Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Step/half siblings - value of the term

83 replies

ChipperCharlie · 30/04/2020 12:10

I'm NC'd for this. DH knows my usual username.

AIBU to feel hurt over this?

DH was on the phone to friends yesterday and were discussing a loss that another friend has just experienced. This friend's brother had just died. General sympathising and expressing concern. His friend casually said "ChipperCharlie will know how they feel" and my DH's first response was to agree and respond with "yes...but.." but this was cut off because his friend had resumed talking.

The "but" has hurt be quite badly. I'll explain.

My Dad died when I was 4 and my Mother remarried a widower with his own daughter. She was only 11 months older than me and we hit it off immediately. Mum adopted her and to the world at large, we became a unit. I regarded her legally, emotionally and socially as my sister. Her Dad became my Dad. He's awesome. We remained close - sisters - until she died. I was 19, she was 20. It tore us all up. Totally unexpected. Life changed forever. I lost a sister and friend, I suffered some sort of emotional breakdown - lost a year of Uni etc. We drew closer as a family. Still, the loss has scarred us all. She is buried in the village cemetery and we go often.

We never, ever regarded one another as anything but a complete unit. She wasn't a step or half and we didn't use that term to introduce one another, to talk to others about one another etc. To me, using step or half somehow diluted our relationship. Mum and Dad felt the same, so we didn't use it.

Fast forward man years and I marry DH. I over-heard him talking to a friend about a year into our marriage and he said "...ChipperCharlie's sister wasn't her real sister...." - it hurt badly, we argued, he defended his position and was totally oblivious to the hurt, but he eventually understood and apologised, or so I thought.

So, to hear him say a "but....", made me realise that he still doesn't value what my family unit was - doesn't understand what she meant to me. I was upset last night but didn't argue with him, didn't bring it up, told him I was just really tired (genuinely was - did a lot of physical work yesterday) and left it at that. Spoke to him normally this morning and he's ignoring me.

I've asked him why he's odd with me and he replied that it's not him that's odd. He was so confrontational about it that I admitted that I was hurt with the "but..." comment but that I had no intention of bringing it up so I'm confused why it's him that's angry with me? He's said angrily that his "...but" comment was going to be followed by a "but even though they weren't 'proper' sisters, they were very very close".

He doesn't understand why I'm so hurt by this and is now ignoring me and seething downstairs. I'm trying to be normal for the DC.

I know my loss is over 20 years ago, but it's raw and it's painful and I so, so miss her. My Dad has never been the same since but it's not made him bitter - he's loved and supported me as he would her. Anyone in a blended family will possibly understand how I feel - Dh doesn't understand at all. I'm not angry with him at all, I just feel hurt.

AIBU? Please be gentle. Am feeling low today and won't want to discuss this with anyone else.

OP posts:
bellabasset · 30/04/2020 16:25

My dm was the oldest of her dp's 4 dcs. They were both widowed each with 2 dcs when they married. The oldest two were born in 1910 and the youngest in 1929. The family are still in touch.

MrsHuntGeneNotJeremyObviously · 30/04/2020 16:59

What's true for one family isn't true for all. Your dh is saying that his interpretation of your family is more accurate that your interpretation. That would massively piss me off.

FeedMeSantiago · 30/04/2020 17:09

So sorry for the loss of your lovely sister OP Flowers

I only have half siblings. In my family we don't generally use the term unless it's relevant, for example in a medical context, or to explain the 20+ year age gap and different racial backgrounds.

My sister died 5 years ago. I would be devastated if my husband ever said 'but they were only half sisters'.

Prawnofthepatriarchy · 30/04/2020 17:16

I have two DS and a DSD. They always describe each other as brother/sister and I'm very glad they're so close.

KindleAndCake · 30/04/2020 17:28

It's a very sensitive issue, I have full blood siblings, half and step. I've been treated poorly by step family in the past, left out of things being just the tip of the iceberg, so I now don't trust them with my emotions and feelings. I am loyal to a fault to my full blood and half siblings though.

To the poster that mentioned her ddad maybe had mild autism, there's no such think as mild autism.

ChipperCharlie · 30/04/2020 19:55

Thanks again everyone. To the poster who asked whether I should have therapy, the answer is no. I did at the time but I don't have unresolved issues with my grief now. We carry it around with us I suppose and it becomes a part of who we are. If I come across as overly upset to some, it's because my supposed ally and life-partner can so casually hurt my feelings because it doesn't match a version of his lived reality.

He's still ignoring me. Yes, this is just part of a bigger problem with him but it's not for this thread.

Thanks all. Stay safe Thanks

OP posts:
ittakes2 · 30/04/2020 20:18

I am very sorry for the loss of your sister. Is there a chance he just has poor language skills? That the choice of ‘proper’ is a poor substitute for him explaining you are not blood relatives? To be honest I would be inclined to think that anyone with even a tiny bit of decency would respect how you feel about your sister and realise that you don’t want people to discuss the ‘blood’ aspect as it is irrelevant - she is your sister end of. I am not sure why this is tricky for him. I hope he is not like this with you with other aspects of your life.

Prawnofthepatriarchy · 01/05/2020 12:26

To the poster that mentioned her ddad maybe had mild autism, there's no such think as mild autism.

I have to disagree. I would describe myself as having mild autism. There's a huge range of the condition.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page