Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbours unfair to blame me for my puppy being run over?

86 replies

stillpinching · 12/02/2017 18:13

About 8 months ago I got a puppy following the death of my beloved old dog. Obviously not had a puppy for a while, so found training hard but we were going to classes and not doing too badly.

Over the road lives a, well, kind but perhaps overly interested in the neighbours type of person. I have lived her for just over a year, and she made herself known from the start, knocking on the door and introducing herself etc. This was nice, but a few times she and her husband seemed to be a little bit over-invested in my life, commenting on the dc and jobs they could see needed doing from looking at the front of my house, which I was obviously aware of. When ds2 broke his leg, she was over within minutes of seeing me get him out of the car with a cast on offering lifts to school - which was obviously very kind, but a bit odd that she had clocked the situation so quickly. She has often as good as told me she feels sorry for me being a single mother - I am currently divorcing.

Anyway, when I got the puppy she started offering to walk with me with her dog, and gave me a lot of tips, some of which contradicted the advice I was given at training, but I was grateful for her help and company.

Three weeks ago, I was out walking my puppy alone and he bolted underneath a hedge onto a road and was run over and killed. Obviously I am extremely sad about this and regret letting him off the lead that day. But his recall was pretty good and the field in question looks to be pretty secure and is always full of dogs off the lead. He crawled under the hedge and it hadn't looked like an obvious risk. Clearly I am paying the price now for what was in hindsight a misjudgement.

The woman made all the right noises at the time I told her, but now she is blanking me. The change is obvious, as previously she always seemed to appear when I left the house/pulled up in the car, and now she never does. If she is there, she turns the other way. Her dil works in the local shop and tonight when I went in, she was in the back room, came out, saw me and went back into the back room (there was a second person there serving as well).

I feel like the whole family hate me now because I made a mistake with my puppy. They clearly blame me for his death and that really hurts. I feel uncomfortable in my own street now and don't know what to do. I was happy to have moved here to have friendly neighbours, but now they seem to hate me. How can I handle this?

OP posts:
Dunkling · 13/02/2017 12:27

I read the title and thought..... of course it's your fault. It is always the owners fault if a dog is hit by a car, it should be under their control.

BUT, when mine was a puppy, once I thought the recall was pretty much down pat, I used to take her to a field, thinking a field with other dogs, surrounded by hedging, is a secure place to try her off lead. What happened to you was a terrible tragedy..... a foreseeable one in hindsight, but that old hindsight eh?

Sorry for your loss. x

Lweji · 13/02/2017 12:30

I'd really like to know how anyone can conclude from a few posts here (about a neighbour, not the death of the dog) that "you don't seem that upset".
Particularly in addition to "Obviously I am extremely sad about this and regret letting him off the lead that day"
What are the guidelines?
How many sad faces are people supposed to put in their posts?
Should people describe exactly how long they cried, all their thoughts, etc, even though it's not relevant at all to the problem they posted about?

FFS

Coloursthatweremyjoy · 13/02/2017 12:33

She sounds rather intense OP. People like that have a tendency to blow hot and cold. As a PP said, it would have been something else eventually. I have learnt to keep neighbours at arms length for just this reason.

My DDog is 5 now. His recall is excellent and he is very well trained. He ought to be I work very hard at it. But it wasn't so long ago that he suddenly bolted while we were walking along quite a busy road. He'd seen a cat. He was on a short lead but he just yanked it out of my hand. I should have had a tighter hold, should have clocked the cat first and told him to leave it. Luckily the driver saw him bolt and slammed the brakes on quickly. He never and I mean never does that but he's an animal and at the end date of the day unpredictable. It wasn't your fault I'm sorry you were unlucky.

Don't let this put you off getting another. Do let it put you off from letting people into your life that need to keep their nose out of it.

stillpinching · 13/02/2017 12:44

limitedperiodonly I'm so sorry to hear what you went through and for your loss. I too saw some sights I can't unsee, but clearly didn't go into as much detail about them to some people's satisfaction on here.

I haven't asked whether it was my fault my dog was run over as it clearly was. And yes, I too feel sorry for the driver, who was luckily for me very kind, calm and understanding. I wouldn't have blamed him at all had he been angry, but he wasn't, or if he was, kept it hidden as he could see how upset I was.

I did find the woman full on, but I also liked her attention. It was a difficult time for me when I moved here. I was adjusting to being on my own and it felt nice to have friendly and helpful neighbours and now that has gone. Her son and dil live next door to her and she is also very close to another couple of people, so it seems like a large swathe of people are now out of bounds to me. having said that, I did notice while we were together that she told me several anecdotes about people she now doesn't talk to and she also said how she much she disliked both the previous owners of my house, so maybe she does have form for this sort of thing.

I think it must be the puppy because she has not spoken to me at all since the day I told her about it. It makes me feel a little anxious as I feel she will still be watching out for me, but not in a good way, iyswim. I often take the dc to the park where she walks her dog and I dread seeing her or her son as it feels so awkward.

OP posts:
lightbulbmoon · 13/02/2017 12:50

horrible situation. i would just be glad to be rid of her she sounds like an absolute arse.

Coloursthatweremyjoy · 13/02/2017 12:53

Don't let her make you feel awkward. Remain the same as you always were, you don't have to make massive conversation or anything but hold your head up high. I can't stand people like this, just bullies who think they have the right to look down on other people and tell them what to do.

You've every right to go about your life as you wish to. I know it's nice to have some one to talk to but really she was never your friend and no it is no coincidence that she disliked the previous owners of your house..maybe they didn't leave...maybe they escaped! Pretend she doesn't exist.

Lweji · 13/02/2017 12:53

I did notice while we were together that she told me several anecdotes about people she now doesn't talk to and she also said how she much she disliked both the previous owners of my house, so maybe she does have form for this sort of thing

I dropped a "friend" like this once. Too full on and too eager to speak badly of others

limitedperiodonly · 13/02/2017 13:26

I too saw some sights I can't unsee, but clearly didn't go into as much detail about them to some people's satisfaction on here.

I bet you did stillpinching Flowers

BlurryFace · 13/02/2017 14:37

Sorry for your lossFlowers. There but for the grace of god go I, after several months of living here with no escapes Ddog wriggled out of our enclosed garden and took herself on one of her walks along a busy road before being brought back by a taxi driver.

Kiroro · 13/02/2017 14:44

Gosh OP, if only you had been more sorry you could have magiced your puppy back to life... oh wait... no. That isn't true.

It was a horrible thing to happen but castigating yourself won't help. The neighbor sounds batty and best off out of her sphere of influence.

limitedperiodonly · 13/02/2017 20:04

kerrywind

Of course it's the OPs fault.I feel sorry for the poor driver.

YouHadMeAtCake

I agreee with pp. You should never have let him off lead near a road and you don't seem that upset. Of course it's your fault and I would be blanking you too. You didn't pay the price by the way, your poor little puppy did. Don't get any more ffs.

What deeply unpleasant views you two hold.

If either of you would like to discuss it with me, please feel free

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread