And the feeling of mild concern I had for my DDs schoolmates primary school yr 6. Who had the height, faces, bodies that would be seen by many as much much older. Essentially 'old enough'. Although only 11.
I think the discomfort I have is essentially to do with how achieving a look which is skilled like a grown up. To successfully look older, and in a way that is apparently seen as great to their mums. When in the past it was a given that young people generally had styles etc that grown ups were ??!! and that's normal and the way most teens naturally are... And still looked pretty young because well they were too young to have got the hang of it etc.
What does that mean in terms of society (men), sex, harassment etc?
She looked older, etc. And the judge jury say. Yep. Totally not your fault...
I understand your qualms, @CheeseMmmm.
Long before she ever tried mascara, my DD1 was propositioned by a stranger in a car on her way home from school, and I am afraid this has been happening ever since man walked upright.
I called the police, who said to her that if anyone ever did that again she should yell, 'I'm a minor!' This is because the plea in court, if these creeps are ever caught, is, 'I had no idea she was underage'. Even if the victim was clearly nowhere near even the age of ten... The law always errs on the side of men. Perving over underage girls will go on until the law starts taking this sort of crime seriously.
Where I live (midwest US) I suspect kids have the same approach as French teens mentioned by PP. In the high school my DCs attended there were no uniforms, and makeup and other forms of embellishment were permitted - piercings, nail polish, intricate hairstyles, 'unnatural' hair colours, whatever. Teens found their own style, boys and girls alike, and there were no artificial barriers to respect in class.
I know that many UK schools forbid makeup, insist on uniforms that are basically schoolboys' clothes in a girls' cut or with a skirt, and in many other ways send out the message that there is a clear demarcation line for girls - being attractive in a conventional sense vs. being taken seriously. I think this is a problem.
Someone gave my DD1 a gift of a book called Teenage Beauty, by Bobbi Brown, basically encouraging teens to make the most of their own individual features, with photos of teen models sporting a minimally made up look. It was an encouraging book for my girls, I felt, as they moved out of childhood and into the teen years. I think it gave them hope that they could one day look and feel sophisticated. The looks in the book and the looks of the teens I see in everyday life are a far cry from the very time-consuming looks a lot of UK teens seem to favour. But taste is a funny thing.