Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to feel irritated that DH's sibling gets monetary handouts and we don't?

86 replies

jumpingjenn3h · 08/06/2020 18:15

Regular poster but name changed ! (Expecting some criticism.. hear me out!)

DH has a very wealthy family and lives in a large house in Surrey. (They also own other properties across the world) The family business was sold approx 15 years ago and made a massive profit (think millions), his parents made many sacrifices to ensure this business ran well when DH was younger and I honestly believe they deserve all the money they have due to the sheer hard work and long hours that were put into running the business at the time.

DH has said that he has never really been given any money by his parents and he thinks that they want him to make his own way in life (understandable) this in a way has been advantageous in the fact that my partner strives to do well on his own merit - hes worked hard and now has a professional job in an engineering role. (I am a teacher). Over the years we have made many sacrifices to enable DP to study and for us to be able to put money together for a deposit for a small 2 bed apartment that we currently live in a cheaper area of the city. We buy our clothes from local charities, ebay, sell clothes and goods on ebay, we haven't been on holiday for 5 years (except the odd UK break here or there), meal prep, never eat out etc. We share a car which is 10 years old and needs upgrading in the nearby future. I imagine there are many people who do similar things to save money and we are not unique in that respect. We have also held out on getting married and having children because we wanted to prioritize getting on the housing ladder and being secure for the future.There has been one occasion when we were in our early 20s where we couldn't afford the rent (before buying) and DH asked his parents whether he could borrow money and it would be returned when he got his next pay packet - his dad agreed but it was never actually paid in to his account, we were never sure why but didn't want to press the issue and after all it is their money so didn't ask again.

SIL and her partner are a few years younger than us and had 2 planned DC shortly after graduating from university, SIL has never worked (although has a good degree to give credit to her) and are fortunate to be able to live in a lovely housing association house within about 30 mins from where we live. SIL partner works in a supermarket and has no desire to progress in his career. (which is fair enough, people have different priorities in life) - however they live a lifestyle that we can't afford due to handouts from DH parents - their house is furnished with brand new, expensive furniture, equipment, multiple game consoles, designer clothes for DC , they have 2 cars, despite only using 1 etc. We were recently told that his parents paid off their outstanding (£6.5k) credit card bill yet they still continue to parade on social media all their new purchases that they have made over the last few weeks - (e.g SIL posted a new red chanel lipstick she had bought online & she posts every friday their pizzas from dominos) They receive monthly payments from DH's parents to help with their DC and SIL has no intention of returning back to work. SIL husband says he is having difficulty obtaining more hours at work - which is understandable it really is but we find it so frustrating that we have to cut back and make so many sacrifices every day and despite their (in my opinion) poor financial decisions they seem to be rewarded and constantly given handouts and DH's parents are full of sympathy about how they are struggling and how life isn't as easy for them. We don't have that much money either and are skimping and saving to upgrade our car in addition to trying to put some money together for the future - except we don't just spend it all on a CC and then bill his parents, to me this is morally wrong.

DH, (although technically none of his business) has said to his parents that if they weren't given so many handouts maybe it would give them the drive to work hard and make sacrifices that we have had to make to be self sufficient - if they were struggling after making the sacrifices then of course I would never begrudge them from obtaining help from parents that naturally want to help their children.

I know AIBU to have a moan and I guess it isn't our business how much money DH parents give siblings but AIBU to feel that DC should be treated equally and the sibling who works hard and has made sacrifices in life should not be treated differently?

Has anyone else experienced anything similar? AIBU that we both get annoyed?

OP posts:
Swiftsseason · 08/06/2020 20:44

It's the gc and their hopeless situation.
Some people just can't get things together but that shouldn't preclude giving your dh something now and then! Very sad when dp are like this, very sad!

I'd also try not to compare different life styles, maybe his dsis has awkward child or struggles being a parent or has a hard time with her dh or in laws... We never really know and it's best to focus on your own lane and life. What I would perhaps do is dh to ask once 'dp, we are a little short of cash could you lend me a couple of hundred please,' perhaps the mum... And go from there, if they say more, I'd push back... 'but your funding Diss everyone month and its a one off lend please....

cptartapp · 08/06/2020 20:50

SIL got £10k for her first house deposit. DH got nothing. SIL got all her wedding paid for. DH got nothing. The favouritism (that they think I haven't noticed) has extended to GC over the years with ours getting less spent. My nephews have let things slip many a time.
SIL went travelling round New Zealand whilst DH re-sat professional exams and now earns well, yet according to MIL "he always lands on his feet."
Very hurtful and unfair. I feel a lot less for them than I let on.

Notajogger · 08/06/2020 21:08

Different situation here but similar upshot. SIL barely spends a penny of her own money and outright guilt-trips the PIL into buying things "for the DC" - stuff which she should be buying and often is for her anyway. They give her everything, to the point of now asking us to borrow money for themselves as they're short Hmm

Notajogger · 08/06/2020 21:09

Oh and we buy everything for our own DC, of course. No handouts coming our way!

WhatsTheFrequencyKennneth · 08/06/2020 21:19

Your SIL probably moans constantly to her parents about how tough her life is and has no qualms about asking and taking help.
I would stay well out and make your own way.

GrumpyHoonMain · 08/06/2020 21:24

Be careful before wading into this as it’s possible your DH may be lying - my bil’s DB did this to his gf, but in reality he was being financially supported (he was just saving the money) and eventually he left her with all the debt to marry someone else.

RandomMess · 08/06/2020 21:26

It's like this between DH and his sister (minus the parents being wealthy). Money hand outs, babysitting, childcare - we always got refused and then they don't understand why DH is so hurt.

Ironically once SIL met her current partner she ditched her Mum. I feel zero responsibility to helping out as they age. Even when the moved house - "we can't move nearer to you than SIL as she would kick off about it" - she has visited as often as us even though we live far, far, far further away. DH doesn't drive and it's virtually impossible via train Confused

Healthyandhappy · 08/06/2020 21:39

So they was very wealthy and husband said he was never given anything. Was he sent to private school?

Healthyandhappy · 08/06/2020 21:42

And as another posted said your on 36k and so is husband so u arent skint!!

THisbackwithavengeance · 08/06/2020 21:53

YANBU.

I can't get over the fact that a child of multi millionaires has applied for and been given a HA property.

What's the point of working hard and making money if you can't use it to ensure that you and your children and grandchildren have comfortable lives.

jumpingjenn3h · 08/06/2020 22:03

@healthyandhally I have said multiple times that we are not skint? We just cant afford the luxuries that they have without making sacrifices.. we are NOT on £36k each.. ! We skimped and saved whilst renting to enable us to to a deposit down - it wasnt easy at all and sacrificed going on holiday, not eating etc to be able to save enough for the deposit. We are trying to build back our savings for the future, but it's a slow process.

No he didnt go to private school nor did he go to university! He worked from the bottom and had partial funding from his employer for a qualification to become an engineer. SIL did go to university but hasnt worked - SIL parters parents helps out a lot with their DC so it could be a possibility for her to work but she doesnt. That's completely up to her of course, but her lifestyle is funded for them , ours isnt!

OP posts:
caringcarer · 08/06/2020 22:10

I think it is because they have children. SiL has made her parents grandparents.

HairyToity · 08/06/2020 22:12

Crikey. My auntie and uncle retired a few years ago and sold a farm for 4 million. They live in a 500k property, and have a nice lifestyle. They also gave their kids 80k each as a deposit for a house. They were both newly graduated and in rented. They could have afforded to buy houses outright but didn't as wanted them to have desire to work and get on in life.

I'm surprised they haven't helped their children more.

Waveysnail · 08/06/2020 22:20

Bil and sil had kids so that's why grandparents pay

Bottleup · 08/06/2020 22:24

It sounds mad to be so rich and not help your kids but you have to let it go. Its not your money, you have no right to it, and if they chose to be stingy and unfair then that's their prerogative. Rise above it and act with grace or itll eat away at you. I'd personally rather be less well off but stood on my own two feet than be living off handoffs from someone who clearly didnt want to help me out. Plus one day your DH is likely to inherit a tidy sum unless they are completely bloody mad.

milveycrohn · 08/06/2020 22:33

It sounds odd if they have made millions from their business, yet both children live in rented apartments.

BenScalesIsAGod · 08/06/2020 22:46

What’s the relevance of asking whether OP’s DH went to private school or not?

caringcarer · 08/06/2020 22:47

I get on well with my in-laws but their younger son who is now 50 still lives at home and does not pay his parents anything towards his food and room. On Fridays they have take away and parents pay. Parents are not well off and struggle to make ends meet. DH worked hard and is smart and now earns good salary. Brother who lived with parents has good degree but chooses to work in job on minimum wage. In past parents always said they would leave house between 2 sons but dote on selfish younger son and I have always told DH I would not be surprised if his parents left house to his brother as they would worry he might have to sell house or move. DH sometimes sends them cash and is very generous when buying them gifts but it pissed im off when he finds out they spend some of the money he sends them to his brother.

I don't care about the money because we don't need it but DH has felt second best his whole life by his parents. He got A's at school for everything his brother hot mostly C's yet they always praised brother and not DH. Once DH questioned this and was told 'one day you will come a cropper'.

I just hope parents do not neglect him in their will as he will be gutted.

Parents should treat kids the same unless there is some very good reason.

My parents left all 5 daughter's exactly the same dispite 2 of us being well off, 2 managing ok and 1 very hard up.

anothermansmother · 08/06/2020 22:55

I wonder if they give the money for their grandchildren. You don't mention that you have children in your op. I know my parents give me ( not money but trips, time help with stuff in the house ) even though I've never asked. My dad says it's only now they can reep the rewards of the work they put in when we were young, but he also says he can spoil his grandchildren if he wants to.
Id get Dh to ask them if ta bothering you, but also I wouldn't take what you see them post on social media as real either.

Luzina · 08/06/2020 23:03

This sounds annoying OP but let it go. It seems that you are relatively happy with your life. Unfortunately you can't change or control someone else's behaviour and you'll drive yourself mad thinking about it.

(Hide your SIL on social media...)

copperoliver · 08/06/2020 23:23

We have the same thing 2 brothers 16 months apart brother gets everything we never get anything. I get sad for my husband x

StarryStrawberry · 08/06/2020 23:24

I just find this totally bizarre. Who has millions in the bank, properties abroad- and watches their son struggle financially and their daughter live in a housing association property? Not saying it's not true, but it's so far removed from my experiences of wealthy families (not mine sadly!Grin)

Viviennemary · 08/06/2020 23:31

Why are you broke on two salaries. Your Dps parents probably think you don't need handouts as you have two salaries, no children and own your own property. Do you think you might have a problem with budgeting.

kennyjenny · 09/06/2020 09:14

They just sound really tight TBH. They could have helped your sil with a deposit. Instead they are happy for your sil to be living in an HA house.

I agree they need to treat them both fairly. You are almost being punished for being sensible and waiting before you are financially ready for kids but that's life. Some people wants kids early on. My sister is the same she decided to have kids at 20 and now gets helped massively by my parents (although they did this before also).
We don't get help at all as we waited till our 30s and could afford them.

Either your oh should think that's life and get over it or say something to them. Not sure if the latter would get anywhere as they sound incredibly tight.

WotnoPasta · 09/06/2020 12:15

I’ve seen this a few times now. One sibling is perceived as needing help and the other one is fine, regardless of actual circumstances.
DHs brother had thousands out of his parents over the year. He actually earns more than us but he’s terrible at money management and they are crazy for spending. They would plead poverty to in laws and ‘borrow’ money. DH never got a penny as his parents perceived him to be the capable one. It still annoys him all these years later that his parents never just gave him some money as a treat.

I have a friend in a similar position. She has a half sibling who frequently gets themselves into financial strife and begs for money. What she doesn’t know is there dad records it all with the accountant and when he dies it will be taken off her share of the inheritance. My friend said the shit will really hit the fan when she finds out.

Swipe left for the next trending thread