Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU or is DH re. DS’s hobby

104 replies

CoffeeChocolateWine · 22/01/2019 10:09

Interested in getting some perspectives on this. Our DS is 10. Since the age of 5 he has been taking part in a sport as a hobby. It involves training on a Saturday and a competitive match on a Sunday during the season. For 5 years he has shown quite admirable commitment to this but over the past year or so he has been losing enthusiasm for it. I should also add that I wouldn’t say he is hugely talented at it...he’s decent and he gets enjoyment from it and likes the social side of it. However, we’ve noticed that he doesn’t always want to go to his training or he’s not putting enough effort into the competitions. He’s lost the passion for it and he admitted this to us about a year ago.

DH’s response to this was that he needed to spend even more time doing it, to practice more and to reignite the passion. So he started practising with DS in the garden and at the park at whatever opportunity they could get. Initially I was pretty supportive of this and DS was enjoying spending that time with his Dad, sometimes his performance in his hobby would improve a bit but it was very up and down, but it was still very clear that the passion for it had gone.

DH has been getting frustrated by it in recent months (he’s taken to taking DS to pretty much all of the training and matches whereas we used to take it in turns). He often comes back annoyed that DS has not put enough effort it and hasn’t done very well. Two weeks ago he ended up having a bit of a go at him about it that he (DH) is putting a lot of his own time into practising with him and supporting him but DS doesn’t put the effort in.

It ended up with DS admitting that he want to stop his hobby. I told him that if ha’s what he wants to do then that’s ok, after all hobbies are meant to be fun and something you really love doing. I also said that it would give us an opportunity to try something new and find something that he does feel passionate about. He seemed up for this and we talked about some things that he might like to try. DH however was very quiet. He later said to me that I gave him a very negative message that ‘quitting is ok’ and keeps saying “I’m not having a quitter for a son”. He’s now talking more and more about spending even more time doing this hobby! This seems ridiculous to me. He’s 10 years old and has been committed to his hobby for 5 years. Now he wants to try something new because he’s decided that the sport he discovered at the age of 5 isn’t his passion. I’m getting frustrated with DH’s attitude because I feel that by spending all his time doing a hobby that he’s not passionate about, we’re holding him back from finding the thing he is passionate about! But DH has got a bee in his bonnet about him being a quitter.

Who is being unreasonable?

OP posts:
BrendasUmbrella · 22/01/2019 10:31

He's either trying to live vicariously through his child, or he wants the bragging rights of saying his son plays football/rugby for a team. But he clearly is only thinking about what benefits him and not what benefits his son.

CostanzaG · 22/01/2019 10:31

I’m not having a quitter for a son

Disgraceful.

Yabbers · 22/01/2019 10:34

Your son now hates it because DH is putting pressure on him and they end up fighting every week and now he is forcing him to do it when he hates it?

I would first do a few weeks of just you dropping him off, see if the joy returns. If not, let him quit. There is nothing worse than being forced into something you hate.

If he starts to enjoy it again, explain to DH that he has to back off and let him be when he takes DD along.

3timeslucky · 22/01/2019 10:34

Your DH is clearly being unreasonable here.

If he wants to have someone excel and show lifelong commitment to a sport, suggest he takes one up himself.

For a 10 year old child to want to try something new is entirely normal (and to be commended imho).

justonemoreminutepls · 22/01/2019 10:34

All this pressure would be enough to ruin most people's passion for something.
If you aren't enjoying something as much, doing more of it is NEVER going to work. Ridiculous.

I will say, one of my biggest regrets in life was being allowed to give up all my hobbies.

Perhaps, if you could look at a skilled hobby for him... an instrument or something... and explain that if he would like to give up current hobby, he'd have to replace it with something else and show the same commitment - explain it will help him later in life etc.

MoreCheeseDear · 22/01/2019 10:34

You don't need a prick for a husband.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 22/01/2019 10:35

Your DH's attitude is really weird.

Does he not want his son to be happy?

Is it more important to him that he spends hours training for a sport he no longer enjoys?

You can't force someone to be passionate about something they don't like... not sure how you broach this though as he sounds like he has dug his heels into this outdated attitude of 'I'm not having a quitter for a son' - horrible words.

CoffeeChocolateWine · 22/01/2019 10:35

Oh yes, Matilda, I meant to say that DS and I agreed that as he has committed to his team for the season that he should honour that so he woll do it till the end of the season.

Gemme, I think part of DH's attitude stems from the fact that as a child he was allowed to quit things at the very first opportunity and he has a few regrets. But as I said in my OP, this has not been a snap decision from DS.

MerryMarigold, DS does also learn a.musical instrument as well whih je been doing for 3 years. He is a really sporty boy which is why I honestly think there is a sport out there for him that will become a passion for him. But it's not this. I should also say that it's not even as if this sport was ever my DH's hobby...but he does now have a group of friends from there whose kids also go and I think there is a part of him that will miss it too.

OP posts:
FishCanFly · 22/01/2019 10:36

can you reach a compromise? like - stick until the end of the season/term/year - then take it from there?

MrsSpenserGregson · 22/01/2019 10:41

I was forced - yes, forced - as a child and all through my teens to take part in a sport (sailing) which my parents, particularly my dad, loved. I hated it. This was the 70s and 80s and my parents were old school - you did what they said, end of.

I won't go near a bloody boat now.

Your DH is BU. Sport is supposed to be fun.

My DD currently does no out-of-school organised activities at all. This is ok. She spends loads of time baking, drawing and painting, walking the dog, and seeing her friends. My DS does loads of football and cricket - this is also ok. Different things for different people.

Secretsquirrelisfedup · 22/01/2019 10:43

I’d ask him what’s so bad about quitting something that isn’t either enjoyable or essential. Also why set the example that if something is not the right fit for you, you must never ever quit or change it? Following that train of thought he would presumably like his son to stick at the first job he ever gets regardless of whether or not it makes him miserable and never look for anything better.

I’d far rather send the message that if something is not working for you it’s ok to make changes and try new things. Especially when it comes to hobbies, which are supposed to be something to enjoy in your free time when you’re not forced to be in school/work.

paintinmyhairAgain · 22/01/2019 10:44

you are married to an selfish idiot with regards to your son, i feel sorry for your ds. he's done so well.

ColdBrexitWithMilkForBreakfast · 22/01/2019 10:44

He's gone along with it for 5 years.

"not having a quitter for a son"

Hmm What an incredibly stupid thing to say. What he is teaching his son is that if he truly hates something he should stay at it to prove a point.

SO crappy job, keep at it. Don't be a quitter.
Shit relationship, stick with it!

Bad friends, don't leave them!

It is just bad parenting.

Purplecatshopaholic · 22/01/2019 10:44

FFS, the child is 10! Your OH is being a twat!

JacksonPillock · 22/01/2019 10:45

Your DH is BU. I had a habit of giving things up a bit easily as a child and later wishing I hadn't, so I'm all for a bit of encouragement to stick things out for a while, but you said your DH has already been doing that for the last year!

Stopping doing a hobby that you no longer enjoy is not "quitting"!

I would try to find something else for DS to start up that he might enjoy more. Trying new hobbies/sports is fun!

JennyHolzersGhost · 22/01/2019 10:45

Maybe your DH can volunteer to coach at the club if he would like to continue his involvement in it.

CoffeeChocolateWine · 22/01/2019 10:47

Also I just want to say that although I get that this issue probably paints in a less than complimentary light, DH is not a bad person. He is a massively hands on Dad who really wants to support and take an interest in his kids in whatever that do. I love that about him but he clearly has got overinvested in this. He's not that type of overcompetitive Dad that shouts at his kid for not doing well or makes him cry or feel rubbish about himself. They certainlyy don't end up arguing every week. But he just gets frustrated hat he's goes along and doesn't do his best when they both dedicate such a lot of time to it.

Anyway I am glad that you agree with my point of view and I will talk to him.

OP posts:
strawberrypenguin · 22/01/2019 10:47

Your DH is being massively unreasonable. Our passions and tastes change as we grow. Your DS has been committed for 5 years and it sounds like a big commitment too taking most of the weekend.

If he isn't enjoying it anymore he should absolutely stop doing it. He's been very grown up in talking to you openly about it as well.

Omzlas · 22/01/2019 10:47

DH is being a bully with his "I'm not having a quitter for a son" bullshit. He's projecting and he needs to wind his neck in

Your DS has already stuck to this hobby for 5 years and he's agreed to see out the season. Can't say fairer. We all outgrow things.

YANBU. DH is BU.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 22/01/2019 10:48

Tell your DH to join his own football team.

Bobbybear10 · 22/01/2019 10:49

I would suggest your DH needs a hobby of his own, could you suggest this and help him find something he might enjoy doing?

Obviously he is completely unreasonable and also has a horribly toxic attitude that hopefully won’t transfer to your DS!

anniehm · 22/01/2019 10:52

Sorry it sounds like a typical football dad scenario. He's far from unusual your dh. But rather than just quitting I would suggest that your ds instead says what he wants to do instead, I would also caution that most kids go through a quitting phase but looking back are glad you encouraged them to continue, eg say ok play to the end of the season then we will discuss what sport for next year rather than him think all day computer games is an option.

MaybeDoctor · 22/01/2019 11:00

I think extra-curricular activities are excellent for children and for adults who wish to continue them. A hobby or sport can inspire, motivate and raise self-esteem. But ultimately that's all they are - extra.

Yes, a few people become PE teachers or turn their hobby into the way they earn their living, but for most young people they go to university or go into the workplace and none of it matters a jot. He can stay active in other ways.

Mummyoflittledragon · 22/01/2019 11:02

My dd is sporty. She is also 10 and does a range of sporting activities. Some she gets bored with for a while and then loves again. Says she wants to stop, is asked to wait for a couple of months to make final decision then decides she still wants to continue. I think this is a sensible approach as dd isn’t stopping on a whim. This is a personality thing and I am aware next year at secondary she will probably start to streamline her activities.

It sounds like you have done the same with your ds. He has decided after a prolonged period he definitely wants to quit. There are very few sporting hobbies your cannot go back to. Your ds can always stop for a while and perhaps go back to it. I’d take him to anything he shows an interest in. Does he have a friend, who goes to a martial art or gymnastics or whatever else he may like to do?

Sarahjconnor · 22/01/2019 11:03

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Swipe left for the next trending thread