Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To attend the funerals or not attend the funerals, that is the question

59 replies

RoseAdagio · 31/07/2019 11:51

I am in something or a moral quandary. Two elderly relatives are dying. We are realistically talking days rather than weeks. Both live many hours from me (3.5 hours min by train, plus the journeys to/from the train station either end so probably closer to 4 hours each way and that's assuming a train is available right when you need it to be).

The relatives are my Grandma and great Aunt. The latter was more like an aunt than a great aunt, being closer in age to my Mum than my Grandma. I saw them both fairly irregularly due to geography but had good relationships with both, and would send them photos of my daughter etc.

The difficulty I have is that I have a 17 month old daughter who is in the throes of separation anxiety, exacerbated by a recent house move and change of nursery. She is still fed to sleep at night as previous attempts at sleep training have unfortunately not been successful.

My Mum has already said to me that she doesn't want me to attend the funeral (they dying relatives are her Mum and Aunt). She doesnt want my daughter being distressed by the absence of her Mum, especially if I end up falling foul of transport delays etc and being even later home. She has said nobody will think any less of me for it and that (I'm paraphrasing here) if anyone does then sod them. My Dad has said much the same, saying I dont need to attend to prove my loyalty to the family etc.

Objectively I believe they are probably right but the idea of not going is leaving me feeling horribly guilty, mostly about the prospect of not being there for my Mum. My Mum was an only child and is about to lose her Mum and the closest thing she had to a sister in the space of a few days. Both will be a relief in some respects - the aunt has had lung cancer, and my Grandma has for around 9 months or so been suffering with what we presumed was dementia but now turns out to be a brain tumour. Her behaviour had become increasingly stressful for my Mum as a result. Grandma is not suffering and is in fact mostly unconscious, Aunt unfortunately must be suffering quite a lot. My brother (much more local) went to see both this weekend and in his words "neither looked the way you would particularly want to remember them tbh"

I'm grappling with the potential guilt over not going and in particular not being there for my Mum, although my Dad and brother will both be there. I'm also feeling guilt over not having made more effort to see them both whilst I still had chance....not so much in this last year and a half since I became a Mum, but more before that. Equally though, from a practical point of view, fraught with difficulties and I dont want to cause distress to my daughter through my absence (I've never not been back in time for her bedtime).

What would you do?

Ps in tears typing this so please go easy on me here.

OP posts:
easyandy101 · 31/07/2019 11:53

Heed their advice probably and then go and pay your respects when it's a more suitable time, child- wise

I reckon

Breathlessness · 31/07/2019 11:56

Is there a reason you can’t take your DD with you?

RachelEllenR · 31/07/2019 11:56

As your mum is understanding of why it is hard for you right now, I wouldn't go. You can pay your respects from where you are and be there for your mum on the phone and maybe go to stay soon with your child. I hope you are ok and they are soon at peace.

CokeAndCrispsAndDip · 31/07/2019 11:58

Your family sound lovely, trust they are being honest with you and take their advise. It would add stress you going, either with a energetic toddler or fretting about being apart from your child. Visit your family after, the funeral is the official ceremony, it's not tbe one and only chance you have to say your goodbyes or be their for your mum.

Fallulah · 31/07/2019 11:58

From what you’ve said, your mum is going to need you more after the funerals. I would heed her words and not go.

IAskTooManyQuestions · 31/07/2019 12:00

I'd take the child to the funeral, no question about it.

TabbyMumz · 31/07/2019 12:06

I wouldn't go. You need to be with your child. We didn't go to in laws funeral fairly recently for various reasons, mainly health reasons. We paid our respects in other ways, privately.

HalfMyLife · 31/07/2019 12:08

Can you plan to go with your DD at around the time of the funerals so you are there for your mum but not having to leave DD? Even if you go at the time of the funeral, but don't actually attend if you don't think it's appropriate with DD, but you're there for support....DD will possibly be a welcome distraction for family at that time too.
Sending hugs your way
xx

TheGlitterFairy · 31/07/2019 12:11

I’d be inclined to go and take your DD with you. Better to not regret not going in the future as you only have one chance with this.

Sparklyboots · 31/07/2019 12:12

I've always taken my two, now 6 and 8, to funerals, because I wanted them not to be fazed by the ceremony when an important one came. They had both been to a couple of funerals by the time my dad died, when they were 2 and 4, and they really knew how to behave and what was going on and were able to participate like everyone else in the process of saying goodbye to someone important to them.

I think it's lovely to see everyone and our kids have always been most welcome

lau888 · 31/07/2019 12:20

As you're still breastfeeding, if you really want to attend the funerals then take your child with you - you can discretely nurse them on the train and/or at the service to keep them calm and quiet. However, bear in mind that you'd be busy looking after an infant.

I'm so sorry for the distress you're going through but not attending the funerals will not change your relationships or your remembrance of your relatives. It is worth taking on board your family's advice; they love you and know your circumstances best. x

spam390 · 31/07/2019 12:22

It will make no practical difference to your family whether you choose to attend or not attend the funerals as they have shown you their love and support at this horrible time.

You should not feel guilty either, as your Grandma and Great Aunt know you love them, and your family know you love them too. Not attending does not mean you love them any less, and your family have given you support and understanding about your position as a mum.

You must do what is right for you and your DC. I realise you want to support your mum through this difficult time, but perhaps you can support her by being there with your DC after the actual funerals ? Maybe by staying at your mums or your brothers house for a couple of days ?

Whatever you choose will be the right thing, because it comes from love for your child and family.

Sending hugs to you. xx

Cohle · 31/07/2019 12:27

I'd go. You'll never have the opportunity to go to those funerals again if you miss them. You have all the time in the world to spend with your daughter. Children are robust, it really won't cause your DD any lasting distress.

QueenEnid · 31/07/2019 12:29

I would go too. Take your DC and if it means that you have to come out of the service due to noise etc then do it.
I have sat at the back and left the room when needed when my DD was small. We went to the wake after and people were quite pleased to see a child there as it seemed to lift the mood a little x

So sorry about your aunt and grandma @RoseAdagio ❤️

Idontwanttotalk · 31/07/2019 12:31

I would automatically go to the funerals of any/all of my relatives unless I was not in contact because they were horrible people.

Your guilt at not seeing them more often isn't just going to go away and neither is your guilt at not being there for your mum. However, if you do go and pay your last respects and celebrate their lives, you will feel like you are there for your mum and will feel like you are there for your nan and great-aunt.

You may regret it if you don't go. I don't think your parents should have said not to go. It is a very personal decision.

Alsohuman · 31/07/2019 12:31

The time you need support after a bereavement isn’t directly afterwards, in my experience. The time before the funeral is very busy and all that activity carries you through. I couldn’t tell who was at my parents’ funerals and who wasn’t.

It was when it was all over and there was nothing left to do that reality kicked in for me and I really needed people who loved me around me. The funerals are neither here nor there, but the support afterwards is massively appreciated and needed.

indianbackground · 31/07/2019 12:32

I’m so sorry you are facing this choice. Flowers If you want to go for yourself as well as to support then could you take your daughter, as long as you log out if she is loud?

Otherwise I agree with PP. Your mother will appreciate support in the weeks and months ahead.

The way your family are I’m sure that your relatives (if thinking about it all) will have understood why you weren’t visiting as regularly. Could you cook your parents a meal for when they get back (if they live near enough)?

Whatever you do you have made the right choice.

pasbeaucoupdegendarme · 31/07/2019 12:37

Over time I have come to realise that if you are in doubt as to whether you should go to a funeral or not, the answer is always that you should go. The ones I’ve missed I regret immensely.

I would go and take dd with me.

cuppycakey · 31/07/2019 12:42

Why can't you take your child?

TheShuttle · 31/07/2019 12:42

I've missed a number of family funerals over the years and regret not going. It's not something I feel guilty about but in retrospect I should have been there.

I would take your DD with you if I were you. You're not particularly far away and it is doable.

ImMeantToBeWorking · 31/07/2019 12:54

Just bare in mind your mother might change her mind once the time comes.

Earlier this year I went skiing with my sis and family from my mams side. My grandfather (DF's father) was sick before we went, but we went and said our goodbyes, and were told to still go skiiing by DF and DM. He died on the day that we were traveling over. DF didn't want us to come home (as granfather would not have wanted that either) but on our second day DF changed his mind and flights and a 3 hr transfer to the airport were booked to get home in time for the funeral (which they had to delay for a day for us to get home).

NuttyOrNice · 31/07/2019 12:59

I wouldn’t go but I’d try and see my Mum soon. Could she come and see you afterwards?

Proseccoinamug · 31/07/2019 13:03

In similar circumstances I took the child with me. I needed to go for me.

VictoriaBun · 31/07/2019 13:05

I would do as your mum suggests , and not attend the funerals, but would it be feasible to go and stay at your mums, obviously take your child, and stay a few days once both funerals have taken place, or failing that have your mum come to stay with you ?

VictoriaBun · 31/07/2019 13:13

For what is worth, my uncle recently died. I live 150 miles away, last saw him 4 years ago at another family funeral and due to dementia , he had no recollection of me . I didn't go to his funeral, partly due to the distance, but also because my own mother ( his sister ) had died several years before ( when he was well ) and he didn't go see her inspite of knowing that she was likely to die within months , he also lived 20 minutes away from her.