Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not tell my aunt that DD shares her name?

79 replies

Dabdabdabdab · 10/04/2020 11:20

Sorry, this is extremely convoluted. Also, NC as it's a bit identifying.

I've just realised my DD has the same first and middle name as my aunt. My aunt doesn't know this and I haven't told her, because DD is not named after her. She only knows my baby is named after her mother (my grandmother.) I don't know whether to tell my aunt as I don't know whether she would think it was a nice thing or slightly offensive.

Let's pretend my DDs name is Maria Georgina. Maria is after my grandmother (auntie's mum). Aunt is called Georgina, which also happens to be the feminine version of my DHs father's name, George. (In his culture, people name their children after their parents.) Aunt lives in another country and has never met DD. However, we keep in contact over email and meet up maybe every five years or so. Nobody in my family has a particularly good relationship with my aunt and her behaviour can be difficult sometimes, but I like being in touch with her as I don't have many relatives.

Aunt has just told me in her last email that her full name is actually Maria Georgina, i.e. that she shares a first name with her mother. (It's normal for people from my country to be called by their middle name instead of their first.) Aunty told me this because she knows my baby is called Maria and I guess she's happy that they share this in common. She doesn't know they share the exact same two names.

Aunt has no children or close family and I think our relationship (scant though it is) means a lot to her. I don't know if I should tell her "oh, incidentally, DD is called the same thing as you because of DH's dad". Or is it slightly offensive to have called her this even though this is my aunt's name and she isn't named after her? (I didn't really want to do this, for this reason, but it was important to DH to honour his dad.)

OP posts:
Iamtryingtobenicehere · 10/04/2020 11:37
Biscuit
Noworrieshere · 10/04/2020 11:38

I really don't understand the problem. Just reply 'gosh, what a coincidence. My Maria is also Maria Georgina. We chose that name because

This. Just tell her.

StealthMama · 10/04/2020 11:41

Well of course you should tell her, I mean, why keep your baby's name secret from her? That's just weird?

bluebeck · 10/04/2020 11:42

I don't get it? Confused

This may be the biggest non issue I have ever come across on here.

GetOffTheTableMabel · 10/04/2020 11:47

What do you think she would do with the information? I am struggling to see the issue.

Meraas · 10/04/2020 12:00

I understand why you are wary, in some cultures naming a child after elders is considered a bit disrespectful because you would be uttering their name instead of 'dad' 'aunt' etc. However, you need to explain to her, the longer you leave it, the more hurt she may be possibly be when she does find out.

SunshineCake · 10/04/2020 12:00

I gave my son a certain middle name as their older sibling chose it. For some reason I felt the need to tell my PIL the baby wasn't named after them as I didn't realise until we came home the middle names were the same for the baby as the PIL. It felt important at the time (I have no family and weird family stuff) but now I feel sad I was/sounded mean and it was 14 years old

SirGawain · 10/04/2020 12:02

I never cease to be puzzled why people seem to get so exercised about people having the same name, and they, or others thinking that they somehow own the name.

Coughsyrupsucks · 10/04/2020 12:05

I’m not sure any of my eight aunts and uncles ever knew my middle names. I wouldn’t even bother mentioning it, it’s not like she’s going to know either way unless she’s coming to a Christening or something?

mistermagpie · 10/04/2020 12:06

I don't understand these kinds of 'dilemmas', like, what exactly is the problem? So what if they share a name and so what if the Aunt thinks you named the baby after her, which she's unlikely to given that you aren't close.

My DS shares the same first and second names as DH's cousin. I didn't know this until recently (DS is nearly 5) because I've never met that cousin. DH did know but never mentioned it because, who cares.

I really doubt the cousin thinks it's anything more than a coincidence.

81Byerley · 10/04/2020 12:08

I would reply and say "How weird! The baby is actually named after my Grandmother and my father, but it's lovely it appears she is named after you as well!"

HoffiCoffi13 · 10/04/2020 12:10

So your aunt doesn’t even know that your baby is called Maria? Has she not asked what your new baby is called?

Windinmyhair · 10/04/2020 12:18

"Oh that's nice, I didn't know that... DD is also Maria Georgina; after Gran and DH's dad, George! You share a name!"

Simple.

bridgetreilly · 10/04/2020 12:20

"Yes, funny coincidence. We didn't know that you were a Maria Georgina, too. But niece will be known as Maria, so no one will get confused."

That's it. You are way overthinking this.

LunaLula83 · 10/04/2020 12:25
Biscuit
GreenTeaMug · 10/04/2020 12:29

I don't understand why your dad didn't tell you at the time because he would surely know his own sister's full name?

Anyway- it's s coincidence and I agree you are giving it too much brain space.

Are you okay? Serious question- when i had PND i was obsessive over things that I can't even remember now.

Stinkycatbreath · 10/04/2020 12:31

Not sure what the problem is .

Alsohuman · 10/04/2020 12:31

Does it matter? Seriously? I wish my life had so little to worry about.

Washyourhandsyoufilthyanimal · 10/04/2020 12:34

I think you’re overthinking. This is a non issue. Tell her it’s not the big deal you think it is.

raviolidreaming · 10/04/2020 12:35

Yeah but I didn't tell her they share any name at all ; She knew I had a new baby but she's not on social media or anything so didn't see any birth announcement on there

Except in your first post, Aunty told me this because she knows my baby is called Maria

You are massively overthinking this and tying yourself up in knots.

QuimReaper · 10/04/2020 12:39

I think OP is just concerned that if she tells Auntie Georgina that her baby is also called Georgina, but then has to add "...but not after you", Auntie G will be a bit crushed. As it is, she doesn't know Georgina is any part of the name so has no expectations that it's after her / isn't hurt that it's not.

On which basis OP, you don't need to announce to her your daughter's middle name out of nowhere along with a "but not after you" caveat. Why would you? It's not like it'll come up. If she for some reason ever asks, you can say "funnily enough it's Georgina, after Stan's dad George. Same as yours! What a coincidence, we didn't even know at the time". Which I assume is the tone you're planning to strike if you do tell her, so just save it up for if you need it, which I really highly doubt you will. It's never occurred to me to ask a person what their child's middle name is. Thinking about it now, I don't know the middle names of anyone in my extended family.

BasicIntentions · 10/04/2020 12:41

It really doesn’t matter.

QuimReaper · 10/04/2020 12:42

@raviolidreaming it's the Georgina part she's worried about, not the Maria part. Auntie G has always known she was called Maria, after OP's grandmother.

I think the OP was confused by the Maria issue, which is basically irrelevant here - the problem would still exist if the child was called Sophie Georgina, OP just doesn't want to say that the child shares a name with her aunt but that the aunt had not a jot to do with that decision. I guess the fact that it's both of her names and neither were to do with her compounds it.

That's if I understand correctly.

Doggodogington · 10/04/2020 12:43

Can you say, “oh what a coincidence! That is DDs name too”
Then she’ll understand you didn’t name your DD after her but she’ll still be happy because it’s a nice thing to share a name. It would be weird in the future If she found out and you’d never mentioned it.

Archewell · 10/04/2020 12:47

I am bewildered.

What does it matter, OP?