Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Right to be fed up or am I just jealous?

86 replies

possiblegreeneyedmonster · 21/12/2019 11:02

My BIL is incredibly wealthy. Think private jet sort of wealthy. He is also incredibly insecure.

We all get on fine, but I'm sat here dreading Christmas because of the constant level of oneupmanship which is beginning to wear me down. I'm probably going to sound crazy and materialistic when I'm not but I'll attempt to explain.

In a nutshell, it seems that BIL can't bear for anyone else to have anything nice. If someone buys something nice/special/unusual he immediately has to get the same thing, but better. It sounds a bit petty when I say it out loud but over the years it has really begun to wear thin.

I should perhaps feel flattered that he likes the things we buy enough to be inspired to get the same but it feels as though it's almost done in a sort of dominant/power games sort of way and it's a game that I am simply not interested in competing in! We are reasonably well off in a normal sort of way and quite happy with our lot, we couldn't dream of having his insanely high level disposable income level so it's not a game we could ever win anyway!

A few examples: last year my husband bought me a beautiful handmade glass lampshade made by an artist I admire. It's unusual and was (for us) a huge amount of money to spend on something special that we would enjoy for a long time. It has pride of place in our living room and I love it. BIL was there on Christmas Day when I opened it and sure enough, the next time we visit weeks later he has a bigger better version of my lamp, but casually shoved in a non-prominent room of his house.

Sounds silly to be irritated by a lamp but this happens with anything and everything nice that we do/buy that he gets wind of.

Last year we went on a special holiday that we had saved for for several years. Unusual location abroad, quirky accommodation. He couldn't bear it- booked a much 'better' version of our holiday a week after hearing what we had booked. So our lovely special trip that we had saved so hard for was immediately brought down a peg or two and was positioned as a bit substandard. We had an awesome time anyway of course but it grated a bit.

This year I have bought my husband a new bike for Christmas. Was a joint birthday/Christmas gift as much more than we'd usually spend on a gift. DH is a keen cyclist and has wanted this bike for a long time, an expensive purchase for us that we talked about a lot together before making a decision that we would buy it. DH must have told BIL about it as lo and behold this morning he gets a text with a photo of the bike BIL bought himself yesterday. Yep, it's the same bike as DH is getting but the top of the range all singing and dancing version that's way out of our budget.

WHY CAN'T MY HUSBAND JUST ENJOY HIS NEW BIKE ON CHRISTMAS DAY WITHOUT IT HAVING TO IMMEDIATELY BE MADE 'LESSER' BY BIL???!!!!! BIL doesn't even like cycling?!!!!!!

There are too many examples to list but basically we aren't allowed to have/do anything nice of our own without it being bettered.

Argh it sounds so petty and 'first world problem' when I type it out but it's really bothering me! We try and keep things to ourselves if we don't want them one-upped which is ridiculous really as him buying better doesn't detract from our enjoyment of our own lives. We aren't particularly showy or ostentatious people so it's not as though we give a shit about impressing people with our stuff so I don't understand why this annoys me so much!!!!

Is it jealousy that makes me so annoyed or is his behaviour actually a bit twatish? I have no idea.

AIBU to be sick of this nonsense?

OP posts:
Firstawake · 21/12/2019 13:34

See it as, you are trend setters and he like to copy your life .

twinboymumma · 21/12/2019 13:39

I stopped talking to my sister (who also happened to be my best friend) after she kept doing this to me. Neither of us are particularly well-off but everything was a competition. We've not spoken for 18 months and I've never been happier. I suggest either confront or ignore.

Waveysnail · 21/12/2019 13:40

You say dh and him are close. I wonder if he actually really admires dh and wants to be like him. That dh is someone worth copying and he trusts him. Does bil come from a not so great family?

SmuggyMcKnobson · 21/12/2019 13:55

Well I bloody want a stuffed hippo now. Grin

Obligatorync · 21/12/2019 15:22

Oh I'd take the mick out of him remorselessly every time. Or say you must have something truly hideous and wait for him to buy it.
Or tell him you've booked to spend Christmas in a hammock near the North Pole. Be sure to express how much more upmarket the one man tents at the pole itself are.

Lunafortheloveogod · 21/12/2019 16:47

@Oldraver but no one would see his 20inch double ended self pumping dildo in action...

Well atleast I bloody hope not Grin

vincettenoir · 21/12/2019 17:06

Yes that does sound really irritating and I don’t think you are petty for being annoyed by it. Unfortunately you can’t really stop him copying your purchases. You might just have to accept that he will continue to copy you like this and this might help you manage your feelings when he does. Sorry, it does sound shit.

ragged · 21/12/2019 17:46

I wish he was my BIL... honestly, I find people like that immensely entertaining. I'd love to divert his philanthropic gifts to causes I like.

TomCruises · 21/12/2019 21:01

@Oldraver so would that be Oneupthebummanship?

Crazycrazylady · 21/12/2019 22:50

Funny my in-laws do this to me regarding our nephew. What ever my ds gets, my dnephew asks for an identical one and they always buy top of range so he gets the best version available where as we are on a budget. Used to drive me absolutely bonkers even though I knew logically it shouldn't! Dsil laughs and just says "he had me tormented".
Strangely in recent times I've found I've made my peace with it .. don't know why

Yesterdayallmyfish · 21/12/2019 23:04

I don't really get it. Why would you enjoy your holiday less because someone else had a more expensive one? Why could your husband not enjoy his bike on Christmas Day because someone else had didn't more on a bike? What?

Yesterdayallmyfish · 21/12/2019 23:05

Not didn't 'spent'

DrManhattan · 21/12/2019 23:10

Tell Tommy Topper to STFU

stopgap · 21/12/2019 23:27

Was he like this as a child, too—always trying to better your husband? Is he the younger brother?

Rosspoldarkssaddle · 21/12/2019 23:33

Time to exercise benevolence. DH could give you a gift of sponsoring an African seamstress to make reusable sanitary towels for young women for a year. You could buy DH an animal sanctuary sponsorship for a year. Share it out a little.

Savingshoes · 21/12/2019 23:42

I have a SIL who sounds similar and a husband who tells his family what "we're planning/like to do" rather than what we've already done.

I've learnt to say/show very little to reduce having our dreams dashed when we have to endure another competitive chat.

alwaysmovingforwards · 21/12/2019 23:53

I'd use the situation to my advantage and have fun!
For instance, get your DH to give you a gift wrapped dog turd for Christmas.
Look shocked and delighted and tell him how on trend he is and how in this gift is of the absolute highest honour, reserved only for the highest members of society, and will bestow upon your house great prestige, love and good fortune. Allow a tear of pure joy to roll down your cheek. Tell him how worldly, creative and forward thinking he is.

BiL will look on utterly confused...

You've obviously now thrown the turd away and given each other your real gifts.
He on the other hand will spend January filling his house with bigger and bigger dog turds in every room.

QueenArseClangers · 21/12/2019 23:55

@TomCruises wins the thread with that quip Xmas Grin

73Sunglasslover · 22/12/2019 00:22

I'm going to suggest an alternative explanation - though whether this rings true or not might depend on just how often this is happening. Lots of the ways in which we 'express ourselves' are actually culturally determined. Things become popular and are heavily marketed and we find ourselves wanting them. Other want them too at the same time though. That's why everyone had gloss kitchens with no handles a couple of years ago. It's not being an individual really. Its being the sort of sheep that marketers love. Is it possible that your BIL is just following the same trends as you - albeit neither of you really know you are doing this?

If you think it's not that at all then find something obscure and hideous and start talking about your plans to buy one (tarantula, holiday to a sewer plant, avocado bathroom suite) and see whether he copies that.

EL8888 · 22/12/2019 00:43

Yep he may appear to have the perfect life but he is clearly insecure. This isn’t your fault obviously, it is his as he clearly has poor self esteem

Personally l wouldn’t tell him much and l would tease his copy cat behaviour

DonutMan · 22/12/2019 01:13

I do wonder if the real problem is that he can't buy himself a bigger willy. 🤭

MissLadyM · 22/12/2019 01:32

He is considdddderably richer than yeeeeeewwww

EL8888 · 22/12/2019 02:21

@DonutMan 🤣😂🤣

LagunaBubbles · 22/12/2019 02:33

Getitwright I spend 7 hours a week volunteering in a professional capacity for a charity supporting some of the worst-off children in the country and my career itself is centred around helping some of our most socio-economically deprived communities access opportunities so I'm afraid you can fuck right off with your judgy 'go see how the other half live' comment

Haha Getitright that told you. Your original comment was pathetic.

NameChangedNoImagination · 22/12/2019 02:35

I feel sorry for him tbh, and I don't usually feel sorry for twats. But it just seems so desperate and fragile and insecure, it makes me feel sorry. I think OP just be really glad you have a lovely life, and don't expect much from him.

Like PP said i think it's either him trying to bond with you, or him trying to emulate the happiness you have, or him trying to prove to himself that money makes him a worthwhile human worthy of admiration. Any of these is really rather sad.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread