Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Girlfriend keeps making me repeat myself it’s driving me batshit. Who’s being unreasonable?

140 replies

Flamingo1980 · 13/05/2019 21:09

Interested in your opinion. My girlfriend and I are a bit at loggerheads at the moment and I’m so so confused as to if I’m being unreasonable or not, or even just how move forward really.
We are both females, late 30’s, six months into our relationship. Recently we’ve started to disagree on the fact that she is frequently asking me to repeat myself over and over and it’s starting to drive me nuts.
She says I should be more patient and it’s because she needs ‘reassuring a lot’ over certain things but I believe that if you’ve told someone (and an adult at that) something once, then that should suffice.
Here’s an example. We visited her parents this weekend. She kept asking if I liked them as she was “worried I would tell all my friends that I didn’t like them”. I said that first of all they were perfectly lovely and so no reason to do said thing and also, I’m not a mean person, so another reason not to say it. She said “are you sure?” I said yes. She said “but are you really sure you won’t?” And I said calmly “yes” again. This went on for a while longer and eventually I left the room to take deep breaths.
Later on we saw her dad play the drums in a band. He was great, the band were a bit strange to be honest but I didn’t care as I enjoyed it and liked him.
On the way home she said “are you going to tell all your friends that you had a rubbish time and you don’t like my dad?”. This time, I answered in quite an exasperated way that AGAIN, I’m NOT the sort of person to “tell all my friends” horrid things about her parents and actually I had a nice time and admired her dad. “Are you sure?”. “Yes”. “But I’m worried you’ll tell your friends.......”
At which point I interrupted her and said “look I just can’t keep repeating myself over and over like this. I’ve told you how it is, it’s making me feel crazy to have to keep repeating myself about things I’ve said once. That should be enough.” She got very very upset and said that she thinks I should accept that she needs a lot of reassurance about things and that I need to keep reassuring her no matter how many times I have to repeat myself. I told her it’s making me feel crazy having to repeat myself to her and I really could do without it. (I have a four year old and I work with dementia patients so I have to repeat myself all day long as it is.)
That was just one example of many many others that I could bore you with but I won’t so please don’t use that particular one as the whole picture as it isn’t. I was giving it as a general idea of the structure of how these discussions go. They happen so so often, it just now seems like endless repetitive questions that I’ve answered again and again and it’s really grinding me down.

Now ladies, I’m genuinely confused. Who the eff is being unreasonable and what can I do about it??

OP posts:
Inkstainedmags · 16/05/2019 20:20

To me this sounds like badgering due to insecurity and would be a deal-breaker for me. It sounds mentally exhausting. Blaming it on 'loving you so much' seems manipulative as well. Like it's ok to imply I don't trust you and need constant reassurance to the point of affecting your mental health because it's a sign of my love for you. Nopity nope.

HeronLanyon · 16/05/2019 20:29

Neither of you are bu. It would drive me bonkers. I recognise it a bit in me during times of real stress. Your relationship is new and the examples you’ve given are to do with how you or others will perceive you being a couple maybe ? Is it about other things also? Maybe she’s not had an easy time for herself in accepting she’s gay ??
Can you nip it in the bud a bit - I mean help her obvs - by a bit more often volunteering normal natural things ? Are you maybe a bit non communicative??
Loads of as which may be rubbish. It that’s what I thought.
Actually my dp and I are a little like this. I have changed a lot for the better but am aware sometimes I still seek assurance - not to this level - but more than dp is comfortable with.
Hmmm are you my dp !? Grin

Inkstainedmags · 16/05/2019 20:29

I'd also like to point out the difference between anxiety (a mental health condition that pervades all aspects of ones life and which a sufferer can manage but never be 'rid of') and insecurity (doubt in oneself or another that you can make up your mind to work on and move past). The partner sounds insecure to me rather than an anxiety sufferer but even if it were anxiety, it is not something that OP could help her partner 'get over' by behaving in just the right way. Suggesting so minimises anxiety and places an impossible burden on OP.

In any case, neither one should be used as an excuse to treat another person in a way that affects their mental health.

CodenameVillanelle · 16/05/2019 20:33

If this is genuinely anxiety then constant reassurance won't help - it will make it worse. The more that reassurance seeking is met with reassurance the more it feeds the anxiety or compulsion.
However this definitely also could be signs of controlling or coercive behaviour. Be wary.

Inkstainedmags · 16/05/2019 20:41

signs of controlling or coercive behaviour

I agree. I think if the partner were male a lot more people would be calling this a red flag rather than telling OP to pander to it a while longer and it will get better.

Flamingo1980 · 16/05/2019 21:15

Hiya all. Sorry I’ve been at work for the last few days but have had so so much to think about thanks to your input. I’ve really changed the way I think about things and am being much firmer with her and much more sure in my assertions that I might actually be right and I don’t back down anymore. She’s reallu seeing the difference and so far obviously isn’t happy with my new firm approach but we will see if it actually makes things progress or break down. Thank you again so much for your incredible advice..

OP posts:
BasilFaulty · 16/05/2019 21:50

Sounds like you're dealing with it well OP, giving her this one last chance to rectify her behaviour and save the relationship.

FWIW, I think you sound incredibly emotionally intelligent and an absolute catch Smile

Shallowhals · 16/05/2019 22:32

I felt dizzy and agitated just reading that OP Confused I’d bow out... neediness/weakness is terribly unattractive to me though.

MrMeSeeks · 17/05/2019 08:23

This really does sound like ocd

StoatofDisarray · 17/05/2019 08:33

It depends how much you (really) like her. Imagine she never changes: is she worth learning to live with? Be honest with yourself. It's only six months and other girlfriends are available!

LetheBiscuit · 17/05/2019 13:03

I have this kind of insecurity, albeit not to this degree, and I found it helpful to talk to friends, rather than the partner involved in the anxiety!

However, she may just not be well suited to you and need someone who is perhaps more demonstrative in general. It's hard to know from your messages how you are, but my current SO is constantly complimenting me and saying reassuring things and I just don't question his love or loyalty for me like i did previous relationships. It isn't wrong at all to not be this demonstrative about feelings - I myself am not! - but perhaps she needs someone like that.

I would say to her that you love her, but it is stressful for you to reassure her so often, and that perhaps it would help if she could talk about her anxieties with friends/family or even a professional in the area. It is a lot of weight to put on a new relationship, even if you both love each other.

Flamingo1980 · 17/05/2019 13:56

Basilfawlty- bless you! I don’t know about being a catch but I’m certainly more clued up emotionally than I used to be - thank god.

And yes we do seem to be pretty badly suited. It’s a shame but that’s life sometimes I guess.

OP posts:
ThatCurlyGirl · 17/05/2019 14:38

Have you ends a @Flamingo1980 or are you still trying but putting your concerns out in the open?

She needs proper distance from you - a break or break up - to get some help with such extreme behaviour and then you could perhaps try again.

If not she will try for a while without getting help but ultimately will revert to usual type. By which point you'll be even more frustrated, resentful and done!

Leaving now is the kindest thing as it will help her think about how she functions in a relationship so could change her life for the better.

She sounds like she may threaten to harm herself if you try to leave further down the line so I'd get out before she gets any more dependent on you.

I really hope you can be strong and do that. Good luck!

ThatCurlyGirl · 17/05/2019 14:39

have you ended it @Flamingo1980*

Sorry typo in previous post

Flamingo1980 · 18/05/2019 10:30

I do have a lot to think about thank you everyone. I really really do appreciate everyone’s input and advice. I’m always so so impressed and humbled by everyone going out of their way to help each other on here. Really life affirming stuff.

That curly girl- I sent you a private message about something you said which resonated so check your inbox 😀.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page