Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to get another dog even though I rehomed my first dog??

106 replies

TinkyWinkyGwerth · 26/07/2021 15:57

As a teenager/young person I was homeless, as in sleeping rough and living in squats homeless. This was from when I was 17 until I was 23. I also had an addiction. I was given a puppy when I was 18, who grew up to be a large dog and was my absolute rock and best friend.

At 23 I found out I was pregnant, extremely unexpectedly. I went into detox/rehab (baby's father looked after the dog) and then was given a small studio flat at 8 months pregnant (would have been housed sooner but I refused to go anywhere like a hostel where I couldn't take my dog). However, my dog struggled to adjust to living in a house or being left alone. I had no money for behavioural support, I had a c section and a new baby and no partner because he refused to give up drinking and drugs so I wouldn't let him live with us. I couldn't ever leave the dog alone as his separation anxiety was so bad, he literally chewed through doors and the neighbours complained about him howling. He would piss and shit on my bed and the babies bed if we even went in the garden or out to the bins without him. I was told I would lose my flat if there were any more complaints about him howling. I managed for a year to never leave him alone, but then it just got too much. I had PND and just couldn't manage. I rehomed him to an old friend (who already had one dog from the same litter) who was going to live on a farming commune in Scotland, who I knew could give him a good life. It was the hardest thing I've done, harder even than detox. I cry about it even now. This was back in 2002 so pre smart phones etc so I would get the odd phone call update but no photos. I missed him more than I can even begin to explain but at the time I simply didn't have the resources to manage his needs as well as everything else I had going on.

Anyway that was 18 years ago. I'm now mid 40s with a long term partner, we have two younger children (8 and 12), my first child has left for uni (I couldn't be prouder), and I run my own business and we own our home. The time is right for us as a family to get a dog and my children living at home are extremely keen.

I mentioned it on FB last week and had a couple of 'friends' (people I've known a long time but don't really see any more tbh) make quite nasty comments saying i shouldn't get another dog after giving mine up. But I feel like things are SO different now. If I had had the money and my own house and the emotional resources then that I have now, I could have kept him! But then I saw a post on MN today saying basically the same things about a similar situation and I'm questioning myself... Should I really never have a dog again? Sad

OP posts:
REP22 · 26/07/2021 17:25

@TinkyWinkyGwerth

Thank you all 😭 Yes I do carry so much guilt over it. I never saw him again and after about 6 years I lost touch with the friend so I don't even know how the story ends. It does eat me up inside to this day. But no, we wouldn't dream of buying a puppy. It would be rescue all the way ❤️
But you knew the friend well enough to trust them with your dog. And your friend took him on. I am sure his story had a happy ending, even if it was a bit different to the one you had planned. x
Gardentiger · 26/07/2021 17:26

The fact that you found it so emotionally hard to part with your first dog shows that you fully understand the responsibility of pet ownership, which I think is why your 'friends' talking shit is making you second guess yourself. Sometimes rehoming is the best for both pet and owner, even though it can be heartbreaking.

You are in a hugely different position now, and it sounds like the perfect time to get a dog - it sounds like a dog would be lucky to have you as an owner! Having been in a difficult situation in the past and having to rehome doesn't put you on some kind of black list for pet ownership.

shockthemonkey · 26/07/2021 17:26

Hats off to you, OP, for your amazing turnaround. So pleased you're happy and fulfilled.

Definitely get that dog - I see you're planning a rescue which would be amazing. If you owe the dog universe anything (and by the way you did the right thing with your first dog, without a doubt), then you are more than redressing the balance by giving a great home to a rescue.

NoLongerWantHugoToWin · 26/07/2021 17:27

I think the issue here isn't whether you should get a dog (of course you should Smile) but a) why you have those so called friends on Facebook and b) why you listen to them.

AliceW89 · 26/07/2021 17:27

You sound incredibly OP. Absolutely amazing what you’ve overcome. Get the dog and enjoy every minute of it! X

TinkyWinkyGwerth · 26/07/2021 17:30

We were close friends a long time ago. They are good friends in their own way still but live very differently to how I do now, but I guess I stay in touch because we understand each others pasts and it is nice to see how they are doing now. I don't think they meant to be nasty, they see it as straight talking but it's a very black and white world view I think!

OP posts:
Feather12 · 26/07/2021 17:31

Sometimes we have to make really hard decisions that are in the best interests of others. In this case you did the best and kindest thing for your dog. There is absolutely no reason why you shouldn’t get a dog now, you have already shown that you are a good pet owner by putting your old dog’s needs first. Go for it! It will be amazing for your family.

Spidey66 · 26/07/2021 17:33

Normally I'd say "No way". That's what I was going to say when I saw the thread title.

But you're the exception! You were in a difficult situation, its been nearly 20 years and you've changed your life. Go for it!

Garfunkle · 26/07/2021 17:37

we wouldn't dream of buying a puppy. It would be rescue all the way

Kudos to you OP 🙌🙌

Ditch the FB friends and replace them with your new best friend. You are AMAZING!! xx

Crinkle77 · 26/07/2021 17:38

I was ready to say yabu but after reading your story I think the circumstances are totally different this time. The only thing I would say is do you have the time to devote to a dog particularly if you're busy with your kids and business. Do you or your husband work long hours and will the dog be left for long periods of time? If not go for it.

wineandcheeseplease · 26/07/2021 17:46

Get the dog. Give it the best life. Enjoy the dog, Stuff the friends! you deserve it!

UnderCaffeinated · 26/07/2021 18:01

To me it sounds like you made a sensible choice in a difficult situation that was beneficial to the dog. In my eyes that is a responsible dog owner and a decision made from love.

Your life is not similar at all to how it was previously, you're in a much better position to have a dog and if you feel ready I'd definitely do it!

Rosebel · 26/07/2021 18:03

When I first read the tittle I thought you shouldn't get a dog but after reading the thread I changed my mind.
What you did all those years ago actually shows that you are a good responsible dog owner. You did the right thing for you and your dog.
I can't see why anyone would think you shouldn't have a dog. Your situation is completely different now.

Dontwatchfootball · 26/07/2021 18:04

FFS - people who dont understand why being a young mother under stress is different from being in your mid 40s and settled. I would be unfriending some people pretty soon if I were you. And also making sure I signed up for training classes (which tbh I feel should be mandatory for any one getting a puppy, not a reflection on you).

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 26/07/2021 18:05

Your "friends" are mad! You made a sensible decision to rehome a dog in completely different circumstances, many years ago.

You are now in a very different place (well done on that), and are sensibly considering getting a pet dog.

Absolutely fine imho. But please OP... I say this nicely.... train it! Don't be another lockdown dog owner Wink

mineofuselessinformation · 26/07/2021 18:06

Don't beat yourself up any more - you did the only thing you could at the time.
I've had to do it too (marriage break-up, two small kids plus two dogs didn't work.
The dogs went on to have a lovely life elsewhere.
You could give a dog a loving home now. Don't let your past hold you back. Thanks

MoiraRose4 · 26/07/2021 18:08

From your thread title, I was ready to come on and say you should never have another dog. Having read the circumstances, I don’t think that for a single second. Of course you can get another dog and shouldn’t feel bad about it in the slightest.

Saoirse82 · 26/07/2021 18:13

How mean of those so called friends to say something like that! You clearly adored your dog very much and you must not feel guilty for giving him up, you literally had no choice and many would have given up sooner. I felt quite sad reading your post because you can see even now how much that dog meant to you. I think you will make a wonderful dog owner and any dog will be lucky to be joining your family. Your 'friends' are horrible, get rid of them and get a dog!

Veryverycalmnow · 26/07/2021 18:34

Well done for doing so well with your DS and life- yes, I think you should get a rescue dog. Time to let go of the guilt.

Christmasfairy2020 · 26/07/2021 18:55

Get a labrador

daisyrain13 · 26/07/2021 20:34

Put those 'friends' in the bin. Get the dog.

If they're willing to drag up something such as this from your past rather than applaud you for completely transforming your life then they aren't friends and probably very envious of the life you have now considering you got there from such a low point.
You did the best thing for yourself, your child and the dog back then.

Chailatteplease · 26/07/2021 20:39

Ignore the nutjobs OP. You did what you had to, it was obviously very hard for you.
Get yourself and your family a lovely dog to enjoy! And massive congrats on turning your life around Flowers

AmIatotalthicko · 26/07/2021 22:12

I think you should definitely get a dog now if your life allows it. Choose breed carefully or if going through a rescue, make sure you thoroughly check them out. What happened all those years ago should not prevent you from getting a dog. I can't believe your judgemental friends. Enjoy your new dog.

Foofer · 26/07/2021 22:22

You did the best thing for your dog and it broke your heart. I’m so sorry for everything you went through, you sound amazing to have come through all of that and turned your life around.

You’re in the perfect position to offer a dog a home and by taking in a rescue you’ll be helping a dog who needs an owner who’s able to provide what it needs - just like someone did for yours.

Your old friends are wrong. Give your family a dog / give a dog a family - make peace with that part of your past x

CatherineAragon · 26/07/2021 22:43

I really wanted to say OP that you sound like an amazing person with a great heart.

Swipe left for the next trending thread