Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be feeling irritated with PIL?

68 replies

poppymatilda · 02/01/2020 12:33

This is a really silly first world problem I know but it really bothers me. PIL are generally pretty good - they make the effort to see our DD (14 mths) and aren't too demanding. FIL likes to lecture us on a few things about how we bring her up and obsessively reads the internet for new pearls of wisdom but we just ignore him. MIL is generally easy going.

The problem is that they buy everything for DD! There is nothing left for me to get her - she has shelves and shelves of books, a cupboard full of toys and every gadget you can think of. When DH and I have asked them to slow down with the buying they've just snuck stuff in - and then I'll find something they don't recognise after they've gone home! At Christmas they made her a stocking (me and DH didn't), bought her an advent calendar of books, a wooden rocking horse and then about 8 or 9 other presents. To be honest I can't even remember what they all were. Then MIL messaged yesterday to say that she'd been to M&S in the sale and got her some clothes as well.

I find it odd because a lot of it is really cheap stuff that she finds in TKMaxx or similar and often doesn't fit (she bought her some clothes for a 3 year old once (when DD was 6 months old) because they were on offer and she couldn't find the label!) or doesn't work very well or isn't at all age appropriate. I feel like she just wastes money for the sake of it.

All of the above I find a bit weird and if I'm honest I feel sad that I haven't really got the chance to buy my DD anything much because she's already always had it all but I also worry that as she gets older she'll just end up a spoil brat, getting presents all the time. DH and I are also not into 'stuff'. But I've mainly let it lie and DH and I have moaned about it privately and agreed we'll tackle more directly as DD gets older and is aware of how much she's being bought.

But the thing that has annoyed me today is about buying a car seat for their car for DD to use when she visits. That hasn't been necessary before because we've had our car with us when we've visited and we suggested not to bother whilst she was less than a year old and in an infant carrier. But now she's older we are thinking about going on the train more in future and they live in a rural area so would need to pick us up from the station. I agree that it makes sense for them to have a car seat in their car and it's nice of them to think about it. But DH and I are very road safety conscious and we have researched and chosen car seats for DD quite carefully - I know that sounds a bit PFB but it's just our thing that we're concerned about given some experiences on the roads we've each had in the past. We've spent more on car seats and less on non-safety things like a buggy - that's just our personal choice.

Last time we were there I tried to suggest we looked on the Mothercare website to see if we could get a good deal after they went bust but FIL just dismissed it and said I'll just pop out the day before you're coming up and get any old one - they had them dead cheap in Lidl the other day. I didn't say anything but I was a bit worried about it because I didn't really want them to choose it without checking in with us.

Now we're going up on the train at the end of Jan and I said in passing in a message this morning that DH and I would sort a car seat in advance and pay for it. They've got really uppity about it, are adamant they want to pay and suddenly it has to be ordered today. They've been inundanting our Whatsapp group with messages and MIL has come up with this story about how she is going to see SIL on Monday and needs it for that (SIL has a 4 week old) so it's urgent. I think that's rubbish - when I saw SIL last week she didn't think they needed to buy one at all as she has two infant carriers at her house anyway (both gifted by family).

The truth is I've actually got no issue with the seat they've chosen. It's not i-size but I'm not bothered about that for occasional use and it's a decent brand. My problem is that they want to take over everything and if I ever express any view or restriction on what they want for DD they make out I'm being idiot or over protective. MIL now seems to have fabricated this whole story about SIL to create urgency and convince us to agree to the seat they've chosen because it's in stock at their local Argos so they can get it today and now FIL is sending me Whatsapp messages about i-size and how it's a waste of money anyway (even though I never said I wanted to buy an i-size but suggested he should check with SIL/BIL that they were ok with it not being i-size too). On the wider family group he's now made a massive thing of the fact that I'm being prescriptive (when actually the first seat they've suggested I've said is fine). I know they're retired so they have nothing better to do but I just wish they'd give it a rest and let me feel in control of my child's needs!

Probably am being a bit over sensitive but I've had lots of family visits due to Christmas and I think I'm just fed up with the lot of them!!!!

OP posts:
lborgia · 02/01/2020 12:37

No, not over sensitive, they're bullies. Talk to DH. He needs to get them in line, at the very least you're going to end up seething, resentful, and blowing up. Maybe not this year, but you will.....

CuriousaboutSamphire · 02/01/2020 12:38

Just text STOP!! into the WhatsApp group.

Then get your DH to tell them that they must curb their desire to buy everything in sight. Remind them that they are loved for themselves...

champagneandfromage50 · 02/01/2020 12:40

I can't believe you have allowed these people to take over. You allowed them to do your DD stocking for Xmas ? Why have you not set some boundaries with these two? Your DH sounds passive and you too while your seething with resentment. Won't get any better unless you stop treating them like they are the parents and your the hired help..... conversation with your DH first and agree the way forward

Cherrysoup · 02/01/2020 12:42

Yup, your dh needs to have a word. This is not a minor first world problem, they’re controlling and bullying you. Re presents, ask (tell!) them you’re having a limit of one item and if they bring more, stand firm, tell them one and ask them to choose. They sound like overbearing pains.

Fizzypoo · 02/01/2020 12:43

My opinion is don't burn your bridges. They like buying your dd 'stuff'. Could you not redirect them tactfully to other things like a zoo pass, tumble tots, national trust pass or savings pot for your dd. This may help with the 'stuff' and also your dd gets to really enjoy what they spend their money on.

Rollonspringtime2020 · 02/01/2020 12:45

Just say you will get a taxi from the station and bring your own seat.
You need to remind them its your dd not theirs.
Or back away before they have paid up front for her first car /flat /wedding /horse...

messolini9 · 02/01/2020 12:47

I didn't say anything but I was a bit worried about it because I didn't really want them to choose it without checking in with us.

This is your problem, not the car seat.
You probably don't speak up because they gang up to shut you down with accusations of being over-protective or an idiot.
You are going to have to get over that or they are going to continue rigding rough-shod over your wishes.

Try the broken record technique next time they push back.
"I know you are trying to be helpful but it's my baby & my choice"
"My baby, my choice"
Repeat, repeat, repeat.

SandyY2K · 02/01/2020 12:48

If the clothes are not to your taste...give them to charity.

If you don't like the other stuff they sneak in..donate it to a playgroup or to a charity shop.

If you aren't happy with the badgering on this visit...you can say it's not happening any more, then mute the group chat and dont answer any of their calls.

poppymatilda · 02/01/2020 12:53

@champagneandfromage50 - I didn't aloow them to do her Christmas stocking. We just turned up at their house the weekend before Christmas and they had one there for her. I had no idea they were doing it!

OP posts:
MaggieFS · 02/01/2020 12:57

Aside from the car seat, could you open a savings account for DD and suggest they put what they spend on toys into that instead?

As for the car seat you either have to get DH to speak his mind, or you do it, or you live with it. It would annoy me no end, but I don't think my family would try it on with me though.

poppymatilda · 02/01/2020 12:59

When MIL said that we need to make sure it's suitable for the other grandchild as well I just wanted to shout - don't bring SIL and BIL into this - just let me choose something for my own child for once!

OP posts:
NoSauce · 02/01/2020 12:59

God they sound so overbearing. All you can do is keep on saying things like “ we are going to buy xyz “ over again and not budge and if she turns up with stuff give it her back to keep at her house.

I think it’s lovely that GPS love their GC and want to buy them things but not like this, it sounds stifling!

NoSauce · 02/01/2020 13:00

Make sure they understand about keeping DD rearward facing too OP.

poppymatilda · 02/01/2020 13:00

@MaggieFS - she has a savings account and we tried that but they just put money in there and carry on buying all the stuff as well. God knows where they get the money from!

OP posts:
poppymatilda · 02/01/2020 13:02

@NoSauce FIL won't listen to that - he'll just find some obscure piece of research on the internet about how it's all bollocks and everything they did in the 80s for car safety was actually fine

OP posts:
Horehound · 02/01/2020 13:03

I think you need to be more assertive. Why are you afraid if saying no? What is your husband doing also?

Btw I think I'd have just picked the car seat, had it delivered to their house and let them know it's on the way. Do stuff before they get a chance
They are controlling.

Horehound · 02/01/2020 13:04

Well op if they do minimise it or try to debunk it then you just say she won't be coming to visit... simple as that.

SandyY2K · 02/01/2020 13:05

If you're not happy with them having DD in their car, regardless of the car seat...just tell them that you aren't comfortable just yet.

They have to accept your decision.

champagneandfromage50 · 02/01/2020 13:06

They are over stepping the mark and neither you or your DH are doing anything about it. Until you act like a team and set some boundaries this will simply continue......

Horehound · 02/01/2020 13:06

In fact ..just drive... That solves it all

NoSauce · 02/01/2020 13:06

@NoSauce FIL won't listen to that - he'll just find some obscure piece of research on the internet about how it's all bollocks and everything they did in the 80s for car safety was actually fine

Well he won’t be taking DD then, surely? There’s no way I’d be letting my baby go with someone that ignored something so important.

Nuttyaboutnutella · 02/01/2020 13:08

Im going to play devil's advocate here but as for the 'stuff' it's not a big deal. My mum goes overboard and does loads for my kids, wanting to put banners/balloons up for birthdays, buying Xmas PJs and advent calendars and so on. It used to bother me sometimes but now, I just leave her crack on. I think we'll at least it saves us money which we just put into their savings account instead.

However, the one thing I'm strict about is car seats. My toddler is still RF. My parents know we're to go in their car on a regular basis, I'd be choosing a car seat. You need to decent the main thing to put your foot down on and get your husband to speak to his parents about it, then leave the rest go. It's good they want to spoil their grandchild and be involved in her life.

poppymatilda · 02/01/2020 13:12

I think this thread is making me see that I've been a bit too soft on them. I've let FIL tell her off for silly things (dropping her cup on the floor) when she's a baby, I've inwardly cringed whilst he gave her a spoonful of his ice cream before she was on solids and all sorts of other similar things just to keep the peace and not be cast as the over-protective first time mother. In hindsight I don't know why - I guess I just don't have much family of my own so I've been keen for it to work with the ILs Sad

OP posts:
Rollonspringtime2020 · 02/01/2020 13:17

Imo they think every £ they spend adds to their entitlement of your dd.

poppymatilda · 02/01/2020 13:18

In fact ..just drive... That solves it all

@horehound - haha good point. Wish I could but DH will have our car that day so the logistics don't work

OP posts: