Sorry to keep banging this Irish border drum, but it’s important. And relevant to the idea of “betrayal”, as suggested by Daphne.
There needs to be a hard border somewhere. Currently that hard border is around all member states of the EU (plus a couple of others depending on whether they are in the single market/customs union).
Going forward, there are three options.
- We remain in the single market/customs union and the hard border remains where it currently is.
If we choose this option, according to many leavers, we will be betraying everyone who voted leave in the referendum.
- We leave the single market and customs union and put up a hard border in Ireland.
If we take this option, we are breaching an international treaty, betraying everyone in Northern Ireland (particularly those who identify as Irish rather than British), not respecting the result of the referendum on the Good Friday Agreement, and risking people’s lives and safety with a return to the violence and unrest of the (fairly recent) past.
- Northern Ireland remains in the single market and customs union and the hard border goes in the Irish Sea.
If we choose this option, the DUP will go apeshit and withdraw their support from the government, we betray everyone in Northern Ireland who identifies as British, the structural integrity of the UK will be threatened (it greatly increases the chances of Northern Ireland breaking away to join the Republic), Scotland will also go apeshit (and want the same deal, which would involve a hard border between England and Scotland and an increased likelihood of Scottish independence too) and the risk of increased violence in Northern Ireland (as per option 2) is also likely.
Which option should we go for?
I genuinely want to know.