother to 3 children and my last child was born 5 months ago. I don't allow no1 to kiss him on the face. They can however kiss him on the head. Like you said that's down the hpv. But don't feel bad some people don't realise till the have actually done it. You have said your sorry so there shouldn't be any problems

Nanny0gg · 24/05/2022 18:30

Thisismynamenow · 22/05/2022 00:49

Herpes virus can kill babies, so it's not unreasonable for parents to not any ANYONE kissing their baby as the risk isn't worth it.

There is plenty of time for kisses (IF) the child wants them at a later age.

I despise people (mainly my MIL who ignores my request not too, despite having the virus herself) kissing my 3 week old even on the forehead, there's no need at all for anyone other than me and DH to be kissing our baby.

Just don't kiss the baby, cuddles are sufficient.

I genuinely wonder how you'll feel in 30 years time when you're a grandparent.

If she has no cold sores, kissing the baby on the head won't give it herpes

inigomontoyahwillcox · 24/05/2022 20:18

Thanks @MrsPelligrinoPetrichor - she does start a lysine topical cream when a breakout occurs and it does help - I'm waiting a bit before trying supplements as I understand it can affect growth in children.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread