Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want nothing more to do with mil if she keeps saying this?

98 replies

Throughautomaticdoors · 19/06/2016 20:13

NC as identifying details...

Firstly let me start by saying dh's dad - I will call him Mike - died around a year ago. Of course MiL was understandably very upset and was worried about Christmas last year. Dh is part of a very large family - three siblings, eight nieces and nephews, four great nieces and nephews and MiL also has two brothers and two sisters on the doorstep. We arranged to all have Christmas lunch with her this year at a pub and BiL said she could stop with them a few nights if she wanted. All the family is within about ten mins of her house except us, we are about half an hour away, so she never would have had Christmas on her own.

Anyway my dc2 was due mid February but after a difficult pregnancy and most of December in hospital she arrived seven weeks early on Christmas Eve. She was quite poorly when she was born. She couldn't breathe for herself and was in neonatal intensive care. I was also unwell after a c section and we were both in hospital for nearly three weeks. During this time dh and dc1 went and stopped the whole time with MiL so MiL got to give dc1 all the gifts id so carefully chosen and do the stocking for him etc

Not long after we were discharged MiL said to me how glad she was that she hadn't had to have Christmas on her own and how she'd been telling everyone how Mike had sent dd early specially for her so that she'd had a lovely Christmas with dc1 and dh. I was really hurt and upset but let it go that first time although I told dh who did the usual 'she doesn't mean it, she's just upset about dad etc.'
Fast forward to a family event a couple of months later and she called me over with dd to introduce me to someone. And she said it again.
'I tell everyone Mike sent the baby early so I didn't have Christmas on my own and got to play Santa. Luckily the baby was really ill so I got to have them for ages! You should have seen the baby, she had wires down her throat, down her nose, in her hands, everywhere!' At which point I knew I was going to start crying so walked off.

And she said it again today. After asking if dd would be 'backwards' as she was prem. she then said 'oh 7 weeks is nothing anyway.' I explained how actually yes, it made a difference and then she said 'anyway I was pleased she was early, I think Mike sent her so I got to have a wonderful Christmas with ds and dh, oh I was glad.'

At which point I could stand it no longer and said 'you might have had a lovely Christmas but I had Christmas on my own, recovering from a c section and a blood transfusion whilst my baby was on a ventilator and I wasn't even well enough to see her for 49 hours.' MiL then said 'she's ok now though isn't she, so it all worked out for the best.' I told her I'd appreciate her not saying how glad she was dd was early again and how Mike supposedly sent her as it was extremely hurtful. I'm really upset. Not least because since having dd I've had awful PND and it has ruined the first 6 months of her life. It was not as easy as oh she's ok now so it's like it never happened.

When we got home I said to dh if MiL makes those remarks again I want nothing more to do with her. This is not an isolated incident but it is the incident which has upset me the most. It is singularly the most selfish thing I think I've ever heard anyone say. She wasn't even going to be on her own at Christmas anyway! I however was separated from my older child, in a hospital room on my own, in a lot of pain and fraught with worry over my dd. dh and ds went to lunch with MiL as originally planned.

Aibu? I actually cant think about it without feeling upset and really really angry. I don't get angry often but this has got me so annoyed it makes my heart race!

OP posts:
pictish · 19/06/2016 20:42

Oh OP she is a self absorbed, tactless twat isn't she? Yanbu. Dreadful thing to pedal out. She ought to be ashamed of herself.

serin · 19/06/2016 20:45

YADNBU Flowers

Atenco · 19/06/2016 20:47

Your MIL is obviously not the most empathetic person in the world.

So you are not going to change her and even if she stops saying that, she will say other horrible things, because she seems to think that she is the only person in the world that matters. Sometimes it helps to make a bit of a joke about people like that, I don't know if you would be up to it, under the circumstances, but it might help.

JassyRadlett · 19/06/2016 20:48

I do not know how you have restrained yourself from saying 'I didn't know Mike was a total arsehole, MIL. I never took him for the sort of man to put two people's lives at risk just so you could put together a child's stocking.'

I agree your DH needs to sort this. And I wouldn't blame you if you cut ties now. It's abhorrent.

grannytomine · 19/06/2016 20:55

Does she have mental health problems? I don't know how old she is but could it be the start of dementia? I can't imagine how anyone could say such things if they don't have mental health problems.

She has had her warning, if she does it again then I think it is perfectly reasonable to refuse to see her again.

sparechange · 19/06/2016 20:58

God, you poor thing
What has DH got to say about it all? And your BIL/SILs?

HackAttack · 19/06/2016 20:59

What an evil thing to say!! Poor you and DD!! Your DH should give her a thorough talking to and if she every dares make one more remark then never go near her again. I'm quite shaken by that, so I can only imagine how you feel x

TheBouquets · 19/06/2016 21:00

I think both you and MIL have been through the worst stresses possible. She lost her husband of ? number of years. Even if DFiL was ill and it was known that he was going to die, it is still a shock when people die. If it was an unexpected death she will be in shock as well as bereaved.
You have had a baby early and neither of you were very well after the birth and having the CS is always a bit of a shock.
MiL is perhaps trying to hold on to DFiL by saying things like the DFiL arranged to have the baby early so that she could have your DP and DC at her house for Christmas.
Christmas is always stress for families. Everyone wondering if they will be invited here or there or left on their own. Some families are right demanding over Christmas and this one she is talking about would be her first without her DH.
It may be that you and MiL need to have a bit of understanding of how much stress the other was under at the time. Your DH should have had a quiet word with his DM to tell her that she is causing upset with her constantly saying her dead DH arranged all this and effectively causing you even more depression. Man are particularly bad at telling their mums that they are causing bad feeling. Perhaps you could quietly say to her to stop it before you get to the stage of strangling her. That is where my MIL got me to with her failure to stop talking about a vertain subject and all my "D"H (now ex) would do was say I was out/in the bath/ asleep.

Don't let it go that far. My Mil has never seen my kids again.

TheBouquets · 19/06/2016 21:02

PS I am not trying to minimise the fact that her words are horrible but I do think you have both been through the mill in different ways. Had my then DH spoken to his DM things might have been so different. He has not seen my kids either as he failed to defend me and the kids.
Could be more of a DH problem

wheresthetea · 19/06/2016 21:03

"Luckily the baby was really ill" Shock Angry Jesus. YANBU.

RaeSkywalker · 19/06/2016 21:07

YANBU.

Also- "backward"... Angry

RaeSkywalker · 19/06/2016 21:08

I agree that your DH needs to step in and 'manage' her now.

KERALA1 · 19/06/2016 21:12

She sounds deranged.

KimmySchmidtsSmile · 19/06/2016 21:16

She sounds bereaved.

Batteriesallgone · 19/06/2016 21:17

Hate to use a Mumsnet catchphrase but it sounds like you don't really have a MIL problem, you have a DH problem.

His wife and child were seriously ill and he left with older child to play happy families with mummy? Sounds like they didn't visit you/baby on Christmas Day?! Fuck. That. Shit.

And now he's allowing his mum to go around saying how lucky it is that his younger child was seriously ill at Christmas.

How can you bear to even look at him?

NeedACleverNN · 19/06/2016 21:17

Bloody hell OP you deserve a medal for dealing with all that

Next time she says anything try your best to really shock her.

As in "you do know your granddaughter could have died right? Now if you seriously think Mike sent her early and therefore nearly killed her so you got to play Santa Claus I don't think you should be around my children. It's obvious he is putting their health over our happiness!"

Probably a bit too harsh though really isn't it?

ProcrastinatorGeneral · 19/06/2016 21:19

Kimmy bereaved isn't an excuse for such foul behaviour. And being gleeful about the life threatening illness of a premature baby is about as foul as it gets.

blitheringbuzzards1234 · 19/06/2016 21:23

How awful. Your DH needs to tell her that she's overstepped the mark. Is she getting on a bit? My MIL sounds a little like this with her 'comments' and she's definitely got a bit of dementia which I believe started off ages ago very slowly. She's alone now so doesn't have anyone else to 'bounce off' with her ideas. It's hard to tolerate.

Swirlingasong · 19/06/2016 21:25

Yanbu, how on earth could she have had a lovely Christmas when her grandchild was in NICU? Quite apart from the supernatural crap. Why does this not upset your dh? Surely he does not remember it as a 'lovely Christmas'? Flowers to you

DixieNormas · 19/06/2016 21:26

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

LardLizard · 19/06/2016 21:29

She sounds horrible, sorry your going through this
But the biggest problem is your dh for not shutting this down ages ago

Heidi42 · 19/06/2016 21:29

She sounds a selfish, stupid woman but she has just lost her dh........ soooooooo all things considered .......give a her a bit of rope and she will hang herself soon , figuratively speaking of course op

CodyKing · 19/06/2016 21:34

What has your DH said about all of this today?

BrioLover · 19/06/2016 21:36

YANBU. Obviously you should let her make another comment so you can remind her of your warning and leave.

You really need your DH on side with this. I cannot believe he went off and had a nice Christmas lunch and left you less than a day after giving birth. That is thoughtless at best. And that is even not considering DD being prem and you being unwell.

What a vile woman. And being bereaved doesn't fucking excuse it. My mum died three months before my DS was born and my dad has never felt the need to be a dickhead.

rumblingDMexploitingbstds · 19/06/2016 21:37

I remember your first thread, I'm Shock that she's still trotting this out in front of you and it hasn't yet dawned on her how awful a thing to say it is! Or that dh hasn't had a very firm word.

I'm glad you spoke to her - although how she can minimise and dismiss what you've said with 'well it was all for the best' I don't know - but you have put up with this long enough. Thanks Dh needs to go and have a firm word with her.

Swipe left for the next trending thread