Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if I’m being precious about mean gifts

80 replies

ForInstance · 28/01/2019 19:19

To start with: very first world problem disclaimer. Happy for responses that say IABU, but not on the grounds of first-worldliness.

I have a very close friend, whom I consider to be my best friend. She was (the only) bridesmaid at my wedding, we have supported each other through a lot. Relevant to the below is that she doesn’t have any financial difficulties.

I recently had my first DC. We / he have received all sorts of lovely new baby presents from friends, colleagues, wider family, etc. This bff got him a large muslin (a very nice one) that I happen to know cost a tenner. Whilst I’d be delighted with that from another friend, I really think it’s on the mean side for a best friend’s first born.

BFF has form for this. For me and DH’s wedding she said she wanted to get us a dinner at a top restaurant in Tokyo (our honeymoon destination). She had been to this restaurant previously. Originally she said she would book it for us and arrange to pick up the bill. This then became: she would give us some yen in advance and tell us where the restaurant was. Then this became: we would pay and she would reimburse us. At her request, I kept the bill and gave it to her with lots of thanks when we returned. She never reimbursed me or mentioned it again. I felt too awkward to ask.

I don’t know what to feel about this. I really don’t want to be the kind of person that sets too much store by material gifts or monetary value, but I feel partly hurt (like this reflects a lack of value for our friendship) and partly just appalled by what I see as her bad manners. DH says I just need to accept her meanness as a character flaw like any other. I guess he’s right, and I’d never say anything to her, but I can’t help it affecting how I feel about her. AIBU?

OP posts:
Mmmhmmm · 29/01/2019 13:44

Your friend is cheap, unfortunately cheap people can't be changed.

catmumof1 · 29/01/2019 15:43

A £10 muslin is a good present I think, she could have spent more but if she might not have any idea what to buy new mums/babies; I've given all my new mum friends muslins and bibs, saying that I also sent one of my closer friends a takeaway voucher!
If she's your best friend and you want flowers and dinner then just ask her.

Tokyo dinner thing is bad though and she was clearly trying to back out of it.

NCjustforthisthread · 29/01/2019 16:02

i Don’t know - it’s all down to what you can afford surely. I would give my siblings children gifts of over £100 and they would do the same for me, my sister spends a lot more on my daughter as she is her godmother.

Maybe your friend has money issues and is too embarrassed to say?

OneStepSideways · 29/01/2019 19:03

The restaurant thing is really bad. Could she have just forgotten? Or was the bill more than she expected and she can't afford to pay it yet or resents it? You say she's well off but she may have expenses you're not aware of, or debt. Or perhaps just a busy few months of weddings/christenings/expensive events?

What did she give you as a wedding gift? Could she have gone off the restaurant idea and given you an expensive wedding gift instead, and expected you to dismiss the meal idea or only pay a bit towards it?

Could she have overspent for your wedding? I was once the only bridesmaid and clocked up around £700 on travel expenses (to and from dress fittings, my outfit and shoes, hair and make up, treating the bride to a spa day, hotel costs the night before and after the wedding). And used up loads of annual Leave too.

The muslin sounds a thoughtful gift. New parents tend to get overwhelmed with baby clothes/toys/accessories they don't use. When my best friend had her first I was so excited I nipped into Boots to buy a pack of rompers then went straight to the hospital! But I've given her many small gifts since, once I knew what sort of things she needed and wanted.

ForInstance · 29/01/2019 20:20

@OneStepSideways This meal was what she gave (didn’t give) us as a wedding gift - that’s the point! I’ve responded to a PP above about whether the wedding and hen party could have left her out of pocket. No travel or accommodation required for either event. So she would have spent on: fancy meal and drinks split 5 ways and subsidised by my sister, dress for the wedding (her completely free choice of dress. I offered to pay but she declined as she said she’d happily wear it in future). Plus one day of leave to attend the hen do. I did try not to put her to too much trouble as I would have hated that.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread