My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

AIBU?

To not get the naked cake thing ?

66 replies

malificent7 · 26/11/2019 00:17

Either ice the cake or don't. Prefereably ice the whole damn thing with lashings of buttercream.
Naked cakes just don't look finished.

OP posts:
Report
Krisskrosskiss · 26/11/2019 00:22

I think they look pretty but I LOVE icing so it's a big no from me for them!
The lady making my wedding cake tried to sell me on the whole naked thing as a look and I shut it straight down. I said I've been dieting for months to get into my wedding dress, if anything the cake is going to be fully formed from icing with no sponge at all... certainly not the other way round!

Report
SleepingStandingUp · 26/11/2019 00:22

Thry do if they're decorated properly with fruit

Report
BrassTactical · 26/11/2019 00:23

Can’t stand icing naked alll the way for me

Report
LEBW · 26/11/2019 00:23

This was a argument between me and my Mum about my wedding cake.
I liked the naked look.
Mum hated it, said it looked weird and she'd bring her own icing to finish it on my wedding day if I got one.
I did end up having one, Mum recoiled at the sight of it.
Obviously just not for everyone Wink

Report
SleepingStandingUp · 26/11/2019 00:25

Here

To not get the naked cake thing ?
Report
AdalindMeisner · 26/11/2019 00:25

I have no idea what a naked cake is - assuming just a cake without icing? - if so that is so wrong unless it is a cake with that rubbery type icing (fondant I think?), that stuff is vile.

Report
Ginkypig · 26/11/2019 00:30

I don't like the icing you roll out and put on cake, I normally pick it off and eat it naked stupid bloody name for it! so if it was that or nothing I'd have nothing but what the hell is wrong with buttercream or ganache etc on the outside of your cake like cake deserves to have.

Report
Ladybirdbookworm · 26/11/2019 00:32

I think it looks pretty and it's a trend at the moment but it really makes the cake dry.

Report
Anotherthink · 26/11/2019 00:36

So it's Victoria sponge without the jam?

Report
managedmis · 26/11/2019 00:38

Like without royal icing?

Are they trying to sexualise cakes now
Hmm

Report
PawPawNoodle · 26/11/2019 00:40

I find them annoying, it's essentially just crumb-coating the cake and going 'fuck it that'll do".

Report
1300cakes · 26/11/2019 00:47

I think they look lovely though as I love icing I wouldn't order one myself.

if anything the cake is going to be fully formed from icing with no sponge at all.

100% would eat this "cake" though

Report
katy1213 · 26/11/2019 00:56

It looks scruffy and very amateur on a wedding cake. All that money for something that looks like a bad DIY effort.

Report
StoppinBy · 26/11/2019 00:59

If done right they can look lovely. The reason that they should be 'semi naked' though (ie, with a smear of icing on the outside) is to prevent them from drying out as they ae usually made as display pieces to sit out for a few hours before cutting.

Report
bpirockin · 26/11/2019 01:06

I rather like them sprinkled with icing sugar, but a nice ganache feels like much more of a treat.

Report
ChristaMSieland · 26/11/2019 01:07

My only thought is "Why do they have to keep giving silly names to ordinary things?" I sound like my granny (miss you Nonna). This must be what happens when you get older.

Seriously, though. It's an un-iced cake, yes? Or part-iced? If the new name requires explanation, it's a stupid name ;-)

Report
MrsTerryPratchett · 26/11/2019 01:20

It's fine if you are literally going to make it then eat it immediately. But standing out, getting all dry and yukky...

I'd fully eat @Krisskrosskiss cake though. Mmmmmmmmm

Report
SummerPlace · 26/11/2019 01:36

For my taste, a really moist cake like a good quality fruit cake, or a carrot cake with pineapple as part of its ingredients is usually moist enough not to need icing.
But, then, I abominate buttercream. I do like icing made with icing sugar, a little knob of butter and lemon juice juice, and then heated. But, for me, nothing beats proper whipped cream in a cake.

Report
Endspeciesism · 26/11/2019 01:39

If it’s going to be covered with the secretions of another species I would rather have a naked cake. Dairy is scary.

Report
Italiangreyhound · 26/11/2019 01:43
Report
Stillamum3 · 26/11/2019 01:58

I'd never seen one until I followed that link! I think they probably look better than they taste!

Report
thecalmorchid · 26/11/2019 02:05

@PolPotNoodle. Yes, absolutely it is.

Report

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

mathanxiety · 26/11/2019 02:08

From a link in ItalianGreyhound's link:
www.confetti.co.uk/wedding-advice/cakes-catering/fig-wedding-cakes-the-perfect-cake-for-modern-couples

I like these more. You could call them partly dressed? They seem to have more of a sense of structure to them.

Report
mathanxiety · 26/11/2019 02:09

LOL, one of them is literally a cheese cake.

Report
BouleBaker · 26/11/2019 03:43

Those naked cakes look seriously shit. Unless each and every layer is perfectly even they will always look shit. Even then they look lazy.

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.