Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you for your awful proposal stories, to make me feel better about mine?

369 replies

FuckYouChrisAndThatHorse · 15/10/2018 10:00

I’m not one of those people who needed a flash proposal, or even really a proposal at all, we’d already decided we’d marry at some point anyway.

But dh wanted to propose and I had no objections, though I did ask that he not do it in front of people. I didn’t want it to be a spectator sport, this was just about us.

It was winter, five years ago, and he was on edge. I suspected he was waiting for a right time to present itself, and girded my loins appropriately.

Christmas came and went - as Christmases so often do - we climbed a mountain together, looking out on an incredible view of the sea in the distance, but perhaps the ground was too soggy for his knees. Clearly the time was still not right.

It began to feel like a strange, psychological experiment. I was carefully not mentioning it, because it meant more to him than me, and I didn’t want to ruin whatever his plan might be, but there was a good chance we’d be married before he got his moment to shine.

Finally it was a couple of days before New Year’s Eve (when we would be taking a trip together, to a picturesque place). The rain was pelting it down, the wind roaring in the chimney, and we were doing a dutiful post-Christmas visit to my parents.

I was cracking nuts in the living room, whilst my mother reheated the final batch of mildly rancid turkey-soup, and my father searched eBay for ‘rejected gift bargains’ that couldn’t wait.

Dh came in and took me nervously by the hand. He looked terrified. The fear was contagious, and it suddenly occurred to me that he was about to drag me out into a downpour to propose.

Perhaps he had a plan? I thought.

He did not have a plan.

There, in the kitchen, whilst my mother froze mid-stir, and my father was illuminated by the light of the computer screen, he got down on one knee and said, “Chris, I love and adore you, will you marry me?”

Now, before I could answer, my father decided to interject with, “Don’t leave her if she says no!” Which really cemented the romance of the moment.

I said yes.

There was an awkward silence whilst he stood, put the ring on my finger, and we hugged.

The awkwardness hung in the air, like an unmentioned fart, as we ate the soup in a silence which lingered until we were in the car.

I walked into our house to the phone ringing, it was my mother, saying that she should have opened the champagne, but it hadn’t occurred to her. Why would it?

I always thought that my expectations were quite achievable really, but no, I’m an awful diva who wanted more.

We’ve been married five years now, and he is a marvellous husband - thoughtful and kind and considerate.

I don’t want your, “We were in a hot air balloon, and the ring was brought to me by a passing dove” stories, I want some, “He tied the ring to the dove and it was immediately snatched from the air by a sparrow-hawk” tales.

OP posts:
krustykittens · 15/10/2018 12:16

We were on the edge of the Sahara desert, looking up at the stars. I sighed, and said, "Isn't this wonderful?" He said, "It's very romantic. I was going to propose but I forgot to get the ring before I left." We have been married for 18 years, two DC. They howl with laughter when they hear that story! But he is a good man and I wouldn't change him for the world.

GoodbyeSummer · 15/10/2018 12:17

I was in the middle of my darkest ever episode of depression and he told me he wanted to talk but it'd have to wait until he came in from work. All bloody day I waited, wondering what was so important and why it was so bad he couldn't tell me over the phone. I was expecting all sorts - diseases, death, splitting up etc etc and was even more of a nervous wreck than normal by the time he got in. When he did get home he just said that he thought we ought to book the register office if we were to get married (we'd talked about it off & on for years up to that point but never actually did anything about it). And that was it - no ring, no bubbly, no big announcement, no fanfare, nothing. It doesn't bother me though, the fact that it wasn't the traditional romantic proposal; I think that bothers me was the worry leading up to it!

purpleweasel · 15/10/2018 12:18

"We've been together 15 years this year, shall we get married?"

"Could do"

wonderandwander · 15/10/2018 12:19

All this advance agreement about getting married and then waiting for the proposal

So odd! Confused

wonderandwander · 15/10/2018 12:20

I’m not telling you mine (because it was lovely, sorry

Your lovely may not be others

GreyCloudsToday · 15/10/2018 12:21

I was recovering from flu but determined to come with him on his work trip to Paris to make the most of the free hotel. After dinner, he wanted us to walk to a beautiful canal side spot but got us so lost - I said I'm so tired can we not just go home? Then he made us get off the Metro early to find a park and I was so ratty about it and insisted we just crack on home. He ended up proposing on a square beside a car park! I was so surprised, but really delighted. I could only manage one drink before having to go back to the hotel to bed early, though.

explodingkitten · 15/10/2018 12:23

We had discussed marriage before and I was waiting for a proposal. After two years waiting I was sitting on the couch one evening and gasped annoyed "Do you even want to marry me?". Which he thought that was me proposing to him...  yes, he is slightly autistic. I thought for a second, decided to go along with it and booked a date etc.

nokidshere · 15/10/2018 12:30

Ahhh ours was very romantic. Not.

We got the tickets for a holiday in the post (way before email was invented) and he said "shall we make it a honeymoon", I said "ah yes why not, that would be good" and we went back to watching Hill St Blues on the telly.

We got married 8 weeks later and, on the day, his mum gave me a family engagement ring that she had been saving for her only sons big proposal and had been gutted that he didn't do one.

That was 36 yrs ago

Summerbabygirl · 15/10/2018 12:30

My husband could have proposed in Thailand during sunset, at a secret beach we had climbed to. He could have proposed on a balcony overlooking the Sydney opera house, he could have proposed in a beautiful Villa we stayed at overlooking the river in Florence. He could have proposed in the Great Barrier Reef or in the Park by Buckingham palace during winter.

He proposed at home in our kitchen, I had just woken up wearing 3 day old sweaty pajamas. I had just got braces and couldn’t eat properly. He’d made heart shaped pancakes and our dog was there. It wasn’t even a surprised- I knew he was going to propose! He had no ring but we went to Tiffany’s to buy it a few days later. Wouldn’t have it any other way he’s an amazing husband. Smile

Patroclus · 15/10/2018 12:31

I like that, very Thomas Hardy

crapface · 15/10/2018 12:37

My now ex while we were out shopping asked if he could borrow my card to go buy me a tracksuit for Xmas- came back empty handed. I asked and he said they'd sold out (even though we were literally just in the shop).. after a few questions I dropped it.
We got back to the car, he then threw a box on to my lap and went "put it on".. i opened it to what looked like a horrendous, huge fake diamond pie that would make pat butcher proud...
Not a word from either of us pretty much all the way home, when we got to his mums he announced happily that we were engaged and that was that.
The real joke is that it cost me £179 and when we split he asked for it back

fuzzywuzzy · 15/10/2018 12:39

Crapface tell me you didn’t give it to him!?

Summerbabygirl · 15/10/2018 12:41

crapface I think yours is the worst! Glad he is an ex.

MoltenLasagne · 15/10/2018 12:42

My uncle took my aunt on a date to Pizza Hut and invited both sets of parents. Apparently he proposed next to the salad bar on slightly crunchy carpet. Aunt was actually quite thrilled at the proposal and that the parents were there to see it but unfortunately the next day they'd all come down with food poisoning.

FuckYouChrisAndThatHorse · 15/10/2018 12:42

Oh crapface, what an awful human. Glad he’s an ex

OP posts:
Karmin · 15/10/2018 12:43

ExH - 18 years old in bed for the night watching a film about 2am. He lumbers out of bed (waterbed so hard to do) and he was a bit overweight and naked so not an attractive look... but love is blind, didn't have a ring, just sort of half-heartedly proposed. I responded yeah ok, popped to argos the next day to get a ring, I pointed at styles I liked and he got the cheapest one of that style available, despite his company doing very well for its self and no money concerns as we lived with his parents... kinda set the scene for a controlling and emotionally abusive marriage...

bellinibobble · 15/10/2018 12:44

Love this thread!

My actual proposal was perfect but there were many false starts the couple of years prior, so I can definitely identify a lot with PPs!

FuckYouChrisAndThatHorse · 15/10/2018 12:44

Karmin Flowers

OP posts:
lifeisthenameofthegame · 15/10/2018 12:47

Nced just in case

We had been living together years and I had brought up the marriage talk a few times but he was happy with the status quo, so things turned to arguments.

After a long argument one Saturday morning in bed in December, I got treated to "Fancy a shag and then lets go look at this ring you like". That's all I ever got proposal wise and it was my Christmas present that year too.

Racecardriver · 15/10/2018 12:48

In the middle of the night in his bed that hadn't been made it days, I bet you can guess why, my husband turned to me (at least I think he did, it was very dark) and said in an absolutely terrified voice 'will you marry me?'. I asked him if it was a joke (we'd only been dating two months) and he said no. A very long pause later I said yes. After a few seconds of relief the panic crept back into his voice as he blurted out 'I don't have a ring! I didn't think you'd say yes.'

DubaiismyBlackpool · 15/10/2018 12:49

DH spent the afternoon at his mates drinking Southern Comfort and they had made me a tape - they couldn't find a blank one so taped over the B side of I should Coco by Supergrass. In it DH professed his undying love and his mate said it was probably cos I was a good shag. Then DH started crying that I'd dump him and he was sorry. When he calmed himself down, he then told me that his grandma had said to be careful we weren't together come Feb 29 as I'd probably propose - we'd been together 3 weeks at this point.
I told him not to be silly, if I wanted to marry him I'd not wait for Leap Year day.
Go on then.
So I did - I meant it, but was prepared for him to panic then I'd say it was a joke. He'd been engaged before but called it off as he didn't love her.
He said 'Yes!! Lets look at the Argos catalog for rings' - yeah, we're proper classy like.

We got married 3 weeks later and still are 23 years later.

TheEmmaDilemma · 15/10/2018 12:52

He copied Martin off Easterenders prosposal. Was late and I had to stay in the car until he finished settting it up.

Oh and I paid for the ring.

exDH that is.

CaMePlaitPas · 15/10/2018 13:06

OP- you have a really nice writing style, are you a writer?

Deepbreathsbabe · 15/10/2018 13:08

My romantic proposal. It was 2009 and were both living at home with my parents whilst we saved for our own house. We had always said we would get married but he wanted to ask my dad. He went out one evening to play football and my mum, my dad and I decided to open a bottle of wine... or 3. I mentioned in tipsy conversation that he would be asking my dad and my mum got all excited and started printing off ring pictures. After finding one I liked, she stuffed in his coat pocket 🙈. He came home to a very merry greeting with my dad saying "I hear you want to ask me something" so when I was out the room, he was pretty much forced to ask my dad. My dad's response was "no, fuck off. You're an arsenal supporter." (He was obviously joking, but he never officially said yes.) 10 minutes later he was on his knee in my bedroom proposing with no ring, still sweaty from football 😂.
The next day he took me out for a walk around the lake and he said "did you really like that ring that you printed off?" Me thinking it was too much money replied "no, not really" to which he pulled out the ring. 🙈
We've been married for 7 years and have two beautiful children, so I don't dwell on the crappy proposal that was entirely my own fault

ThePlatypusAlwaysTriumphs · 15/10/2018 13:17

Ah, the non-proposal has been a sore spot with me for years. Every time someone we know gets engaged and shares their lovely proposal story, DH gets The Look.

We had been together for almost two years. I had a Christmas night out with my work and partners were invited. The following Monday there was a lot of giggling and whispering and I finally beat it out of someone got someone to tell me what it was all about, and apparently then DP had confided in everyone his plan to propose to me on Boxing Day. How he was going to take me to a special place where we had often gone while courting, under the stars. Sounded lovely!

Drove through to his home town on Boxing Day. His sister gets all emotional and gives me a bottle of champagne as a Christmas present. His whole family seem on edge. And then.....

Nothing. Nada. No walk under the stars, no special place, no proposal.

I stayed for 2 days, and still nothing. Finally I got really cross as now I had to go back to work and tell everyone I WASN'T engaged. He said he did want to get married, but "hadn't got round to" getting a ring, or asking my dad's permission. I yelled that I would want to choose my own ring and didn't need my dad's damn permission.

I told him to forget it, as it would be ridiculously cheesy to ask me now and the moment was gone.

I ended up asking HIM on NYE. We were both so smashed we had to call our friends the next day to see if we actually got engaged.

We've had 16 happy years. But every time someone gets a lovely proposal in a gondola in Venice at sunset, I feel a little bit of rage..