Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to get another dog even though I rehomed my first dog??

106 replies

TinkyWinkyGwerth · 26/07/2021 15:57

As a teenager/young person I was homeless, as in sleeping rough and living in squats homeless. This was from when I was 17 until I was 23. I also had an addiction. I was given a puppy when I was 18, who grew up to be a large dog and was my absolute rock and best friend.

At 23 I found out I was pregnant, extremely unexpectedly. I went into detox/rehab (baby's father looked after the dog) and then was given a small studio flat at 8 months pregnant (would have been housed sooner but I refused to go anywhere like a hostel where I couldn't take my dog). However, my dog struggled to adjust to living in a house or being left alone. I had no money for behavioural support, I had a c section and a new baby and no partner because he refused to give up drinking and drugs so I wouldn't let him live with us. I couldn't ever leave the dog alone as his separation anxiety was so bad, he literally chewed through doors and the neighbours complained about him howling. He would piss and shit on my bed and the babies bed if we even went in the garden or out to the bins without him. I was told I would lose my flat if there were any more complaints about him howling. I managed for a year to never leave him alone, but then it just got too much. I had PND and just couldn't manage. I rehomed him to an old friend (who already had one dog from the same litter) who was going to live on a farming commune in Scotland, who I knew could give him a good life. It was the hardest thing I've done, harder even than detox. I cry about it even now. This was back in 2002 so pre smart phones etc so I would get the odd phone call update but no photos. I missed him more than I can even begin to explain but at the time I simply didn't have the resources to manage his needs as well as everything else I had going on.

Anyway that was 18 years ago. I'm now mid 40s with a long term partner, we have two younger children (8 and 12), my first child has left for uni (I couldn't be prouder), and I run my own business and we own our home. The time is right for us as a family to get a dog and my children living at home are extremely keen.

I mentioned it on FB last week and had a couple of 'friends' (people I've known a long time but don't really see any more tbh) make quite nasty comments saying i shouldn't get another dog after giving mine up. But I feel like things are SO different now. If I had had the money and my own house and the emotional resources then that I have now, I could have kept him! But then I saw a post on MN today saying basically the same things about a similar situation and I'm questioning myself... Should I really never have a dog again? Sad

OP posts:
SunshineCake · 26/07/2021 16:57

Get a dog. Get rid of the non friends on your Facebook. Learn to make your own choices without needing validation from anyone never mind people who are narrow minded, thick and unkind.

1WayOrAnother2 · 26/07/2021 16:58

Rehome the 'old friend's' (strangers on here are less judgy and unkind!) and replace them asap.

Do get a dog - you sound to have made amazing changes in your life but to have remained a person sound values. You know what looking after a dog entails and understand how it will fit in with your life.

trailrunner · 26/07/2021 16:59

Sometimes rehoming a dog is the kindest thing to do. It was a long time ago and things have changed, your so-called friends are being unkind. Get a new dog and new friends!

krustykittens · 26/07/2021 16:59

You re-homed your first dog because it was in his best interests. That is what a good owner does. Drop the friends and get yourself a new dog. x

Smartiepants79 · 26/07/2021 17:00

Your circumstances are not even close to same as the ones in the other thread!
You did what was necessary for you, your child and the dog. He was miserable and it was the right thing to do.
If you can offer a dog a good and stable home now then I can’t see why you don’t deserve to do so.
Especially if you can rescue one??

Cuddlyrottweiler · 26/07/2021 17:01

You did the right thing then and it shouldn't impact on whether you get a dog now.
And I'd usually not say that

PinkLilyPinkRose · 26/07/2021 17:03

Those people are not friends, of any sort.

It sounds like you tried hard for your dog and did the right thing rehiring him to the countryside.

Enjoy your new dog. 🐶

PinkLilyPinkRose · 26/07/2021 17:04

Rehiring! Should be rehoming.

FudgeFlake · 26/07/2021 17:05

I'm in the process of hand-holding a friend who is going through the agonising process of re-homing her dog due to a very similar situation to yours eighteen years ago. You did the right thing then, and bringing a new dog into your loving home is the right thing to be doing now. Putting on my dog professional hat, I always say at the beginning 'Every dog is different and every family is different. It's my job to support your dog and you to make it fun and safe for everyone'.

Narutocrazyfox · 26/07/2021 17:05

Well done, on all counts!

I'd say a dog would be very lucky to be part of your family. If you can look into rehoming - you may get a pup who was given up in similar circumstances Smile

TinkyWinkyGwerth · 26/07/2021 17:05

Thank you all 😭 Yes I do carry so much guilt over it. I never saw him again and after about 6 years I lost touch with the friend so I don't even know how the story ends. It does eat me up inside to this day. But no, we wouldn't dream of buying a puppy. It would be rescue all the way ❤️

OP posts:
GreeboIsMySpiritAnimal · 26/07/2021 17:06

Oh bless you. You've done so well to transform your life. Of course you shouldn't let the circumstances of 18 years ago stop you if you're now able to give a dog a good home.

ChunkySloth · 26/07/2021 17:06

@TinkyWinkyGwerth

As a teenager/young person I was homeless, as in sleeping rough and living in squats homeless. This was from when I was 17 until I was 23. I also had an addiction. I was given a puppy when I was 18, who grew up to be a large dog and was my absolute rock and best friend.

At 23 I found out I was pregnant, extremely unexpectedly. I went into detox/rehab (baby's father looked after the dog) and then was given a small studio flat at 8 months pregnant (would have been housed sooner but I refused to go anywhere like a hostel where I couldn't take my dog). However, my dog struggled to adjust to living in a house or being left alone. I had no money for behavioural support, I had a c section and a new baby and no partner because he refused to give up drinking and drugs so I wouldn't let him live with us. I couldn't ever leave the dog alone as his separation anxiety was so bad, he literally chewed through doors and the neighbours complained about him howling. He would piss and shit on my bed and the babies bed if we even went in the garden or out to the bins without him. I was told I would lose my flat if there were any more complaints about him howling. I managed for a year to never leave him alone, but then it just got too much. I had PND and just couldn't manage. I rehomed him to an old friend (who already had one dog from the same litter) who was going to live on a farming commune in Scotland, who I knew could give him a good life. It was the hardest thing I've done, harder even than detox. I cry about it even now. This was back in 2002 so pre smart phones etc so I would get the odd phone call update but no photos. I missed him more than I can even begin to explain but at the time I simply didn't have the resources to manage his needs as well as everything else I had going on.

Anyway that was 18 years ago. I'm now mid 40s with a long term partner, we have two younger children (8 and 12), my first child has left for uni (I couldn't be prouder), and I run my own business and we own our home. The time is right for us as a family to get a dog and my children living at home are extremely keen.

I mentioned it on FB last week and had a couple of 'friends' (people I've known a long time but don't really see any more tbh) make quite nasty comments saying i shouldn't get another dog after giving mine up. But I feel like things are SO different now. If I had had the money and my own house and the emotional resources then that I have now, I could have kept him! But then I saw a post on MN today saying basically the same things about a similar situation and I'm questioning myself... Should I really never have a dog again? Sad

I hope you've unfriended those arseholes, op?
FudgeFlake · 26/07/2021 17:07

And sometimes that support may include advice to consider a new home.

m0therofdragons · 26/07/2021 17:08

I absolutely love my dog and get frustrated when people rehome with no effort but what you describe is exactly why someone should rehome. You did the right thing. Unfriend those people on fb and move on knowing you are doing well. Moving away from addiction is hard and you’ve done it and made a lovely life. If I were your friend I’d be bloody proud of you!

Holothane · 26/07/2021 17:09

Totally different now you have a loving stable home to bring a new dog into, enjoy your new puppy.

Throckmorton · 26/07/2021 17:10

WTF?! Go get a dog!! Maybe rehome the "friends" though!!

Cam2020 · 26/07/2021 17:11

Don't persecute yourself for something that happened so long when you were a different person. Get a dog, give it a loving home and put those demons to rest.

AtrociousCircumstance · 26/07/2021 17:14

You did the right thing to rehome your dog and you did it responsibly.

You should be very, very proud of yourself and how far you’ve come Flowers

FlatCheese · 26/07/2021 17:15

Crikey - I read the title and was all set to say YABU to get a dog, rehome it and then get another, thinking it was over a short period of time, but what you've described is not even close to that! Your whole life has changed since then, you did the absolute best for your first dog and, with all you've overcome, I think you'd be a great dog owner. Get the dog. Ditch the friends.

AlmostSummer21 · 26/07/2021 17:17

Ignore the bloody lot of them!

Even what you did 18 years ago is pretty impressive given your background, no one could have done more and you rehomed him to a friend, you didn't see him on gumtree. It's fine to still be sad about it, but don't you dare be ashamed! You tried your best to keep him & when you absolutely couldn't, you made sure he had a loving home.

What you did shows you are just the sort of person who should have a dog!!

The only thing I'd say is make sure your partner is 100% onboard with getting a dog because you don't want to be in a position of having to choose between rehoming your dog or your DP.

Don't let stupid people drag you down, might be time for a FB cull!

Unsure33 · 26/07/2021 17:19

of course you should get a dog . You did what was right at the time and this is a different circumstance .

why not rescue then you will have cancelled out your imaginary dog deficit (:

And well done for turning your life around .

FlibbertigibbetArmadillo · 26/07/2021 17:19

You did the very best thing for your dog at the time and it sounds like he got to go on and live a very nice life.
The fact you still think about and miss him says you are very much the right sort of person to own a dog.

Blue4YOU · 26/07/2021 17:19

OP you sound like a wonderful person.
You deserve a new dog. Get your new best friend and good luck

IReallyLikeCrows · 26/07/2021 17:24

When I read the title of the thread I thought "absolutely not" which shows that you need to read the details before you make a comment. You absolutely should get a dog. You didn't rehome your former dog because you couldn't be arsed, you rehomed him to give him a better life and to ensure that you and your dc wouldn't lose your home. Your life is so much better now. Go ahead and get your dog, be happy, stop blaming yourself for something that was done out of love and bin the nasty friends.

Swipe left for the next trending thread