To think this isn't a useful question to ask a football player

[Raramumaran]

Dd plays in a girls football team. At her player review they asked her to say who she thought the strongest player and the weakest player was. She answered but it made her feel really uncomfortable. AIBU to think that's not really appropriate? She's 11.

When my daughter played, they voted for player of the match and player of the season. I think that's quite usual.

I'm guessing it's quite a serious/talented team if they have 1 to 1 player reviews. So maybe getting them to start thinking about the strengths and weaknesses of the team and where they fit in to it is part of the overall program? A bit of reflection.

Asking who they rate as strongest may be ok, but its a bit hard to see how naming the weakest is going to be helpful.