Can we have a definitive list on types of people whose appearance it is acceptable to pass comment on here?

[RuffleCrow]

As far as i can work out MNHQ have two categories:

People about whom it is never acceptable to pass aesthetic judgement:

People who self define as trans and mnhq also agree are trans.

People about whom it is always acceptable to pass aesthetic judgement:

Everyone else - including babies if their parents are famous enough.

Can we at least get a coherent rule that accords with the Equality Act 2010 please MNHQ?

Uh, freedom of speech? Chill out Corbyn.

From what I've read on here of late everyone apart from an adult human female is totes protected

You're kidding yourself if you think MN is somewhere free speech is welcome quite frankly @AliceAbsolum. That's the point I'm trying to make. MN has adopted an arbitrary protected status for one category of person and one category of person only as far as I can see.

You're kidding yourself if you think MN is somewhere free speech is welcome quite frankly @AliceAbsolum. That's the point I'm trying to make. MN has adopted an arbitrary protected status for one category of person and one category of person only as far as I can see.

have no idea what you are talking about.

Me neither.

@samcro op is quite clear in the post.

When men are presenting as women, we are not allowed to comment on their appearance at all.
But we are allowed to tear into adult human females with abandon, because sexism.

I'll probably be deleted for my last post. It's that bad here.

user1471449295 may be to you. but not to me.

I think it's only relevant to comment on appearance if it's relevant. And then it can be done tactfully and kindly.

Unless we're talking about trump or bojo, then all rules are out the window.

We could just not comment on anyone's appearance?

So are we not allowed to say whether or not we think a transwoman passes? Are we allowed to say if someone looks scary? Or totally unintimidating? No matter their sex, gender, or snowflake status.

Not unless you want a deleted post and a rash of 'friendly' emails from MNHQ @fromage.

I see.
YANBU.