Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you for your awful proposal stories, to make me feel better about mine?

369 replies

FuckYouChrisAndThatHorse · 15/10/2018 10:00

I’m not one of those people who needed a flash proposal, or even really a proposal at all, we’d already decided we’d marry at some point anyway.

But dh wanted to propose and I had no objections, though I did ask that he not do it in front of people. I didn’t want it to be a spectator sport, this was just about us.

It was winter, five years ago, and he was on edge. I suspected he was waiting for a right time to present itself, and girded my loins appropriately.

Christmas came and went - as Christmases so often do - we climbed a mountain together, looking out on an incredible view of the sea in the distance, but perhaps the ground was too soggy for his knees. Clearly the time was still not right.

It began to feel like a strange, psychological experiment. I was carefully not mentioning it, because it meant more to him than me, and I didn’t want to ruin whatever his plan might be, but there was a good chance we’d be married before he got his moment to shine.

Finally it was a couple of days before New Year’s Eve (when we would be taking a trip together, to a picturesque place). The rain was pelting it down, the wind roaring in the chimney, and we were doing a dutiful post-Christmas visit to my parents.

I was cracking nuts in the living room, whilst my mother reheated the final batch of mildly rancid turkey-soup, and my father searched eBay for ‘rejected gift bargains’ that couldn’t wait.

Dh came in and took me nervously by the hand. He looked terrified. The fear was contagious, and it suddenly occurred to me that he was about to drag me out into a downpour to propose.

Perhaps he had a plan? I thought.

He did not have a plan.

There, in the kitchen, whilst my mother froze mid-stir, and my father was illuminated by the light of the computer screen, he got down on one knee and said, “Chris, I love and adore you, will you marry me?”

Now, before I could answer, my father decided to interject with, “Don’t leave her if she says no!” Which really cemented the romance of the moment.

I said yes.

There was an awkward silence whilst he stood, put the ring on my finger, and we hugged.

The awkwardness hung in the air, like an unmentioned fart, as we ate the soup in a silence which lingered until we were in the car.

I walked into our house to the phone ringing, it was my mother, saying that she should have opened the champagne, but it hadn’t occurred to her. Why would it?

I always thought that my expectations were quite achievable really, but no, I’m an awful diva who wanted more.

We’ve been married five years now, and he is a marvellous husband - thoughtful and kind and considerate.

I don’t want your, “We were in a hot air balloon, and the ring was brought to me by a passing dove” stories, I want some, “He tied the ring to the dove and it was immediately snatched from the air by a sparrow-hawk” tales.

OP posts:
KeepServingTheDrinks · 15/10/2018 20:23

sat in a pub garden having a general chat (nothing to do with "us") about getting married versus living together. Can't remember the point I was making, but he said "well, I'd better marry you then". So I asked if he was proposing, and he said he was.
I said "that's not very romantic" and he said "it's the best you'll get out of me". So I said yes.

The worst thing was we then went round to my parent's house for a family party. I went off to the loo or something, and when I got back, everyone's beaming and my soppy cousin is crying (!) and so is my mum. And he'd only gone and asked my dad's consent in front of everyone.

DrMadelineMaxwell · 15/10/2018 20:25

DH had the lovely idea of proposing to me at the place we went on holiday each year, a place that I love.

Sounds great.

In reality, he proposed... in the dark. In a car park. Down on one knee in a puddle.

PamPooveysCow · 15/10/2018 20:32

We were packing to go to Rome on holiday, and he passed me a little box and said 'you might as well have this now, I don't want to lose it'.

That was it! The next day, in Rome, I asked him if that meant we were getting married, and he replied 'Oh yeah'. Twenty years ago now, but luckily he's an amazing husband (and he really hates that story).

WhenIWasAYoungWarthog · 15/10/2018 20:43

I forgot to mention I also nearly accused our cleaner of stealing before dh proposed. I wear a ring on the ring finger of my right hand, it’s completely worthless but one of the few things my late father gave me. I only take it off to have a shower and would always put it in a dish on my dressing table. One day I took it off and it wasn’t there when I got out of the shower, dh swore blind he hadn’t touched it and cleaned had just left. I was convinced she’d taken it/ moved it and wanted to call her. Dh convinced me not to, said he move my dressing table and hunt for it while I was at work.

It turned out he’d nicked it to take to the jewellers to find out the size. He ‘found’ it a couple of days later saying he’d hunted through the hoover bag and found it in there?! The most annoying part is that the jeweller said ‘are you sure she wears it on her ring finger as it’s very small’. Dh decided I probably didn’t wear it on my ring finger but on my pinky so got a ring made 2 sizes bigger than the one he’d nicked. Which then needed to be resized at the same jeweller as it was way too big.

pumpkinpie01 · 15/10/2018 20:45

I haven’t ( I don’t actually remember my ex’s proposal 😀) but I was there when my sister was proposed to . Boxing Day at my parents house she was getting some nibbles out of the oven she turned round to find him on one knee after ‘ will you marry me ?’ She put the pizzas down and said ‘ yes I suppose so but you’ll have to change ‘ . He obviously didn’t change enough for her, the marriage lasted 5 years .

SilentBob · 15/10/2018 20:47

We had been together for 3 months, he was very, very drunk on spiced rum. And very, very naked.

Despite the above, I said yes.

He then did the proposal "properly" somewhere more memorable, when he had actually thought it through and bought a ring. I preferred the first proposal. It was more us- he's not a drinker, but when he does it's astounding!

FlaviaAlbia · 15/10/2018 20:47

This isn't mine but a colleagues, I think it's possibly the creepiest engagement story possible.

He wanted to surprise his girlfriend with a proposal so he bought a teddy bear and unpicked the seam, took out some filling and put the ring inside it.

Having done that, he takes his girlfriend out for a fancy dinner (according to him, but as he was as tight as a ducks arse, I'm dubious) then tells her he has something for her and hands her the teddy bear. Since she's gazing at him in bafflement obviously he has to tell her there's something inside it.

So then she has to disembowel a soft toy at a restaurant table in public and fish a ring out of it.

Aah, sweet romance Grin He claimed she never wore the ring as she was very shy and embarrassed by being engaged. I was betting on her making plans to run for the hills tbh...

FuckYouChrisAndThatHorse · 15/10/2018 20:48

@iliketomoveitmoveitMOVEIT oh that! Well... it all started back when mumsnet was all fields. I name changed for an AIBU. There are three threads in classics. Think it was called “to kick these people out?”

I namechanged back to FYChris (a catchphrase from the Bugle podcast) halfway through, and then, in honour of the thread, added on, “and that horse”

I’m not sure I’ve explained it well Grin

OP posts:
Iseesheep · 15/10/2018 20:52

Now husband had just come back from a tour (he's Forces, not a member of Guns n Roses!) and we'd gone off to my parents' holiday home by the coast. We got completely trollied on gin and my dad's home brew red wine and staggered off to bed. He fell out landing on his knees in a heep and said "while I'm down here will you marry me?" Perhaps not quite so coherently but you get the gist.

There was no ring, no flowers, no sense of occasion. Nothing!! But then again I never expected a proposal because we'd only been together a matter of months and only thought he'd come back to see me because he'd left his Suede and James CDs at my house.

Married 22 years. There are times when I curse home brewed red wine!

Villainelle · 15/10/2018 20:59

I love these stories. My proposal was similarly unromantic. After a big blazing argument, I think he did it to get himself out of hot water 😂
I can't think of anything worse than a cheesy engagement in front of loads of people, involving roses, teddy bears, champagne etc

heather1 · 15/10/2018 21:08

My now DH came out of the toilet in his flat (having done a no2, looked at me and said Will you marry me. He had planned to ask me at a black tie ball that weekend but apparently couldn’t wait that long. I said I needed to think about it and then said yes in Noodle Time near East Croydon train station. Romantic it is not!

FuckKnuckle · 15/10/2018 21:13

We were on holiday and he was holding forth about how he didn't see the point in getting married, it was just a bit of paper, etc etc. When he paused for breath I said, in a small voice, "Er - but I would like to be Mrs Knuckle one day..." He agreed.

About six months later we were out for a walk and talking about the fact that we were sort of engaged, and I pointed out (joking) that he had never actually gone down on one knee. So he did, there and then, in the mud.

My parents said I'd done very well for myself Confused, his said they'd like him to have have waited a bit longer and played the field a bit more. I felt so loved...

32nd anniversary coming up soon Smile

DesertIslandPenguin · 15/10/2018 21:15

The proposal was perfect, down on bended knee in a private area of the restaurant we had our first date at, gorgeous ring. Later that night we were evacuated out of our hotel room as it flooded dramatically during a storm. Hotel hairdryers are wholly inadequate for drying two outfits!!

kashleesi · 15/10/2018 21:39

I was writing my food shopping list Grin and then we went to do the shopping before we told anyone!

batshitbetty · 15/10/2018 21:39

As a way of showing how serious we were about this, we both wrote a love letter to each other. One crisp winter night we went to a river (why?!) to read them, write our wedding vows and then burn the letters/vows as some kind of heavenly offering of our love and wanky-ness.

🤣

StepAwayFromGoogle · 15/10/2018 21:56

My OH tried his best. Lovely day in London - drinks at posh hotel, walk through parks, matinee at theatre (Wicked, so a bit of an odd choice), drinks at a pub and then dinner with my family. I can only assume he had bottled it repeatedly throughout the day because he chose to do it in the limo (yes, limo) on the way home. Somewhere around Streatham. In front of my Mum, Dad and brother. I was mortified. He's a big lad (6'4'') and couldn't really kneel properly in the car so ended up twisted up like a hobbit. We were all hammered (too much champagne) and Dad was trying to get a photo of the 'moment' but couldn't get his phone to work. He lost his temper, shouted ' FUCKING THING!' and chucked his phone across the limo. It hit my brother on the head and he said 'Ow! For fucks sake, Dad!'. I have to say that really spoilt the moment. I wasn't expecting my engagement to be peppered with so many expletives. Why my OH felt the need to involve my family in the event, I'll never know.

LarryFreakinStylinson · 15/10/2018 22:07

DH does all the cooking in our house. Has done since we got together. Anyway this one night I was in charge of the evening meal. I kept it simple. Chicken Kiev, oven chips and beans 😂 I managed to burn the chicken Kiev’s on the outside but they remained raw on the inside Confused DH cut into it, sighed and said ‘There is no way you can ever be left to live on your own, will you marry me?’

MrsCatE · 15/10/2018 22:44

Already half asleep when MrCat got into bed and gave me nightly, affectionate cuddle and said the immortal words: "Forgot to tell you, financial advisor said made more sense to get married". The romance, I tell you, the romance...

QOD · 15/10/2018 23:09

I went home from work and said ‘Kate got engaged at the weekend. It’s so weird. I don’t understand why you’d get engaged and not actually know when you’re getting married. Surely you say will you marry me - let’s do it a year today’
Dh said. ‘ Yeah. I know what you mean. Shall we get engaged on and get married a year to the day?’

So. That wS my proposal. Married 28 yrs

DeborahDowner · 15/10/2018 23:13

He proposed very, very drunkenly over the phone whilst out at someone’s stag do and just wouldn’t quite take no, not like this.... for an answer, going on and on about it when I finally said yes to get him off the phone and back to his evening out. The next day he rang (we were in a LDR and in v different time zones) and desperately apologised for not calling me as he’d promised to the previous evening....totally did not recall the epic love story that had unfolded the night before for him. 😂

When he did finally propose properly later that year, it was fancy dinner and west end theatre, followed by him managing to bizarrely flick the ring straight into the grass at a major London royal park, with a comedy ‘shiiiiiiiiiiit’ thrown in when he tried to casually whip the ring out of his coat pocket.

We spent ages patting the ground together till blessedly it was found & he proposed while we were both on our knees. It was lovely and funny actually, if not the ideal moment he thought it would be.

He’s not much of a drinker or curser or a clumsy person so each experience was very amusing for me and more fun than some ‘perfect’ moment!

Very very happily married nearly 20 years. 😊

KennDodd · 15/10/2018 23:24

A friend of mine proposed to his wife while they were both on the tube going to work one morning. And then they had to go to work.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 15/10/2018 23:33

I don't have a story but just wanted to say you win the internet with that one wonderful sentence:

The awkwardness hung in the air, like an unmentioned fart

Grin Grin

SputnikBear · 15/10/2018 23:38

My friend’s DP took her to NYC and proposed on top of the Empire State Building. I made a point of telling my DP how romantic it was, and made it clear that it was important to me and I wanted something similarly flashy.

He took me out for dinner to a cheap restaurant and ordered an extra bottle of wine without considering that he’d be proposing while drunk. Then took me for a walk in the freezing cold (frosty January) to a local landmark, during which it peed down with rain. He hadn’t checked opening times or made any arrangements so the landmark was closed and the street was fenced off with plastic security barriers. A sensible man would have aborted at this point! But DP got down on his knees beside the plastic barriers in the rain and muttered something that neither of us remembers because we were pissed. I do however remember the security guard trying to move him on mid-proposal. Then he tried to ring a taxi but nobody was available and it was too cold to hang around waiting so he had to ring my Dad to pick us up.

A few weeks later my friend’s DP wangled his way on stage during a musical and sang his proposal in front of a thousand people. There was even a dance number. I love DH but I’m still gutted that he didn’t make more of that once in a lifetime opportunity to be romantic. He knew it was important to me and he still didn’t make an effort.

TheMonkeyMummy · 15/10/2018 23:39

DH sent me a text.

MsAwesomeDragon · 15/10/2018 23:51

It was Christmas Day, just after I'd put the kids to bed. Dd2 was a toddler and it had been a LONG day with her being overexcited and overtired. I flopped onto the sofa ready to watch some TV. He looked at me and said "so do you fancy making this permanent?" I laughed and replied that we were already permanent as we'd been together 10 years and had 2 kids by that point. It took an hour before he asked if I had an actual answer because that was apparently a proposal. I hadn't even noticed.