Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Any mothers days present is a privilege not a right

89 replies

cheesyinkent · 26/03/2017 14:05

So several unhappy MD threads today, shock horror. Any thread on inheritance always goes on about its not a right. Can't the same apply to mothers day?

OP posts:
remoaniac · 27/03/2017 09:13

Is breakfast in bed on Mother's Day really a thing?

even worse are the threads where women get the arse because their DHs actually want to spend time with their actual Mothers on Mother's Day

Maybe people should stop concentrating all their hopes and dreams into one commercialised day. For example, we can't see MiL at Easter as we are seeing my mum, so we went to see MiL last week and took her out for lunch for an early Mother's Day lunch instead. Why not spread the love around a bit? If DH spends time with his mother on Mother's Day, does that mean his wife/partner gets left at home with the kids? What happens if she wants to see her mum on Mother's Day? It all gets a bit silly with who is more important and whose mother is more important (demanding).

SailAwayWithMeHoney · 27/03/2017 09:17

YANBU.

halcyondays · 27/03/2017 09:20

According to some on MN, you're never allowed to feel unappreciated or ever expect anything from anyone ever. Being upset because you didn't get expensive presents is a bit silly, but I'd feel a bit sad if nothing at all was done to mark the day.

Clnz4fun · 27/03/2017 09:26

I couldn't give a stuff about MD, I'm a single mum and my dc was away for most of the day. Her and her gp made two cereal cakes one for me and one for her, MD done.

I had a lovely day chilling in the sun while babysitting a df kids while she worked.

Sure it's nice to be appreciated but I don't buy into the one day a year to do it. Equally not bothered about my birthday or valentines.

Butterymuffin · 27/03/2017 09:30

The posters who didn't get so much as a card or a verbal 'Happy Mother's Day' - not unreasonable. And there are plenty of those, usually who work their arses off all year. The posters like the one who started the 'Worst Mother's Day gift ever?' complaining that her toddler had given her D&V (not great, but it was hardly deliberate) and then said 'oh, but I did get flowers and breakfast in bed' - the ones like that made me Hmm

Huldra · 27/03/2017 10:11

It's one of those occasions that can highlight unfairness in a relationship.

Its fine if both parties don't want to put effort into mothers and fathers day.

But you get situations such as

Fathers Day, mother puts effort into reminding children and facilitating them choosing or making cards and gifts. They tell the kids to be quite so daddy can sleep in a little, they prompt and help make Daddy breakfast, or organise brunch or lunch out. Using the opportunity to do some parenting, look kids this is one way show appreciation to someone we love. At no point does he say, inbetween bites of bacon and slurps of beer no love sit down, Your not MY Father! I will wait until the children are old enough to do everything by themselves. Of course they probably never will because they wont have grown up with Fathers day as a thing.

Mothers Day comes, "but you're not my Mother! I'm off to take all these things to my Mother whlist you look after the kids and so have more work to do than usual.

Mothers Day in my house revolves around my husband going to visit his mother, which is fine. We can't go anywhere because its mothers day and he seems to think she will combust if for ONE year she doesn't get to make him tea whilst he hands over some flowers, on a mothers day itself. He would never come to visit my mother because it's Mothers Day. Now this would all be fine if every fucking year he looks so shocked when I don't tag along to see his mother Confused Yes, darling you keep saying it's mothers day, it is not mil day. I am going to sit at home and drink wine whilst you take the kids with you,

BusterGonad · 27/03/2017 10:29

Huldra 😂 one Mother's Day I took my son out to the shops as my husband was busy/having a lie in. I presumed he had forgotten it was Mother's Day so me and my son had a look around the shops and had a coffee and cake in a cafe, I'm thinking 'this is quite enjoyable' as I eat my cake, then my husband rings up and asks when are you coming home because I've spoken to my mother and we are meeting up for a Mother's Day pub lunch! Wtf....I just wanted some peace and quiet!!!! Maybe a cup of tea made for me......not a effing pub lunch with the mil!!!

daisychain01 · 27/03/2017 10:37

Any disappointment tends to be a sign of deeper malaise in the relationship. Theres often a back story and history of general arseholery to a greater or lesser extent. Either lack of communication, inability or unwillingness to reinforce love in the relationship. And sometimes just downright thoughtlessness and CBA-ness. And thats on both sides not just the DH/DP

halcyondays · 27/03/2017 10:57

If someone can't be bothered to make any effort at all for Mother's Day/ birthdays /Xmas etc, it seems unlikely they'll be showering you with love and affection on other days of the year.

gluteustothemaximus · 27/03/2017 13:07

Huldra - I love you post Grin

gluteustothemaximus · 27/03/2017 13:08

Your post, not I love you!! Haha

StatisticallyChallenged · 27/03/2017 13:30

Whilst a gift or card on mothers day, or birthday, or Xmas, or inheritance from parents are all in the privilege not right category we also have social norms around each of these. Those will differ between cultures and different families but those norms do exist and if someone chooses to ignore them, especially if they are aware of your expectations, then it's not unreasonable to be hurt and to reevaluate your relationship in some way as a result.

We have a situation in our family where parents have split, one has remarried to the person they had an affair with and has since announced that they intend to leave everything (rather a lot, not of a level necessary to maintain a decent life iyswim) to the new spouse. Trusts and such like will not be considered because they want the spouses to be free to shop Hmm. That is of course the parents choice but if you do that you can't be surprised if your children feel that maybe you don't actually care about them or their future all that much and decide that if you don't care much then neither do they.

My DH always makes an effort on mothers day. This year he didn't and yes as a result I am fucked off because it is hurtful.

AllDaBoats · 27/03/2017 15:18

I feel very torn on this.

On one hand it doesn't take much for kids or husbands / partners or even ex husbands (where kids are too young etc) to buy a card and a box of chocolates and prosecco to show appreciation. And that would be nice.

On the other hand... you chose to be a mother and surely you look after your family because you want to. So Why do you NEED to have a gift to feel appreciated ? surely they tell you in other ways?

It shouldn't just be about one day of the year anyway , if you don't feel appreciated long term then communicate this

Ontopofthesunset · 27/03/2017 15:25

I think it's rubbish that if people don't make an effort on Mothers' Day they don't shower you with love and affection the rest of the year. Mothering Sunday has been massively hyped up by the avaricious makers of cards, chocolates and flowers, to name but a few. We have lots of love and affection here but I don't really care about Mothers' Day. Like Christmas, it seems to become bigger and bigger every year. I actually resent the suggestion that we should all go out for meals and turn it into a gift fest. I don't need cards and presents.

If they tell me they love me, give me a hug, make me a cup of tea, go round the corner to buy me an almond croissant for breakfast, that's enough. Neither of my teenagers gave me a card, though my husband did. I sent my mum a card and called her. My son called from university. My husband made dinner (though he usually does at the weekend).

New posts on this thread. Refresh page