Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's none of MIL business.

93 replies

Pereie · 11/07/2018 08:16

We are pregnant with our first child. It's a boy, I make no secret of longing for a DD one day and have mentioned to family that if our next baby is also a boy I would like to try for a third.

Now this is all very hypothetical, we might decide that one is enough or we can't have any more or that two is more than enough etc. But I did mention that trying for that girl is definitely not off the table. Husband agrees that two would be the ideal but three is a possibility.

Anyway, I flippantly said this months ago when we found out baby was a boy. Now, every time I see MIL she brings it up in conversation. It usually goes along the lines of "three is too many, you won't be able to cope, how will you afford three, you won't be able to look after them properly(?!)" etc. I am one of three myself and almost exploded at the last comment... like I wasn't brought up properly because I have two other siblings. What. Anyway, it's really grating on me now, we don't know ourselves how many children we will have or want. Would I be unreasonable to politely tell her it's none of her business how many children we may or may not have.

Additional info: we are both mid 30s, working, well paid, responsible, own our own home, don't depend on parents for anything, won't need them for childcare etc. I have a great relationship with MIL, If that helps.

Maybe there is a something I am missing, why is wanting three kids such a drama?

Anyway, points of view appreciated.

OP posts:
SmileSweetly · 11/07/2018 10:37

I think you made it her business when you told her you'd consider trying for a third.

That's quite a personal and private decision that you have shared with her.

Iwantaunicorn · 11/07/2018 10:55

I don’t see the big drama with wanting three. I also don’t see the big drama about wanting a girl, it’s fine to have wants and preferences. The only time it becomes a problem is if you’re disappointed and badly treat the sex you didn’t want, which you’ve already said isn’t a concern!

I have DTs, I wanted 2 girls, DH wanted 2 boys, we have one of each. We have both said hundreds of times that we were both wrong, and quite a bit silly to want the same sex as ourselves, because we’re so in love with both of them. If we have anymore, I honestly don’t care what we have, but sneakily I’d actually now quite like another little boy!

Unfortunately, people will always comment, judge and make remarks regardless of how many kids you have, their sex, pressure you to have more, to have no more etc. If your MILs comments are upsetting you, I’d ask her to stop the comments saying they upset you - blame hormones if you like!

thecatsarecrazy · 11/07/2018 11:04

I felt the same op. Had a boy oh well hes not going to be an only child might have a girl next time. 2 years later boy! 9 year gap oh dh lets have another baby might get a girl? .... Boy! I honestly wouldn't mind so much if people didn't talk with pitty. Oh u have 3 boys?? Sad face

BrushingTheTangles · 11/07/2018 11:25

After the 3rd my friend said with her announcements 'No, we don't care if it's a boy or a girl' because she was that sick of peoples misplaced pity.

I think the might go for a third is a red herring. The problem is that you will have more just for the chance you might get a girl.

KokoandAllBall · 11/07/2018 11:45

The problem is that you will have more just for the chance you might get a girl.

It's not nice to see a family with several children of one sex, then the last child is of the other sex. It's clear that the kids in between were failed attempts to get that boy/girl which can't do wonders for their self esteem.

MikeUniformMike · 11/07/2018 12:04

If you have two of the same you get asked "Were you disappointed you didn't have one of each?". With 3 of the same, you'll get "Are you going to keep trying until you get a girl/boy?"
The 10th Baron Braybrooke needed a son to inherit his title. He had eight daughters.

Seasawride · 11/07/2018 12:08

Just laugh it off op. And be careful oversharing anything else with her. 3 kids is perfectly normal.

She would hate us we had 6! Grin

Koko my 4 grown up lads are fine thanks and always adored their twin sisters. Grin

Kids only have angst if parents are daft.

Anon12345ABC · 11/07/2018 12:22

A relative of mine always craved a daughter. She had a son first, she doted on him. Lovely little boy he was. Then her much wanted daughter came along. She was a fucking witch to that poor boy and treated them both very differently. He has real issues as an adult.

I never get why people are soooo hung up on having to have a certain sex of child. Yes, I always said I would have quite liked a daughter but I wouldn't have gone to the lengths of already deciding to try for a 3rd if my first 2 were boys. That's just making it known that you aren't happy with the boys you have because they aren't that longed for daughter.

hobnobsaremyfavourite · 11/07/2018 12:53

I have three of one gender and the youngest is the other
Fuck off whoever said that those parents obviously only kept going to get the gender they wanted and they pity the other children
Just fuck off
My plan and dh’s was to have four
We have four
All loved equally, all very different.
I am sick of comments and assumptions like this
I get it almost every time I’m asked about my family
“Ooh you got your girl in the end”
Angry
After secondary infertility, a child needing major surgery before their first birthday, a high risk pregnancy and one dc with a possible ASC diagnosis plus several miscarriages I seriously get pissed off at these sort of judgements
You have no idea why people have the families they have keep your beak out
Angry

InfiniteVariety · 11/07/2018 12:58

We have 3DDs and my DH is Chinese where there is a cultural preference for boys. When the DDs were very small and we were living in Singapore I lost count of the times people looked at me with disbelief & pity that I had produced only girls! Every time I gave birth, somebody (usually a female Chinese family member) said consolingly, "never mind, you can have a boy next time".... We were thrilled & happy every time so it rolled off us

mikado1 · 11/07/2018 13:33

Ah banivani your friend sounds really thoughtful.

crispysausagerolls · 11/07/2018 14:43

Some of these comments are ridiculous. It’s fine to want a girl; I’m sure you will love you son just as much. It’s also fine in context for you and DH to have confided in his mother about your childbearing plans.

It’s not fine for her to passive aggressively bring up what you confided in her time and time again and tell you not to do what you want to do. Next time she says something, just say “sorry MIL, but I’ve had enough. You bring this up every time i see you - DH and I will have as many children as we like, whether that’s 1 or 5. Please don’t make me regret confiding in you about our plans. I’ve heard your opinion about 3 children. I disagree with it. You do not need to continue repeating it. Thanks”

banivani · 11/07/2018 15:23

mikado She is! I don’t deserve her. ❤️ And I just make sure when speaking that I’m quite literal and don’t make those offhand comments to fill space in conversation because that’s not her style. 😁

Annalogy · 11/07/2018 15:27

I'd be upset at the 'not being able to look after them properly' comment, too. It's none of her business and she's just being an arse.

When I was pregnant, I wanted a little mummy's boy. I had a beautiful daughter instead. Did that make me love her any less? Absolutely not Smile

Why are some MILs like this? Mine was saying throughout my pregnancy that I would most likely have to have a caesarean because of my 'lack of birthing hips' Hmm

Maybe they're hating the fact that we've taken their little boys away? God knows Smile

Ignore her and laugh it off, OP Thanks

Maelstrop · 11/07/2018 15:52

Just stop talking about it in front of her if you don't want to continuously hear her opinion about it, failry simple.

LagunaBubbles · 11/07/2018 16:07

He tells them that he can't trust them with the baby and he hopes the "likes" are worth losing a relationship with their grandchild for

I actually can't believe that someone would stop their parents or in laws seeing and having a relationship with their Grandchdren over this. I despair of how controlling, nasty and spiteful people could actually be.

LagunaBubbles · 11/07/2018 16:08

Sorry wrong thread.

flumpybear · 13/07/2018 06:36

@brassbrass - seriously?! It's hardly the same saying you need to exercise boys (comparing to families who have to take their family pet out for exercise too) in comparison to calling somebody a bitch - one is stating a fact that boys (perhaps not yours!) need to run off steam (Fwiw loads of my friends like me
With boys have to do the same) and then other is being very nasty - think you need a chill pill 🙄

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread