Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I long for a third baby but hubby says no

86 replies

Juicegoose · 01/06/2020 13:07

Hello I’m new to this. I wondered if anyone could offer some advice? I’ve wanted a third baby for over a year now. It’s caused huge problems between myself and DH and he is still adamant that he will not budge. He is happy with two children and does not want anymore. I cannot move on and cannot stop thinking about a third. I’m completely and utterly grateful for my two ,I’m aware some mothers cannot be as lucky. For some reason I cannot shift the thought from my mind. I brought up the subject again yesterday as I’m 38 and he is 44 but again no movement from DH. I wish I could just move on but I can’t.

OP posts:
Conspiracy3 · 03/06/2020 09:43

At 44 I don't blame him.

I'm 35 and wouldn't start over again now.
It's not like you're childless. Enjoy the babies you have.

Waveysnail · 03/06/2020 10:17

I'm 41 and would hate to start over again now that all mine are in school. All school pick ups and drop off, school stuff, after school activities- not fun when dragging a baby about with you

CourtneyLurve · 03/06/2020 10:43

Neither of you is BU.

I don't agree with other posters telling you to 'get over it'. Your resentment over not having a kid could be just as strong as his if you did have another.

Only you can decide if it's worth leaving over.

Darbs76 · 03/06/2020 10:49

I know how you feel as I was in this situation, I had 2 boys and we planned a 3rd (1st child was previous relationship) but then my DP (now ex, nothing to do with this) changed his mind. He eventually changed his mind, it was a horrible feeling planning a 3rd then being told no I’ve changed my mind. We had a baby girl and my ex absolutely dotes on her. She’s 12 now, he always says he’s so glad he changed his mind. After she was born I knew that I was done with babies, but I know if he hadn’t have changed his mind if have had to live with the what if’s. We were a lot younger, 31 and 28. I am 43 now and no way I could consider starting again, it’s definitely hard to go back to the baby stage

Juicegoose · 03/06/2020 12:31

It's more the fact that my hubby is saying no. I wouldn't mind if there was anbit of give but there isn't and I think that's what's made me resent him. It's so sad because we were happily married up to this point, lovely house and holidays, good children....I also dont understand why some husbands are fine with more children yet mine isn't. It baffles me sometimes x

OP posts:
TerrorWig · 03/06/2020 12:38

He’s literally told you why he doesn’t want another child. It’s not baffling, it’s just not what you want!

I think you need to make your peace with it unless you’re really willing to potentially break up your family to have another baby.

I’m the same age as you and sometimes have a longing for a new baby. But it’s just the baby stage I miss - I don’t want to go back to pregnancy, then sleepless nights, then potty training, and then everything else. Embrace the changes that growing children being and make your peace.

PennyNotSoWise · 03/06/2020 12:40

I wouldn't mind if there was anbit of give but there isn't and I think that's what's made me resent him

Why does there need to be a bit of give though? If he doesn't want another, he doesn't want another. Having a third could cause a whole heap of resentment, and could potentially lead to the end of your marriage.Would it be worth that, for you and your existing children?

QueenofmyPrinces · 03/06/2020 12:43

Me and DH always said we’d just have one child (for various reasons) but when our son hit about 15 months I so desperately wanted a second. I would frequently bring it up (in a semi serious manner) and he would laugh it off with a firm no!

However, as time passed my yearning only deepened and about a year after initially raiding it with him he agreed we could try for a second. He was approaching 34 years old at the time and he said that if I wasn’t pregnant by the time he was 35 then we would stop trying as in his eyes he didn’t want to be an “old new dad” and 35 was his cut off point.

Thankfully I fell pregnant 6 months before he hit 35.

When our second son was approaching a year old the yearning began again and I so desperately wanted a third. I was 35 at this point. I mentioned it to my husband a few times and he kept saying no. However, part of me thought, “He changed his mind about having a second so maybe I can change his mind about faving a third,” so I continued to raise the subject.

Eventually I called his bluff and said that if he genuinely didn’t want another then he should go and get a vasectomy! I didn’t think he would, I was just trying to make a point, but a few months later he had it done.

When he told me he was having it done (he told me a week before his appointment) I felt like crying, I was so upset.

However, as the months passed I realised I felt much better because I knew then that I was never going to get my third baby and I made peace with it. Prior to the vasectomy I just kept hoping and hoping that he’d change his mind and it was the clinging onto that hope that had been destroying me.

It’s been about 10 months now since he has his vasectomy and although I still wonder what it would have been like to have a third I don’t dwell on it because I know it can’t happen.

You have my sympathy OP, it’s so hard to want a baby so much and be denied it Flowers

YetAnotherSpartacus · 03/06/2020 12:43

It's more the fact that my hubby is saying no. I wouldn't mind if there was anbit of give but there isn't and I think that's what's made me resent him

Have half a baby?

FGS - he's clear that at 44 he does not want to go through the baby stage again. That's perfectly reasonable. It is not as if he has not explained himself. As for 'other husbands' most, I suspect, would be younger.

heartsonacake · 03/06/2020 12:46

It doesn’t matter what other husbands want, it matters what yours wants. He’s his own individual person with his own wants and needs, and he doesn’t want another baby.

You either have to accept and respect that (and stop nagging him because no means no) or you leave him to try and have another baby with someone else. Those are your only two choices.

Babymamamama · 03/06/2020 12:51

I can't believe those posters suggesting the OP leave her husband purely to have a third child with another unknown person. Her poor children. Harsh though it may be, focus on your blessings as they stand OP. Two healthy children and a supportive partner are more than what many are blessed with.

SerenDippitty · 03/06/2020 12:52

You can't always have what you want. Why not try wanting what you have?

GrumpyHoonMain · 03/06/2020 13:01

Has he given reasons for saying no, or is he just ending the conversation?

MaudebeGonne · 03/06/2020 13:02

You can't change his mind. He is 44, he is probably knackered! Is he the main breadwinner? I can totally see his point and it isn't fair to keep pushing him. He has told you he loves the family he has and he is ready for the next stage.

So what can you do? You can take the time to grieve for the kids of your baby making days, and start making plans for yourself for your next phase. You might need to seek some counselling or life coaching to help you make that adjustment. But that is all that is in your control.

merryhouse · 03/06/2020 13:02

I had the same issue 15 years ago - two children, husband said he really didn't want another (previously I'd said I wanted LOADS and he'd vetoed more than 4...)

I was Not Happy about this, and was (quietly) sad about it for some time.

About 7 or 8 years ago I realised that I was ok with not having any more children - which was something of a surprise to me.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 03/06/2020 13:03

What "give" do you want? You can't have a bit of a baby, or a part-time baby, can you?

Having a baby is an all or nothing thing and your husband just doesn't want to. If the boot was on the other foot, would it be right for him to keep on at you for a child you didn't want to have?

I also dont understand why some husbands are fine with more children yet mine isn't

Because everyone is different. Or are all husbands supposed to be a homogeneous group?

I feel quite sorry for your husband, TBH, if his wife thinks that he should behave as everyone else does and isn't supposed to have his own thoughts and opinions about a relationship in which he's actually a part.

Lynda07 · 03/06/2020 13:04

I don't blame your husband one bit for not wanting to start all over again.

SerenDippitty Wed 03-Jun-20 12:52:42
You can't always have what you want. Why not try wanting what you have?
.....
That.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 03/06/2020 13:05

By "give" I suspect you mean "hope" in the sense of hope that he will change his mind. You need to come to terms with the fact that that is probably not going to happen.

PurpleDaisies · 03/06/2020 13:07

It's more the fact that my hubby is saying no. I wouldn't mind if there was anbit of give but there isn't and I think that's what's made me resent him.

Giving you false hope is far crueler.

CycleWoman · 03/06/2020 13:08

Me and my partner are the same age as you and yours. We also have two little ones. I would love a third but my husband isn’t so keen. Our second is still very small but I really feel like I don’t want him to be my last. I have no immediate family myself and always imagined having a few children.

I don’t think it will happen because as most people have said, it doesn’t really work if one person doesn’t want it.

That said, it does feel unfair when it isn’t a conversation and you are given a point blank ‘no’. Feels like your wants are completely ignored. I’m trying to find a way to come to terms with that at the moment.

MashedSpud · 03/06/2020 13:14

He doesn’t want another.

Either accept that and enjoy the two you have or leave him and find someone who wants children.

backseatcookers · 03/06/2020 13:15

It's more the fact that my hubby is saying no. I wouldn't mind if there was anbit of give but there isn't and I think that's what's made me resent him.

You can't have half a baby, this is an option a or option b situation.

I also dont understand why some husbands are fine with more children yet mine isn't

This is a silly thing to say because your husband could say "I don't understand why some wives are fine with two children yet mine isn't". Because you're individual people!

It's so sad because we were happily married up to this point, lovely house and holidays, good children....

So he's a lovely husband and a good dad, just as you are a lovely wife and good mum. That's a lovely life to have and you aren't appreciating him being clear with you.

His honesty is kindness - he would be a dick to give you false hope. He could think he can put you off long enough that it's too late, or keep saying yes let's try next year etc but he's being honest.

If you want a third baby more than you want to stay with him then that would indicate you're not in a good relationship, but it sounds like you are and you want the best of both worlds - you want what you have now but also the final say on more children, on your terms even though you are meant to be a team.

User8008135 · 03/06/2020 13:22

This isn't something that can have a bit of give though can it? You either try to get pregnant or you use contraception. What would happen if you became pregnant through contraception failure?
Genuinely i mean, certainly not suggesting that deceit. But surely you've discussed it? If you want a third then if it happened, he knows you wouldn't want an abortion? Or is he refusing to discuss that too unless it happens?

We've said no more dc though i do really want another, we did discuss contraception failure and agreed what we would do then.

PrimeroseHillAnnie · 03/06/2020 13:34

I've seen advice on here about how you can cajole and bully a man into having another - contrantly bringing the subject up , pointing out babies when ever you see them , nagging , crying , arguing, shouting , accusing him of being cruel and uncaring. Even issuing an ultimatum but jeeze , can you imagine having to bring up a child you knew was a mistake !.

He 44 , he feels he's done his part in populating the world and I don't blame him. You seem to have a good marriage. Don't f*ck it up.

Dancingalong · 03/06/2020 13:47

I understand your feelings. I have been desperate for a third for the last 3/4 years. Our youngest is almost 6 eldest is 8. Pre kids we always said 3 or 4 but after having two my husband decided he didn’t want another. I won’t lie we’ve had some really difficult times over the last few years navigating the issue and he has said on more then one occasion lets just do it, but I couldn’t agree when it’s not what we both want one hundred percent. He’s a brilliant father and I know he would be again but it’s a big commitment. In hindsight I think we both wish we had another a few years ago and didn’t spend the last few years procrastinating.

I do still find it hard sometimes and have a few quiet days while I process how I feel. I can’t imagine ever feeling happy that we chose not too but maybe that will change and I will make peace with it. I did decide that I wanted my marriage to work more then I wanted a third child.