Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you for your awful proposal stories, to make me feel better about mine?

369 replies

FuckYouChrisAndThatHorse · 15/10/2018 10:00

I’m not one of those people who needed a flash proposal, or even really a proposal at all, we’d already decided we’d marry at some point anyway.

But dh wanted to propose and I had no objections, though I did ask that he not do it in front of people. I didn’t want it to be a spectator sport, this was just about us.

It was winter, five years ago, and he was on edge. I suspected he was waiting for a right time to present itself, and girded my loins appropriately.

Christmas came and went - as Christmases so often do - we climbed a mountain together, looking out on an incredible view of the sea in the distance, but perhaps the ground was too soggy for his knees. Clearly the time was still not right.

It began to feel like a strange, psychological experiment. I was carefully not mentioning it, because it meant more to him than me, and I didn’t want to ruin whatever his plan might be, but there was a good chance we’d be married before he got his moment to shine.

Finally it was a couple of days before New Year’s Eve (when we would be taking a trip together, to a picturesque place). The rain was pelting it down, the wind roaring in the chimney, and we were doing a dutiful post-Christmas visit to my parents.

I was cracking nuts in the living room, whilst my mother reheated the final batch of mildly rancid turkey-soup, and my father searched eBay for ‘rejected gift bargains’ that couldn’t wait.

Dh came in and took me nervously by the hand. He looked terrified. The fear was contagious, and it suddenly occurred to me that he was about to drag me out into a downpour to propose.

Perhaps he had a plan? I thought.

He did not have a plan.

There, in the kitchen, whilst my mother froze mid-stir, and my father was illuminated by the light of the computer screen, he got down on one knee and said, “Chris, I love and adore you, will you marry me?”

Now, before I could answer, my father decided to interject with, “Don’t leave her if she says no!” Which really cemented the romance of the moment.

I said yes.

There was an awkward silence whilst he stood, put the ring on my finger, and we hugged.

The awkwardness hung in the air, like an unmentioned fart, as we ate the soup in a silence which lingered until we were in the car.

I walked into our house to the phone ringing, it was my mother, saying that she should have opened the champagne, but it hadn’t occurred to her. Why would it?

I always thought that my expectations were quite achievable really, but no, I’m an awful diva who wanted more.

We’ve been married five years now, and he is a marvellous husband - thoughtful and kind and considerate.

I don’t want your, “We were in a hot air balloon, and the ring was brought to me by a passing dove” stories, I want some, “He tied the ring to the dove and it was immediately snatched from the air by a sparrow-hawk” tales.

OP posts:
GloriousMystery · 15/10/2018 15:09

he gets my (formidable) dad alone to ask him for my hand, only for my dad to reply "what an old fashioned idea, Sunday is more than capable of deciding her own future"

My brother asked his prospective father in law for permission to marry his wife, FIL to be said, "Don't you think you should ask her not me?"

But those are both exactly the right response!

ThePlatypusAlwaysTriumphs · 15/10/2018 15:23

Loving reading these, made me feel a bit better!

Just remembered my non-proposal was not my only proposal. I once propsed , somewhat tipsy, to an ex-bf in the cold meat section of Wm. Low. He walked away in embarrassment leaving me down on one knee in front of the chopped pork.

While still going out with this charmer, I went on a girls weekend and met a lovely guy. We got on so well that he joked he wanted to marry me. I told him I wouldn't settle for such a proposal. We were out in a pizza restaurant with a crowd, and he disappeared, then came back with a keyring squashed into shape, went down on one knee and asked me to marry him in front of the whole restaurant. I had to say yes as I was too embarrassed to say anything else! The whole restaurant started cheering and we were brought champagne on the house! It was a fun evening, but of course I never saw him again.

VioletPickles · 15/10/2018 15:27

My dad announced it to the family. After my then dp had asked his permission but well before dp had actually proposed to me. Rather took the surprise away!

scarbados · 15/10/2018 15:29

We'd lived together ten years and we were both taking a few days off work before the Easter break to spin out our holiday allowance. It was a cold and wet Monday in Birmingham. We'd been to the supermarket and were on the way back up Coventry Road (no car). A horse-drawn wedding coach passed us as we waited at a junction and there was another going round the roundabout as we got off the bus.

Him - I'm surprised to see those wedding coaches. I thought everyone got married on a Saturday.

Me - It's traditional but a lot of people have mid-week weddings because it's cheaper. That lovely register office in Dudley is cheaper on a Wednesday than a Saturday.

Him - Oh! We could do that one day, couldn't we?

Me - Does that mean I can start planning our wedding/

Him - If that's what you want to do, yes.

So he went off to the Co-op to get the eggs we'd forgotten at Morrisons and I went home to start the plans.

Longleggedlovely · 15/10/2018 15:42

We were on a city break, DH stood on a very busy but beautiful bridge and said “shall we do it then?” as he had produced a ring I assumed it was a proposal and he wasn’t referring to anything else but he wasn’t on one knee etc, put the ring on my finger and I promptly lost a new bracelet over the side of the bridge but we both initially thought I’d thrown my ring over the side.... that was 14 years ago and we’ve been very happily married for 10. His initial chat up line wasn’t much better so guess I’m just used to his ways haha!

iliketomoveitmoveitMOVEIT · 15/10/2018 15:42

“Will you marry me? I’m not buying you a ring though.”

My friend’s notoriously tight husband (perhaps surprisingl unbelievably after that!).

Trinpy · 15/10/2018 15:53

We were sitting by the river one afternoon having a cream tea, dh asked if I'd like to marry him and I said yes. The sun was shining, there were (non violent) swans paddling nearby; it was a simple yet truly beautiful moment.

DH has absolutely no recollection of any of this happening Hmm.

ElleMcFearsome · 15/10/2018 16:33

So now-DH and I had been together for the grand total of 6 weeks. We were due to go on holiday the next day, he was at mine and I got out of bed to go downstairs to the loo. As I walked out the bedroom door I said, "you are going to marry me, aren't you?" then off I went. Shut the loo door behind me and thought, 'FUCK I said that rather than just think it. FUCK'. Stood in the loo, dying, actually dying of embarrassment.

Eventually realised that at some point I need to leave the loo and go back and see him. I was fully prepared for him to have chucked his passport out of the window and be knotting bedsheets together to follow it but no, he was in bed grinning and said, as I came through the door, "well, yes but I thought we should maybe see if we can spend a week together first!" We got married a year and a week after we had first met and remain blissfully happy 8 years on, but God I still am embarrassed by my 'proposal' (or The Directive, as it's usually referred to)

KawaiiUnicorn · 15/10/2018 16:38

We were split up at the time, I’d caught him cheating. Me and the kids had nowhere else to go and his mum owned the house so living arrangements were complicated. He came home drunk on a week day told me he still loved me and got down on one knee (no ring of course) I was totally shocked! He told me he was ready to be the man I deserved after 7 years of treating me like crap. I was horrified and what’s worse he managed to convince me to agree and so I took him back and back and said yes thinking it was what’s best for the kids.

He left me two weeks later for a women he worked with. He admitted he’d fancied her for at least two years and was in love with her. I was actually relieved as I was so miserable with him. I told him to leave and he did!

My current partner doesn’t want to get married anymore, I’m not gonna lie it really p*** me off that that’s the closest to a proposal I’ll ever get! My boyfriends still legally married to his ex, I knew from the start and it didn’t bother me as he said they were definitely over and he wanted a divorce. He’s spent the last few years talking about divorcing her but never made a move, Then finally a couple of months ago he told me he’d been in contact with her, was going ahead with the divorce and had been looking at engagement rings. I thought “Wow! A real proposal, can this really be?” Nope, turns out he’s changed his mind, after years of leading me to believe that we’d get married one day he just can’t be bothered with it anymore. Instead we should get wedding rings tattooed on our fingers and just “pretend” we are married. Can you imagine it?

“No Nanna we’re just pretend married.....No it’s not until his divorce comes through he’s not getting one anymore.....I just changed my last name to his by deed poll......No you needn’t buy a new hat there’s not going to be a ceremony and there’s no need to look out for the invitation either....no party......nope sorry, not even a slice of cake......Yes Nanna I know things were different in your day!

How embarrassing. I mean I’m not too fussed about the dress and the party etc. But still.....

My boyfriend did ask me if I’d be ok with not having a big wedding, he seemed to miss the point though that there’s a difference between not having having a big wedding and not having one at all.

Let’s just say my surname is the same and I haven’t had any tattoos done lately lol.

Deep down I don’t think I’ll ever forgive him for this, and no I don’t think he’ll change his mind either. If it’s choice between a fake marriage and no marriage I will choose to stay unmarried forever. (which is probably approximately how long he’ll stay married to his ex) Sorry, know I’m rambling.....probably just the hormones lol.

OutrageousFlavourLikeFreesias · 15/10/2018 16:42

I'd just given birth to our DD - EMCS as I had severe pre-eclampsia. He'd been planning to ask me on Christmas Day (six days later), but didn't want me to think he'd only asked because of DD being born. So he went home, got the ring and came back - at 6am, so I'd know he had the ring in advance and hadn't come to see me via the jewellers. My hands were so swollen the ring wouldn't fit (had it taken in by 6 sizes after the swelling went), I hadn't had a shower, and I was absolutely off my face on morphine. I can honestly say I've never looked worse. And that's how I know he reeeally loves me.

Sashkin · 15/10/2018 16:44

I told DH that for me to apply for a job transfer back to him, I needed a “substantial change in personal circumstances”, and that in practice that meant either getting married or having a baby.

He thought for a bit, then said “If we have to do one of the two, I think I’d prefer to just get married. I don’t really want a baby at the minute”.

The end. He didn’t want to get me an engagement ring because he disagrees with the diamond trade, but I convinced him to get me an antique one. The wedding itself was nice, he threw himself into it once he got used to the idea that it was happening.

cleopatracomingatya · 15/10/2018 16:52

uh oh, the journalists have liked this one:

www.thesun.co.uk/fabulous/7497775/mumsnet-proposal-horror-stories/

AJPTaylor · 15/10/2018 17:12

Lol. In reality i told dh that we should get married the following August and bought my own ring. No proposal. I found out by accident from a friend that he didnt want to get married at all, about 10 years too late!
We have been married for 30 years though. Had to make up some guff for the kids though about a proposal!

PassMeTheBleach · 15/10/2018 17:50

This is going to be long because it was a disaster from beginning to end!

My husband had booked us a special break away with a theatre trip for our anniversary of becoming a couple. I knew he was going to propose at some point because we’d already discussed it and we’d chosen a ring together, but I told him I wanted the actual proposal to be a surprise. He said “by the time you see the show, we’ll be engaged”.

Well, the morning of the show came and I’d still had no proposal, so the element of surprise had kind of gone. But still, I pretended I didn’t know he’d chosen that day.

Halfway on our journey, he realises he’s left the tickets at home so has to double back, adding an extra hour to our journey. Then the restaurant he was taking us to was closed down, so we had to visit a different one nearby as we didn’t have time to try somewhere else. It was eyewateringly expensive, so he ended up spending all of the money he’d put aside for the trip on one meal.

Because of our delayed journey, we wolfed down the food, ran to our hotel and got ready as quickly as we could. Just as we were leaving, he called my name. I turned around and there he was, on one knee, in a bloody Travelodge These days I wouldn’t be so fussed but I was young and wanted everything perfect, and this was not the proposal I’d dreamed of, so I said something like “not here!” and carried on rushing out Blush

We took our seats just as the lights went down so I was a bit flustered and couldn’t really relax into the performance. In the interval, he tried again but I was very shy and hated the idea of a public proposal, so as soon as he got on the floor and started fumbling in his pocket, I asked him to get up.

Eventually, after the performance, we went for a nighttime stroll along the river. It was dark, peaceful, and there was a busker around the corner playing some beautiful acoustic guitar. He finally proposed and it was perfect.

Then we got back to the hotel and the bloody ring broke Grin

PassMeTheBleach · 15/10/2018 17:51

Should add- we’ve been together 10 years now and we’re very happy (and, after five engagement rings, I finally got the perfect one!)

FuckYouChrisAndThatHorse · 15/10/2018 18:09

Cleopatra, they have mangled my carefully told tale. The Sun sucks

OP posts:
WhenIWasAYoungWarthog · 15/10/2018 18:12

Dh (then BF, obvs) and I were staying on a beautiful archipelago of islands. We took a boat for a day trip to a deserted island and we were to be picked up 4 hours later by the boat but from the other side of the island, a couple of miles walk. It was made very clear that if we weren’t there the boat wouldn’t wait and we would have to stay on this island overnight (we had no tent or anything, just the clothes we were in and a picnic). We had a lovely picnic lunch then set off to the other side of the island.

We were waiting at the collection point when dh said he was just going to pop behind a nearby sand dune for a wee. Ten minutes go by and he doesn’t reappear. I see the boat coming towards the island and start calling for dh, he’s nowhere to be found. I get more and more stressed and pissed off that he’s just fucked off and disappeared. Boat pulls up and the boatman asks me where dh is. I tell him I don’t know, boatman says he can’t wait. I’m so fucked off with dh that I say ‘fine, let’s go without him’, get the boat back to the hotel alone.

I’m half pissed off with dh, half worried he was eaten by a whale or something when 2 hours later he comes storming in asking me where the fuck I’d gone. We have a massive row, I end up telling him I never want to see him again, that he abandoned me on an island in a foreign country. He tells me that with someone from the hotel he’d arranged a meal on the beach, cooked by a chef on the deserted island just for us and that he’d just got it all perfect, was planning to propose, it had been months being organised and was coming to get me when he saw me fucking off in the boat. He’d arranged for a speedboat trip back to our hotel and had just forgotten to cancel the original boat.

We laugh about it now, sort of. Especially about poor old dh having to eat a romantic meal prepared by a chef just for him on a deserted island. He said it was the most awkward meal of his life.

ThomasRichard · 15/10/2018 18:16

Ex-H proposed to me after a date I had organised, in a dark car park (no shenanigans happening, I promise!), after pretending to break up with me. Why I said yes, I have no idea. 10 years on it’s utterly mystifying.

The marriage was awful and it cost me an arm and a leg to divorce his lazy, misogynistic behind.

I’m currently angling for a proposal from DP. If it’s crap I’m saying no and making him do it again. I don’t need a hot air balloon ride, just a nice dinner date and the proposal during a stroll afterwards would be lovely.

Snugglepiggy · 15/10/2018 18:17

We were at DHs parents house looking after the animals whilst they were away.Had a few friends round for drinks -with their permission I might add ,they were pretty easy going - and I'd been feeling increasingly rubbish all day.I ended up going to bed early as realised I had some bug.Some hours later I woke up to find DH kneeling at the side of the bed,perfectly pleasant but very drunk.He asked how I felt ,and would I like to get married.I said yes,then immediately said actually can I think about it.How awful !But I wasn't sure if he really meant it.Nothing more was said the next day and then the day after we were walking the dogs and he was quietly plodding ahead of me looking glum.I asked him to stop for a minute,and if he remembered what he'd asked me and if he meant it.He said of course.So I said yes please and he just beamed.Not the most romantic, or planned proposal but he's the kindest most caring person I know and 30 plus years on no regrets.

FuckYouChrisAndThatHorse · 15/10/2018 18:21

Warthog, that is amazing Grin

OP posts:
LaBelleSausage · 15/10/2018 18:23

I still like how my DF proposed to DM, mid tax return.
“You know, it would be more fiscally efficient if we were a married couple rather than a co-habiting one. Shall we?”

Grin
mogglemoo · 15/10/2018 18:26

Drunk, in a club, about 2am. Age 22 and living in different cities

Can’t remember the exact words, but it was something like, ‘we could just get married?’

Had to double check he knew what had been discussed the following morning.

Married for 22 years now.

bitmynailbrokemytooth · 15/10/2018 18:32

DH proposed to me, standing up, outside a Chinese take-away.

I was wearing a very short tarty dress. We had both had a few beers. I accepted.

The moment was actually dead romantic because it was midnight on New Year's Eve and the church bells were ringing and you could see your breath and it was all frosty. It was also unexpected.

Later on I told him he should ask me again when he was sober. He did. Silver wedding next year.

Tobebythesea · 15/10/2018 18:33

My DH proposed the week before we went to the Maldives. We’d just been for an average meal and then he suddenly got down on one knee in front of a water feature. It could have been worse but it could have been a lot better. Beach, sunset, cocktails.....no!

His reasoning was my sister was coming to visit the next day so I could go with her and pick a ring. Er, I would have preferred going with my fiancé! He also said he wanted it to be a surprise and the holiday would have been too obvious and too much pressure.

MissClarke86 · 15/10/2018 18:36

Me: “I’m pregnant.”
Him: “Shit: I wanted to propose first.”