Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you for your awful proposal stories, to make me feel better about mine?

369 replies

FuckYouChrisAndThatHorse · 15/10/2018 10:00

I’m not one of those people who needed a flash proposal, or even really a proposal at all, we’d already decided we’d marry at some point anyway.

But dh wanted to propose and I had no objections, though I did ask that he not do it in front of people. I didn’t want it to be a spectator sport, this was just about us.

It was winter, five years ago, and he was on edge. I suspected he was waiting for a right time to present itself, and girded my loins appropriately.

Christmas came and went - as Christmases so often do - we climbed a mountain together, looking out on an incredible view of the sea in the distance, but perhaps the ground was too soggy for his knees. Clearly the time was still not right.

It began to feel like a strange, psychological experiment. I was carefully not mentioning it, because it meant more to him than me, and I didn’t want to ruin whatever his plan might be, but there was a good chance we’d be married before he got his moment to shine.

Finally it was a couple of days before New Year’s Eve (when we would be taking a trip together, to a picturesque place). The rain was pelting it down, the wind roaring in the chimney, and we were doing a dutiful post-Christmas visit to my parents.

I was cracking nuts in the living room, whilst my mother reheated the final batch of mildly rancid turkey-soup, and my father searched eBay for ‘rejected gift bargains’ that couldn’t wait.

Dh came in and took me nervously by the hand. He looked terrified. The fear was contagious, and it suddenly occurred to me that he was about to drag me out into a downpour to propose.

Perhaps he had a plan? I thought.

He did not have a plan.

There, in the kitchen, whilst my mother froze mid-stir, and my father was illuminated by the light of the computer screen, he got down on one knee and said, “Chris, I love and adore you, will you marry me?”

Now, before I could answer, my father decided to interject with, “Don’t leave her if she says no!” Which really cemented the romance of the moment.

I said yes.

There was an awkward silence whilst he stood, put the ring on my finger, and we hugged.

The awkwardness hung in the air, like an unmentioned fart, as we ate the soup in a silence which lingered until we were in the car.

I walked into our house to the phone ringing, it was my mother, saying that she should have opened the champagne, but it hadn’t occurred to her. Why would it?

I always thought that my expectations were quite achievable really, but no, I’m an awful diva who wanted more.

We’ve been married five years now, and he is a marvellous husband - thoughtful and kind and considerate.

I don’t want your, “We were in a hot air balloon, and the ring was brought to me by a passing dove” stories, I want some, “He tied the ring to the dove and it was immediately snatched from the air by a sparrow-hawk” tales.

OP posts:
EssentialHummus · 15/10/2018 10:29

(And can I throw in a "Daily Mail are cuntweasels", as it's that sort of thread?)

PrivateDoor · 15/10/2018 10:30

OP I loved reading your post, your writing skills are amazing!! However I agree with pp who said your family were the problem here, not DH! Imagine just sitting in silence eating soup after such a huge moment Grin I think you should write a book about your family, I would buy it!!

TheNoodlesIncident · 15/10/2018 10:32

I got proposed to at a dinner dance. In front of lots of people. One of DH's friends scampered off to tell the DJ to announce it over the microphone, just in case anyone had missed it. (Friend did buy bottles of champagne to open though, which was very kind.)

I am a very shy and retiring person. It wasn't the venue I would have chosen, although I'm glad he did actually get round to it.

There were no swans, disappointingly. Some people have all the luck

FuckYouChrisAndThatHorse · 15/10/2018 10:32

Please do, essential hummus, I should have started with that.

EdwardBear, that’s all rather lovely and warming. Despite the lacklustre wordage

OP posts:
Lovelydovey · 15/10/2018 10:32

Friday 13th Feb (day before Valentines TV) in front of the TV with pizza cos I was upduffed. No ring though it did mean that I got to choose my own. Is it any surprise that 10 years later we’re still engaged and not married....

fuzzywuzzy · 15/10/2018 10:32

DP proposed to me in Sloan square tube station (if you know me in rl you’ll know exactly who I am).

I was only half listening, he grabbed me made a long speech, which I wasn’t listening to as my train was pulling into the station and I was thinking ‘I have to catch that train..’ as he wouldn’t let me go without an answer I responded with ‘oh ok then’. Then jumped on the train.

He never gave me the ring either as the ring heh ad with him, was a ‘blessed’ ring given him by his best friends mum who had told him it would bring him luck, so he had it in his pocket for luck but couldn’t face giving it to me as it wouldn’t have fit and is so ugly it’s amazing!

I think it’s the funniest proposal ever, & he is wonderful and I’ll remember it forever. And it gives family members laugh too.

He was very nervous, he had ample opportunity to propose at some gorgeous landmarks or over lunch which was quiet and intimate and lovely but nope, he chose the tube station amongst the slightly bemused looking folk waiting for their tube (so glad he didn’t go down on one knee, it had been raining and the ground was not pleasant).

DragonNoodleCake · 15/10/2018 10:33

We went out for dinner in Edinburgh, lovely place in the new town. When we left, he did it on the steps outside - but it was raining and he had a work suit on still(yes midweek after work) so didn't bother with one knee 😂😂

Your story is great, your mam and dad bit is hilarious.

Co-incidentally my DM's cousin made my ring and my mum brought it to DH. Think train journey etc. She had palpitations the whole way as she was carrying it 😂😂

FuckYouChrisAndThatHorse · 15/10/2018 10:33

PrivateDoor Grin no one would believe it

OP posts:
Myfanwyprice · 15/10/2018 10:33

DH isn’t noted for his romantic tendencies, we were on the train going for an apparently romantic day out, I was excited at the prospect that today might be the day he will propose.

He turned to me and uttered the romantic words, I’ve got something hard in my pocket for you.

Thankfully it was a diamond ring, but not exactly a story we can tell the grandchildren 😂

Roomba · 15/10/2018 10:33

Apparently my father proposed to my mother while they were drunkenly waiting for a train home one night. They were chatting and he said, 'So are we getting married then or what?'. Tres romantique Grin

He also took her shopping for an engagement ring, then they decided for some reason that it was more sensible to buy a sheepskin coat for him instead!

My mither did eventually get a very nice 'engagement' ring though - they'd been married about 20 years at that point. And they are still happily married after 46 years. He has been a wonderful husband and father, he just doesn't have a way with words. He is one of those people who shows his love through actions instead. So don't despair, OP - life isn't like romantic movies and that's probably a very good thing.

Echobelly · 15/10/2018 10:33

Our proposal was low-key though I was actually very happy with it. We'd just been to see an exhibition and he kissed and said 'Marry me' and he says he honestly didn't know he was going to say it until it came out of his mouth (though we had talked about getting married in general so I knew it was on his mind and vice versa).

It was a freezing, wet night at the beginning of January and we went on to meet some mates at the pub as we had planned. He didn't have a ring and I didn't care. My parents were delighted when we called on the way to tell them the news... my in-laws were somewhat frosty, but generally got better with me than they had been once we were 'official'

Ggirl27 · 15/10/2018 10:34

Mine said 'Shall we get married' whilst I was doing the ironing...

Givemeallyourcucumber · 15/10/2018 10:35

I was sat on the toilet and DH was in the bath and I was begging him to just say yes so we could get on with it! He said yes and we got married 2 months later, no wedding just had our mums as witnesses. It was more like taxing the car then getting married. Still happily married now!

Calamityjac · 15/10/2018 10:35

That sounded a bit like my proposal, I was in the kitchen of my parents house, I knew we were getting engaged, the ring was bought but I didn’t know when it would happen, then one Sunday morning, I was frying eggs for something to eat and he took my hand and asked me to marry him! Who says romance is dead lol 😝

ThePants999 · 15/10/2018 10:36

I gotta say, I don't understand the point of a proposal whose terms have been dictated in advance. If your beloved has already told you how you should propose, she's already accepted the damn proposal.

That said, I'm not one to talk. I was going for the lovely surprise proposal - got her best mate to find out her ring size for me, booked a European city break for the proposal - then she came round mine, was using my PC, typed "the" into a browser and "thediamondshop.co.uk" or something like that appeared. Obviously she twigged immedately. Buggrit. Still went on the damned city break though, as you do, and figured I might as well still do the proposal. Didn't know the city, wandered around for so long trying to find somewhere picturesque to do it that it got dark and I ended up doing it knelt in front of a park bench next to an overflowing bin. Yay.

crumpet · 15/10/2018 10:37

Very good stories - loved the dream proposal!

Titsywoo · 15/10/2018 10:37

DH asked me to marry him a few times when we were dating (this was all in the first year), and I always said no as it seemed too early (to be fair though we had been friends for many years before). After a bad health scare I turned to him in the car and said if he was to propose I wouldn't say no (think I was feeling a bit high from the negative test) and eh got very excited and started calling people to say we were engaged! I was a bit Confused but thought fuck it. He did buy me a nice ring but I never got a proper proposal. Not that it really matters 16 years and 2 kids later (we've been happily married nearly 10 years now).

FuckYouChrisAndThatHorse · 15/10/2018 10:38

I am really loving all these.

And yes, you’re all right. Dh didn’t actually get anything wrong. I should have warned him against doing it in front of them. I think I didn’t want him to realise what he was marrying into until it was too late!

My parents are lovely in very many ways, but they are not great at positive off-the-cuff reactions. They like to expect the worse

OP posts:
FuckYouChrisAndThatHorse · 15/10/2018 10:39

Echobelly, that sounds perfect to me

OP posts:
darkriver198868 · 15/10/2018 10:40

New years eve 2012. I was pissed (something I dont do a lot) and my bf said something about getting married but, I was to drunk to even take notice. I woke up the next morning and he was staring at me.

"You never said yes"
"Uh"
"I asked you to marry me."

We had been best friends for two years before we got together.

I said yes.

Got pregnant pretty soon after, married at 4 months and seperated when DD was 10 months old. IF I ever get married again I want bells and whistles.

Laska5772 · 15/10/2018 10:40

Out cycling , he yelled something about getting married over his shoulder and then cycled off fast !.. About a mile later when I had finally caught up I said 'did you just say what i thought you said'? I cant remember his answer .. but we have been married 12 years now ..

FarrahMoan · 15/10/2018 10:41

My DH proposed in a lay by on the way to a hotel where we were celebrating having been together 3(?) years. I unintentionally made it really difficult by wandering around.
He maintains it is a scenic viewpoint - it's a lay by

QueenOfIce · 15/10/2018 10:41

One evening my now dh said we should go for a drive as it was a lovely evening, it was pitch black! We had discussed marriage and in the back of my mind I thought 'this is it' we drove down some dark country lanes for what seemed like forever comically I text my mum and said we're out for a drive if I don't come home he did it. After our weird outing we returned home no proposal.

A few months later I in my tracksuit bottoms boobs dangling happily bra free in my fluffy hoody my oh brought me dinner on a tray..breaded chicken, chips and beans classy on the side of the tray was a box. He towered above me and said will you marry me..I am so ashamed of my reply but I was so shocked and said 'I am not being proposed to in bloody tracksuit bottoms and no bra!' He replied "well get dressed then and I'll take you outside and do it"

It wasn't funny at the time but we laughed about it later and I realised once we'd got married it really didn't matter how he proposed. He's a lovely dh and I couldn't wish for a more loving and supportive partner in life.

Mamabear12 · 15/10/2018 10:43

Haha. I still don’t understand why my dh proposed the way he did. We had an amazing trip to the Bahamas a week later. It is still my favourite trip we ever took together. Super romantic as we went island hopping on our own boat and islands were empty and all to ourselves. I’m talking clear blue waters and sky. Deserted island type (we had lunch on the island via picnic). That’s how he should have proposed!!!! But no, he decided to propose one week prior in our living room while we were about to go for dinner. Not the worst proposal, but I felt a little sad that more effort wasn’t put into it. However, not all men are good at putting big effort. He has done other romantic things and he is a good man. That’s the most important 😀

spiderlight · 15/10/2018 10:43

My dad holds the record for the least romantic proposal ever. He and my mum had known each other since childhood, lived round the corner form each other and apparently it had been pretty much assumed by both families that they'd get married eventually. They tiptoed around each other, never really dated as such, but one day he took her for a drive, awkwardly pulled out a payslip, showed it to her and said 'I could keep you, you know?' She didn't have an engagement ring until after the wedding!

(This was just after the war, when it was very much expected that women would leave their jobs when they got married, and they had the most wonderful marriage despite the inauspicious proposal).