I think that this thread is contrary to MN spirit. The poster you're bitching about has said many times that she doesn't allow herself to be affected by what strangers think, and as far as I can see you're taking advantage of this to be snide, safe in the knowledge that she can't report the thread or complain about it without contradicting herself. If you're concerned about empathy and sympathetic behaviour (the desirable qualities around which your arguments on the other thread revolve), I think you should take a step back and let this die a death.