Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To attend the funerals or not attend the funerals, that is the question

59 replies

RoseAdagio · 31/07/2019 11:51

I am in something or a moral quandary. Two elderly relatives are dying. We are realistically talking days rather than weeks. Both live many hours from me (3.5 hours min by train, plus the journeys to/from the train station either end so probably closer to 4 hours each way and that's assuming a train is available right when you need it to be).

The relatives are my Grandma and great Aunt. The latter was more like an aunt than a great aunt, being closer in age to my Mum than my Grandma. I saw them both fairly irregularly due to geography but had good relationships with both, and would send them photos of my daughter etc.

The difficulty I have is that I have a 17 month old daughter who is in the throes of separation anxiety, exacerbated by a recent house move and change of nursery. She is still fed to sleep at night as previous attempts at sleep training have unfortunately not been successful.

My Mum has already said to me that she doesn't want me to attend the funeral (they dying relatives are her Mum and Aunt). She doesnt want my daughter being distressed by the absence of her Mum, especially if I end up falling foul of transport delays etc and being even later home. She has said nobody will think any less of me for it and that (I'm paraphrasing here) if anyone does then sod them. My Dad has said much the same, saying I dont need to attend to prove my loyalty to the family etc.

Objectively I believe they are probably right but the idea of not going is leaving me feeling horribly guilty, mostly about the prospect of not being there for my Mum. My Mum was an only child and is about to lose her Mum and the closest thing she had to a sister in the space of a few days. Both will be a relief in some respects - the aunt has had lung cancer, and my Grandma has for around 9 months or so been suffering with what we presumed was dementia but now turns out to be a brain tumour. Her behaviour had become increasingly stressful for my Mum as a result. Grandma is not suffering and is in fact mostly unconscious, Aunt unfortunately must be suffering quite a lot. My brother (much more local) went to see both this weekend and in his words "neither looked the way you would particularly want to remember them tbh"

I'm grappling with the potential guilt over not going and in particular not being there for my Mum, although my Dad and brother will both be there. I'm also feeling guilt over not having made more effort to see them both whilst I still had chance....not so much in this last year and a half since I became a Mum, but more before that. Equally though, from a practical point of view, fraught with difficulties and I dont want to cause distress to my daughter through my absence (I've never not been back in time for her bedtime).

What would you do?

Ps in tears typing this so please go easy on me here.

OP posts:
Yogurtcoveredricecake · 31/07/2019 13:15

I'd go and take your child. They won't understand and you can sit and the back and take them out if she get gets upset/noisy/talks about Peppa Pig. I'd rather be there than not.

scissy · 31/07/2019 13:36

Do you want to go for your sake?
There have been a couple of funerals that I missed (For good reason at the time) but looking back I wish I'd gone.

AlwaysCheddar · 31/07/2019 13:38

I’d take the child. They won’t understand and it would mean so much to you and your mum. Can’t your dh go and wait with the child?

CheerfulMuddler · 31/07/2019 13:43

I'd go and take the child too. If possible I'd ask my DH to come with me to look after DD and take her out if necessary. I think this sort of thing is important, to you and your mum.
I used to take DS on trains a lot when he was this age. It's fine - it's much easier than taking them in a car. They can wander about, and they love looking at all the other passengers and making friends. DS used to stand up in my lap and wave at all the other people on the train. Book a seat, take a couple of little books and small toys.

lyralalala · 31/07/2019 13:46

It’s nice that your mum is saying not to feel pressure to go, but that doesn’t mean you have to not go.

If you want to go then go. For your grandma’s especially I would go. Can your DH take time off so he can go with you for that one?

stucknoue · 31/07/2019 13:52

I would go and take my child with me - a small child can actually help at funerals because it's quite symbolic, she's the hopes and dreams of the next generation. If your mum objects obviously heed it but I think your mum is trying to protect you. Alternatively go and visit your mum with your daughter afterwards, support her and be a family

Pikapikachooo · 31/07/2019 14:05

Take DD and some books and toys and sit at the back of the service x and do what you want Flowers

LaurieMarlow · 31/07/2019 14:08

I’d go and take DD. But then I’m Irish and there’s a slightly different attitude to funerals here.

HypatiaCade · 31/07/2019 14:10

I'd definitely go and take DD. I think children are a wonderful pick me up to others there. I think your DM would get something out of her being there.

fatfluffycushion · 31/07/2019 14:13

I would take your daughter and go , I couldn't imagine not going to my grandmothers funeral

GreigLaidlawsbarofsoap · 31/07/2019 14:20

I would go. I think in time you will have huge regrets if you don't. I'm sure your family, despite their kind words, would absolutely love to have you there as well.

Is she your first born? Travelling, logistics, etc can seem overwhelming with a little one at first but actually she's very portable, not like having a 4 year old who can out run you (speaking from experience here 🙈) and will be a welcome little ray of sunshine I'm sure in the midst of sad times. She's also young enough to not understand what a funeral is so wont be emotionally affected by it all.

RoseAdagio · 31/07/2019 15:11

Thanks everyone for the feedback.

Taking my daughter really isn't an option. Aside from the fact it would be a logistical nightmare getting her there and back, her presence would in reality exacerbate the stress levels of everyone there considerably, myself included. She wouldn't understand what was going on and the sight of her Mum and Nan sobbing would be confusing and distressing for her. My Mum would be mortified if I took her for that reason. As much as getting cuddles with her afterwards would be nice for my Mum, I know everyone involved well enough to know it would make everyone involved feel a lot more pressure.

I dont hold it against other people that they take toddlers to funerals but I know in the case of our family it would not be in anyone's best interests.

My present inclination is not to go. My Mum and Dad will be coming down here soon and I will get to give my Mum lots of support in person here, in an environment she will find far more soothing. I dont personally feel going to a funeral would give me closure. I saw my Grandma back in October when my parents brought her down to meet her great grand daughter. She was relatively compos mentis and my daughter was on good form. We all had a lovely time. I knew in my head and my heart that would be the last time I saw her and in my head I said goodbye to her then. I would rather that be my last memory of her tbh rather than her funeral.

I feel at this point that I would rather take the hit on not being able to attend personally and potentially feel a lack of closure further down the line, and give my Mum ongoing moral support in person and by being available to contact when she needs me over the coming months, rather than attend with or without my daughter and end up being an additional source of stress and pressure by making my Mum worry about the stress I am causing my daughter (either by taking her with me or by being apart from her for a lengthy period).

So I think I have made my decision. Thank you to all for the feedback and for helping me clarify my thoughts and thank you to all those who have expressed sympathies.

Xxx

OP posts:
Alsohuman · 31/07/2019 15:36

You’ve made the right decision for the right reasons. 💐

Mrsjayy · 31/07/2019 15:43

I would go and stay at your mums take the baby your mum probably doesn't want to worry about you on top of losing her mum and aunt but I thi nk if youcan it would be nice to support your mum.

Breathlessness · 31/07/2019 17:10

As you can’t take your DD that sounds like the right decision. If you can, you could plan to go with your DD 6-8 weeks after the funerals when your Mum will really need some support.

Arizona85 · 31/07/2019 18:51

You’re going to miss your grandmothers funeral to avoid upsetting your toddler?!

Your toddler will cope. They always do. And she won’t remember thing. I think this is batshit if I’m honest.

Pineapplefish · 31/07/2019 18:56

I think you're doing the right thing OP. Flowers for you.

Montsti · 31/07/2019 19:03

I would go. Take your daughter and dh/dp with you..these are close relatives. If you’re even questioning it then I think you will regret not going..

Sunshine93 · 31/07/2019 19:06

I would go but i see you have already made the decision. Your daughter will not be permanently scarred by a day or 2 without you. She won't remember it and it means something to you and your mum who will remember it.

underneaththeash · 31/07/2019 19:15

I'd go too. Your daughter won't remember it.

AnnonniMoose · 31/07/2019 19:47

I agree with @Alsohuman. Your DM is going to need you much more in the weeks/months after the funerals than at the funerals.

I know after my DH passed I was so busy planning things, people are all there for you during the funeral and make a big fuss. Then they get on with their lives and you're suddenly left alone with little support to face the grief. In general people stop 'being there' after a funeral as they've done their bit attending. So, when you need it the most you're left alone. And I can honestly hardly remember anything about the funeral itself - it all passed in a blur.

Your choice on whether to go or not, but your DM will need you more after than during.

ForalltheSaints · 31/07/2019 21:22

You have made your decision after careful thought and I am not going to re-visit it.

Perhaps there is something you can do later on to remember your grandmother and great-aunt. Maybe on what would have been their birthday, or the anniversary of something in their life. Something together with your Mum and Dad when they visit you.

I don't know if you are religious, but if you are, you could visit your local church for a few minutes on the day of the funeral. Many churches seem to provide for prayer requests which may be read out at a service- I found this in a church I visited on Monday, and left a prayer request for a friend of my mum who died last week.

maddiemookins16mum · 31/07/2019 21:26

Personally I’d think badly of you not attending at least your Granny’s funeral.

TheVoiceInTheShed · 31/07/2019 21:38

THE OP HAS MADE HER DECISION! After careful consideration too, why on earth pile on with unhelpful comments Confused

VenusClapTrap · 31/07/2019 21:43

I have always regretted missing my grandmother’s funeral. My mother said pretty much the same as yours, and I was strongly encouraged not to go (but for different reasons).

Your toddler would get over it very quickly.