My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

AIBU?

leaving kids behind to go on a two week holiday

163 replies

glasgowsfinest · 30/01/2017 21:59

Have totally got my judgy pants on, but here goes! My cousin and his wife have gone off on a 16 day holiday to Sri Lanka, leaving their three year old and ten year old with her mum. It''s for his 40th bday.

Now, part of me would love two weeks without my DD's. But I know, in reality, I would miss them like mad after a couple of days. I've had three days away before and was so glad to get back to them in the end (but if five days in New York were on offer I think I'd take it!)

I'm judging for;
1/ two weeks is a lot for a 3yo to be away from his parents
2/ It's a big ask of a nan to look after two kids for over two weeks. She's fit and healthy, but is it not taking her generosity a bit too far?

I'm not jealous, BTW, although that may be how it sounds. Honestly I'm not.

So, MN jury, what do you reckon?

OP posts:
Report
MommaGee · 31/01/2017 01:19

I've been to Sri Lanka, its a bloody long trek home if something happens and flights tend to be only a few times a week. I couldn't cope being that far away.
Also wouldn't be able to mannagw that long.

When we were in hospital recently one of the kids in there was brought in as an emergency by grandparents. Parents were at a wedding on the continent. At least they were able to pack up and get homr relatively easily

Report
BitOfFun · 31/01/2017 01:22

God, I thought you meant they'd been left home alone! It's no big deal, surely? I doubt it will come up with their analysts in adult life.

Report
bummymummy77 · 31/01/2017 01:25

I wouldn't leave 3 year old ds alone for one night let alone 16. That's an eternity for a toddler!

Report
MyWhatICallNameChange · 31/01/2017 01:33

I went away for a week without my kids last year.

I left them and DH at home and went with a friend.

My youngest was 8.

Is that all right? Or is just because they both went away?

I'm sure the kids will have a great time being spoiled by the grandparents and the parents will have a relaxing time, even though I'm sure they'll miss the children.

Sounds bliss! I want to go away again!

Report
SingingInTheRainstorm · 31/01/2017 01:48

I don't think YABU, maybe it depends what type of community you live in. Whether everyone knows everyone's business. But when DS was a toddler and I was pregnant with DD I had to go off for a week at a time with work, only a car drive back but people were judgey not only that I abandoned my DC but did so whilst pregnant.
Even now if I'm required to go somewhere for a few days as a one off with a contract people have their views, that's only a few days. So those saying oh how can you judge, in communities across the world that happens. Gold star to those who don't.
We always holiday as a family as in both our minds we think, what if something God forbid happened to us or DC's. You'd feel pretty guilty you weren't there.
Yes as a child I spent most of my time with grandparents, plus friends and relatives. But I was born in an era when the family unit was closer together. We all lived within a 5 minute walk of each other. We preferred one set of GP's to the other. One was strict, one spoilt us rotten.
Now we rarely go out at all without DC's as to this glorious phrase, you enjoyed, you look after. Yet both children went beyond planned parenting, we needed intervention to get them. Just to offset my Gran's lovely phrase I did not enjoy any part of the IVF process.
On that note I don't think any of our family would babysit for that time. Although I suspect DM does it for her step kids. But we won't go there. Smile
It depends how old Gran is too, how capable she is. It wouldn't be an issue capability wise for DM or DD, but they have their own lives which 2 DGK's would interfere with.
In my day I was babysitting quite young, now you wouldn't have a babysitter who wasn't CRB checked with first aid training etc. Unless it was a family member, but again most are 35+ like us.
I think my DP's went away for weekends, but only in the UK. Sri Lanka is ages away, I can't imagine emergency flights being that cheap. But I guess some of us over worry about things, others can let go and relax. Plus you can be a Grandmother in your early 30's now, which makes a difference.
OP don't feel bad that by your standards it's off. There's been some including myself who disagree on varying levels.

Report
Motherfuckers · 31/01/2017 02:19

You are jealous, you are spending too much time denying it. And why shouldn't you be? Many people have lives away from their children, you sound a bit downtrodden by it all?

Report
gazingatthestars · 31/01/2017 03:34

Oooo I'm judging them too. Awful parents and poor kids bring abandoned like that. Yanbu

Report
Bloodybridget · 31/01/2017 03:52

Blimey, some people love to jump all over an OP, don't they? You know, it's possible to disagree without being rude and aggressive.

Report
SheFeedsYouTeaAndOranges · 31/01/2017 04:34

FFS, the children are hardly being abandoned. They are having their own 2 week holiday with their nan.

Maybe they just couldn't afford to take all of them. Maybe they wanted some child free adult time.

I'm guessing they probably discussed it with the grandma before they booked it, so she's probably happy with it or she wouldn't have agreed to it.

Report
Atenco · 31/01/2017 05:36

Mmm, my mother had an accident when I was three and I vaguely remember being looked after by my grandmother while mum was in bed, I certainly don't think of it as traumatic. The children are with someone who is familiar to them, I cannot see the harm.

Report
DailyMailFuckRightOff · 31/01/2017 05:47

Genuinely none of your business, no.
Just because you couldn't do it doesn't mean that you are in the right and they are in the wrong.

Report
FairNotFair · 31/01/2017 05:53

^What's with the judge and jury shit?
^
Worra Grin

Although, to be fair, without the judge and jury shit, MN would be a barren place indeed.

Report
Parker231 · 31/01/2017 05:56

Wow - am surprised at the numbers of people unable to be parted from their DC's ! I have worked away from home regularly and when they were little DT's often stayed with grandparents as DH was doing his residency at the hospital and his hours were all over the place. We all missed each other but no damage done!

Report
StealthPolarBear · 31/01/2017 06:10

Put down that laptop my children miss me more when I'm away and they're at home with their dad for one night than when they go to their grandparents for a couple of nights. I think its because they're him, everything's the same but I'm not there. Plus daddy doesn't spoil them quite as much as the GPs!

Report
pigeondujour · 31/01/2017 06:13

I've had three days away before and was so glad to get back to them in the end (but if five days in New York were on offer I think I'd take it!)

This logic I really do not understand. Away is away. You can't go to Sri Lanka for a mini break.

I'm judging for;
1/ two weeks is a lot for a 3yo to be away from his parents

Three year olds don't know if it's new year or New York. Two weeks is a meaningless concept to them. You're projecting adult feelings onto kids. Why is your arbitrary five days the right length of time anyway?

2/ It's a big ask of a nan to look after two kids for over two weeks. She's fit and healthy, but is it not taking her generosity a bit too far?

Where's the cutoff point? Those five days in New York again? My parents would genuinely combust with delight at the prospect of not having to share their grandson (my nephew) for two weeks.

Report
mycatwantstokillme1 · 31/01/2017 06:33

I can't stand the term 'judgy pants' so I can't stop myself judging you for that (I've really tried not to!) Smile

Report
Letmesleepalready · 31/01/2017 06:33

I'd do it, my DM is constantly saying she wants us to send the kids to hers unaccompanied. And we could definitely do with some time alone to strengthen our marriage.

Report
NavyandWhite · 31/01/2017 07:19

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

NavyandWhite · 31/01/2017 07:20

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

SheldonCRules · 31/01/2017 07:22

It's not just about not wanting to leave the children though, I can't imagine telling mine that mum and dad are off on holiday but that they don't get to come. It sends a message that they aren't deserving of he holiday or money spent on it.

Report
NavyandWhite · 31/01/2017 07:26

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

CantChoose · 31/01/2017 07:38

My parents used to go away and I would stay with my aunt. I loved it (fond memories of pancakes EVERY DAY!!), she loved it and they got a break.
I'm sure it's not right for every family doesn't make it morally wrong.

Report

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

kilmuir · 31/01/2017 07:46

Your whole world does not start and end with the children.
Not sure I would have gone that long though

Report
famousfour · 31/01/2017 07:48

Hmm. It depends on the child and their relationship with the grandparents I guess. I would assume the parents are comfortable with the arrangements rather than callous.

Personally, I have no problem in principle with holiday without children (especially the 10 year old) but I know my own 4yo would be unhappy if both my husband and I disappeared for 10 days so I wouldn't do it. A couple of days maybe. I also work full time so my annual leave is family time - but that doesn't apply to everyone obviously.

Report
ChairRider4 · 31/01/2017 07:50

I left DS 3 age 3 for just over a week and yes I missed him but the chance to just be me helped me recover from rough time and gave me strength to keep going

Even now when things are rough (ds3 has sn from birth ) that week in my memory still makes me smile

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.