Fitbit cheating

[EndoplasmicReticulum]

So, if you were spending an hour in the back garden sawing wood, is it cheating to swap your fitbit to your sawing arm in order to gain extra steps? (I got 3,000. It was a lot of sawing).

I think it's fair enough. Husband is saying it's cheating.

In my mind sawing would burn off more calories than walking so YANBU

Embrace it

I dont know much about fitbits - are they designed to work out how much energy you've used or how much distance you've covered?

If it's how much distance it's probably cheating but if energy used perhaps less so, although I've no idea whether sawing burns a comparable amount of calories to walking.

I accidentally did about 5000 'steps' sawing up my Christmas tree just after I got my Fitbit. It probably burned at least as many cals as walking!

I joked to my riding instructor that I should halve my number of steps after a recent lesson, owing to the fact I would get double steps. I've only recently returned to riding, so am not 'riding fit' yet. After my 45 min lesson she asked if I felt I had cheated....as I could barely speak or walk, I decided that I hadn't!

Sawing is bloody hard work, YANBU or cheating

Riding is tricky because you won't get steps. Unless you can put the fitbit on the horse?

Totoro - they count "steps" although I've found that you can get steps for waving your arms about generally too - changing beds also gets more than it should. You're supposed to do 10,000 steps a day although who knows how that was decided.

Driving along a bumpy road will also add 'steps' to a fitbit!

My partner jiggles his arm around to take him over his steps target if he hasn't quite made it! Now that is cheating! Doing some actual physical exercise is fair enough in my book

I have to switch arms otherwise my Fitbit counts my counting money as steps. (I work in a bank). I was 'doing' 15000 step till I realised.

DH did 25000 steps one day. About 22000 was jiggling the baby to sleep!

So what is the benefit to 'cheating?'

I can understand if you're doing an activity that burns similar calories to walking why you might want them to be counted but for those saying they 'chest' by waving their arms etc - why? Presumably the 10,000 aim is to stay healthy but why make it think you've done 10,000 if you haven't? Without wanting to sound cliche aren't you only lying to yourself?

Sorry, 'chest' = 'cheat'!!

I wouldn't cheat on the steps but log the hour of exercise as a separate activity.

I think I did that at the weekend, I was trimming a hedge and I'm sure I got more steps than I should have!

MyNew Some workplaces etc are offering staff bonuses for highest step count!

I don't think it is cheating, the Apple Watch actually recommend you move the watch onto the more active wrist, if for example you are pushing a pram or something.

When I ride my horse,even in walk, it registers the horse's steps on my Fitbit. I can do thousands extra from just sitting.

mynew you can do challenges with other people who have fitbits so there maybe an impulse to cheat! esp. If the 'loser' has to pay for the next round!

I think sawing (unless using an electric one) counts. It's physical exertion, and I think even gets tour heart rate going. Not cheating.

However, sitting in the sofa crocheting has given me some impressive step counts, and there is no way I can justify that. If you can drink tea while doing it, it isn't exercise.

Doing the laundry is pretty good at gaining steps & flights of stairs

I hit my step target while pulling my tights back up post wee today!

I have to take it off to wash the dishes because it suddenly thinks I've gone for a trek not just stood on the spot.

I speak sign language.

Enthusiastic signing is a good few steps

Crochet counts? Wow. Knitting doesn't, and neither does playing the violin (although maybe it would if it was on my bowing arm?)